The Suicide Squad Review: 9 Ups & 1 Down

James Gunn redeems the Squad with the DCEU's strongest movie to date.

The Suicide Squad
Warner Bros.

Almost five years to the day that David Ayer's hugely anticipated Suicide Squad released to muted reviews and millions of disappointed fans, James Gunn's quasi-sequel do-over, The Suicide Squad, begins its rollout in cinemas worldwide.

Sensible though it is to keep your expectations middling for any DC Extended Universe movie, Gunn's involvement awarded the film an implicit stamp of quality from the moment he was hired to direct, and true to form, Gunn has knocked it out of the park once again.

In a year that's been jam-packed full of mediocre, OK, and "pretty good" blockbuster films, it's so enormously refreshing to watch one that's truly great - a film with an holistic creative vision that doesn't just feel like it's ticking off studio-mandated boxes.

The Suicide Squad won't change anyone's mind about James Gunn - so if you're not a fan, you're still out of luck - but the filmmaker successfully melds his off-the-wall comedic predilections and character work with a more adult, no-holds-barred sensibility that's really quite difficult to resist.

The DCEU just got its first truly great movie. It's about damn time...


Downs...

1. The Undeniably Basic Plot

The Suicide Squad
Warner Bros.

This movie is such a pervasively fun time that there's only one real issue with it, and it's hardly a deal breaker by any means.

Gunn clearly made a pragmatic decision to focus his creative energies on his characters and the wacky scenarios they get themselves into, while folding them into an incredibly straight-forward, even generic core narrative.

In its most basic terms the story is a pretty typical Dirty Dozen-esque men-and-women-on-a-mission setup, which is collided with the conventions of a monster movie later on.

Yet Gunn does such a fantastic job of propelling the film along with humour and violence that, honestly, few are likely to care too much about it hardly being a masterclass of intricate storytelling.

And with that in mind, here are the many, many things Gunn and co. got right...


Ups...

9. James Gunn's Stylish, Hilarious, R-Rated Direction

The Suicide Squad King Shark
Warner Bros.

The Suicide Squad finds James Gunn at his most ferociously free and unrestrained, combining the gonzo insanity of his earlier movies with the tight ensemble character work of his Guardians of the Galaxy films.

Armed with an evidently massive budget but also an R rating, Gunn is able to go to places that Marvel would never let him, and because the 2016 Suicide Squad was such a miss with audiences, one feels like Warner Bros. basically gave him carte blanche to do whatever he wanted here.

And the result is one of the most appealingly loose, do-whatever-the-f**k-we-want superhero movies ever made.

The laughs come thick and fast but never at the expense of the genuine character work, and the film is packed to the gills with grotesque, over-the-top gore sure to have viewers laughing and wincing in near-equal measure.

All in all, it's another exemplary calling card for Gunn, who proves himself a highly capable director across distinct tones and different cinematic universes.


8. It's A (Mostly) Standalone DCEU Movie

The Suicide Squad
Warner Bros.

Almost any movie that's part of an ongoing cinematic universe will be beholden to the demands of that wider enterprise, often requiring them to tie in to the cosmic narrative fabric or, more grossly, set up future movies in the series.

And while it's little surprise that The Suicide Squad leaves the door open for a sequel and also nods towards the upcoming Peacemaker TV series, for the most part the film functions extremely well as a standalone entity.

Even if you've never seen the 2016 film or another DCEU movie, Gunn does a great job of wiping the slate semi-clean and giving new audience members an accessible "in" to this world.

There are occasional references to the larger universe - an early comment about Bloodshot putting Superman in the hospital, for instance - but the film lives very much in the now, rather than constantly looking to the past or future in order to appease studio executives.

If you were worried the film was going to have shoehorned teases for Black Adam, The Flash, or sequels to Aquaman and Shazam!, fear not, because there's nothing of the sort.


7. Idris Elba Steals The Show

The Suicide Squad Bloodsport Idris Elba
Warner Bros.

The entire ensemble cast is so great in this movie that it's tough to pick out an MVP, though if pushed, it'd have to be Idris Elba.

While audiences might understandably assume Harley Quinn (Margot Robbie) to be the de facto main character, that honour really falls to Bloodsport (Elba), the interminably exasperated mercenary keen to deny that he's a natural born leader and, underneath all that bloodshed, not an entirely terrible person.

Elba, who has been squandered in so many blockbuster movies over the years, gets a beefy lead role and sinks his teeth down deep into it, in turn delivering surely the funniest and most entertaining big-screen performance of his entire career.


6. It's Full Of Surprises

The Suicide Squad
Warner Bros.

If you think you know what James Gunn's doing with this movie from the marketing alone, you probably don't.

It's not a spoiler to say that a large number of the film's decorated cast members doesn't make it to the end of the movie - or in some cases, anywhere close to the end - but Gunn also relishes toying with expectations and leaving the audience totally unsure of what's about to happen.

There are several "Holy s**t!" moments in the movie where, thanks to some slyly edited trailers and generally sneaky marketing, viewers will be left genuinely shocked at what they're watching.

And even beyond the unpredictability of who will live and who will die, Gunn's playful approach to risque comedy gags and stomach-churning violence ensures viewers are likely to be gasping and roaring with laughter on the regular.


5. The AWESOME Ensemble Cast

The Suicide Squad
Warner Bros.

James Gunn sure knows how to pick a cast and make the absolute most of them, and without giving away any hints as to who makes it to the end of the movie, these are some of the highlights among the ensemble.

In addition to Idris Elba and Margot Robbie knocking it out of the park, John Cena is perfectly cast as the murderous Captain America-esque Peacemaker, David Dastmalchian is an absolute riot as the sad sack superhero Polka Dot Man, and Sylvester Stallone steals many scenes with his voiceover work for the delightfully stupid man-shark King Shark.

Joel Kinnaman, Viola Davis, and Jai Courtney are also given ripe opportunities to flesh out their returning characters, and each absolutely rises to the occasion.

This covers just a small fraction of the name actors appearing in the film, but collectively they ensure there's never a dull moment throughout.


4. Its Unexpectedly Sharp Politics

The Suicide Squad Idris Elba Viola Davis
Warner Bros.

Considering that Hollywood blockbusters need to appeal to audiences around the world, it's pretty rare for them to wade far into political debates, for fear of risking that sweet, sweet box office.

And while The Suicide Squad is hardly writing a dense, Earth-shattering treatise on American foreign policy, it is surprising to see just how eager the film is to paint the United States as the unambiguous bad guys.

Numerous times throughout the film the U.S. government is called out for things they do in real life - exhibiting casual disregard for non-American human beings, and as perhaps best embodied by the psychopathic Peacemaker, a willingness to stack the bodies impossibly high if it can benefit the home-front.

Though the film is primarily set on the fictional South American island of Corto Maltese, Gunn goes out of his way to dunk on American solipsism and patriotism run amok.

It's glorious to see in such a mainstream movie, yet never feels like it's a lecture that gets in the way of the fun.


3. It's Brilliantly Paced

The Suicide Squad Harley Quinn Margot Robbie
Warner Bros.

Proving once again that no great movie is too long and no bad movie short enough, The Suicide Squad runs about 10 minutes longer than the 2016 version, but feels so much breezier.

Gunn demonstrates once again that he knows how to keep a blockbuster engine chugging along speedily, never sticking around in one place for too long or tiring the audience out with excessive reams of exposition.

He is a quintessential "show, don't tell" filmmaker, and at the end of the movie's breathless 132 minutes, you'll likely be surprised that the end credits have arrived already.

In an era where so many tentpoles feel like they're painfully elongated amid the misguided belief that "more movie = better movie," The Suicide Squad earns every deranged second of its runtime.


2. The Totally INSANE Third Act

The Suicide Squad
Warner Bros.

Despite how strong the first two acts of the movie are, Gunn basically saves the best for last, as the remaining members of the team arm up to take on the kaiju Starro.

But if you're worried that the trailers have given too much away by spoiling Starro's presence, the final third of the film is far more involved than the marketing has shown off, with the epic, city-spanning final battle boasting some of Gunn's most inspired, unhinged filmmaking to date.

The gory action, the inspired character beats, and the sheer chaotic scale of it all adds up to make this one of the most playfully insane final acts to any superhero movie in recent memory.


1. It's The DCEU's Best Movie BY FAR

The Suicide Squad
Warner Bros.

In case it isn't clear already, The Suicide Squad is without question the best of the 10 DCEU movies produced to date, and it's really not in any way close.

Long-suffering fans of DC can chalk this up as a win, that Warner Bros. got out of the way and just let a talented filmmaker deliver his vision free of interference or impediments.

It's also probably not a coincidence that it's so far divorced from the larger universe, again confirming that Warner Bros.' decision to pump the brakes on the interconnectedness of their DCEU movies in recent years has been an incredibly smart one.

It remains to be seen what the future holds for the franchise, and whether we'll see Gunn return to the DCEU once again after he's filmed Guardians of the Galaxy Vol. 3, but The Suicide Squad sets a tonal and aesthetic template more movies in the franchise could stand to follow.


Contributor
Contributor

Stay at home dad who spends as much time teaching his kids the merits of Martin Scorsese as possible (against the missus' wishes). General video game, TV and film nut. Occasional sports fan. Full time loon.