Truth Or Dare Review: 2 Ups & 8 Downs

Truth: this movie sucks.

Truth Or Dare Lucy Hale
Blumhouse

If you're craving some deeply, deeply idiotic horror film nonsense right now, Truth or Dare probably still isn't the movie for you, unless your standards are gutter-level low, of course.

Critics have relished ripping the film a new one so far - yes, they were actually screened it in advance, surprisingly - and while it's sure to be a surging box office success when it's all said and done, it's ultimately another depressingly cynical Blumhouse trash-fire rather than the pleasant surprise we were all hoping for (like last year's Happy Death Day).

Unless you have Moviepass or a similar subscription service, there's no way to recommend spending your money on this. It's stupid, lazy and frequently groan-worthy teen-pandering slop that you're best saving for Netflix in a few months' time.

If you're still not deterred from seeing it, get all your favourite cinema snacks, slink down comfortably in your seat and let the awfulness wash over you. You were warned...


Downs...

8. The Lame PG-13 Death Scenes

Truth Or Dare
Blumhouse

Alarm bells started ringing as soon as it was confirmed that Truth or Dare was rated PG-13 in the U.S., meaning Blumhouse was targeting the teen demographic for those lucrative young millennial bucks.

Financially, it makes a ton of sense, but creatively? In a horror movie about teens dying in grisly, over-the-top ways? Not so much. Blumhouse just about got away with it in last year's Happy Death Day, but here the low body count and awkwardly-edited death scenes just feel infuriatingly tame.

It's especially frustrating as the film shares more than a little DNA with the Final Destination franchise, which of course relished R-rated violence at all times.

Here, it all feels tepid and mild, because it's been constructed to print money from kids who don't know better, when the film's evidently low budget should've allowed it to be R-rated no problem.


7. The Characters Are Totally Unlikeable

Truth Or Dare
Blumhouse

If Truth or Dare's tone had veered a little closer to that of the Final Destination franchise, then perhaps there wouldn't feel like such a dissonance between the film asking the audience to root for these teens and how totally unlikeable they are.

With perhaps one major exception - that's Brad (Hayden Szeto), a nice young man who is struggling to come out to his dad - most of the focal teen characters are vapid, self-absorbed and simply irritating.

Setting them up to die horrifically sounds fun for a schlocky trash-fest such as this, but the film quite earnestly expects audiences to want them to survive, and it just doesn't work, at all.


6. It's Unintentionally Hilarious

Truth Or Dare
Blumhouse

You'll probably laugh a lot while watching this movie, but very little of it will be as the filmmakers intended. For starters, the digitally distorted faces that appear whenever a "player" is playing the game look more silly than creepy, making it hard to take the whole conceit remotely seriously.

Then there's the abundance of eye-rollingly awful dialogue, the film's generally nonsensical narrative, and how deathly seriously it takes itself at times.

Bad film aficionados just might have a field day with it in that regard, though as a tense, unsettling horror flick, it abjectly fails in almost every aspect.


5. There's No Internal Logic Whatsoever

Truth Or Dare
Blumhouse

Trying to make sense of this film is, well, a bit of a headache. Now, thinking too much about any PG-13 horror film isn't a particularly good idea, but in this case it's especially troublesome, as so little attention has been paid to the details or even just establishing a basic set of rules and sticking to them.

By the end of the movie, the screenplay, which was cobbled together by four (!) writers, has essentially flipped the bird to the audience and dropped all pretense that there's any sort of logical through-line to all this.

Even before then, though, viewers will likely find themselves frequently questioning how events play out in reality, as the film often cuts between the warped perspective of the player playing the Truth or Dare game and what's actually going on.

Sometimes it's not quite clear how these two perspectives line up, which can prove oddly distracting, to say nothing of the various dubious revelations that take place in act three.


4. It Totally Blows Its Satirical Potential

Truth Or Dare
Blumhouse

There is absolutely a version of this film which could've been so much more fun, by digging deep into the satirical aspect of these narcissistic, social media-obsessed teens and actually giving audiences a film where they're supposed to root for the supernatural entity to defeat the dopey protagonists.

There was also huge potential for the dares to get much more extreme and embarrassing, and while having one character break another's hand with a hammer was a fun start - even with the PG-13 restrictions - it clearly could've gone much, much further than that.

It's easy to suspect that having four writers working together on the script most probably stripped away much of its singular identity, and with just one voice working on the film, there may have been more room for the tongue-in-cheek potential to creep in.


3. The Script Explains Too Much

Truth Or Dare
Blumhouse

If Happy Death Day got one major thing right, it was refusing to explain how the protagonist got caught in a Groundhog Day-esque time loop, because the answers to these questions are rarely satisfying, and so often take the focus away from the fun of the actual premise itself.

Truth or Dare sadly doesn't follow that lead, and in its third act in particular decides to vomit exposition at the viewer as it explains in no uncertain terms why this game is happening and who is behind it.

There are frantic searches on laptops, shady meetings in the middle of nowhere, and countless other supernatural horror cliches which all eat up precious screen time that could've been spent torturing idiotic teenagers for our entertainment.

By explaining less and just focusing on exploiting the central conceit - which, honestly, isn't such a bad premise - the film could've been so, so much better.


2. It's Not Scary At All

Truth Or Dare
Blumhouse

Though movies such as The Ring, 1408, Insidious and Lights Out have proven that a horror movie doesn't need an R rating to be scary, it's depressing just how little effort is put into making this film remotely atmospheric or even basically suspenseful.

The film is full of jump scares horror fans will see coming a mile away, and most of what passes for creepy stems from people with weird faces staring at the screen, or "Truth or Dare" being written on a wall in an unexpected place.

It's woefully lame and just underlines a production that's desperately trying to cash-in on young teenagers who've only seen one or two horror movies in their lives.


1. The Ending Is Infuriatingly Bad

Truth Or Dare Lucy Hale
Blumhouse

No spoilers of course, but nothing in this movie is more obnoxious or annoying than its final scene. Now, it doesn't end with the sex scene from the trailer as many had predicted, but you'll probably be wishing it had considering how enthusiastically it dives off the deep-end regardless.

The final scene throws pretty much all character and narrative logic to the wind in the pursuit of a head-smackingly bad sequel-bait ending, which desperately promises - or rather, threatens - a bigger, "better" sequel.

The worst thing of all? It's incredibly likely that the $3.5 million horror will post gangbusters box office business and get a sequel quickly churned out by this time next year.

So, Truth or Dare mostly sucks, but almost no movies are all terrible, so here's what it actually got right...


Ups...

2. There Are Some Neat Ideas

Truth Or Dare
Blumhouse

Though it makes so many basic, fundamental storytelling mistakes, there are definitely flecks of inspiration barely visible at the heart of this movie.

There are individual, isolated moments that actually work - namely a mildly engaging sequence where one poor girl is dared to walk barefoot on the roof of her house while drinking vodka - and some brief snippets of dialogue which hint at a far more interesting film, one that obviously didn't materialise here.

Several beats actually nod towards the potential for the central game to change lives for the positive and also to test the participants in ways they couldn't have expected, but these allusions to anything more than dumb horror movie schlock basically come and go very quickly.


1. The Performances Aren't Bad At All

Truth Or Dare
Blumhouse

You know what? It would've been easy for the filmmakers to just cast generically attractive, CW-calibre actors and call it a day, but the performances are, for the most part, pretty damn solid.

Lucy Hale in particular gives it her all as protagonist Olivia, and while it's all in the service of a film that doesn't really deserve much actorly effort at all, at least it makes the wretched script a little easier to suffer through.

Then again, if the film had The Room-level acting, perhaps it would've transcended to a whole other level? It's a tough call, but these kids can clearly act for the majority, even if the script's general stupidity does them few favours.

What did you think of Truth or Dare? Shout it out in the comments!


Contributor
Contributor

Stay at home dad who spends as much time teaching his kids the merits of Martin Scorsese as possible (against the missus' wishes). General video game, TV and film nut. Occasional sports fan. Full time loon.