The Magnificent Seven Review: 5 Ups And 5 Downs

D'Onofrio really drops the ball, but Pratt's dependably awesome in Antoine Fuqua’s surprisingly solid remake..

Magnificent Seven Ups Downs
Sony Pictures

Everyone loves to talk about how the western’s dead and buried, but we’ve actually seen a major resurgence in the genre over the past few years. The Salvation, Slow West, The Hateful Eight, The Revenant and, best of all, Bone Tomahawk all offered something new within the well-worn conventions, typically (but not exclusively) using the end of the era to produce a powerful, wistful meditation on changing times.

On the back of all that, The Magnificent Seven looked like a massive comedown. Here was a remake of a smash hit of the genre’s original run with an overbearing focus on action (complete with shoe-horned in machine gun) and a bunch of 21st century banner names picked to appeal to the widest possible audience. The genre had just clawed back its respectability, and now all that was going to be overshadowed by one heavily-marketed Hollywood dud.

In the end, however, the result isn’t that at all. The Magnificent Seven is a fine film, a fun time at the movies that offers enough good to outweigh some rather lumbering negatives. Just weeks after an God-awful Ben-Hur remake, it looks to be positively Kurosawa. Here’s fives Ups and five Downs from The Magnificent Seven.


Ups:

5. It’s Not A Full-On Remake

Sony Pictures

I think the most important thing to establish about The Magnificent Seven is that it isn’t a remake. Sure, it’s trading almost entirely on the vague name recognition (with a sprinkling of Hateful Eight-invoking marketing) and follows a eclectic ensemble of seven outlaws, but that’s all rather superficial; there’s no Kurosawa derivative here.

If anything it’s more Wild Bunch, with the gang assembled to save a town from a vicious businessman, and that’s a certainly refreshing blend. There’s no pressure to bend the knee to pre-existing story tropes and instead the film has the freedom to craft its own story and characters without feeling derivative.

Sure, it’s cynical from a Hollywood standpoint, but if “remakes” can at least try and do their own thing, there’s some light in the darkness (Antoine Fuqua’s next film is likely to be a remake of another remake, Scarface, so fingers crossed he'll do something equally novel).


4. The Ensemble Interactions Are Spot On

The Magnificent Seven
Sony Pictures

The essential part of The Magnificent Seven is, well, the seven guys, and this is the film’s biggest strength. You have Denzel and Pratt playing their usual characters, Ethan Hawke as the war-addled sharpshooter, Vincent D’Onofrio the hulking brute, and then we’re rounded off with the quick-fire Mexican, brutal native American and knife-throwing Korean. Sure, most of the non-name actors are stereotypes, but it operates as a shorthand to get us right to the interaction.

And what interaction. The interplay between the ensemble, both on an individual level (everyone has a verbal sparring partner, and interacts one-on-one with the everyone else at one point or another) and as a group is spot on, showing a real sense of camaraderie that feels so natural and organic.

It’s the movie’s big selling point, and while other elements can be a little hit-and-miss, this one is pitched just right.


3. The Basic Action Construction Is Thrilling (If A Tad Incomprehensible)

The Magnificent Seven Denzel Washington
Sony Pictures

If there’s one thing you can guarantee Fuqua will to do well in whatever he's directing it’s gunfights, so it’s somewhat surprising it’s taken him this long to dip his toe in the genre where gunfights are the entire point. As expected the approach to the action here, with heightened period realism making way for kinetic, yet not OTT fights, is on-point, with the raindrops of pistols going off all around a sound to behold.

A mid-point standoff is the highlight, chock full of convention-mocking beats in the build up that makes way for a relentless, character driven takedown of crooked lawgivers. Although even later on when the stakes are bigger there's still an intense grounding.

There are issues that make this more of a love-hate relationship, especially in the final showdown, but I’ll get to that in the Downs.


2. It Has Neat Ideas (But They Don’t Get In The Way)

The Magnificent Seven Denzel Washington
Sony Pictures

There’s nothing more dangerous to a blockbuster than an overbearing message. Subtext is essential to making an impactful film, sure, but so many big budget enterprises pitched on entertainment can rush it, shoving in a couple of obvious scenes before going back to being dumb. Thankfully, The Magnificent Seven doesn’t; you have beats that look at worthiness, vengeance, capitalism and more, yet they’re not pushed too far, instead tying into the character’s journeys.

This is best seen in how the film approaches the essential element of friendship; rather than being forced, with the heroes constantly reminding us they're forming strong bonds in spite of their differences, it just plays out over the film matter-of-factly, in turn making later interactions all the weightier.

To call a remake of The Magnificent Seven subtle may be going a bit too far, but there’s a deftness of touch in the balance of the film’s ideas all the same.


1. Chris Pratt Is The Man

The Magnificent Seven Chris Pratt
Sony Pictures

Chris Pratt is that rare actor to rise up in the modern landscape and become a genuine box office draw, and that's thanks to his very wide set of talents. He’s charismatic, funny, self-deprecating and everything else you want from a 2016 movie, but still has the rugged charm from days gone by. Men want to be him, women want to yadda yadda (just imagine how well Passengers, in which he co-stars with Jennifer Lawrence, will do).

In The Magnificent Seven he plays the most universal version of his “character” to excellent effect. It’s a mid-point between Jurassic World’s Owen and Guardians Of The Galaxy’s Star-Lord; smart, rugged action hero with a sense of humour. Sure, he’s not as deliriously fun as the latter, but what he brings to Faraday is more fitting of a generic action film. In the spirit of Paul Newman, I can see him playing a variation on this role for the next ten years to rapturous attention each time.

He’s just that good. The film picks up dramatically whenever he appears on screen with effortless, likeable energy, and even if the rest of the gang were wooden boards, it’d still likely be a thrilling experience to see him play off them.


Downs:

5. The Villain Is Undernourished

The Magnificent Seven Peter Sarsgaard
Sony Pictures

There’s no debating Peter Sarsgaard’s skills as an actor, nor his ability to play nuanced villains, but he doesn’t really get to show it in big budget projects. His Hector Hammond was one of the biggest laughing stocks in King Of The Laughing Stocks Green Lantern, and in The Magnificent Seven he doesn’t fare much better.

He’s the snarling Bogue, an industrialist with a small army trying to take down the town of Rose Krick. What are his feelings about this? Motivations? Why is he the way he is? Who knows, because he’s barely in the film for much of the runtime (he’s established in the opening scene before returning for the finale) and when he is it’s just as an eccentric with no clear direction.

The Marvel movies have shown that movies about the heroes, especially ensembles, don’t necessarily need an overbearing villain, but Bogue is so undernourished and unexplored it makes Ronan the Accuser (remember him?) look like a screen icon.


4. Whatever The F*ck Vincent D'Onofrio Is Doing Doesn't Work

The Magnificent Seven Vincent D Onofrio
Sony Pictures

The presence of Vincent D’Onofrio in a film is now the ultimate endorsement; after decades of being “that guy from Full Metal Jacket” he’s pulled a major career comeback, centred around a head-smashing turn as Kingpin in Netflix’s Daredevil. So he should be brilliant in The Magnificent Seven, getting to sink his teeth into another interesting supporting role, rught?

Not quite. We’re introduced to him as a violent, native American slaughtering tracker, throwing axes and punching others to death, but then he talks. Oh god he talks. I don’t know what D’Onofrio was going for here, but he’s severely missed the mark; it’s a high-pitched, meek register that goes directly against the physicality we just saw. Things are toned down a little after that titter-holding introduction, but it still underscores a confusing characterisation, making it impossible to take him remotely seriously.

I think there’s just a misrepresentation of who his Jack Horne is meant to be. At one point Pratt comments “that bear is wearing people clothes”, which fits his position as the brute, but his squeaky weakness just doesn't back that up.


3. The Opening Starts Things Off Terribly

The Magnificent Seven Opening
Sony Pictures

There’s a whole host of ways you could open The Magnificent Seven. A montage showing each of the gang on their own exploits, neatly setting up their personalities in mere minutes. Or how about Denzel Washington on a mission to make clear he’s the lead (oddly enough, he’s not as prominent as his position in the marketing would suggest)? Perhaps a tense showdown where you don’t realise you’re meeting two of the key characters at once? Heck, I’d settle for an in media res slow-mo shot of the seven riding against the setting sun before jumping back to the beginning.

Instead, there’s an arduous sequence that provides backstory for the gang’s mission starring only two character who’re important later on, neither of whom are that interesting. Worse, despite filling in blanks, it still manages to start in the middle of the action and thus causes you to spend most of the time struggling to keep up.

We eventually get that Denzel reveal and gradual introduction of the others, but by that point you’ve had to sit through ten random minutes that only hurt your investment.


2. It Has Awful CGI At The Most Inopportune Points

The Magnificent Seven Shootout
Sony Pictures

For the most part, The Magnificent Seven looks rather good. It’s got the wide open vistas that any self-respecting western needs (if not presenting them with quite the beauty of Slow West, the vastness of The Hateful Eight or the unforgivingness of Bone Tomahawk) and Fuqua’s oddly adept at shooting bullet action. Much of this comes from the film being mostly in-camera, something indicative of the genre; it looks real because it is.

However, when we move to computers, things take a sharp, noticeable turn. It’s infrequent, but that only makes it more jarring. You get several wide shots where towering mountains are clearly composites (most prominently with Hawke's introduction, which despite being set in the middle of a valley is clearly shot on a soundstage with greenscreen), making things feel that little bit less epic.

Things are worse for the final scene, which for some reason appears to be all digital, despite being rather simply to achieve practically. It’s intended to be an emotional beat, a cap on the film and a evocative look towards the future, but instead falls flat with an inexplicable shrug (although it doesn’t help that this is where the title is namedropped too).


1. Its Pacing Is Very Stop-Start

The Magnificent Seven
Sony Pictures

2016 has been the year of terrible movie pacing; films just don’t seem to care for the three-act structure any more, and those that do are slaughtered in the edit. In that regard there’s something exciting about The Magnificent Seven; its pacing problems are of a completely different type.

The film is incredibly stop-start, never quite able to balance the difference between character development and forward momentum in the same way it does its themes, making a real meal of its really rather simple plot in the process. We're either stuck waiting for things to happen, or it all comes jumbled in one go.

This regrettably crosses over into the action. The final battle may have some thrills within it, but it’s so choppy and randomly put together that there’s no real coherence, to the point where you get lost in a town consisting of two streets.

Many of The Magnificent Seven's takeaways are ignorable, but this one means that at points it becomes a trawl.

The Magnificent Seven is in cinemas from 23rd September.


Contributor
Contributor

Film Editor (2014-2016). Loves The Usual Suspects. Hates Transformers 2. Everything else lies somewhere in the middle. Once met the Chuckle Brothers.