Twilight Breaking Dawn Part 2: 10 Reasons It Sucked
10. Cringe-Inducing Dialogue
Now, the Twilight series has never been a hallmark for pristine, David Mamet-inspired dialogue, but there are some especially bad zingers in this final film, perhaps because the filmmakers are so urgent to push the epic finality of the film. Perhaps the best of all occurs early on when Jacob mentions to Bella that he has a nickname for her child, Nessie. Bella flips out and screams: "You nicknamed my daughter after the Loch Ness Monster!?" Though the line is clearly intended to evoke laughter, it's still awful all the same, both in concoction and delivery, and a Google search revealed that it's a line actually taken verbatim from the novel, so I guess we have Stephenie Meyer to thank for that one. Even if you can tolerate that line, the overall schmaltz of the romantic dialogue is enough to make even the most ardent love bug throw up. Woeful.
9. Awful CGI
This has been a frequent complaint for the series; the standard of the visual effects, for a franchise which has cost several-hundred million dollars to produce, is absolutely abominable. And what's more, the quality of the effects doesn't really seem to have improved one bit since the first film; it's as though they cheaply farmed the work out to some low-rent effects house to cut costs, and they're just re-using the same models they rendered for the first film. To be fair, the wolves look rather good when they're standing still, but the second they move, they're rendered close to incomprehensible in a horrible motion blur. And then there's the scenes of vampires running fast; the opening scenes of the film show a lot of Bella running around, experimenting with her new abilities, meaning we get a bunch of cheesy shots of Kristen Stewart running against what is clearly a green-screened background, and then blurry effects of a figure of some kind darting about a forest. It's like someone smeared butter all over the camera lens.8. Terrible Editing
A similar complaint to the above, though not one as persistent - given that previous directors have had experience in action fare - is the fact that Bill Condon is not a skilled or experienced action director, thus he doesn't give himself enough coverage for shots, meaning that he directs himself into a corner in the editing room. Far too many shots in this film are rushed and don't give us time to focus on what is going on; combined with the blurry CGI, this often makes for an extremely frustrating time when we're trying to get into the action. Further problematic is the 12A rating, limiting the level of violence that can be shown, and while Condon gets away with a surprising amount of decapitation - no doubt mitigated by the fantastical context - there are some jarring cuts clearly made for censorship reasons that make for annoying viewing and probably don't do the source material that much justice either.
7. Dull Performances
Again, a frequent complaint of the series, albeit surprising given that Robert Pattinson and Kristen Stewart have both proven themselves skilled actors in other films (Adventureland and Cosmopolis respectively). The feeling is that both of them are probably pretty bored with the series by now; they've made their money, and they probably just want to get to the finish line so they can work on worthier fare more befitting their talents, but there's still the overarching feeling that they're really phoning it in here. Aside from them, Taylor Lautner is as reliably wooden as you can expect, though is thankfully pushed to the background for a lot of the film's run-time; there's just so many bland, uninspired performances that a lot of the characters - especially those who already look quite similar - tend to blend into one for anybody who hasn't read the books. Furthermore - and we'll get to this more later - some of the strongest actors in the entire cast barely get a look in this time around.6. Jacob Is A Massive Creep
This one's been foreshadowed for a little while, and it's a complaint that even fans of the book have had about Stephenie Meyer's books, that Jacob Black's so-called "imprinting" upon Edward and Bella's daughter, Renesmee, is freaking creepy any way you look at it. To be fair, at least the story has good enough sense to draw attention to this; Edward and especially Bella are not particularly fond of how Jacob looks at their baby daughter, though they do eventually come to reconcile this. Still, the viewer doesn't have it quite so easy; it's an awkward concept that the film really does not need at all, and it just feels like an arbitrary way for Jacob to stop being obsessed with Bella and move on. Surely there were far less messy ways to resolve this? Instead, it ends with Alice having a flash-forward that shows Jacob with a fully-grown Renesmee, greeting Edward and Bella; it's meant to be a sweet, poignant moment, but it really just comes off as sinister and creepy.
5. Tame Sex Scene
Granted, there's only so much they can get away with when broaching the awkward 12A rating, but after the bed-breaking hysterics of the last film, the sex in this film just feels exceedingly tame and, well, sexless. There's only one love scene in the entire film, but it's directed like a softcore porn film; soft lighting, lots of facial close-ups and shots of hands gripping, but of course, there's no nudity, nor really any indication that this is meant to be a visceral scene, despite what the two characters might suggest post-coitus. It's all the funnier when you remember that, at the time of filming, R-Patz and K-Stew were still a couple, so a lack of chemistry should not be a problem, but in the film their "steamy" quickie really doesn't seem that passionate; perhaps it's the pressure of being filmed, but it really comes off as sterile and not at all taking advantage of its leads' tremendous sex appeal (to fans, at least).4. Not Enough Michael Sheen
Far and away the best thing about these films has always been Michael Sheen as the leader of the Volturi, Aro, who in Breaking Dawn Part 2 threatens to ruin the party by killing Renesmee, fearing her to be a terrifying abomination who needs to be eliminated. Sheen has been the warm, hammy center of these films ever since he first showed up in the second film, New Moon; he seems to be basically the only actor who gets how terrible the material is, and is absolutely having a hoot taking the piss and just enjoying himself. It reaches a fever pitch in this final film, as Sheen munches on the scenery with the might of a Centurion returning from battle, most notably as he first glimpses Renesmee ahead of the final battle and cackles to himself like a witch. But he's not in the film enough; his screen time totals maybe twenty minutes, and given he's easily the most entertaining aspect, it's a shame he wasn't used more in this or the previous films. The same goes for the series' other great actors, such as Billy Burke and Peter Facinelli.
3. Too Many New Characters
While it doesn't feature enough of the best characters, the film is also busy introducing us to a glut of new ones who we're soon enough going to forget, because they just aren't developed at all beyond whatever their core function is (largely to fill out the numbers for the final battle). Why, for instance, bring a great actor like Lee Pace (above) into the fold to play a relatively inconsequential character who largely stands around during the final battle and doesn't even get his moment to shine? He's probably the most prominent new character, though there are loads more; it's just a pain to remember them because they all look so similar and don't have distinct, developed personalities. The prevailing feeling is that Condon made sure they were thrown in there to keep the novel's fans happy, but this is at the expense of cohesive storytelling; as many nods to the book are shoehorned in, making for an overstuffed brew we don't care much about.2. The Fake-Out Twist
The copout, fake-out twist during the climax of Breaking Dawn Part 2 nearly had me audibly scream in anger at how manipulative and idiotic it was. The stage is set for an epic showdown, it all kicks off, with heads being ripped off, main characters like Carlisle and Jasper dying with an odd lack of sentiment, and finally, Bella murdering Aro. However, everything then cuts suddenly back to Alice, who tells Aro that this is how things will end if he decides to fight them; it makes the last 10 minutes we've seen completely pointless, and as evidenced by the countless groans, sighs and laughs heard in my screening, it isn't exactly a satisfying turn of events. Basically, everyone's still alive, Aro basically decides not to kill Renesmee, and everyone goes home, so the climax is far from that; it's a complete anti-climax, which baits the viewer with awesomeness (as the final battle is easily the liveliest, best scene in the film) and then tells us that it was all just a possibility that doesn't happen. At least readers of the book had been let down gently...