Venom Review: 5 Ups & 5 Downs
How does Tom Hardy's Spider-Man spin-off hold up?
When Sony announced plans to make their own Spider-Verse spin-off movies at the same time as Marvel's MCU Spider-Man ones, it was deemed either genius or ridiculous. The studio heads were either inspired in the alignment of their totally unlinked movies with the biggest, most marketable juggernaut or they were damning the spin-offs by proximity.
How you felt about that would no doubt depend on the quality of the final movie and now it's here and we can all start the real assessment. It was always going to be a pretty divisive (even with those hilarious accusations that Lady Gaga fans have tanked the reviews), but the broad picture is... not great for Ruben Fleischer's spin-off according to reviews.
But give it a chance. It's not all ENTIRELY terrible and this could be another of those films that split fans and critics right down the middle, so there's space to assess both the good and the bad. First the negatives...
Downs
5. The Trailers Misrepresent A LOT
Venom is not the movie that the trailers claim it is. They suggest this is a sort of buddy-cop movie where Eddie Brock and Venom learn to co-exist and share a body, Hulk-like. They suggest that Venom arrives fully formed as a wise-cracking, sentient being. They are lying to you.
Maybe this is all why Tom Hardy said what he said about those 40 missing minutes of "fun" material that he enjoyed making the most. Maybe, in the end, the best film Venom could be - and the one it wanted to be and its star wanted it to be - doesn't yet exist. But if they continue down the path of the second half of the movie and iron out the issues, the second one could be that movie. Hopefully.
4. The Tonal Shifts
Whether this is the most genius meta thing of all time ever or just a massive mistake, there's actually a pretty clever identity crisis at play in Venom. You could claim that the two parts of the film are supposed to be a conscious mirror of the split between Eddie Brock and the symbiote. You could claim that until you're blue in the face, but you'll notice the film-makers haven't yet, so it's probably not true.
The reality is that the film has a serious identity problem. For the first half - pretty much until we get to see Venom in full flow, in fact - it's a dull, quasi-horror film that plods along with only Tom Hardy's interesting performance really keeping it above water. The writing is poor, characters are instantly forgettable and it really, really drags.
However - and it's a big however, kids - there's a moment of revelation that comes when Venom starts to get his claws in and suddenly Ruben Fleischer realises he should be making an entirely different film. He picks up his How To Make Deadpool handbook and takes the best of what happened in Ryan Reynolds' first film and runs with it, pulling in from other sources like The Mask, The Nutty Professor and Steve Martin's All Of Me. There's even an edge of Fight Club in there too.
And honestly, that second film in there is absolutely brilliant. It's just a shame it's pulled down by the other bit.
3. The Ending Is A Little Lacking
Considering how great most of Tom Hardy-centric second half of the film is, it's a bit of a shame that we're led down a path towards an explosive finale that simply does not happen. Or not in enough of a meaningful way anyway.
As the trailers ruined (needlessly), we get a a climactic battle between Hardy's Brock/Venom and Riz Ahmed's Riot - good(ish) versus definitely evil - and we're told for a while that the baddy is a really big deal. In fact, at one point, he's referred to as unstoppable, by which point you should be salivating like Venom considering turning someone into a turd in the wind.
Sadly, it simply doesn't live up to the billing and the film ends on a bit of a down note (though the post-climax tag is actually great) thanks to that vacuum. The Deadpool parallel comes up again here, because that film suffered when there wasn't enough focus on Ryan Reynolds and the ending was a bit of a disappointment. So maybe there's hope for a sequel still?
2. The Supporting Cast (Especially Poor Michelle Williams)
If you were to remove all of the supporting cast and just have Tom Hardy walkign around having arguments with himself for two hours, Venom would be a better film. The script even seems to know that, because everything centred on him is great and charitable and very funny and then everything else is... not.
Chief offender among all the elements (other than the writing, which is coming up soon) is the supporting cast. Riz Ahmed plays an amalgamation of Richard Branson and Elon Musk with all the cliched markers of a corporate bad science dude, Jenny Slate's Dr Dora Skirth is basically a non-entity other than helping Brock get into the mysterious Life corporation and nobody else really qualifies as a notable character. Well, nobody other than poor Michelle Williams who has been absolutely neglected by this movie.
She has pretty much one notable moment and for the rest of the time is lumbered with that issue that way too many female characters in the MCU struggled with for so long. She has precious little to do and the little there actually is just isn't all that interesting or well written.
1. It's Fatally Boring A Lot Of The Time
The first half of Venom is an absolute snooze-fest that seems to almost provocatively mishandle Tom Hardy's charismatic lead to the point that it's almost akin to abuse of him.
You can see what they're trying to do (and indeed the set up of it being a conventional movie in order to make Venom's appearance then even more impactful works to a certain degree), but if you took Hardy out of it, it would be absolutely irredeemable. None of the characters are particularly well-drawn or interesting, the science-fiction elements are derivative and uninspiring and the attempts to make it a horror die on arrival.
Curiously, it also feels completely outdated, as if it was made before the MCU watershed and before comic book movies became something else. That feeling persists even after Venom appears, but he masks it well (albeit with the caveat that the film definitely belongs around 2001 without him).
The most frustrating thing about the entire thing is that if you read much about the first half, you won't go and see it. And not only that, but it feels like a lot of the reviews are so spiteful simply because the reviewers couldn't stomach how poor that first half was and ended up misreading the rest of the movie as unintentionally funny when it's genuinely intentionally hilarious.
And now for the positives...
Ups
5. The Venom Snark
The point where the film suddenly gets good is when we start to hear more of Hardy's Venom to go along with Eddie Brock's increasingly frayed appearance. He's basically a walking, talking ball of snark (fittingly for his name, really) who adds a hilarious almost-fourth-wall-breaking commentary to the events happening around Eddie.
It's in the dynamic between Brock and Venom that the film really soars (hence that comment about how good it would have been to just see a one-and-a-half-man show of them at war. And despite how poor the script can be at other times, pretty much everything that Venom says - particularly when he's chewing someone out or making threats - is the best writing in there.
4. The Humour
Weirdly, a lot of the reviews that appeared ahead of release seemed to insinuate - or outright state - that they didn't know whether they were supposed to be laughing or whether the laughs that the film inspired were actually intentional. This is absolute horse-sh*t of the highest order.
Sure, there's way too much po-facedness about the first half and the potential for laughs there are very few and far between (in fact only Michelle Williams and Stan Lee - yes that guy's in it have moments that inspire laughs other than Hardy), but as soon as the film realises that it's genuinely a black comedy, it's very successful with it.
Hardy arguing with himself as Brock and Venom is gloriously funny and Venom essentially being Brock's Tyler Durden and mocking him when he's not up to being his ideal host is just as good too. If you somehow don't get a laugh out of this, you've got something wrong with you. And you can rest assured it was probably intended to have that effect too.
3. The Deadpool Vibes (and The Promise Of A Better Future)
The biggest problem with Deadpool's first film is the same one that threatens to destabilise Venom a little too much: when it's not focused tightly on the titular character (or in this case Eddie Brock also), it flags a little. No other characters can really hope to compete with the central two and none of the story is as interesting as the evolution of their dynamic.
Having said that, the parallel to Deadpool also works positively for Venom too, because Deadpool made a lot of money despite how limited the supporting elements were. That has a lot to do with what marks Venom out as great too - the humour, the charm of the character and most of all the promise of how much more we could get out of a sequel that runs with the better parts of the original.
The marketing of Venom has done it a disservice, because it seems to be suggesting a body shock horror film that made everyone wish it was R-rated, when it should have been focusing on the fact that Venom is actually a cinematic cousin of Deadpool - outrageous, funny, ridiculous, rewarding... That's where Sony should have pitched this at audiences and they would have made more money out of it.
Now, let's just hope we can SOMEHOW get a movie where Spider-Man, Venom and Deadpool all get together. Marvel need to do the right thing.
2. The Effects (Mostly)
Despite the fact that the trailers were a little iffy with some of the effects work (and that recent commercial borrowing Hardy as a football mascot was downright horrific), the effects work in Venom is pretty brilliant.
The character himself looks great (even with the challenges of being a man made of shiny goop), the transitional sequences are great and the body shock stuff borrowed from or paying homage to David Cronenberg that IS in there is convincing and awful at the same time.
Clearly, there's been a lot of money spent on making this all work and even though the action sequences leave a little to be desired (aside for the choreography where Hardy genuinely looks like a rag-doll being puppetted by someone else), the effects and Venom's presence within them is all great.
1. Tom Hardy's Performance
This film is all about Tom Hardy and you can see why he lamented the missing footage that robbed us of the 40 minutes of film that he supposedly had the most fun making. He's had an absolute riot making this film and his duel performances as Eddie Brock and Venom deserve an awful lot more than the rest of the film provides for him.
There's something of Tyler Durden's bravado in his Venom, something of Vincent D'Onofrio's brilliant body-snatched performance in Men In Black in his Eddie Brock and some brilliant choreography that has him literally fighting with himself at times. He's funny, charming and self-effacing at times and enough of an Alex Jones-like douchebag at the start (albeit with a better moral compass) that you're sort of glad he becomes a loser and starts a two man Loser Band with Venom pretty quickly.
If there's not a sequel that hands Hardy even more control over how this story unfolds - in the same way Ryan Reynolds took over the Deadpool sequel - it will be an absolute travesty. Because we deserve to see more of the Tom Hardy/Venom show as soon as possible. It's really that good.
What did you think of Venom? Share your reactions below in the comments thread.