The Mountain Between Us Review: 4 Ups & 6 Downs

Nicholas Sparks with Oscar-caliber actors?

The Mountain Between Us Kate Winslet Idris Elba
Fox

The Idris Elba and Kate Winslet-starring disaster-romance The Mountain Between Us, adapted from Charles Martin's hit 2011 novel, has begun its international rollout this weekend, and, well, it's a bit of a mixed bag to say the least.

Critics are heavily divided on the much-hyped potential awards player, though it's safe to say that this division pretty much takes it out of the awards running right off the bat. Nobody's winning Oscars for this one (or even Golden Globes, for that matter).

Whether or not the more compelling survival narrative and game performances are enough to compensate for the gooey romance will vary wildly, but it's hard not to see the movie as an overall massively missed opportunity.

On the other hand, if you know what you're getting yourself into, perhaps some slushy romance starring two beautiful people will be just what you're craving. As the saying goes, though, buyer beware...


Downs...

6. The Romance Just Doesn't Work

The Mountain Between Us Kate Winslet Idris Elba
Fox

If you weren't aware that this movie was ultimately a romance, don't feel bad: the marketing mostly leaned away from suggesting a love story between Idris Elba and Kate Winslet's marooned characters, and instead focused on the more interesting (and ultimately better-executed) disaster film elements.

But no, the movie is framed by Winslet's photojournalist Alex Martin trying to get home for her wedding, while Elba's dashing neurosurgeon Ben Bass is haunted by memories of his ex-wife. You can see where it's going, right?

Yes, horrendous circumstances bring people together, but the two actors don't exactly share sizzling chemistry, and more to the point, the film's focus is largely on the survival aspect, so when the word "love" is thrown around in the third act, it feels unearned and out of place.

These moments unfortunately recall a Nicholas Sparks adaptation rather than what you'd expect from a film starring world-class actors such as Elba and Winslet.


5. It's Surprisingly Dull

The Mountain Between Us Idris Elba
Fox

Selling a survival movie starring these two actors stranded on a mountain can't exactly be difficult, but it feels like the movie ultimately leans far too much on that inherent intrigue while rarely populating it with much more than that.

Twice Oscar-nominated director Hany Abu-Assad (Paradise Now, Omar) sadly can't bring much energy or interest to a screenplay that takes the easiest option almost every time.

Plus, the film frequently leaves Elba and Winslet's characters on their own and not exactly doing much exciting, so it's easy for your mind to wander or perhaps even check out entirely. To that end, if you really must watch this film, it's probably best seen streamed on a hungover Sunday afternoon when you've got nothing better to do.


4. Ramin Djawadi's Overbearing Musical Score

The Mountain Between Us Idris Elba Kate Winslet
Fox

Though Ramin Djawadi has received plenty of acclaim throughout his career for his work on TV shows such as Prison Break, Game of Thrones and Westworld, his wildly over-the-top musical score for this film is just too much of a muchness.

Djawadi gives himself over to the film's full-tilt, Oscar-baiting style and tone, ramping up the orchestra for those dangerous and emotional moments, to the point that it's distracting and actually ultimately takes away from several otherwise compelling sequences.

The compositions themselves are just fine, if rather workmanlike, but placed within the context of scenes that would play better with something more subdued, they don't work at all.


3. It Makes Unnecessary Changes To The Novel

The Mountain Between Us Idris Elba Kate Winslet
Fox

For those who've read Charles Martin's source material, you might be a little miffed that the movie makes a number of unnecessary changes to the 2011 novel.

From the opening set-up of the movie through to its conclusion, Chris Weitz and J. Mills Goodloe's script remixes the original story for little rhyme or reason.

While some of the changes do work, far more of them only make the end result seem that much sappier, while also brushing other aspects of the plot under the carpet (such as totally forgetting about Beau Bridges' pilot character the moment he dies).

It'll annoy the purists for sure, and while it's sometimes appropriate to make changes to a novel in order to adapt it to the big screen, that's not really the case here for the most part.


2. The Cast Deserves Better

The Mountain Between Us Idris Elba
Fox

Kate Winslet and Idris Elba really deserve better: that's the biggest takeaway from this film. Initially mounted as a serious awards contender in every major aspect, it sadly became clear as soon as the film premiered at TIFF last month that this wouldn't be the case.

It's frankly just surprising that actors of this calibre would sign onto such an airless and often blatantly sappy film. Perhaps the whiff of potential awards glory convinced them, and while they certainly don't embarrass themselves with their performances, you'll probably be left wondering why they signed on in the first place.

Someone owed someone a favour, perhaps?


1. The Painful 15-Minute Epilogue

The Mountain Between Us Idris Elba Kate Winslet
Fox

The film clocks in at 112 minutes, but the actual survival scenario wraps itself up at around the 90-minute mark, with a lengthy, Return of the King-esque epilogue being tacked onto the back-end of the film for little reason at all.

It's as though Hany Abu-Assad was wrapping up production and realised he was meant to be making a survival-romance, so hastily lumped a gratuitous dramatic follow-up onto what was a relatively harmless survival film.

It says a lot that one of the epilogue scenes was re-shot less than two months before the film's September premiere, because the syrupy, sentimental finale feels both rushed and overlong all at the same time.

But the film wasn't all bad, in fact, so here's what actually works...


Ups...

4. Idris Elba & Kate Winslet Keep It Watchable

The Mountain Between Us Idris Elba Kate Winslet
Fox

In even its worst moments, Idris Elba and Kate Winslet are trying, by God they are trying. Even when the film gets laughably sappy or the two don't have much more to do than squabble with one another, they're doing their level best to sell the whole shtick, and if you're going to make a movie like this, you couldn't really ask for two better actors to appear in it.

Again, they don't exactly have the fiery chemistry that perhaps would've made the romance more convincing, but they're both doing their earnest best to play the sometimes-silly material totally straight.

They won't be earning themselves any Razzie nods off the back of it and it's hardly a bad blip on their filmographies, because the acting chops that have won them so many fans over the years remain very much in place.


3. Mandy Walker's Gorgeous Cinematography

The Mountain Between Us Idris Elba
Fox

Say what you will about the film's script, but this is one impressive-looking production for sure, largely thanks to Mandy Walker's beautifully scenic cinematography.

Walker, who helmed 2008's hollow-but-gorgeous Baz Luhrmann disaster Australia, is no stranger to making the most of sweeping vistas, and does a fantastic job here evoking the chilly, beautiful bleakness of Utah's High Uintas Wilderness.

Hany Abu-Assad ably exploits the story's setting even if the screenplay is sorely lacking, and if people come away from the film moved or excited, it's as much due to Walker as it is the actors or director.


2. The Nerve-Wracking Plane Crash Sequence

The Mountain Between Us Kate Winslet Idris Elba
Fox

Well, at least the movie begins strong, right? It wastes little time at all getting its protagonists up into the air, and the subsequent plane crash is by far the best-executed part of the entire film.

Thanks to unexpectedly convincing visual effects and clever use of long takes (albeit presumably digitally-assisted), the build-up to the crash and subsequent payoff are bone-rattling visceral, staying with the actors at all times and creating the film's one true "wow" moment.

While it would've been unreasonable to expect the rest of the movie to be this thrilling and exciting, it is a top-notch sequence which shows every aspect of the film's production bringing their A-game all at once.


1. The Dog Is Awesome

The Mountain Between Us Idris Elba Kate Winslet
Fox

And if the idea of Idris Elba and Kate Winslet falling in love on a mountain isn't enough of a sell for you, the presence of a super-cute dog just might be.

After Beau Bridges' goofball pilot dies in the crash, he leaves behind his adorable canine, who the pair arbitrarily adopt as their companion throughout the adventure.

Sure, it's a relatively cynical ploy to make audiences more emotionally involved in what's going on, but the dog gives a great performance and probably creates the most truly likeable character in the film. Seriously.

If you can't get invested in a dog surviving the aftermath of the plane crash, are you even human? Again, it's a cheap trick, but it's actually pretty effective, especially as far as the rest of the movie is concerned.

What did you think of The Mountain Between Us? Shout it out in the comments!


Contributor
Contributor

Stay at home dad who spends as much time teaching his kids the merits of Martin Scorsese as possible (against the missus' wishes). General video game, TV and film nut. Occasional sports fan. Full time loon.