Will Smith: 5 Awesome Performances And 5 That Sucked

Big Willy style.

With Suicide Squad set to begin filming as soon as someone sorts out the screenplay, Will Smith has a lot on his hands at the minute, and today sees the latest addition to his CV, in the shape of con caper Focus. Early buzz suggests it's a mixed bag, but at least it offers an opportunity to see Smith and Suicide Squad co-star Margot Robbie on screen together. Since first appearing on screens back in 1990 as The Fresh Prince of Bel Air, following his musical breakthrough, Smith hasn't acted in as many films as an actor of his stature could have. He famously turned down roles he should probably regret like Superman And Django Unchained, though he also turned down The Matrix and it's terrible sequels, so being restrained clearly isn't all that bad. But despite some smart decisions, Smith has also signed on to some seriously questionable films: for every Oscar-nominated turn like Ali, there's something that nags insistently that he's not quite as great an actor as he's billed. So with that in mind, here's a comprehensive look at his best films alongside his five worst, proving that the man who will play Deadshot's aim isn't always true...


5 Awesome Performances...

5. Paul - Six Degrees Of Separation

Who would have thought that the rapper/actor who was making his name making shapes and splitting sides as the infamous Fresh Prince would offer such a fantastic, measured performance in a film like Six Degrees Of Separation as his first real stand-out role? Long before Smith was cutting his teeth as a tent-pole action star in Independence Day, and while he was still only halfway through his tenure on The Fresh Prince Of Bel Air, the very young actor starred alongside a hugely impressive cast (including Sir Ian McKellen and Donald Sutherland no less) in Fred Schepisi's drama of high-class deception. Smith's performance as Paul, the cuckoo con-man who prayed on socialites by pretending to be one of their own was a revelation, especially considering his comparative lack of experience, and it is he, along with Grease's Stockard Channing who really sell the film. He is charismatic and charming, and utterly sells the constructs of his conniving character, to the extent that he never loses our empathy. Interestingly, as well as marking Smith's transition to dramatic acting, Six Degrees also featured a brief appearance by JJ Abrams.

4. Agent J - Men In Black III

Though his first performance as Agent J was great, Smith was still very wet behind the ears, and he was very much playing the younger side of the central dynamic, which comes with very different requirements. He was given licence to be cocky and arrogant and protected by his charisma and the freshness of youth, but the emotional weight was notably absent. That changed in the third Men In Black film, which replaced the grotesquely out-of-sorts "comedy" of the second film with a great story, a strong script and good cast additions. It also added weight where it hadn't existed before, exploring J's back-story and explaining the relationship between J and K that was utterly irresistible and disarmingly heart-breaking. In the third film, Smith is far more mature, and brings more of his leading man presence, and it enriches a performance that could have been seen as a fatal over-extension of the franchise.

3. Chris Gardner - The Pursuit Of Happyness

Often accused of being Oscar-bait, The Pursuit Of Happyness is instead a triumph of simple, dramatic human story-telling. The film, based on the true story of Chris Gardner, could well have ended up in a daytime TV slot, thanks to the almost cliched redemptive element of the story, but the star quality of Smith, and the money-can't-buy chemistry between the lead and his son Jaden drove it well above that level. Smith's performance is wounded and perpetually on the verge of breaking - he is a picture of vulnerability, mixed with a furious need to protect his family, and driven by a singular desire to do better for himself and his son. He is the archetypal rags to riches character, utterly charismatic and engaging, thanks to his love and devotion to his son in even the starkest situations, and the performance could never have worked as well in another actor's hands. Watching Smith stumble and fall, before reaching his ultimate goal is hugely affecting, even despite some sticky accusations of tweeness, and there is certainly something in his presence that sells that arc better than most could.

2. Muhammad Ali - Ali

For an actor who has worked for more than 20 years in prominent roles, Smith hasn't actually taken on as many jobs as others in his position would perhaps have. He has clearly reserved his choice to work for certain projects - whether because they appealed to his agenda to become the biggest film star in the world, or because they were locked into a particularly strong franchise - and it seems he enjoys a particular type of role. He enjoys a triumph over adversity story, and being the shining hero, and he also clearly has a thing for stories based on real life tales. But then, why wouldn't he, considering his prowess in such roles (this is, after all, the third "real" character to make this list?) And Ali must have been as easy a choice for him as Ray was for Jamie Foxx. Ali presented Smith with the opportunity to blend the two things he had built his career on: slightly-arrogant charm, and an enduring everyman appeal that made his stories completely irresistible. The role was never going to be easy, but the actor was perfectly cast, and his version of Muhammad Ali is a celebration of the man, without ever becoming an over-wrought parody through perfectionism, and you get the sense that there is as much of Smith in the performance as there is of Ali.

1. Will - The Fresh Prince Of Bel-Air

Someone needs to resurrect The Fresh Prince Of Bel-Air - whether for Where Are They Now? style movie, or for a final reunion series - because those characters we grew up with still have a huge amount of appeal even to generations who didn't necessarily get to see it air first time round. Fresh from near-bankruptcy, Smith took on the role of Will, a charmer from the West Philly, born and raised on the streets who found himself in the ultimate culture clash situation, living with his rich aunt and uncle in the affluent Bel-Air area. He was like the ugly duckling, or the black sheep, a cause for embarrassment, but never victimised by the show's comic gaze, and thanks to Smith's endless charm and comic prowess (both in terms of timing and physical comedy) he was the most unlikely of enduring heroes. As part of a great cast, Smith shone brightest, and his chemistry with each of the other characters was what sold the show, and gave it the longevity to still be relevant enough to overshadow the actor's auspicious career achievements even now when he lands on chat show couches. And now on to the performances that sucked...

5 Performances That Sucked...

5. Hancock - Hancock

On paper, Hancock had a lot of appeal, but someone decided to take a dark but brilliant script and tone it down in such a way that the darker elements that remained gave the film a jarring personality disorder. The film - which initially would have featured Hancock committing crimes including rape - never quite knows what it is, stumbling from clever post-superhero film, to traditional actioner to tragedy-tinged romance with misplaced classical aspirations. And sadly, the lack of strong identity is catastrophic for Will Smith's performance. He begins on good form, offering an irresistible anti-hero - the kind of washed-up hero that fans of late-era Westerns and late-career John Wayne movies would recognise as the hero without a purpose - but the shift in tone means he becomes almost immediately uninteresting as soon as Charlize Theron turns up. Smith was well cast - though an actor more suited to darker material may have meant less changes to the initial direction - but the material is so horribly lost, that his performance is only memorable for the first fifteen minutes or so, and by the end it's hard to even care what happens to him.

4. Agent J - Men In Black II

Having scored a big win with the first film - his star-maker movie - Smith returned to the sequel no doubt full of confidence for a similar success. Sadly though, the scriptwriters, director and casting team turned up with a misplaced sense of confidence in a shoddy product. And Johnny bloody Knoxville. From the outset, Smith is forced to push water up a hill, and the result is a larger than necessary performance that for some reason seeks to follow Knoxville's grotesque pantomime villain into the gutter, and which seems - obscenely - to believe that the comedy is actually any good. And it's that seemingly numb-headed commitment to the material that is the most distressing thing about it.

3. Detective Mike Lowrey - Bad Boys 2

Apologists of Will Smith's poorer career moves will no doubt point out that two of his terrible performances listed here have come from sequels that he probably couldn't choose not to do for fear of derailing the entire franchises, but that's no excuse for those films. Men In Black 2 is problematic, misusing Smith entirely, and robbing him of most of the things that made his performance so appealing in the first film, but Bad Boys 2 is a more unforgivable misstep. The film pushes its loose cannon cops on a personal vendetta agenda too far, and suffers most for Michael Bay's now characteristic lack of restraint. Instead of getting a funny buddy cop movie with edge (which was how the first film succeeded,) we get a sillier romp, featuring drug-filled cadavers exploding during a car chase and rats having sex in the missionary position. Jokes that Bay probably loved, in other words, but which made the film a tasteless, sun-drenched mess that reduced Smith to a caricature, and almost - fatally - a clown.

2. After Earth

M Night Shyamalan has a lot of things he should apologise for, and most of them come from his wayward Blockbuster Period when he started using millions of dollars to ignore everything that had made his smaller films even worthy of note. The straw that broke the camel's back (since he's going back to indies, apparently forever) was this bloated, bland sci-fi with a despicably bad script and some horribly wooden acting from Smith and his real life son. Who definitely hasn't profited from any nepotism. Smith looks bored for most of the film, and confused for the rest of it, like someone who has been impregnated with catastrophic self-awareness just after signing a water tight contract. But at least he might have killed Shyamalan's blockbuster career.

1. Capt. James West - Wild Wild West

Wild Wild West could well be one of the most famous turkey in Hollywood history, thanks to a certain Kevin Smith Superman movie, and some deliriously odd creative choices that nailed the lid on the Western's coffin, before some much smarter film-makers started making revisionist genre additions years later. Smith plays former Civil War hero Jim West, an all-guns-blazing hero, forced to work with Kevin Kline's US Marshall with a penchant for disguises, and his performance is completely destroyed by a ridiculous plot, a comically poor script and the director's obvious belief that building a steam-punk Wild West would be enough to hide the fact that he has no idea how to create likable human characters. Wild Wild West feels like an ADHD fever dream, with a giant mechanical spider thrown in to distract from some serious problems at its heart, and though Smith and Kline struggle manfully to offer memorable performances, they're doomed from the start, and there's no room for anyone to escape this particular monstrosity with any dignity intact. Did we miss any of your favourite or least favourite Will Smith performances? Share your own picks below.

Contributor
Contributor

WhatCulture's former COO, veteran writer and editor.