Why The Mummy Was A Disaster

Not even Tom Cruise is flop-proof.

The Mummy Tom Cruise Annabelle Wallis
Universal

As it stands, the Tom Cruise-starring reboot of The Mummy is a dud, scoring thorough pannings from most critics and serving up a massively underwhelming box office gross to date, for though it generated the biggest opening of Cruise's career, it's still set to lose Universal $95 million in the long run.

So, what went wrong? Why was the new Mummy movie such a failure, even an abject disaster, both with reviewers and audiences? Why did Tom Cruise endure a rare career hiccup? And what does it say about the changing nature of the blockbuster landscape?

Blame can certainly point in a number of directions, but it's clear that the Dark Universe isn't off to a particularly encouraging start, and it'll be interesting to see how Universal's strategy shifts moving forward...

10. Nobody Asked For It

The Mummy
Universal

Perhaps the most blatant reason for The Mummy's critical and commercial failure is, simply, that audiences generally didn't ask for it.

The Brendan Fraser Mummy movies hold a special place in the hearts of millions of moviegoers, and few actually desired an out-of-nowhere retooling with Fraser being replaced by Tom Cruise.

When the project was first announced, the vocal online repsonse was a chorus of, "Why?", and post-release, that sentiment hasn't much changed.

Sure, there are movies that people never asked for, like the new Jump Street movies for instance, that turned out pleasantly surprising. However, these instances are major outliers, and generally if audiences en masse are ambivalent about a project pre-release, it's with good reason.


9. Tom Cruise Had Too Much Creative Control

The Mummy Tom Cruise
Universal

Following the movie's release, a report emerged which suggested that Tom Cruise had "excessive control" over the project, ordering significant script re-writes and essentially being the project's driving creative force, far more so than inexperienced director Alex Kurtzman.

Cruise apparently even had a say in post-production, how the movie was marketed, and its release date, and considering the movie's lack of strong success, it's hard not to see his commanding role as ultimately detrimental to the project.

Filmmaking is, of course, a collaborative medium, and if the reports that Cruise essentially strong-armed the production are true, then he may have benefited from listening to his colleagues a little more.


8. Over-Eagerness To Build A Franchise

Dark Universe
Universal

The Mummy is the first movie in Universal's Dark Universe, an attempt to build a Marvel Cinematic Universe-esque world which will eventually include the likes of The Wolfman, The Invisible Man, The Bride of Frankenstein, Van Helsing, Dracula and so on.

The problem is that large chunks of the film just feel like an advertisement for this shared universe, especially whenever Russell Crowe's Dr. Jekyll is on screen.

Sometimes audiences just want to watch a standalone movie without being sold a dozen other films in the bargain, and The Mummy's attempt to promote its follow-ups just felt desperate. How's about making one good film before committing to more?


7. The Tone Was All Wrong

The Mummy Tom Cruise Jake Johnson
Universal

The Brendan Fraser films had a very specific tone that worked incredibly well, resembling a breezy, fun B-movie, but also throwing in some legitimately disturbing moments of violence when the titular antagonist attacked.

The new movie, though, jettisons this formula and reimagines The Mummy as a far more generic, formulaic blockbuster. It tries to be funny and largely falls flat, while the new villain is far less imposing than Imhotep, and simply feels nowhere near as threatening.

Universal clearly tried to make the safest, most sanitised movie possible, and ironically audiences didn't turn out for it in droves like they expected. The cynicism didn't pay off, thankfully.


6. It Was Savaged By Critics

The Mummy Rotten Tomatoes
Universal / Rotten Tomatoes

Yes, a big factor in the movie's underwhelming financial performance so far is those pesky critics and their absolutely savage reviews of the film.

Pre-release it seemed like The Mummy was probably going to score mixed reviews on Rotten Tomatoes, say 30-50%, given how few total critical bombs Tom Cruise has to his name. Then the reviews came out and they were some of the year's worst for a major Hollywood release, which surely put a huge dent in its financial success.

Yes, a lot of dumb blockbusters are critic-proof, and this is absolutely the sort of movie that will always fare better internationally, but even so, the film's consistent panning from the press and everything that's been written about it post-release are surely to blame for it being such a financial disappointment.


5. A Lack Of Compelling Female Characters

Annabelle Wallis The Mummy
Universal

It's staggering how blockbuster cinema often still struggles to come up with compelling, meaningful female roles, most often pigeonholing them as the damsel-in-distress or arbitrary eye candy.

The Mummy isn't much of an exception, with Annabelle Wallis' Jenny Halsey having such little agency, being rescued by Tom Cruise numerous times, and worse still, being charmlessly performed by Wallis.

Though Sofia Boutella does well enough in the antagonist role, it's still an underwhelming, underwritten part that pales massively compared to Imhotep from the Fraser movies.

Considering that women are 50% of a potential audience, it's absolutely shambolic that they continue to get such a skewed treatment in major tentpole films like this, and as a result it's no surprise that women would be turned off going to see it.


4. Reboot Fatigue

the mummy tom cruise
Universal Pictures

The reboot trend has been going on for a while now, and though there are absolutely some successes in that arena, it also seems that audiences are getting a little fatigued with it.

Consider the recent likes of Ghostbusters, Power Rangers and Baywatch, all big-budget retoolings of classic franchises that fell on deaf ears with audiences, if not critics too.

Viewers are tired of seeing their childhoods lazily dredged up for easy money driven by nostalgia, and The Mummy's underwhelming box office performance is a further testament to that. That's not to say a Mummy reboot was always doomed, but one this transparently cynical absolutely was.


3. The Marketing Made It Into A Joke

The Mummy Tom Cruise
Universal

The Mummy struggled right out of the gate thanks to an infamous marketing gaffe which turned one of the movie's trailers into a meme. Back in December, Universal accidentally released a version of the movie's trailer without the correct sound mix, which gained notoriety online for Tom Cruise's dubbed-over scream, which was clearly re-recorded by someone else.

Though some suspected Universal deliberately leaked the incomplete trailer in order to "meme-ify" the film and heighten its box office potential, it doesn't seem likely, considering it just led to people mocking it rather than professing it a must-see movie.

Plus, even with the trailer screw up, The Mummy failed to track high on social media chatter leading up to its release, so the writing for its mediocre showing was very much on the wall.


2. Tom Cruise Was Totally Miscast

Tom Cruise Annabelle Wallis The Mummy
Universal

It's very clear that Universal felt like they could just throw Tom Cruise into this movie and it would be a major hit, considering his general aptitude for picking sturdy projects and his consistent box office success.

However, just as Baywatch proved, a beloved movie star can't always sell a bad movie, and aside from Cruise just not having enough pull to make the movie a big hit, he was so, so wrong for the part.

Cruise succeeds at playing unstoppable heroes with an iron will who overcome the odds, not a**hole treasure hunters who the audience is encouraged to warm to over the course of the movie. It's just not his strength, especially in the blockbuster arena, and the part of the smarmy douche you end up liking would've been much better-suited to, say, a Chris Pratt or Bradley Cooper.


1. It Went Up Against Wonder Woman

Wonder Woman Gal Gadot
Warner Bros.

And finally, The Mummy hit screens the week after Wonder Woman, which has massively exceeded both critical and commercial expectations so far, so audiences largely went to see that instead, while those still vaguely interested in The Mummy will probably catch it on Netflix later in the year.

Plus, with The Mummy representing women so poorly, Wonder Woman was an easy sell for female audiences looking for their blockbuster fix. Going up against a superhero movie, even a DC one, is always a risky bet, and it absolutely didn't pay off for this film. That the gulf of quality between the two projects is so huge only makes it that much worse.

Why do you think The Mummy reboot turned out so terribly? Shout it out in the comments!


Watch Next


Contributor
Contributor

Stay at home dad who spends as much time teaching his kids the merits of Martin Scorsese as possible (against the missus' wishes). General video game, TV and film nut. Occasional sports fan. Full time loon.