The Lion King Review: 3 Ups & 7 Downs

2019's most disappointing blockbuster (so far).

The Lion King Simba
Disney

Disney's third and final live-action remake of the summer is here, with the highly anticipated re-do of 1994's legendary animated classic The Lion King.

Expectations are high, of course, and the film is about as critic-proof as any ever gets, but there's no joy in reporting that, even under the direction of the usually reliable Jon Favreau, this new take just fundamentally doesn't work.

Critics are firmly divided on the new Lion King, with praise for its visuals and some of its performances, but quite rightly also plenty of hand-wringing over questionable creative calls Favreau and Disney have made while bringing the film into the realm of photorealistic CGI animation.

Joining Dumbo and Aladdin as yet another thoroughly forgettable stab at rejuvenating an animated classic, it might benefit the Mouse House to pump the breaks and slow down their conveyor-belt of money-printing cash-grabs, lest not "Disney fatigue" might set in.

But in a summer that's been full of big-budget disappointments, The Lion King has to be the biggest of the lot, if only because it actually had so much obvious potential. And so, here's everything the movie got wrong...


Downs...

7. The Totally Underwhelming Performances

The Lion King Scar
Disney

The Lion King boasts an enviable, top-notch cast of A-list actors, so it's extremely disheartening that so few of them are actually used appropriately.

Generally speaking, most of the focal cast members sound weirdly bored, as though Favreau directed them to tone down their voice work in order to match the more "realistic" and reined-in photorealistic animals.

Where to begin? Donald Glover feels miscast as adult Simba and never quite convinces, while Chiwetel Ejiofor tries to bring menace to Scar, but he can't match the brilliance of Jeremy Irons' original.

Elsewhere, James Earl Jones' reprise of Mufasa feels oddly weary and lacking in energy when the role needs it most, John Oliver's Zazu is a poor substitute for Rowan Atkinson, and Keegan-Michael Key and Eric Andre fall totally flat as hyenas Kamari and Azizi.

It is an epic squandering of talent like few movies in recent times have achieved, and with so many brilliant actors acting so thoroughly disinterested, we can only assume it's a directorial problem rather than one almost the entire cast has individually brought to the table.

And that neatly brings us to our next point...


6. Jon Favreau's Incredibly Disappointing Direction

The Lion King Simba Nala.jpg
Disney

Despite the obvious nervousness about Disney giving The Lion King the "live action" treatment, it was easy to be relatively optimistic with Jon Favreau at the helm, given that his 2016 remake of The Jungle Book wasn't just great - it arguably bettered the original.

Sadly Favreau can't muster the same energy or stylistic nous this time, delivering an oddly flat experience more often than not, which fails to make the cinematic best of many of the original animation's most iconic moments.

Mufasa's death, for example, is unintentionally comical in this version due to Favreau's awkward attempt to copy the original's framing, even though it's not remotely appropriate for photorealistic animals.

Misguidedly, he also throws up an iffy slow-motion flashback to Mufasa's death during Simba's final confrontation with Scar, and it looks hilariously cheap for a $260 million movie.

That's not to forget basic storytelling missteps like setting the "Can You Feel the Love Tonight?" musical number during the day for some reason, and basically toning down the colourful vibrancy of the source material to be more Earthy and "realistic."

Favreau also over-relies on smooth tracking shots which feels like a lazy attempt to avoid coming up with any actually creative shots, and despite the obviously prestigious nature of the project, it seems like the celebrated filmmaker is more-or-less on auto-pilot for the most part.

It feels like a film directed by a VFX house rather than an actual filmmaker with a vision, as though the animators and artists were just given a copy of the 1994 original and told to figure it out for themselves.


5. It's TOO Reverent To The Original

The Lion King Simba Scar
Disney

It wasn't exactly clear just how close The Lion King would be to the original movie pre-release, but given that most of the recent remakes have actually injected some of their own contemporary personality into the fray, for better and worse, it seemed likely the same would be true here.

As it turns out, this new take is dangerously close to being a shot-for-shot remake of the original at times, lifting entire sequences pretty much wholesale while adding almost nothing new in terms of shot selections, personality or modern flavour.

It's oddly reminiscent of Gus Van Sant's misguided shot-for-shot Psycho remake, which cleared the bar of matching Hitchcock's imagery but did so with none of his charm or brio.

It's hard to shake the feeling the new Lion King should've actually tried to reinterpret the material rather than simply produce a facsimile. Otherwise, beyond printing a few billion bucks for Disney, what's the point?

There's obviously a line where remakes deviate too far from what made the original great, but there was certainly room for a new take that stayed true to the core themes and ideas while reinventing it for a new generation.

Instead Favreau, presumably at Disney's mandate, went the safest, least-creative and most boring route possible. What a missed opportunity.


4. The Characters Lack Expressiveness & Emotion

The Lion King Zazu Simba
Disney

In conjunction with the bizarrely flat performances, the actual designs of the movie's characters are themselves an issue.

In an attempt to create the most impressively realistic digital animals possible, Favreau has traded the ability for the characters to emote expressively, as is a vital aspect of the character designs in the animation.

The heightened style of the original allowed the actors to emote and add dimension to their characters, but here the animals never really show sufficient fear, anger or sadness.

It emphasises the feeling that we're basically watching a Planet Earth-type documentary with celebrity voiceovers, because as fantastic as the CGI absolutely is throughout, a slightly less-realistic approach would surely have allowed the characters to feel a little less cold and detached than they ultimately do.


3. The Songs Are A Wildly Mixed Bag

The Lion King Simba Nala
Disney

The original Lion King of course features many of the most iconic songs from Disney's entire cachet, and though renditions of the likes of "Circle of Life" and "Hakuna Matata" evoke the necessary feeling, they're pretty much the outliers.

As mentioned, "Can You Feel the Love Tonight?" takes place at the wrong time of day, stripping it much of its impact, while Scar's "Be Prepared" is chopped up and transformed into a bizarre spoken poem-like number.

Then there's Beyonce's mediocre new song, "Spirit", which lacks the instantly iconic appeal of the original soundtrack, and confirms that her role in the movie ultimately feels more like a cynical stunt than anything.

Again, some of the reprised songs do work, but given how fool-proof it should've been to reproduce these hit tunes - especially with Elton John returning to rework his own tracks - the results are certainly much wonkier than expected.


2. It's Sluggishly Paced

The Lion King
Disney

The new movie clocks in at a fairly hefty 118 minutes - that's an entire half-hour longer than the animation.

Though a slight uptick is expected owing to the movie's more realistic animation style, the end result is nevertheless a film with numerous notable pacing sags.

While 1994's original is pretty much a perfectly-paced movie, one dares to call the new film "boring" at several junctures, likely a result of not only a more laid-back, "relaxed" approach to the material, but also the aforementioned blank faces of the digital animals.

The irony, ultimately, is that many of the film's major dramatic beats feel rushed or underdeveloped, even with an extra 30 minutes to make everything click into place.


1. It's Worse Than The Original In EVERY Way

The Lion King
Mouse

It has to be said that the new Lion King really doesn't do a single thing better than the original - not even visually, because the animated original committed to a far more appropriate style and nailed it, while here, the technical prowess constantly undermines the drama.

The performances, the direction, the emotion, the music - it's all inferior to what we got in 1994, making this an especially dubious remake that fails to justify its own existence.

At least Dumbo fashioned a semi-ambitious expansion of the original story complete with an anti-corporate animal rights message, while Aladdin gave Jasmine a more appropriate feminist update. 2019's The Lion King, meanwhile, does not a single thing in a better or more interesting way than its forebear.

So, not a good movie, then. But it's not a total disaster either, and here are its few bright spots worth considering...


Ups...

3. The Opening Sequence Is Incredible

The Lion King Circle of Life
Disney

Say what you want about the new film, but in the very least it absolutely nails a reproduction of the original's iconic Circle of Life sequence.

Though Jon Favreau doesn't stray far at all from the scene's original conception, it at least feels like a suitably emotional and atmospheric recreation, perhaps aided by the fact that it doesn't require any of the film's characters to actually speak.

Relying on the amazing music, statuesque visuals and sheer nostalgia factor, it sets a high bar that the rest of the film sadly can't even begin to live up to. Once the animals start talking and not-emoting, it's all over.


2. Timon & Pumbaa Steal The Show

The Lion King Timon Pumbaa
Disney

If the movie boasts any single, undeniable success, it's surely the brilliant two-hander between Billy Eichner and Seth Rogen as Simba's jovial sidekicks Timon and Pumbaa.

More than any other actors in the film, they extensively express themselves and get somewhere close to the spirit of the original characters as a result.

Eichner's wonderfully sarcastic Timon is a campy delight, while Rogen is perfectly cast as the charmingly boorish warthog Pumbaa. Hell, he even gets to do the "Seth Rogen laugh" not once, but twice.

Their banter throughout the film is naturalistic enough that it almost sounds as though ad-libbed, despite Disney clearly locking the movie's script down tight and giving the actors little-to-no input on the end product.

It's a shame that Timon and Pumbaa are really the only two characters to survive the soulless, airtight creative environment of this remake, but they do provide plenty of fun relief in the film's second half even when nothing else is really working.


1. The Stunning Visual Effects

The Lion King Simba
Disney

And finally, it bears repeating that though Favreau and Disney have certainly gone a few steps too far in striving for absolutely convincing CGI animals, the movie's visual effects are an absolute triumph on their own merits.

So many individual shots from this movie could be hung on a wall - especially the eye-watering scenic shots - and when the animals aren't busy talking, they totally pass muster as believable reproductions of actual living things.

In that stead it's clear to see where the film's stonking budget has gone, even if it's a shame that nobody realised the obsessive focus on photorealism massively hampered the audience's ability to relate to these characters.

When the film is inevitably nominated for the Best Visual Effects Oscar - and possibly even wins it - it'll be with damn good reason, assuming there isn't a controversy regarding its status as either live action or animated, of course.


Contributor
Contributor

Stay at home dad who spends as much time teaching his kids the merits of Martin Scorsese as possible (against the missus' wishes). General video game, TV and film nut. Occasional sports fan. Full time loon.