Will The MCU Replace Avengers With The Illuminati?
A conspiracy theory for the ages.
Now, for those not versed in the world of Marvel Comics, there are few sentences that sound weirder than "the Illuminati exist in the Marvel universe". It's twice as weird for the fact that this Illuminati is not the same group conspiracy theorists purport to exist in the real world, but rather a group of superheroes who have made a secret team.
In order to explain why they might be popping into the Marvel Cinematic Universe sometime soon, it's worth delving into who the Marvel Illuminati are, and why exactly they formed.
So, for starters, this group has an intensely powerful line up. When Namor, Professor X, Black Bolt, Mr. Fantastic, Iron Man, Black Panther and Doctor Strange all agree to get together, you know it's over something serious.
Indeed, their unlikely formation was over a pretty big deal: an alien invasion. Or, well, the aftermath of an alien invasion. After the ordeal that was the Kree-Skrull War, Iron Man came to a troubling realisation: a whole bunch of heroes had known about it, but since they had never discussed it with others, the information had been rendered useless.
Wanting to ensure this kind of problem wouldn't occur again, he suggested that these figureheads of various groups joined together in order to police their world behind the scenes. While most heroes were wary, they did all agree that sharing information on threats to the world was a logical plan, and thus the Illuminati was formed. At Namor's insistence, they kept their meetings secret to even their loved ones, in order to prevent it becoming an issue in the superhero community.
[Article continues on next page...]
The MCU Has Already Taken Inspiration From Illuminati Storylines
Although, they also likely kept their new team secret because they did some pretty unheroic things. They sent the Hulk into space without consulting anyone else, wiped Captain America's memory of their existence, and also destroyed several other alternate universes. As you'd expect, this results in some pretty serious conflict in the superhero community, and generally lands the group in some of the biggest Marvel storylines of all time.
However, the Marvel Cinematic Universe has used some of these storylines without the Illuminati being involved, like when the Hulk ends up on Sakaar between Avengers: Age of Ultron and Thor: Ragnarok, which is under totally different circumstances than how it happened in the comics.
It's also worth noting that the current MCU has taken a LOT of inspiration from writer Jonathan Hickman, who is also the same person who penned the majority of the Illuminati storylines in books like New Avengers, Infinity, and Secret Wars.
As such, there's still very real potential for the Illuminati to make it into the MCU. If there's one thing that Civil War proved, it's that morally complex conflict between heroes tends to make for some of the most interesting viewing. And also some sweet fights. (Because it's just not a superhero film without someone managing to throw someone else through a table at an absolute minimum.)
This is exactly where the sordid group of superheroes would shine. Nobody joined the Illuminati to be underhand - they did it because they genuinely believed working together would make a difference. But it would reflect poorly on them to publicly work together, as many of them belong to other groups that are often at odds with one another, such as the X-Men and Inhumans.
The fact that all these awful deeds are done for good reasons would make for a genuinely engaging topic that would divide our cast of heroes, as well as provided us fans a topic to discuss that isn't a simple case of good and evil.
[Article continues on next page...]
How The MCU Has Already Provided The Conditions For The Illuminati
But, without the Kree-Skrull War, how could this be pulled off? Well, the MCU has just had a similarly traumatic event happen in the form of "The Snap". When you remember that this universe's heroes have been collectively traumatised by the effects of Infinity War, they'd no doubt be willing to do just about anything to prevent anything similar from happening again. Which could easily be enough to convince them to build such a sketchy organisation.
And with Doctor Strange having had to make choices that decided who lived and who died throughout the entire Infinity War saga, it'd be very easy for him to form this cult-like group out of a desire to prevent anything similar ever happening again. This is arguably an even better justification than the comics had, as when literally half the universe died for a while, you'd be more inclined to do questionable things like form an actual Illuminati.
Now, true, an MCU Illuminati wouldn't be the exact same as the comics, given Tony Stark is dead, and the X-Men don't properly exist yet in the universe, meaning Professor X can't just rock up right now. But there's nothing wrong with the Illuminati having different members to their comic counterparts - or to wait a phase or two until Namor, the Fantastic Four, and the X-Men all finally appear. The MCU has long played fast and loose with the comic lore it does use, and giving this group different members could arguably make for a better surprise when the big reveal comes.
In fact, there'd also be nothing wrong with having this fit into the current trend of having films take place in the "gaps" in the current timeline - so it'd be perfectly possible for them to have this event retroactively happen. Although the status quo with things like character relationships would have to be restored for it to fit in the timeline, which might take some of the punch out of it unless done cleverly.
[Article continues on next page...]
Why The Illuminati Would Improve The MCU
The scale of Infinity War and Endgame has left many fans questioning how these films could possibly be followed up. This internal conflict could be that - especially if it's used to lead into any big comic series like Secret Wars or Dark Reign.
Should the Illuminati appear, there's a good chance their appearance will be one of the best reveals in the history of the MCU, so it's only fair to hope we might see them formed on the big screen.
While the Avengers have become too much of a film staple now for them to likely ever be replaced, having the franchise either feature the Illuminati, or have them a spin-off seems like a smart way to add a little extra zest to the overall series. And to start, like, a million Marvel conspiracy theories, which would also be pretty great.
Do you want to see the Illuminati in the MCU? Let us know in the comments below.
Watch Next
MCU Quiz: How Well Do You ACTUALLY Remember Avengers: Infinity War?