What Does The Ending Of Blair Witch Really Mean?

Get in the corner and find out.

Blair Witch Woods
Lionsgate

When you boil it down, The Blair Witch Project is all about our fear of the unknown. Throughout the 1999 game-changer we never see the mysterious force that's tormenting the protagonists, and that's why the film still stands as a genuinely chilling experience; there's no explanation, no reason, just prolonged, sleepless terror.

On a basic level, that's what Blair Witch, the stealth legacy-quel nobody even knew was coming until a few months ago, is also about. A part remake, part ante-upping follow-on, Adam Wingard's film taps into that same fear - of the dark, of the woods, of what we sense but can't see - and it does it edge-of-seat-freezing effect.

But there's more to it that just that. The movie provides a major expansion of the Blair Witch mythology, carefully answering key dangling threads from the original, while also uses the seventeen year gap to pass comment on how much society has changed since the original. Let's break it down (but first, a quick recap).

So, What Is The Plot?

Lionsgate

Eighteen years after the events of The Blair Witch Project, a new tape surfaces from the Burkittsville woods. Original director Heather's brother, James, and his friends - Lisa, Peter and Ashley - believe it may be the clue to his sister's disappearance and as part of a film school project start shooting a documentary. Along the way they pick up local obsessives Lane and Talia, the couple who actually found the new tape.

After the first night, the gang wake up to find themselves surrounding by the iconic stick figures, which later turn out to be fakes made by the loc, who are forced away from the group. However, the film crew don't fare too well without them; their GPS stops working and after a day's walking they wind up back at the previous night's campsite. Things only get weirder from here, with flying tents, shock returns and strange infections.

And What Happens At The End?

Blair Witch
Lionsgate

Talia's back is snapped when Ashley breaks one of the wooden figures. Peter is crushed by a tree. Ashley is thrown out of a tree by some unseen figure and dragged away.

Then, as terror mounts, James and Lisa find the house. James is tricked and locked in a room by a mysterious apparition while Lisa is stalked by the Witch until she enters. She runs into Lane, now under the command of the Witch, who she ultimately kills, then runs upstairs, in doing so capturing the instigating video. Her and James are trapped in the attic, the Witch breaks in, they get in the corner to avoid her gaze, but eventually fall prey to her mind-games.

Pretty intense. Now let's try and crack what's going on with that witch.


What's The Deal With The Witch?

Lionsgate

In the original film, all that was really known about the Blair Witch was that she was a 1700s myth of dubious believability. There was little elaboration and absolutely nothing shown.

Blair Witch gives a lot more. Turns out the Witch was indeed tormenting the people of Blair centuries ago, until the townspeople revolted and hung her on a makeshift rack. Her spirit lived on, however, and after she murdered several townsfolk people fled, leaving a deserted settlement that was later repurposed as Burkittsville.

She now haunts the woods, a naked, gangly, heart-stopping presence barely glimpsed between the trees ensnaring anybody who dares stay the night in a deadly trap, with stick voodoo dolls, self-looping trails, strange infections, a transporting building and other telekinetic powers like toppling trees as if by lightening (there's also time travel, but that's so big it needs looking at by itself later). Biggest of all, she's so horrifically grotesque that simply looking at her will kill you instantaneously. This is how she gets Lisa and James at the end, playing on their fears to get them to turn around from that corner.

Crucially, she's also able to control victims into doing her bidding, something we see in the movie with Lane. What this means in context of the Coffin Rock massacre (where bodies were trussed up in a strange structure, then moved before officials arrived), is unclear, but it's likely it was her doing, either directly or by a controlled disciple.


And Rustin Parr?

Blair Witch Project Rustin Parr
Artisan Entertainment

As Lane says to Lisa near the end of the film, the only way to survive is to "do as she says". He's started obeying what the Witch commands him to do, which based on everything we've heard about him, seems to be what also happened to Rustin Parr.

As detailed in the first movie, in the early 1900s Parr killed seven kids in his cabin, now destroyed (a copy of which the Witch uses as part of her book of tricks), which was likely a spiritual link to the earlier, vengeful murders she committed shortly following her death. Afterwards, Parr was released from his curse and stumbled back down to Burkittsville, the last time any went up to the woods before 1996.

A big part of his killings was getting one of the kids to stand in the corner while he brutalised another, which was previously suggested to be because Parr didn't want the other children to watch him, but in the scope of the expanded mythology, is because the other child would die instantaneously looking at the Witch manipulating him. In some ways, he was actually protecting the children, showing some empathy in the face of the self-preserving acts he was doing, making him a more empathetic villain.


What Happened In The Original?

Blair Witch Ending
Artisan Entertainment

So if that's the truth behind the mythology, what does that tell us about what happened to Heather, Mike and Josh in 1999? Well, it's now clear that by simply venturing into the woods they were dooming themselves and that the mysterious goings on were resolutely the work of the Witch (something that was admittedly possible to conclude even then).

It's in the final act where things get interesting. Josh disappears, Heather and Mike end up in the transporting house where they're both are attacked from behind, in Heather's case with Mike in the corner.

Taking the logic of the world, the best conclusion to be drawn is that Josh, whose mind was more fragile than it seemed, evidenced in his scathing camera assault the evening before disappearing, was corrupted by the Witch, enacted his own torture, and then lured the remaining two to the cabin, where he split and murdered them on the Witch's command. Yes - a toothless Josh kills Heather.

The exact line of the Witch's involvement - she will have been behind the tent attack - is unknown, but the final physical attack must come from a human, hence Josh. Mystery solved.


The Witch's Time Travel

Blair Witch Time Travel
Lionsgate

An essential, newly introduced skill of the Witch is her ability to manipulate time. We first see this when everyone oddly sleeps in until 2pm, and is hammered home when Lane and Talia turn up after being lost for "six days", compared to the group's one, and Lisa's 7am alarm wakes her and James in the middle of the night. At the end, this is pushed to the extreme, with the Witch rushing through days in matter of seconds.

This particular power explains how the Witch is able to so easily ensnare victims, confusing and trapping them before having to physically alter the woods.

The big reveal, however, is that the film that inspired James to start off this whole journey is actually the one we're watching - it was shot by Lisa as she was running through the house, meaning we're dealing with an infinite closed loop; the Witch released the tape weeks in the past so she could ensure the gang would come to the woods.

While at first this may seem to be a new trick - the Witch can also go backwards in time - logically it's an extension of the time dilation, just on a much larger scale. Aside from allowing for a down-played twist and the snazzy lightening effect, however, this leads to a lot of big reveals about the other characters.


What Were Lane And Talia Up To?

Blair Witch Lane Talia
Lionsgate

When Lane and Talia found the plot-instigating clip of Lisa, they claimed it was the only usable bit of footage on the tape, something we now know to be false; quite how much footage was on that tape is unclear (presumably it starts after Lane is killed), but they'll have known that her and James would ultimately fall foul of the Witch, meaning they chose to use the unidentifiable part as bait.

All of this will have been motivated by their fascination with the legend and a desire to discover what exactly everybody in Burkittsville is afraid to say. Although them faking the first batch of stick figures may have dismissed them as frauds, they were actually as dangerous as the gang originally fear; they were fanatics playing into the myth, to the point Talia even questioned whether what they were doing - leading these people to certain death - was right.

Of course, while they were accidentally flirting with fate, doing the Witch's will before she's even got her claws into their mind, it still didn't end positively, with both falling foul of the time dilation and dying regardless of what they did for the spirit. In the end, the Witch has no allegiances and takes no prisoners or friends.


James Thought Lisa Was Heather

Blair Witch James
Lionsgate

The other major reveal with the tape is that James had mistaken Lisa for Heather. While that's fair enough - it's a split-second glimpse, Lisa's covered in mud and they're not dissimilar looking - it does provide a bit more of an in into James' psychology beyond holding out hope for finding his sister.

Throughout the movie we see that there's clearly some sexual tension between the pair, especially from James' side of things - they're far too quick to downplay being in the same tent and when things go to hell cuddle up. If he's mistaking the girl he fancies for Heather, it's clear his obsession over her disappearance goes beyond tricking himself into thinking she's survived.

There's something stilted in James' emotional development that almost has him dependent on finding Heather - even after admitting he was probably wrong, he still chases after what could be his sister - and that relationship shows it lies much deeper than it at first seems. He's destroyed by grief as first insinuated, sure, but it's developed into something more obsessive.


The Generation Gap

Blair Witch
Lionsgate

One of the big differences between The Blair Witch Project and the more sveltey titled sequel is the mentality of its heroes. Both are obnoxious film school types, but they're from different generations; Heather, Josh and Mike are stone-cold Gen-Xers, whereas James, Lisa and co are millennials.

This is immediately obvious in the attitudes of the characters. The new batch readily fall back on humour and an almost removed disbelief even after creepy things have started happening, and because this is a school project, rather than an attempt to genuinely make a piece of great cinema, they opt to head back to civilisation a lot more readily. This is how modern twenty-somethings would act, but it's not only here where Wingard distinguishes his 2016 film from the 1999 one; everything is ramped up, which reflects the trends of modern cinema.

You also have an element of meta legacy, as any good legacy-quel would have, with several characters directly influenced by the effects of the previous film; James is driven by the loss of his sister, a viewer looking for answers, while Lane and Talia are Blair Witch obsessives who've read every article (read: viral piece) and want to see what they've always suspected.


The Oversaturation Of Technology

Blair Witch Lisa
Lionsgate

The original Blair Witch Project came at a time where having a single video camera was rather novel, but its sequel hits when oversaturation of technology is the topic of the day. Heck, within reach of me right now I have two devices that can do everything involved in the production of The Blair Witch Project.

As such, there's a lot of different recording devices in Blair Witch: earpieces, SD cameras, tape cameras, drones, each with their own distinct shooting style and picture grain.

The film simply lets these elements be for much of the runtime, itself a reminder of how blaze we are about major technological leaps, only really drawing attention to it when we have multiple feeds to choose from. In the campsite scenes there can be as many as seven angles, and the film cuts frantically between them all as confrontations arise. It's a disorientating effect, and while Wingard doesn't push the theme through fully to conclusion, it does see him pass comment on the sheer amount of recordings we have in 2016.


An "Assembled" Story

Blair Witch 2016
Lionsgate

At the very start of Blair Witch we get the requisite found footage text cards that give us some context for the events. However, there's something very unique about this one; Wingard states that this was "assembled" from the footage that was, well, found. It's not just everything that was filmed, but a parsed down version.

Now this was also the case with The Blair Witch Project, which had sound from a single camera and swift cross-cutting, but the sequel's up-front about it, leading to a film that, while scrappily shot, has an element of structure, polish and almost an overseeing hand in the scares; rather than letting the horror sit, this modern take tries to inject some more in there. You have long, black pauses between set-pieces, very leading cross-cutting and even flourishes attempting to show the character's increasing psychological degradation.

Like with some of the previous points, it's not delved into enough to make a wider thematic point - there's certainly an opening for a discussion on storytelling technique and the effect of perspective - but it's definitely an example of Wingard taking a pre-existing horror trope, in this case the structure of a found footage film, and twisting it, having the story of the film permeate and influence the editing.

What did you make of the ending of Blair Witch? What was the film really about? Share your thoughts down in the comments.


In this post: 
Blair-Witch
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Film Editor (2014-2016). Loves The Usual Suspects. Hates Transformers 2. Everything else lies somewhere in the middle. Once met the Chuckle Brothers.