Why Batgirl Just Got Cancelled
The real reasons behind WB canning the DC superhero movie.
In what's no doubt going to go down as the weirdest movie news of the year, WB has just cancelled its upcoming Batgirl film.
Now, projects are cancelled all the time, even big-budget studio tentpoles (will we ever forget Marvel's promise of a big-screen Inhumans flick?), so what makes this one so special? Well, the fact that the studio had already sunk $90 million into the blockbuster, and the fact that it was nearing the end of its post-production process. It was pretty much done, and now it’s pretty much dead.
As first reported by the New York Post, WB's Batgirl, which was originally set for release in 2023, is being shelved indefinitely. The studio has since confirmed that it has decided to release the film neither in theatres nor on its flagship streaming service HBO Max, opting to take a near $100 million dollar loss.
The big question that remains now is simply, why? There were plenty of reasons to be excited for Batgirl - not least the all-star cast which would have seen fan-favourite Michael Keaton return as Bruce Wayne - and as a Batman spin-off that's near complete, it doesn't seem to make sense to not release it in some form.
The reality of the decision actually goes back a few years now though, and in the hours since the news dropped there have been numerous reports explaining why Batgirl just got cancelled.
6. WB Is On A Cancelling Spree
One of the major reasons behind Batgirl's sudden cancellation comes down to the simple fact that the WB of today is not the WB of even a year ago. A major part of that comes down to the company's merger with Discovery and the implementation of new CEO, David Zaslav.
Since Zaslav's appointment, every WB department has been completely overhauled, with multiple projects across the board getting the axe. In order to save money, WB Discover has been on a cancelling spree. CNN+ got canned despite a $300million spend, and recently WB's small-screen superhero offerings have been totally gutted.
In fact, Batgirl is not the only superhero project cancelled this week. A few days ago, The CW confirmed that The Flash would be ending following a shortened 13-episode final season. This actually plays into a larger restructuring process though, with The CW cancelling most of its big-budget scripted shows earlier this year (including Batwoman and Legends of Tomorrow) and then WB selling a majority stake in the company to Nexstar Media Group.
Nothing is safe under Zaslav's cost-cutting approach, and Batgirl is just one of many casualties.
5. Too Big For Streaming, Too Small For Cinemas
Another key change in the Zaslov era has been WB's approach to its theatrical and streaming service goals.
The previous regime had an ambitious goal for the then-new streaming service HBO Max. Not only was it going to put its biggest movies day and date on the service alongside their theatrical releases, but executives were opting to greenlight a bunch of mid-high budget movies around the $70million range to debut exclusively only HBO Max.
The plan was to rival the spectacle of original shows on Disney+ and Netflix without letting budgets spiral out of control, and Batgirl was one of the projects moulded around this approach. Greenlit for $70million (though that budget has reportedly bloated since), Batgirl was set to be a flagship title for the streamer.
That was the idea under the old regime though. According to reports, Zaslav had an entirely different view of how to approach movie and streaming distribution. The CEO has since ripped up those old plans, no longer releasing movies simultaneously in theatres and on streaming, and opting instead for bigger budget theatrical projects.
Deadline reports that Batgirl simply fell into a budgetary no-man's land: not flashy enough to compete with superhero tentpoles, and such WB is opting not to bother.
4. It's A Tax "Opportunity"
Though there's been a lot of speculation as to why Batgirl got cancelled, one reason is that not releasing it would apparently make WB more money than if it did.
According to Deadline, the official line is that the decision is down to "purchase accounting". Cancelling and writing the film off now, according to the report, "allows Warner Bros Discovery to not have to carry the losses on its books at a time when the studio is trying to pare down $3 billion in debt across its divisions."
This write up essentially says that Warners was faced with a choice: gamble on Batgirl and pump a load more money into reshoots to make it more of a tentpole and then splash out on marketing and hope it wins big, or write the film off and use this "purchase accounting" opportunity to write off some of its losses. Ultimately it decided on the latter.
This was also backed up by Variety, which stated that the decision was down to the decidedly un-sexy decision to save money by marking the film off as a "tax write-down".
3. Test Screenings Were Not Good
One of the first reasons touted as to why Batgirl got cancelled is simply that the movie sucked. In the New York Post article, the writer claimed that initial test screenings had not been promising. The report read:
"Those tests were said to be so poorly received by moviegoers that the studio decided to cut its losses and run, for the sake of the brand’s future. It’s a DC disaster."
Allegedly, WB head honchos worried that the brand would be "irredeemable" if the movie was bad, and as such got cold feet over the whole project.
Collider reporters also talked to people who had seen the test screenings and concurred that the reception was negative. In fact, they reported that Batgirl was distinctly cheap looking, with Keaton’s Batman outfit apparently being particularly shoddy.
However, other sources have contested that this was the main reasons, with Deadline explaining that their sources informed them that there was only one test screening, and it was more mixed than outright awful.
Either way it's clear the response wasn't glowing, and while this is probably not the main reason for the cancellation, the results probably didn't fill WB execs with confidence that Batgirl was worth taking a gamble on.
2. WB Wants To Save Characters For Other Movies
One interesting tidbit in the Deadline report suggested that part of the reason why WB cancelled Batgirl is that the studio had other plans for characters involved in the story.
As we know, the DCEU has received a creative shift internally, and plans previously laid down for its future have changed. Just this past month we've had confirmation that Ben Affleck is returning as Batman in Aquaman and the Lost Kingdom, alongside rumours that Henry Cavill may once again be suiting up as Superman. Of course there's also The Flash, which once again stars Affleck as well as Michael Keaton reprising his role as a multiversal Batman.
The Deadline report suggests that executives thought the re-appearance of actors like Keaton would be best saved for once of these tentpoles. It does make sense in a way: we haven't seen Keaton as Batman for decades, and his return would give the marketing for that movie a huge boost. Inherently, it would feel less special if fans had already seen him on HBO Max.
Still, that's an issue that should have been brought up years ago - not at a point where both movies are nearly complete.
1. DCEU's Future
With all of this restructuring and these cancellations then, what does the future of the DCEU look like?
Thankfully, reports claim that there should be no more surprise cancellations in the same vein as Batgirl. The future of DC movies seem to be decidedly focused on big-screen output, with Aquaman and the Lost Kingdom and The Flash both releasing next year. The Flash is reportedly still going ahead despite the bevvy of disturbing allegations levelled at star Ezra Miller, though reports indicate that the actor will not be reprising their role in future DCEU instalments.
Other than that, it has been reported that WB is searching for a Kevin Feige-esque figure in order to oversee their DC superhero movies. How that will impact upcoming movies such as The Batman sequel, Joker 2 and Wonder Woman 3 remains to be seen, but don't be surprised if there's a change of direction across the coming year, with some other projects yet to begin production getting the can.
WB is in a weird place, and Batgirl may be just one of many casualties to come.