Why X-Men: Dark Phoenix Failed

A critical mauling and $100m lost? Ouch.

Dark Phoenix RT
Fox

The X-Men movie franchise has lost its way a few times since Bryan Singer's X-Men gave birth to it back in 2000. In fact, when you look back, it's quite remarkable that the series managed to recover from The Last Stand, X-Men: Origins and the most recent disappointment of Apocalypse, which dribbled its way to a 47% Rotten Tomatoes score and was considered an embarrassment.

But then, you can take those losses if your franchise also has high-points as high as Logan, X-2 and Deadpool 2. It's all just swings and roundabouts and usually, if something goes wrong, we get something great to balance it. The problem for Dark Phoenix, which currently sits on just 23% on Rotten Tomatoes and is headed towards a deeply uninspiring box office return. In fact, it's not only scored the worst debut of the 2019 summer movie season, it's also managed to earn the worst ever opening for any X-Men movie.

This movie was supposed to be the start of a new trilogy and would be followed by something new and different in the shape of New Mutants, but then everything changed and Dark Phoenix has ended up being something of a disaster.

So, how did it all go so terribly wrong?

7. The Production Tale Over-Shadowed The Release

Dark Phoenix Sophie Turner
Fox

Without getting too deep into what actually happened with all of the reshoots (because that's coming up very soon in this exploration), any film release conversation that is so heavily defined by talk of production problems and which very visibly gets shunted around the release calendar is starting from a poisoned position.

You have to take into account what that looks like to an audience demographic made up of people who have now been bred to expect "reshoots" to be indicative of failure even before release. After all, the sensational take on reshooting is that it's a lack of faith from the people who MADE the thing and that's very much what audiences are now fed.

To a certain extent, Fox's marketing campaign was always going to be overshadowed by the decision to move the movie several times, by the extensive, expensive reshoots and by talk of a "difficult" test screening period. Fox failed to manage what came out and how it was transmitted and it killed the film on arrival.


6. Franchise Fatigue

Logan Xmen
20th Century Fox

This isn't a point on the superhero bubble bursting or even about the unwillingness of fans to come out for the X-Men brand, because neither are true entirely and the context of Dark Phoenix requires some slightly more specific thinking. Because the franchise fatigue for this franchise, in particular, comes from the fact that they've already killed it. Twice.

First, you have to consider Deadpool and how Ryan Reynolds' acerbic, witty superhero pastiche takes down the conventions the entire X-Men franchise had been built on. Even though they stuck him in what amounts to an annex and suggested (without completely clarifying) that he existed in an alternate universe, the Deadpool movies effectively became a fourth-wall-breaking, meta-loving spoof take-down. And once you get to the point of spoofery, the thing you're spoofing is dead. It's pretty much the rules.

And then, more importantly, there's Logan, which SHOULD have been the ending point to this entire franchise. The story was the perfect end, while offering a hint of a future with an X-23 movie: we'd seen the X-Men killed, Hugh Jackman's definitive Wolverine retired and something that just all round felt like the perfect full-stop.

To then reset and have to get back into a continuing story off the back of Apocalypse, which hadn't gone down well with fans at all anyway, was enough to give you whiplash. Assuming you could even muster up enough concern for the film, anyway.


5. The Rewritten Third Act

Dark Phoenix Fight
20th Century Fox

There has been some talk that Dark Phoenix was rewritten over concerns that it was too much like Captain Marvel - partly because James McAvoy hinted as much in an interview before it came out - but according to Deadline, that's just not true. The timeline wouldn't have fit, for a start, because it would have relied upon anyone working on Dark Phoenix having prior knowledge of Captain Marvel's plot before it came out. It's simply not possible.

But that doesn't mean the reshoots get a free pass, because the inspiration for them almost doesn't matter. It's the IMPACT of them that matters most and that's way beyond what's already been said about it impacting fan expectations. Reshoots happen all the time - in actual fact, Dark Phoenix was reshot less than Days Of Future Past.

Apparently, the third act was said to be set in space, which fits with how much Simon Kinberg talked up the cosmic elements of the story way back before we knew all that much about it. Hell, that was an exciting thing for fans who wanted Dark Phoenix to be something different and something fresh - for those plans to be scrapped for an Earth-set train heist that felt a little too similar to the train heist in Deadpool 2 was an awful revelation. Particularly because everyone was told about it before the film came out.

Again, it's impossible for any movie to really get over negative earworms and something as instantly marketable as the story that Kinberg and Fox scrapped the ending and rewrote it after making it once (which is how it was spun) is a killer.


4. It Is WAY Too Serious

Dark Phoenix Jessica Chastain Jean Grey
20th Century Fox

X-Men: Apocalypse has a lot to answer for when it comes to the tonal mistakes of Dark Phoenix. That more camp, sillier film tanked critically and was widely called the worst ever X-Men movie (harsh words, but it's not hard to find them repeatedly used online) with particular focus on the more outrageous elements and the slightly strange tone. It was too camp, too zany and Oscar Isaac's titular villain was too pantomimey by half.

Naturally, because the response to any "failure" pin-pointed to those sorts of issues is for people involved to promise that the next time things will be darker or grittier, that's what happened here. Interviews appeared with those promises and Fox absolutely sought to make a darker film.

The problem with that is they released it when you don't release dark films. Say what you want about the shifting release patterns of recent years, but summer blockbusters are not dark and complex and even if Dark Phoenix fails to be as complex as it wanted, it aspires to be both of those compared to Apocalypse.

Releasing it in February as planned would have matched its tone far better, because it's fundamentally an on-season blockbuster. Unfortunately, Fox Studios CEO Stacey Snider insisted on the change to give Alita: Battle Angel more space and screwing Dark Phoenix not only on the tonal disparity but also by putting it out after Captain Marvel and Endgame both scored major victories for Marvel. It was in a graveyard before it was even alive.


3. The Marketing Errors

Jean Grey Dark Phoenix
Fox

It's fair to say that Dark Phoenix's first trailer didn't exactly light the world up and unfortunately the entire marketing campaign has had issues. Again, you can't not mention the fact that the studio's publicity team failed to manage the reshoot leaks, which could have been minimised far better rather than becoming absolutely disastrous in audience perceptions.

But the trailers were a problem too. They never seemed to fully capture the tone we'd been promised (particularly if you were expecting a more cosmic X-Men movie) and then the decision to show Mystique's death in the second trailer quite overtly was just baffling. Why would anyone in their right mind think that confirming a bankable brand like Jennifer Lawrence's was going to be killed off early (which is what placement in the trailer confirmed absolutely) was a good idea?

Even looking at reports from the marketing on what internal sources THINK should have happened in the marketing suggests they just didn't have the right people in the right positions. According to one Deadline source, the marketing failed because they didn't take advantage of Sophie Turner's physical attractiveness:

"Sophie Turner is a beautiful actress, and they never showed that in any of the marketing materials. Instead, they made her look like a zombie.”

Maybe it did have an impact, but that definitely makes it sound like Fox's marketing team for this was just broken.

They should have taken a leaf out of Venom and Suicide Squad's books. Both were badly reviewed, but their marketing campaigns pushed how fun the movies were. Both were really championed and it looked like the studios were proud of what they made. Fox released a trailer for Dark Phoenix and then changed the release date while the trailer they'd JUST released had the wrong release date on it. Perception is everything.


2. We've Seen This Story Before

X Men The Last Stand Dark Phoenix Jean Grey Famke Janssen Sophie Turner
Fox

If you're remaking something that lots of people hated, rule number one is to make damn sure that you're letting every one of the fans who were disappointed that first time that it's completely different and thus worth their time. That simply never happened in the marketing campaign.

The result, inevitably, saw mainstream fans wondering why Fox were bothering to try again with something that simply hadn't worked the first time because so little was done to address this being a fresh take. It always felt like a retread and like Fox were simply taking advantage of the opportunity provided by Days Of Future Past to tackle an iconic storyline.

The same thing happened with The Amazing Spider-Man movies, which purported to remake Spider-Man's origin story in a fresh way, but which never managed to get away from the fact that their reboot was so close to the original. And while The Last Stand was a benchmark Fox should have been confident of clearing with Dark Phoenix, they failed to get around fans keeping The Last Stand's take on the story as the original one.


1. The Disney Deal

Disney Plus Logo
Disney

A lot of the issues talked about already - particularly the marketing issues - come down to one of the most exciting developments for Marvel fans in recent years. Not so long ago, rumours started to swirl that Disney wanted to buy Fox and would be able to bring key Fox-owned Marvel characters like the X-Men and the Fantastic Four into the MCU. Naturally, we all lost our minds at how exciting it would be to have an X-Men Vs Avengers movie.

For insiders at Fox, the impending deal was more nightmarish. The looming deal led to big changes at executive level, particularly in the marketing department, meaning the film-makers were stuck dealing with a revolving roster of executives. That's far from ideal when you want to get a clear advertising message out.

And then there's the way the Disney deal impacted fans too. As soon as we started to think about the possibility of an X-Men movie in the MCU, both Dark Phoenix and New Mutants became inherently redundant. They weren't the X-Men movies fans really wanted to see, because those ones - we were repeatedly told - wouldn't be made for years. But they were still coming and their shadows still loomed large over two movies that looked like little more than unwanted hangovers for Disney.

Whether it's anywhere near the truth or not, Dark Phoenix became a loose end in fans' eyes and while some might have seen it as a free swing for the fence with no stakes going forward that ultimately ended up being an issue for it too. We were basically presented with a strange situation where we knew a reboot was coming, but the thing being rebooted hadn't even been released yet. That was never ideal, frankly.

What did you think of Dark Phoenix? Share your thoughts below in the comments thread.


Watch Next


X-Men Quiz: Who's That Mutant?

Who's That Mutant Wolverine
Marvel

Who's That Mutant?

Contributor
Contributor

WhatCulture's former COO, veteran writer and editor.