World War Z: 10 Reasons It's An Absolute Disaster
10. It Doesn't Do The Novel Justice
Max Brooks' novel on which the movie is based unfolds over a number of interviews and accounts of the zombie apocalypse, meaning that it's not the easiest material in the world to adapt into a film. Marc Forster and his writers decided to try and capture the spirit of the novel within a new narrative, but little of the core elements remain; the origins in China were cut out so as not to alienate the Chinese market (who opted not to release the film in the end anyway), nor does it explore the Pakistan-Iran war, or America's over-confidence in attempting to stem the plague. Any political satire or currency the source material had has been duly stripped out to make way for a witless, overly serious zombie film. Wouldn't it have been more entertaining to just craft an anthology film that depicts the various events of the novel?
9. Editing
Marc Forster's Quantum of Solace received similar flak for its poor editing, and World War Z sadly is perhaps even worse. Right from the opening set-piece, in which Brad Pitt's Gerry Lane is driving a car through the city, trying to escape the zombie outbreak, the editing makes it difficult to make out what's going on; many shots last less than a second, so ascertaining spatial sense of the scenario proves incredibly difficult. It becomes clear soon enough as well that because of the PG-13 rating - which I'll get to later - Forster is fast to cut frantically between violent images so that the gory dismemberment is implied rather than actually shown. Above all else, this approach to the aesthetic of the film is simply headache-inducing and irritating.
8. Direction
This goes hand in hand with Forster's direction, which takes the divisive "shaky cam" route popularised by Paul Greengrass, hurling the camera all over the place during action scenes to give the impression of frantic intensity. I surely cannot be the only one who likes steady, focused coverage of action scenes? The result is that the action scenes - which should probably be the most enjoyable aspect of the film - prove to be close to incomprehensible at times, and though Forster claimed pre-release that he had toned down his much-criticised approach from Quantum, that doesn't really appear to be the case in reality. If you're going to go the shaky cam route, employ it judiciously like Paul Greengrass, rather than as a needless gimmick in a film that should be emphasising the scale of the catastrophe rather than moving in close and disorientating us.
7. Murky Cinematography
It's well known that 3D functions best with the bright, spritely colours of animated films, while cinematographers tend to avoid using darker shades, especially in live action films, because 3D glasses can darken the image up to 30%. If a scene is going to be dark, then the colour grading will need to be adjusted to compensate for 3D screenings, though going by last night's 3D showing of World War Z, post-production has not factored this in. Early on, when Gerry and his family are fleeing from a gang of zombies around a dim complex, the lack of light combined with the poor editing makes it close to impossible to work out exactly what's going on; we can see people running, zombies making noises, but the two don't fuse together in the most basic way that any film should. It is for this reason I thoroughly implore anyone going to see WWZ to ensure they see it in 2D - if not to get a stronger perspective of the action, then simply because the 3D isn't very good either.
6. Stupid Characters
This is a movie full of idiotic characters who are almost impossible to root for; the tone is set perfectly early on when an important character trips over and shoots himself in the head. It gets worse when the film focuses on Gerry's daughters, the youngest of whom is resigned to whining about her blanket, her daddy, and how scared she is. It's hardly the fault of the young actress in question - and let's face it, what journalist wants to start criticising a child? - but simply the way her character is written. And to think, we all assumed it couldn't possibly get any worse than Dakota Fanning's Rachel in War of the Worlds, up to this point the most irritating banshee-kid to ever slink onto the big screen.
5. PG-13 Rating
Who makes a zombie film that's rated PG-13? Of all the missed opportunities and terrible ideas in this list, this just might be the most egregious and non-sensical, given the fact that zombie movies by their sheer nature need to be gory (Warm Bodies also suffered from a similar problem). We've all been reared on George A. Romero zombie flicks, and one of the major appeals of a zombie film is seeing all the brain-munching, none of which is even remotely depicted here. Generally we see distant, blurry images of people being savaged by the zombies - accompanied by the aforementioned editing and directorial flourishes - but the most head-smackingly awful moment comes when Gerry has to cut the hand off of one of his comrades. The scene has no visceral appeal whatsoever; we don't see the slice, nor do we hear it, and instead Forster is forced to awkwardly focus on pained reaction shots as Gerry applies a bandage to the wound. Zombie films are meant to be terrifying, and give the fast-moving zombies this one boasts, it totally should be; instead, it's as meek and mild as they come, a result of a studio clearly clambering for box office receipts. How's about slashing the budget and making it R-rated instead?
4. Performances
Brad Pitt is one of Hollywood's generally more reliable A-list actors, yet even he is hamstrung here by a careless script, which causes the actor to appear bored and unfussed by a project that he himself is a producer on. There is no urgency to his character, no emphatic emotion at anything that happens; he is simply a hollow shell throughout, failing to muster up any emotion or relatability in this viewer. The same is true of almost everyone else in the film; though plenty of talented actors abound, they're simply given nothing of mention to do, and perhaps most cruelly, Lost's Matthew Fox appears as a soldier for all of five seconds, presumably having had his role largely left on the cutting room floor.
3. CGI Zombies
It's inevitable that in a project like this, it's going to need a lot of visual effects, and I have no problem with Marc Forster employing CGI to easier convey the massive zombie hordes rushing to make meals out of the humans. It is an effective tool for depicting scale, but this becomes troublesome when the director also uses CGI for some of the more close-up zombie images, such that when we see them diving over walls and leaping forward, there's absolutely no weightiness to the physics, and our mind knows this, subsequently rejecting it. As a result, a lot of the zombie attacks appear extremely artificial, as though the humans are running from a computer simulation - precisely because they are. Though one can appreciate the need to convey the speed and ferocity of the zombies, could this not have been achieved with wires and some trick photography? It surely cannot have been as garish an option as this risible CGI dreck.
2. Lack Of Tension
One of the more surprising issues with World War Z is how absolutely bereft of tension it is for the most part; Gerry manages to negotiate safe haven for his family aboard a military ship early on, and because his family are safe for the majority of the rest of the film, where is the suspense? Gerry searching for an end to the plague simply isn't interesting enough, and the man by himself is not sufficient for us to care, largely because his character is an everyman shell rather than a developed entity in his own right. This follows right through to the Wales-set finale, which has Gerry and others creeping down hallways, trying not to alert the zombies to their presence, but we're so uninvested in the characters that there's simply no reason to care about whether they get munched on or not.
1. Predictable Ending
WARNING: SPOILERS FOR THE END OF WORLD WAR Z WILL FOLLOW. In the third act of World War Z, Gerry suggests an idea to hold off the zombie plague, to "disguise" the surviving humans by infecting them with a virus humans are already well-acquainted with, such as Meningitis or SARS. The logic is that the zombies only attack healthy hosts, and so illness will essentially render them "invisible" to the horde. This theory is accepted by the scientists situated in the WHO building of the film's climax, yet the question seems to be - who will volunteer to try? Of course, we all know it's going to be Gerry, but the film waits another 10 or so minutes before trundling out this point as though it's supposed to be a big surprise. Of course, it works, the zombies start getting killed off, and the film ends. It's just such a lazy, simple way to write the film to a conclusion... What are your expecting from World War Z? Let us know in the comments below.
