Will Smith: 5 Awesome Performances And 5 That Sucked

Which shots hit their target and which were dead in the water?

Remember when the Big Willie Weekend was a thing? Will Smith, rapper-cum-sitcom-star-cum-blockbuster-king was so beloved by general audiences that having his big mug on a poster was enough to almost guarantee a box office success? Yeah, seems a long time ago now, doesn't it.

Despite repeatedly proclaiming himself the "biggest movie star in the world", he's had a bit an up and down time since his 90s heydey; there's been big successes in dramas, sci-fis and everything in between, but as time's gone he's lost his magic touch and turned out a fair few flounderers. And then there's all the stuff with Jaden (although, like the Smith's at Christmas dinner, we don't talk about Jaden).

Well, you can bet Smith's hoping for things to come back with Suicide Squad, which is out today; although it's an ensemble piece, he's clearly positioned as the lead, with the most screentime and biggest emotional arc. Sadly, the film itself isn't up to much (you can read our assessment here) and Smith's part is another case of his trademark character type having an overbearing impact on the script. He's good, but it's not anything like his best. Although it's thankfully not his worst either.

And, on that note, let's look at the two sides of Will Smith, taking in five of his most awesome performances and five that just plain sucked.


5 Awesome Performances:

5. Agent J - Men In Black

Will Smith Men In Black
Sony Pictures

The first Men In Black feels a bit kitsch now, with clunky model work, early CGI and a very 90s vibe. Just look at that video. But what makes it still rewatchable is Will Smith’s Agent J. With any other actor playing it straight, this would be just another alien invasion film, but Smith leads with the right balance of disbelief, all-out shock, forced cool and genuine cool.

It needs Tommy Lee Jones to riff off, sure, but that’s no discredit to either half of the double act. Although that is why I can't quite count the sequels. The second one flips the pair's roles, but uses it to be a retread, not an advancement, and the third is tired, with Smith lost his trademark charm.


4. Robert Neville - I Am Legend

I Am Legend Will Smith
Warner Bros. Pictures

I Am Legend isn’t a great movie. It wastes a thrilling sci-fi concept, boasts some of the most unengaging creature design imaginable and the butchering of the ending is legend (pun very much intended).

But through all that Smith is solid, especially in the first half where it’s just him and Sam working their way around an empty New York populated only by those zombie-vampire things, where he calmly and methodically deals with surmounting problems. Even the saccharine flashbacks to his lost family back an emotional punch.

Heck, even when things take a turn for the crap in the final act, he’s still a likeable reluctant hero. It’s just a shame the rest of the film doesn’t come in around him and instead has to go the usual Smith-movie hero route.


3. Muhammad Ali - Ali

Will Smith Ali
Columbia Pictures

Ali is Will Smith’s most “acting-y” role. A physical biopic that sheds some light on an iconic figure (in this case Muhammad Ali), this could have easily been an obvious attempt to turn mainstream appeal into awards recognition (like, y’know, Concussion), but it isn’t. It’s a solid movie; not a boxing classic like Raging Bull, but an interesting dissection all the same.

Oddly, Smith is better in the physical parts than he is the trademark barbs that defined the real-life Ali, but he’s helped along by Michael Mann’s assured directing hand.

It’s just a shame he’s not really followed it up with anything comparable. Well, aside from Concussion, which is so bland it doesn’t make either side of this list.


2. Chris Gardner - The Pursuit of Happyness

The Pursuit Of Happyness Will Jaden Smith
Warner Bros. Pictures

Today the thought of a Will-Jaden team-up is enough to make you want to burn all of Hollywood to the ground, but back in 2006 it was only something you’d maybe commit first-degree arson for. So, not great, but you'd take it.

The Pursuit of Happyness was a rather big surprise then. It looked to be Smith the Elder forcibly trying to show how sensitive he was now he’s a father, but is actually a really rather affecting film about the power of the human spirit entirely anchored by the father-son performance. In stark contrast to his public persona, you can totally buy Smith as a struggling man with a dream and are won over almost immediately. The ending is the absolute definition of feel-good.


1. Steven Hiller - Independence Day

Will Smith Independence Day
20th Century Fox

The original Independence Day has so much good stuff in it. The massive destruction sequences, the speech, the themes of global unity, the Star Wars-aping fights, the unrelenting iconography - but what brings it all home is the characters. They’re broad yet accessible, and make you care about everything going on.

And the standout is Captain Steven Hiller. He’s not the President dealing with the invasion or a scientist who predicted it or a cropduster who was anally probed (probably). He’s the family man who sleeps through the invasion and has big dreams but relatable barriers, and eventually steps up to the plate in a massive way. His level of seriousness is exactly how the film wants to be taken.

It’s no coincidence that he chose to not return for Independence Day: Resurgence and that the movie was a charisma-less bore.

Not everything in Will Smith’s career’s fireworks though. Here’s five times his desperation for a Big Willy Weekend failed spectacularly.


And 5 That Sucked:

5. Del Spooner - I, Robot

I robot
20th Century Fox

I, Robot is a perfect example of a film ruined by being a “Will Smith Picture”. There’s an interesting movie behind the concept of a robot going rogue that immerses itself in the works of Asimov, but I, Robot is really only paying lip-service to the sci-fi master and the script has clearly been smashed to pieces so Smith gets all of his required cool dialogue.

It’s Smith on exuberant auto-pilot, going through his affable schtick without ever engaging or trying to add something to the story. This isn’t Men In Black, where Smith-ism add to the tone, it’s meant to be a semi-serious action movie. Instead it’s oddly boring.


4. Nicky Spurgeon - Focus

Focus Will Smith Margot Robbie
Warner Bros. Pictures

After the failure of a certain movie that you can bet will appear later on in this list, Smith says he realised he wasn’t in the 90s any more and was really going to push himself with his project choices.

Then he did Focus.

It’s just another of those movies where it feels like the finished script has been butchered to advance the Smith brand, sometimes to a ridiculous degree. There’s a scene where a character we later find out is Will’s father criticises Smith because he doesn’t understand younger generation and their use of Twitter. WHAT?! Smith is 47 and doesn’t use Twitter. Stop pretending it’s 1998.

Beyond that though, it's not all that different from his other roles. He's still super suave, he's still a badass, and he still wins in the end.


3. Jim West - Wild, Wild West

Warner Bros.

Wild, Wild West isn’t just a bad Will Smith movie, it’s a terrible movie that pretty much signalled the end of an entire era of the star-led Hollywood and capped out a run of massive flops for Warner Bros. But it is still a bad Will Smith movie though.

Jim West is treated as if he has the usual Smith charm, but is never once actually endearing or funny. He just looks so unengaged, only showing emotion when he’s OTT in the fights, and while that’s likely the point, it doesn’t make for an exciting hero. It's a grind to watch, and was the first time most audiences realised Smith wasn't this infallible force of great acting.

The only time he seems to get into it is the tie-in rap video. And that’s another kind of awful.


2. Oscar - Shark Tale

Shark Tale Will Smith
Dreamworks

Shark Tale was the first movie I remember seeing in the cinema and going “nope, nadda, not for me”.

I mean, it was early-naughties Dreamworks, so it was never going to be anything all that amazing, but f*ck me. Shark Goodfellas? Whale wash? The most hackneyed of “This is how Pixar do it, right?” plots?

Smith’s exuberance should really work in a kids film, but he’s so unbearable here, unlikeable, over the top and - while this isn’t part of the acting - horribly designed. The whole movie’s garbage, but it’s his performance that’s the most grating. What makes it all the more irritating is they seemed to actually have fun making this cr*p.


1. Cypher Raige - After Earth

Will Smith After Earth
Columbia PicturesI

OK. Where to begin? After Earth fails on pretty much every conceivable level and hurt the Smith brand more than even Wild, Wild West.

Although what did he expect? Not only did he choose - yes, choose - to have master dud-maker M. Night Shyamalan direct his Jaden vanity project, but he spent the entire movie more wooden than the villains in The Happening.

He plays Cypher Raige - stop laughing - as a joyless soldier who never raises his voice above a slow drawl unless it’s a random screaming outburst. And that’s the point of the movie. His literal superpower in that he’s able of not showing any emotion, and that’s presented as a good thing. Do you even know who you are Will? I just... I can’t...

What's your favourite Will Smith performance? And your least? Have your say down in the comments.


Contributor
Contributor

Film Editor (2014-2016). Loves The Usual Suspects. Hates Transformers 2. Everything else lies somewhere in the middle. Once met the Chuckle Brothers.