The Mummy 1999 Vs The Mummy 2017: Which Is Better?

Did Tom Cruise outdo Brendan Fraser?

The Mummy Brendan Fraser Tom Cruise
Universal & Paramount

With Tom Cruise's controversial The Mummy reboot now in cinemas worldwide, audiences can decide for themselves whether the movie is a pleasant surprise or, indeed, the wildly unnecessary trainwreck that its detractors claim it to be.

1999's Brendan Fraser-starring The Mummy was of course itself a remake of the 1932 Boris Karloff classic, though it has endured over the last two decades as a thoroughly entertaining adventure film, and one that many suspected Cruise's new take on the material would be unable to live up to.

So, running down all the crucial criteria on which a movie can be judged, it's time to figure out which of the two films, when taken precisely on their own terms, is actually the best. Does Fraser's rollicking adventure flick stand the test of time, or does Cruise's bigger-budget tentpole make the most of advances in filmmaking tech and improve upon what came before?

13. Direction

Stephen Sommers The Mummy Alex Kurtzman Tom Cruise
Paramount & Universal

The 1999 Mummy was eventually written and directed by Stephen Sommers, who had just directed middling monster flick Deep Rising the year before. Despite his fairly dubious prior credits, he did a rock solid job making the movie feel like an old-school adventure serial in the tone of the Indiana Jones movies. It popped visually and Universal were happy enough with his work to invite him back for The Mummy Returns two years later.

The Mummy reboot is meanwhile helmed by Transformers and Star Trek writer Alex Kurtzman, in his first gig directing a blockbuster movie. Though Kurtzman certainly delivers better-than-expected work given his lack of experience, he also doesn't really do much to write home about, and is clearly just working from the bland tentpole playbook.

Winner: Sommers' work simply feels much more confident and assured, while Kurtzman still has a lot to learn.


12. Narrative

The Mummy 1999 2017
Universal & Paramount

The Brendan Fraser-starring Mummy knew exactly what it was and succeeded at delivering a fairly brainless but charming action adventure caper, topped with just enough self-awareness to fend off the eye-rolls. The plot isn't super coherent if you dig into it, but as a fun film with entertaining characters, exotic locales and gonzo effects-driven action, it delivers.

To its credit, 2017's version actually has a lot of ambition and potential behind it, what with its attempt to establish Universal's Dark Universe and the unexpected journey that Tom Cruise's protagonist Nick Morton takes over the course of the film. Sadly, these intriguing ideas aren't capitalised on in particularly memorable fashion, leaving them half-baked at best.

Winner: Neither excels much in this department, but the 1999 movie is so much more coherent and successful at what it sets out to achieve.


11. The Hero

The Mummy Brendan Fraser Tom Cruise
Paramount & Universal

Brendan Fraser became a worldwide movie icon beyond any question with his charismatic performance as adventurer Rick O'Connell, and though his star power has drained considerably since the Mummy trilogy came to an end, Fraser was perfectly-cast as the wise-cracking and weirdly likeable a**hole protagonist.

Tom Cruise's casting as the lead of a Mummy reboot was instantly met with raised eyebrows from, well, just about everyone, and sadly it doesn't make that much more sense in the final movie. Much like Rick, Cruise's Nick Moran is meant to be something of a dick, which isn't really Cruise's forte, and the script doesn't even begin to take advantage of his charming persona.

Winner: This one's not even a contest, really. Cruise may be the better actor by a country mile, but Fraser was far better-cast and simply much more effective in the hero role.


10. The Villain

The Mummy Sofia Boutella Arnold Vosloo
Paramount & Universal

The 1999 villain is Pharaoh's cursed High Priest Imhotep, played with delicious menace by the terrific Arnold Vosloo, so good in fact that he was asked to reprise his role for The Mummy Returns. Admittedly, Vosloo didn't really get to do all that much, as a lot of Imhotep's screen time was digitally-created, but he did well with what he had.

Here's an area where the new movie actually really succeeds: gender-swapping the titular antagonist was a nifty idea, and casting Sofia Boutella as the scary-sexy Princess Ahmanet was a smart move. Also, the new film makes her somewhat more sympathetic and complex compared to Imhotep, and for all the mistakes the movie makes, at least they get the baddie mostly right.

Winner: Neither are exactly great and both respective actors have to battle against some fairly wonky effects, but Boutella's villain is more interesting and ambiguous, so she just about clinches it.


9. Scare Factor

The Mummy Imhotep Ahmanet
Universal & Paramount

One word: scarabs. The original Fraser movie may have been fairly light-hearted, but it also wasn't afraid to get brutal on occasion, with the flesh-eating scarab beetles proving particularly disturbing. Some of Imhotep's kills were also rather unsettling for a PG-13 movie, and if that's not enough, he even rips out a dude's eyes and tongue. Nasty.

Comparatively, 2017's effort is really rather tame on the scares front: the horror aspect is toned down significantly, and though Sofia Boutella gives her damn best effort, the script, Kurtzman's direction and the overall tone of the film don't really add up to a remotely scary experience.

Winner: 1999 by a landslide. The new one doesn't even make much of an attempt to be creepy or scary.


8. The Female Lead

The Mummy Annabelle Wallis Rachel Weisz
Paramount & Universal

Rachel Weisz endeared herself to audiences with her portrayal of Evie Carnahan in the 1999 movie. Weisz did fine work as the whip-smart Egyptologist who has to deal with half the movie's cast drooling over her, and though she proves resourceful and intelligent throughout, she does ultimately end up charmed by Rick.

Weisz is great in the part, and her popularity in the role is no more evident than the outrage that erupted when she was replaced by Maria Bello for the rancid third film.

Annabelle Wallis meanwhile plays archaeologist Jenny Halsey in the new movie, though she's basically just a generic love interest and damsel-in-distress, and it sure doesn't help that Wallis' performance is so thoroughly wooden and charmless.

Winner: It's hard to imagine many caring if Wallis was recast or Jenny was straight-up ditched from the next Mummy movie, so Weisz wins this one without even blinking.


7. Fun Factor

The Mummy Brendan Fraser Oded Fehr Tom Cruise Annabelle Wallis
Universal & Paramount

There's a reason the 1999 film made a huge $415.9 million against an $80 million budget: because it's an extremely fun movie in spite of its flaws. It doesn't take itself too seriously, there's great banter between Fraser and Weisz, and at its core it's simply a well-oiled blockbuster that plays extremely well to its strengths.

While the most undemanding audiences might view the new Mummy as dumb fun, it's hard to ignore the movie's overwhelming blandness, with moldy gags about Nick and Jenny's prior hook-ups, and set-pieces that simply aren't interesting enough to be especially enjoyable or memorable.

Winner: 1999 without needing to try, really. The reboot's marketing suggested a rather dull, unnecessary retread, and that's pretty much exactly what it was.


6. Supporting Cast

The Mummy Russell Crowe John Hannah
Paramount & Universal

1999's film was definitely a mixed bag as far as its supporting cast was concerned: John Hannah was intermittently irritating and amusing as Evelyn's foppish older brother Jonathan, and Omid Djalili was incredibly annoying as the creepy prison warden, but Kevin J. O'Connor's Beni was great, and Oded Fehr made for a bada** Ardeth Bay.

The new movie had a fantastic supporting cast on paper but also made rather uneven use of them. Jake Johnson is basically a grating, loud sidekick who doesn't do much of real amusement or interest and recent Golden Globe nominee Courtney B. Vance ends up killed after just a few minutes of screen time. Still, Russell Crowe shows up and basically steals the entire movie as Dr. Henry Jekyll.

Winner: This is a real tough one because both movies could really have done much better, but Crowe's over-the-top performance is about as fun as the reboot gets, and his infectious energy brings a lot to the table.


5. Action Sequences

The Mummy Brendan Fraser
Paramount & Universal

Stephen Sommers did a fine job peppering the 1999 movie with fun action beats, from the opening Battle of Hamunaptra, to the riverboat shootout, the scarabs, and Imhotep's various attacks throughout, even if his death scene is rather anti-climactic.

The reboot boasts a thrilling plane crash sequence, but everything else is pretty damn forgettable, to be honest. Most of the action feels lazily lifted from other, better blockbusters, and the look of the film is simply too generic and boilerplate to rouse much interest.

Winner: Though it actually has less action than you probably remember, 1999 wins with its stronger melding of practical action and digital wizardry.


4. Pacing

The Mummy Brendan Frasier Sofia Boutella
Paramount & Universal

Here's a fact that's easily forgotten if you haven't watched the 1999 movie in a while: it's actually pretty slow at times. Clocking in at 125 minutes, it takes quite a while for Imhotep to actually show up, meaning the first act is a bit of a drag, and there is also some blatant filler later on (especially the plane sequence).

Conversely, the Cruise film runs in at a fairly svelte 107 minutes, and considering how long the credits to movies are these days, the movie is actually over after around only 95 minutes.

Winner: Despite its many faults, the new Mummy at least moves relatively fast and gets things done in relatively pacy fashion. The 1999 movie could've been trimmed back by 10-15 minutes for sure.


3. Music

The Mummy OST
Paramount & Universal

Legendary composer Jerry Goldsmith provided the score for 1999's movie, and it has endured as something of a fan favourite over the years, with its memorable main theme and agreeably over-the-top nature emphasising the bonkers adventure movie tone. If you don't love "Night Boarders", there's something wrong with you.

Frequent Marvel composer Brian Tyler meanwhile provided the score for the new film, and as well as lacking a distinctive theme, it just doesn't evoke the same sense of fun. That's not to call it bad, but just not at all memorable.

Winner: Nostalgia is probably influencing this one somewhat, but is it really much surprising if Goldsmith, an 18-time Oscar nominee (and one-time winner) really did better work than, well, just about anyone?


2. Standalone Appeal

Dark Universe Mummy Trilogy
Paramount & Universal

The 1999 Mummy may have eventually been part of a three-movie franchise, but it would've also operated just fine as a single movie, because it had few blatant pretentions towards anything bigger.

The new one, though? It's desperately vying for this Dark Universe right out of the gate, so if that never happens due to financial reasons, this is going to end up looking rather silly as a solo venture.

Winner: The original Fraser film actually left people wanting more yet functioned superbly as a one-off, whereas the reboot was arrogantly built as something more from the get-go yet, going by those laughably bad reviews, there won't be much eagerness for more of it.


1. Overall

The Mummy Brendan Fraser John Hannah
Paramount

Not much needs to be said here: of these twelve areas, the 1999 movie came out on top nine times, leaving the Tom Cruise-led effort with just three victories.

It shouldn't really surprise anyone who saw the new movie for themselves or just looked at the critical consensus, but indeed, for all of the unfortunate turns Brendan Fraser's career has taken as of late, at least he can hold his head high knowing that his near-20-year-old movie is, to an entire generation, the definitive Mummy, and not even Tom Cruise's star power can change that.

Winner: A wildly unnecessary reboot isn't as good as its predecessor...which also happens to be a reboot (before the term "reboot" was in fashion, though). Shocker.

Did Tom Cruise's The Mummy manage to dethrone the 1999 classic? Shout it out in the comments!


Contributor
Contributor

Stay at home dad who spends as much time teaching his kids the merits of Martin Scorsese as possible (against the missus' wishes). General video game, TV and film nut. Occasional sports fan. Full time loon.