Warcraft Review – 4 Ups And 6 Downs
Still waiting on that great video game movie.

Rating:
You know those videos where some enterprising YouTuber takes all the cutscenes from a game and edits them together into a movie, except theres massive gaps where the gameplay would be, so everything's reliant on in-the-moment-randomness and ultimately makes no sense? A lets play without the play, essentially? Well thats what Warcraft is.
It's a confusing, empty film and, while it may not be quite as damnable as some are making out (it's no 2016 companion to Fant4stic or anything), it's a pretty resounding disappointment whatever your thoughts going into it.
The advertising didn't do much to instil faith, but I really wanted this one to be good. Its Duncan Jones. High-fantasy deserves better than all the Rings rip-offs since 2003. This year has already had its fair share of duds. But most of all, we need that break-out video game movie that doesnt suck and, while this tried hard, its flopped. Lets not get to the end of year and have Angry Birds (which is totally serviceable, even if its plot is garbage btw) be the best we could do. Its all up to you Fassbender.
But while we wait for Assassin's Creed, let's take a look back over Warcraft and look at the four ups and six downs from the much belated WoW movie.
The Ups:
4. Creative Visuals

For all its faults (which Ill get into, dont worry), Warcraft is still from Duncan Jones, who did such good jobs with Moon and the underrated Source Code its not even necessary to point out his celebrity Dad anymore.
And while it feels like his directorial freedoms been a little squished under the blockbuster weight, he still leaves a stamp on the film, especially in the visual department. The world of Azeroth looks gorgeous and distinct and, despite limited sets, sweeping shots linking them to the cartoony CGI world make everything feel big. And even though the action may not always capture the weight to all the warhammer smacking, there is care to make sure each fight feels a unique event.
The CGI is slightly more cartoony than were used to from the likes of The Lord Of The Rings and Game Of Thrones, but that mostly works to Warcraft's advantage and makes the cracks in the effects harder to spot.
3. You Experience Both Sides Of The Conflict

The basic story of Warcraft is the battle between orcs and humans. And even though itd be very easy to just tell it from the humans perspective because, well, were humans, we actually get to see the conflict from both sides.
In fact, if anything, we get more orc-ing about. We start the film in their world, prepping to venture over to the human realm, and much of the plot is driven by one invaders moral confusion. Beyond narrative balance, theres some cool ideas used to show this too the battle tactics vary, with humans agile against their enemies brute force and, in a move straight out of The Hunt For Red October, we jump from English to Orcish constantly, even in the same scene with a neat little audio effect.
The orcs are still clearly the bad guys, but its not as morally binary as even the pillars of the fantasy genre make it out to be.
2. The Motion-Capture Is Solid

A key part of making that duality work, and on a bigger scale giving an emotional throughline to the story, is that the motion-capture of the orcs is so on-point. You rarely think that the human characters are just flapping around a greenscreen play acting, and while thats in part down to solid effects, the main reason is in the actors breathing life into their sparring partners.
Despite being so caricaturish, the amount of full-body expression on all the orcs is phenomenal. It helps that theyre all led by Toby Kebbell hes basically next-in-line to the mo-cap crown at this point and excels at making Durotan, the main turncoat orc, emotive and nuanced.
Now there are some other issues with the orcs and how theyre portrayed, but Ill get to that in the downs.
1. The Video Game Inflections Are Well Balanced

Its a rule that every movie based on a game has to have some bit that contrives a key gameplaying mechanic into the story: Angry Birds was all about reclaiming eggs; Mario managed to namecheck everything in the most insensitive way possible; even Battleship had that ridiculous grid bit.
Warcraft predictably does this too, but its nowhere near as distracting or dominant as those examples. There's a nice extended shot where we see the orcs sacking villages from the same overhead angle as the game and other, smaller visual tics (like the spell casting and the way the hulking characters interact) provide nice acknowledgement to Warcraft's original medium without being out of place in the movie itself.
It's a shame the same cant be said about the other big thing that comes from the source. And that brings us neatly to the downs...
The Downs:
6. It Doesnt Explain The Mythology

Woe betide you if youve never played World Of Warcraft, because Warcrafts mythology is basically impenetrable. The film goes back to the early days of the mythos, but its background is still so dense that you can never get into those gorgeous worlds.
Nothing is explained. Places and peoples and warnings are tossed around like loose change and none of them make any sense. I dont really want to just point to The Lord Of The Rings, but thats a text book example of setting up a complicated world before diving into the minutiae - a similar tactic would have worked wonders here.
Look, theres nothing wrong with a franchise film having extra benefit for the pre-existing fanbase (Captain America: Civil War had loads of that), but it needs to offer some entry level for newcomers to get into it. Especially when it's a series that is lauded for such a great story.
5. The Plot Doesn't Make You Care

OK, youre already overwhelmed by the world were in, but maybe you can plug your ears to the noise and just enjoy the story at hand. Eh, not quite
The broad scope of the plot is easy enough to follow because its motivated by character decisions rather than intangible powers, but the characters are so uninteresting and their decisions so confusing - either rooted in that vague mythology or relying on random coincidence - that youre lost again.
Youll sit through action sequences but be distracted by trying to figure out how portals and fels and guardians all fit into why this orc is saving that human hes never met and... There were entire scenes where I had no idea what was going on and it was incredibly hard to not just give up.
4. The Editing Undoes The Orcs

I usually dont like to bring in contextual stuff into a review, but this ones too big to not. Duncan Jones has stated he cut out about forty minutes of fottage to get the movie prepped for release, something that's really hard to miss in the finished film.
It's had a big impact on the overall pacing for sure, although where its most immediately noticeable is with the orcs, managing to undermine a lot of that solid mo-cap grounding I talked about in Ups. Their personalities come across as flawed and indistinguishable, and character allegiances just jump back-and-forth from scene-to-scene; one good orc finds the time to betray both sides and suddenly our heros captured with no explanation.
Its so messy I was amazed the human characters could remember who they held grudges against (especially when you factor in the "Fel", which changes an orc's skin colour green at random intervals).
3. Orc Moses

Here's an unexpected Up for you Warcraft doesnt have a half-baked Jesus metaphor that is a total narrative tangent, has no place within the story its telling and exists only to go for the most baseless symbolism.
Cancelling-out Down it has a Moses one instead. Great...
2. The Tactless, Trope Heavy Script

Whats so disappointing about this being a Duncan Jones film is how much it just wallows in convention. His previous films felt fresh and unreliant on hard-fast genre tropes, but this one just repeats so much that weve seen before.
The dialogue is like the work of a video game script-writer circa 2005 - generic old-timey language mixed with fantasy inflections that the actors clearly dont fully understand - and delivers what exposition we do get in such an obvious way. Its also incredibly oddly structured, with lots of cheap narrative clichés popping up; something is revealed about a character and the next scene we see them doing that explicit thing.
Of course, some of this is going to stem from those problems in the edit, but that doesnt really excuse it at all.
1. The Finale Doesn't Work At All

Its kinda ironic that the films being called Warcraft: The Beginning internationally. Not just because getting a sequel looks incredibly unlikely, but because the film really cant get the ending to work.
It's becoming an increasingly common trend in recent blockbusters to have the final battle comes out of nowhere because the plot demands it, a likely by-product of studio mandates meddling with traditional narrative flow. But what we get in Warcraft is particularly ugly; nothing seems to fit as we barrel towards the conclusion and the battle itself has no sense of coherence.
Without going into spoilers, it breaks its own rules both on a story and mythological basis, introduces key concepts on the fly and manages to lose track of an entire army. If youre not 100% on board with the film when things kick off (and that's incredibly unlikely) then your reaction is going to be one ranging between confusion and disbelief.
Have you seen Warcraft? What did you think? Share your mix of ups and downs down in the comments.