Thor: Ragnarok Review - 9 Ups & 4 Downs

Funny, fun but slightly frivolous...

Thor Ragnarok Hela Thor
Marvel Studios

Thor: Ragnarok is a film about difference. It might be a threequel in the midst of a huge extended universe narrative, but it sticks out like a sore thumb in terms of style and tone and substance from the rest of the MCU. Part of that probably comes down to the decision to hire a director who feels like a real auteur.

The decision to hire Taika Waititi was always going to lead to one thing - a film absolutely slathered in Waititiness - so it's no surprise that that's what Ragnarok is. If you're already a fan of him, that will be like a warm bath of his references and his particular brand of humour, but if - for some reason - you like your comic book movie homogenous, it might not be for you.

But maybe try broadening your horizons, yeah?

The film is a solid four star movie, better than Guardians Of The Galaxy Vol 2 and certainly the most successfully funny addition to the MCU. It's not entirely as expected, but that isn't always a bad thing, and for the most part, anything that detracts from it being a great film is far from fatal. But there are definitely some things that stop it being among the very top level of Marvel movies.

Then again, having said that, it's an experiential release, and it really has to be seen for the high-points and the laughs alone.

First the positives...


Ups

9. Chris Hemsworth's Performance

Thor New York
Marvel Studios

As Waititi's Civil War short films proved, Chris Hemsworth has been hiding some wonderfully honed comedy chops under that Asgardian beard secretly. He was already leaning into a comedic role in his Avengers appearances (mostly because of the culture clash element of his story) and he's taken fully off the leash here to brilliant effect.

His timing - from the very first scene - is precise and can be devastatingly effective, and he's obviously benefited massively from working with Waititi. It's not an entirely frivolous comedy performance either, though, as Thor goes on a well-defined evolutionary arc - similar to a war-time rebel leader, basically - as we finally get an answer to what it means to be worthy. And none of the laughs distract from that.

To be fair, it feels a little unfair to single him out - Mark Ruffalo is brilliant too, Tom Hiddleston is his usual self (with a little more fun thrown in), Cate Blanchett is an irresistible marvel and Taika Waititi is a scene-stealer. And of course, Jeff Goldblum is on great form, as you'd expect.


8. It Is Incredibly Stylish (In Look And Sound)

Thor Ragnarok SDCC Poster
Marvel Studios

Considering Taika Waititi isn't exactly known for his visual flair, Thor: Ragnarok is stunningly stylish. It is both futuristic and nostalgic, taking in elements of Star Wars, classic Star Trek, Blade Runner and John Carter Of Mars (neither a bad source or a bad movie, for your information).

It's colourful even beyond the usual MCU palette, with delightfully weird costume and set designs that should earn it lots of awards attention for the art department and it swaggers with a charm not usually seen in high-concept sci-fi (which is what it flirts with being a lot of the time).

The references to Jack Kirby are so well-phrased that the film feels almost like a living tribute to his work. It's not just like a lick of paint in the background - it's so much more tangible than that.

It also sounds great, with a wonderful 80s-edged score (all Flash Gordon and Tron vibes) and tub-thumping rock music (Led Zeppelin's "Immigrant Song" is used perfectly TWICE, in moments that will make you want to beat your swelling chest). In the context of the MCU - which tends to be criticised for homogenous scores - it stands out beautifully.


7. Korg

Korg Thor Ragnarok
Marvel Studios

As Star Wars film-makers are increasingly aware, you really have to introduce a new character in sequels who can become a walking meme to help build marketing momentum (hence BB-8 being replaced by the Porgs for The Last Jedi).

In a crowded cast of newcomers - most of which are faultless - the MVP and complete scene-stealer is Korg, the Kronan warrior trapped on Sakaar who "warms up the crowd" and hints at having led at least one failed rebellion. He's voiced by Taika Waititi himself, so there's immediately a pleasant contradiction in his rocky look and his warm, lilting voice and rather than being the brutish hulk you might expect he's a hilarious, charming doofus with a good heart.

It's no exaggeration to say that Korg steals absolutely every scene he's in (he also comes with sidekick Miek - another of the Warbound from Planet Hulk's comic) and every line he delivers is designed with precisely devastating comic intentions. They all work and there's a very good chance he'll be the most talked about character once the film is out widely. And he deserves all of those plaudits.


6. It Works As A Stand-Alone

Avengers age of ultron infinity gauntlet
Marvel Studios

For months, it's felt like we were being primed to receive Thor: Ragnarok as the final step towards Infinity War (because Black Panther would be a more pure stand-alone). With that in mind, the question of how an Infinity Stone would play into the plot - with theories suggesting that either Odin or Heimdall or Hela secretly had one - was obsessively picked apart.

But Thor: Ragnarok is not an Infinity War stepping stone. Sure, there are links to the wider MCU, but it's no more tied to Thanos' story than Spider-Man: Homecoming is, which - on reflection - was the best idea. It means an already complex story is given more space to play out without the shadow of Infinity War standing over it and distracting from the drama.

Crucially, that means the drama and the high-stakes in here are never diluted by the impending appearance of an even bigger threat. The drama is respectfully framed, which helps build the mythology of Hela and Ragnarok itself, and thanks to how the end is set up, there absolutely is lots of scope for this to turn into a longer Thor movie story. And after this, that's a great thing.


5. The Hulk/Banner Conflict

Thor Ragnarok Hulk
Marvel Studios

There's a pretty good chance that the way Hulk is depicted in Thor: Ragnarok might well be slightly divisive. There's lots of humour there and he's basically a distilled version of some ideas introduced previously in the MCU, but it flirts with pushing the joke a little far at times.

Luckily, it's all balanced with a smart Jekyll/Hyde dynamic between Bruce Banner and Hulk as the fears Banner has already expressed of losing himself to the Hulk are realised and we get Hulk angrily stomping around shouting "no Banner, only Hulk". As Banner says at one point, their relationship has changed from each having one hand on the wheel at the same time and the fruits of that change are great to watch. Hopefully, we'll get to see more of it in both the upcoming Avengers movies.

Mark Ruffalo is brilliant as both Banner - who is a slightly fuzzy-round the edges dorkier version of what we've seen before (on account of being out of action for so long) - and as Hulk (who is pretty much a giant, angry toddler) and he has enough depth to sell his fundamental identity fears while firing off jokier lines almost constantly.


4. There Are Some Surprises (And It Doesn't Take The Easiest Roads)

Surtur Thor Ragnarok
Marvel Studios

Given how over-zealous Marvel tend to be in their marketing, it's quite wonderful to see how many surprises there are in Ragnarok. Sure, there were some things in the trailers that probably didn't need to be shown, but there's not a great deal in there that really spoils how they fit into the wider narrative. In short, there's a lot of misdirection, and it's entirely welcome to have been duped.

The biggest surprise comes early in the film with a hilarious sequence that will be widely spoken about once it's been seen and might well be one of the funniest scenes in the entire MCU to date. But even the way the story plays out is pleasantly surprising (as is the tone and the commitment to comedy).

Basically, if you have expectations of how this story will play out, you're probably a lot wronger than you usually are. There are some things you'll have caught onto, but Marvel deserve a lot of credit for showing just about enough in the trailers to inspire discussion without ruining anything at all.


3. Hela Is Not Another Throw-Away Villain

Thor Ragnarok Hela
Marvel Studios

It's almost a cliche now to talk about how the MCU has a villain problem. Putting aside Loki's successes and the smaller positives of Ultron (though he's divisive) and Zemo (rightly called understated), there aren't too many to really crow about (though Ego and Vulture have been good additions in 2017) and lots of talk pre-release focused on the expectations on Cate Blanchett's shoulders.

And though she's not in it as much as you might expect - mostly because of the split story focus - she lives up to the hype. She's utterly spell-binding, thanks to a combination of her costume and make-up design and Blanchett's almost serpentine physical performance. She's haughty, arrogant and terrifying, but with a confidence in her strut that is pure femme fatale, and honestly, she needs to come back to the MCU very soon.

She's also almost casually devastating, swiping away enemies, tearing strips off Thor, threatening to squash Loki and Heimdall like bugs... This is a big deal villain with a glorious performance behind her. And you're going to remember her.


2. Nobody Has Ever Had As Much Fun As Jeff Goldblum

Thor Ragnarok Grandmaster Reacts
Marvel Studios

Obviously, when you hire Jeff Goldblum, you know you're going to be getting a full-on Jeff Goldblum performance. He doesn't so much inhabit characters as wear them as an excuse to flex the muscles of his own established brand of quirk. And there's no way that will ever run out of appeal.

Sometimes, it can be a little jarring - like when he's asked to be a sci-fi, alien-fighting action man (as in Independence Day: Resurgence) - but the marriage of his oddness and Taika Waititi's material is one made in Heaven. He was made to play an aloof, arrogant Elder of the Universe, high on his own supply who has space orgies and mistreats flunkies and subjects in equal measure.

He's not even a villain, per se, because he's so damn charming that it's impossible to hate him even when he's doing detestable things. In short, it's one of the most complex character builds seen in the MCU, at the same time as it being a pure, unfiltered Goldblum performance. And you can tell he's having an absolute ball.


1. It Is Incredibly Funny

Thor Ragnarok Work
Marvel Studios

Even with Waititi directing, it wasn't immediately obvious that Ragnarok would be a straight comedy. Given the weighty drama involved in the Ragnarok mythology (as well as in Planet Hulk), it seemed to be widely accepted that we'd still get a fairly serious film with lots of comic beats.

How wrong we were.

Ragnarok is a comedy sci-fi, pure and simple. Yes, it has moments of drama and more serious elements, but this is Waititi in full comedic flow and the result is a film unlike any other MCU movie in tone. It's significantly more developed as a comedy than Ant-Man and the Guardians movies, and aims squarely at making you laugh beyond anything else.

Unfortunately, there's very much a sense that that will be divisive, but the gags here aren't shoe-horned in for laughs in an otherwise serious framework, so it feels far more organic and far less distracting than most dissenters would probably say about the other movies.

Now on to what doesn't quite work...


Downs

4. The Action Lacks A Little Punch

Thor ragnarok Thor Hulk Fight
Marvel Studios

Perhaps it's because Waititi doesn't really have a great deal of experience with big-scale action spectacle, but the only time the film feels like it's not on its full A-game is in the action sequences.

They're good, but they aren't quite fitting the billing of Hulk vs Thor, or Hela vs an entire Asgardian defence force. The zombie Hela underlings are little more than cannon fodder, so their action is similarly stunted to the Ultron drone and Chitauri attack sequences, and you find yourself wishing for action that matches the quality of the script. There are certainly flashes of Waititi's humour in there, but otherwise, they're a little light on personality.

They aren't bad, per se, but they just don't feel like they really push anything and that's a shame in a film that otherwise revels in its difference.


3. The Character Imbalance

Thor Ragnarok Hogun
Marvel Studios

Most of the time, the film does well to share time between its principle players. Thor, Loki, Odin, Valkyrie, Korg and The Grandmaster all have a satisfying split of screen-time, but the others are a little over-looked. Heimdall's entire sub-plot is a little undercooked and he's just not in it enough, Skurge is a bit of a passenger at times and Hela could have been used more.

But the true crime comes in the way the film deals with three characters left over from The Dark World (Lady Sif is left out entirely with no in-universe explanation, sadly). It's no exaggeration at all to say that The Warriors Three are completely screwed by this movie. Literally just leaving them out would have been better than what actually happens.

And it's a shame, particularly, because it looks like very cynical house-cleaning.


2. Some Of The Accents Jar

Thor Ragnarok Hela Skurge
Marvel Studios

Karl Urban is really well-cast as Skurge, who is a snivelling wretch wrapped in the hard outer casing of a high-school jock. He looks the part, he pulls off the range of emotions required across his character arc and he's funny when called upon, but he sounds absolutely terrible.

The decision to go with a plummy English accent for him was a mistake that threatens to derail him entirely - it's not quite Dick Van Dyke levels, but there are definitely shades of that in his worst moments. Fundamentally, it distracts too much from an otherwise great supporting performance.

The same goes for Tessa Thompson, who is great for the most part, but who lets her accent slip into nonsense a couple of times.


1. The Lack Of Pathos

Thor Ragnarok Odin Anthony Hopkins
Marvel Studios

If you're a fan of Taika Waititi's work, you know to expect more than just laughs - what the director does better than most is marrying legitimate belly laughs with cutting pathos that lands just as heavy an emotional blow.

That made him the perfect candidate for Ragnarok, as the story would no doubt require death and emotional turmoil as Thor struggled to find his place and save his kingdom. But the film just doesn't have that sort of trademark Waititi sadness to it.

Even when devastating things happen, they lack the poignancy of scenes like the funeral scene in Hunt For The Wilderpeople. And that pathos is called for - especially in the opening act - so the lack of emotional balance is a little frustrating, particularly when it's nailed on that some cynics will say it's way too happy to tell jokes frivolously.

With that, and the action feeling a little undercooked, Ragnarok feels a little lightweight (again, the comedy defines that too), and how you feel about that sort of balance will definitely dictate how you feel about it generally.

Are you looking forward to seeing Thor: Ragnarok? Share your reactions below in the comments thread.


Contributor
Contributor

WhatCulture's former COO, veteran writer and editor.