Wonder Woman Review: 7 Ups & 4 Downs

The DCEU gets back on track.

Wonder Woman Trailer
Warner Bros.

As the DC Extended Universe struggles to right itself after three disappointing misses, what a relief it is to see critics falling over themselves to praise Wonder Woman as a stylish and entertaining origin story for the most iconic female superhero of all time.

The film holds a tremendous amount at stake considering the depressing lack of female-led comic book movies and what its reception will mean to movie studios going forward, so it's a relief that movie number four finally gives DC fans the film they were hoping for.

Sure, there are issues, but they seem positively minuscule in light of the DCEU's recent failings, and though it's still healthy to be skeptical about Justice League later this year, Wonder Woman at least provides more hope that it could end up striking the right tone.

Downs

4. The Villains Aren't Very Interesting

Wonder Woman General Ludendorff Doctor Poison
Warner Bros.

It's a frequently common problem in comic book movies that the villains feel underdeveloped compared to the heroes, and as generally great as Wonder Woman is, it's also no exception in this department.

The film has three main antagonists, the most interesting of whom is without question Doctor Poison (Elena Anaya), even if she's ultimately fatally underused. Then there's Danny Huston's General Ludendorff, and though Huston's clearly having fun with his hammy German accent, he's not as much of a fixture as you'd expect and entirely absent from the film for long stretches.

And finally, there's the big bad, the God of War himself, Ares, whose final form is a generic CGI mish-mash, failing to distinguish himself from the overwhelming glut of digitally-enhanced supervillains.

It doesn't sink the film by any means, but it's just frustrating that so many superhero movies don't feel the need to put much effort into their baddies, especially given the extensive rogues gallery that can be drawn from.


3. There's Too Much Slow-Motion

Wonder Woman
Warner Bros.

Some fans have been nervous that director Patty Jenkins may have made excessive use of slow-motion considering how abundantly it appears in the film's trailers, and unfortunately, their fears are mostly right.

Though Jenkins does a mostly rock solid job making the action coherent and entertaining, she also goes a little overboard with the slow-mo, to the point where it sometimes feels like she's attempting to ape Zack Snyder's own love for slow-mo.

At least there's no speed ramping, which can look awful, but it still means that some of the action beats end up looking cheesier than they need to. A little slow-mo here and there makes sense considering the speed with which Diana fights, but Jenkins basically ends up abusing it here.


2. The Frequently Terrible CGI

Wonder Woman Gal Gadot
Warner Bros.

The visual effects in this movie are completely all over the place, as they so often are in superhero movies, and particularly in the DC Extended Universe. Though some of the effects indeed work well, there are far too many scenes where characters have been blatantly green-screened in, and Diana's movement has a weird, fluid-like look to it during some of the action beats that's rather distracting.

That's to say nothing of the "screw it" finale, where every remaining cent of the VFX budget is unceremoniously hurled at the screen, and it ends up looking rather messy and drab in the same way that Batman v Superman's Doomsday showdown did.

Sometimes less is more, and watching action that's clearly been filmed on a soundstage is rarely as engaging as a tangible fight against a real, physical opponent, but the prevailing issue is that the visual effects just look surprisingly cheap at times for a $150 million movie.


1. The Third Act Is Typical Superhero Fare

Wonder Woman Final Trailer
Warner Bros.

As sharp and entertaining as the movie's first 90 minutes are, it does lose its way somewhat when entering the final stretch, becoming decidedly less interesting as two extremely predictable plot beats unfold.

The first is a twist that's been widely known for months now, so making a big deal out of it is rather unfortunate, and the other is a dramatic necessity that nevertheless works pretty well.

The real issue with the movie's final reel, though, is the climactic battle between Diana and Ares, a typically CGI-doused, laughably over-the-top nonsense finale that's decidedly average-at-best compared to the rest of the movie.

Thankfully the prior two acts are so great that it's fairly easy to forgive it devolving into more conventional superhero fare in the end, but it's still a shame that third act wasn't more unique.

But on the whole, Wonder Woman is the riveting female-led superhero movie everyone wanted it to be, so here's everything that works...


Ups

7. Gal Gadot Proves The Doubters Wrong

Wonder Woman Slavery
Warner Bros.

Even though Gal Gadot was arguably the best thing about Batman v Superman, stealing the show with a glorified extended cameo is very different to shouldering an entire movie, especially considering that her thick accent caused her to garble some of her lines in BvS, and that could end up decidedly less tolerable in a two-plus-hour movie.

Thankfully, the doubters and haters have been proved thoroughly wrong here. Yes, Gadot's line readings aren't always 100%, but for the most part she gives a charismatic, charming performance, and most importantly is thoroughly convincing as a physical force-of-nature.

Plus, she's a great role model for young women everywhere, and that's absolutely something worth celebrating.


6. The Refreshingly Hopeful Tone

Wonder Woman Gal Gadot
Warner Bros.

As far as recent superhero movies go, Wonder Woman has a refreshingly unique tone. Far away from the grimdark dourness of previous DCEU movies or the relentless quip-heavy sarcasm of the Marvel Cinematic Universe, it actually feels much closer in spirit to Richard Donner's 1978 Superman or Captain America: The Winter Soldier.

Diana's naivete and optimism about humanity gives the film a distinctly old-fashioned, earnest tone that's a breath of fresh air among most current superhero fare, and that the film manages to combine this with some musings on the darker side of human nature and also be funny as Hell is a very pleasant surprise indeed.


5. The Action Is (Mostly) Great

Wonder Woman War
Warner Bros.

Yes, there are issues with the overuse of slow-motion and that generic final battle, but for the most part, this is some of the more compelling and distinct action seen in a superhero film of recent years.

From an opening Themyscira-set fight scene between the Amazons and German soldiers, to a riveting showdown on No Man's Land and even certain action beats of the third act, there's a lot of slick, dynamic action here, helping to wholly distinguish the film from its genre brethren.

Simply, Warner Bros. would be smart to hold onto Patty Jenkins for the inevitable sequel, as long as they give her a few notes about her borderline-fetishistic use of slow-mo.


4. It's Terrifically Paced

Wonder Woman Queen Hippolyta And Diana
Warner Bros.

Superhero movies can be so needlessly bloated that there was good reason to be a little worried about Wonder Woman's 141-minute run-time, but it's actually one of the better-paced comic book movies of recent times, and for the most part justifies its beefy length.

The film takes its time introducing audiences to Themiscyra before throwing her out into the world, and thanks to a combination of strong writing and entertaining action, the first two acts in particular just sail by, and it absolutely doesn't feel as long as it is.

Sure, it gets more monotonous in act three, but it's impressive overall how well the film plays even when there are relatively long stretches without action. Rather than delivering an over-indulgent end product as many perhaps expected, Jenkins makes great use of her time and respects the audience's.


3. The Romance Is Surprisingly Compelling

Wonder Woman Steve Diana Close
Warner Bros.

One thing that most superhero movies get wrong is romance: even the MCU struggles to conjure up love stories that don't feel horrendously forced and unnecessary, yet Wonder Woman dares to actually give it center stage.

The romance between Diana and Steve Trevor (Chris Pine) feels surprisingly organic considering how inherently absurd it is, in large part thanks to the sizzling chemistry between Gal Gadot and Chris Pine.

As such, when the movie stops for five minutes for the pair to talk and dance, it actually works and adds to their characterisation rather than feeling like a studio-mandated affectation.

It's absolutely one of the best romances in recent superhero memory, and is pretty much the last thing you'd expect the DCEU to totally nail.


2. The Excellent Supporting Cast

Wonder Woman Etta Candy
Warner Bros.

Though it's fair to say that much of the movie's illustrious supporting cast isn't in the movie as much as one might like, collectively they nevertheless form a terrific ensemble.

The highlights include Connie Nielsen as Diana's mother Queen Hippolyta, Robin Wright as the ferocious Amazon General Antiope, Elena Anaya's savage Doctor Poison, Lucy Davis' comical secretary Etta Candy, and Saïd Taghmaoui and Ewen Bremner as Steve's allies Sameer and Charlie.

It's no coincidence that most of the best roles have been reserved for women, of course, and the film's diverse cast serves as a fantastic display of smart, powerful, beautiful and sometimes terrifying women.


1. It's A Standalone Movie (As It Should Be)

Wonder Woman Poster
Warner Bros.

After Batman v Superman strained itself to basically function as a feature-length commercial for Justice League, it's a relief to report that Wonder Woman is for the most part a standalone movie.

Beyond a present-day framing narrative, it's basically a period war movie with only passing links to the exterior DCEU, and features not a single hamfisted Justice League cameo. There aren't any credits scenes hinting at Diana's future, and weirdly, there isn't even any explicit mention of her self-imposed retirement from heroism before Doomsday's arrival.

So many superhero movies are obsessed with paying lip service to the wider world that it's a relief to see Wonder Woman confidently tackling a largely self-contained adventure, especially considering the DCEU's early troubles winning over fans. It's no coincidence, then, that it's the series' only critically fresh movie to date.

What did you think of Wonder Woman? Shout it out in the comments!


Contributor
Contributor

Stay at home dad who spends as much time teaching his kids the merits of Martin Scorsese as possible (against the missus' wishes). General video game, TV and film nut. Occasional sports fan. Full time loon.