World War Z: 10 Unforgivable Cuts From The Book
Whenever I hear a book I like is being adapted into a film, I'm cautiously optimistic. I'm not thrilled years of movie-watching have made me far too jaded for such a thing but whenever something good looks like it's going to take the step up to the big screen, excitement courses through my veins. What if, just this once, they completely nailed it? Hitting the bulls-eye when it comes to an adaptation is notoriously difficult, but we all live in hope. So when it was announced that World War Z was being made into a film, I was pleased. World War Z stands alone in the zombie genre because it tackles the problem at a national level, rather than a few nutcases holed up somewhere trying to ride out the end-times. There's a sense of scale which marks it out as unique, so even when the film ran into production difficulties, I was still optimistic. After all, crafting something of World War Z's scope was going to be difficult, and I was grateful for them trying it. Yet as the plot began to trickle through, I heard the worst possible term 'loose adaptation' and my heart sank. I always realised that they'd need to take some liberties with the film, giving it a main character for the sake of an involving dramatic arc and cutting the gore to achieve a marketable age-rating. But some of the changes here tore the heart and soul out of what the World War Z book was, and I couldn't help but feel slightly gutted as I left the cinema. Please don't misunderstand me I really enjoyed World War Z. It's a good film with excellent set-pieces and a decent central character. But the problem for me is that it isn't a real adaptation of the book it's just a regular zombie film. When taken on those merits, it's fine excellent, even. But taken on the high benchmark it set itself by adapting a genre classic, it falls short by cutting too much. So over the next 10 pages, I hope to explain the most unforgivable cuts from the book. Please note, there are SPOILERS from here on in.
The World War Z film begins immediately in the thick of the action martial law has already been declared and the Lanes encounter a horde during an everyday commute. This first act carnage is usually good for a film as it makes for instant momentum, but in terms of a World War Z movie, Id argue its an opportunity missed. The book looks at what is known as The Great Panic and the months before, where people didnt know quite how to deal with something as different as the zombie plague. The story was in the reactions, yet the film swept all this up into an opening credit sequence. For book fans that had to suck, and it missed out one of the biggest parts of the World War Z Universe Phalanx, the fake drug marketed as a vaccine for the zombie plague. Phalanx couldve helped explain why the zombies took over so quickly and would have explained why the horde had got to such a size when the Lanes encountered it. Its absence is also a shame as Phalanx, and its inventor Breckenridge Scott, permeates the entirety of mid-zombie-war society as some sort of cure-all as well as offering the ultimate condemnation of American individualism Scott wanted to profit, so he condemned millions to un-death for the sake of his own bottom line. It was a great subtext but sadly, the film chose to can it.
9. The Pre-Outbreak Containment
Following on from the glossed-over Great Panic, you could go further and ask why the film didnt show the events leading up to it. While the film roughly explains the plagues origin and how it got into the country, theres no attention paid to how it spread from a few individuals to giant maraudering crowds. As it is, it just instantly chucks thousands of zombies at the screen and tells us to go with it. Once again, that may be fine for a regular zombie movie, but this isnt one World War Z was supposed to explore what sort of reaction was taken to the initial threat on a world-wide stage. In the book, different countries responded in different ways the North Koreans all went underground, the South Africans enacted the Redeker Plan (more on that later) and the Americans went with Phase One, where special forces appeared to put down pockets of zombies where they turned up. The point was that in the book, though the government didnt know these people were zombies, they knew something was wrong and took preventative steps. The people were also aware of these mystery outbreaks, and that they eventually got out of control. However, in the film Gerry appeared not just shocked when the horde turns up being fair, you would be too but completely baffled as to what they were, as if this million-zombie run just sort of dropped from the sky. For zombies to turn up on this scale, youd have to have known about it for weeks, and weirdly, the national leaders share his amnesia theyre just as surprised when the plague takes Boston, New York and Philadelphia in a matter of hours. By cutting the outbreak stage, the film-makers accidentally opened a big plot hole which looks frankly confusing after a re-watch.
8. The Redeker Plan
One of the biggest themes in the book is that humanity will do anything to survive, and nothing embodied it more than the brutal pragmatism of the South African Redeker Plan. However, this feature integral part of the World War Z story was curiously omitted from the film. Put simply, the Redeker Plan was a set of pre-Apartheid directives laying down what the Afrikaners would do if the black population rose up to kill them, and could easily be re-fitted for a zombies-versus-humans situation. What was so chilling about it was that it instantly dismissed the notion of saving everyone, stating that if you sufficiently armed a small base elsewhere and filled it with people, it would provide a distraction long enough for everyone else to prepare properly. Grimly pragmatic, it was a solution adopted by every other country in an effort to survive. Its very existence offered a great insight into the human condition and the lengths we would go to ensure survival, but the film just dropped it in favour of Israels we put up a wall because we cottoned on quickest strategy. Really, this was such a wasted opportunity not only did the plan explain how humanity survived the onrushing hordes, but it also set out the practical-at-all-costs philosophy of the zombie world like nothing else before it. Now a vaccines been discovered, I doubt itll make an appearance at all in the sequels, and thats a shame. Speaking of which
7. Theres No Vaccine/Cure
One of the more horrifying aspects of World War Z in book form was that there was no way you could protect yourself against the zombie virus. It didnt have a vaccine and it didnt have a cure, which meant it could just spread unchecked. Really, thats the most horrifying thing about zombies they just get exponentially larger until theres nothing left. Humanity is supposed to feel helpless against that, and so it proved throughout much of the films run-time. But then Gerry discovered a vaccine and the whole dynamic changed. Simply put, its not a World War anymore. The humans have the equivalent of zombie kryptonite, an absolute game changer which will make the problem less about active warfare and more about pest control. If the enemy cant see you, theres no way you can call that a fair fight. Seriously, where are they going to go from here in the now green-lit sequel? Once you take away a zombies ability to hunt and turn humans, what use are they? Theyre just a big, stupid bag of bones. It would be more of threat fighting monkeys, as at least they could see you. Effectively, theyve robbed themselves of any meaningful drama in the second instalment. The books major strength was explaining in great detail the creative ways in which the world got around the problem of the undead on their doorstep, but with a one-size cure-all that tension will be lost if a character is threatened, we wont wonder how theyre going to get out of this, well ask why they hadnt had their vaccines. That shouldnt be the case in an action film.
6. Zombies Being Able To Swim
The film establishes very early on that the UN ship flotilla is like some sort of Shangri-La for refugees fleeing the zombie apocalypse. If youre on one of their ships, youre perfectly safe, because after all, zombies cant swim, right? Wrong. In World War Z all zombies can swim. Well, swim is a strong word they just sort of float around under the waves and let the tide drag their indestructible behinds about. But even then, they cant climb, right? Wrong again. The book specifically mentions that zombies climb up the chains of anchored ships, buoyed on by the waters force. In fact, sea-borne zombies become the biggest threat in the post-war world, because they keep washing up on beaches and attacking boats. Taking away this fundamental part of the narrative robs the film of the tension it desperately needs to maintain. Theres a reason why the plot loses momentum whenever the film cut back to the ship it takes away the sense of urgency which should be apparent at all levels of films in the zombie genre. Nowhere should be safe in a zombie apocalypse. In fact, thats kind of the whole point. Yet the film somehow makes out that ships are some sort of safe haven, that if you can make it on to one everything will be OK and the only thing youll have to worry about is resources. When the bean counters represent more of a threat than the walking dead, I dont think things have gone quite right.
5. Canada Being A Hellhole
Following on from the ships being a safe haven, the only thing people on them are threatened with is deportation to refugee camps. The film makes a big show of this, implying that the people Mrs Lane and the children witness being turned away from the ships are effectively being given a death sentence. And really, this matches up with the book. No refugee camps did particularly well on the page, with most of them being co-opted into the Redeker Plan as bait. So for book fans, when we hear that Gerrys family is being moved to Nova Scotia, we fear the worst. Of all the places taken up by refugees, the book takes great pains in telling you that those who trekked to Canada had a bad time. They suffered snows they were unprepared for, as well as banditry and food shortages. They actually ended up resorting to cannibalism, which Im sure is ironic in some way. But when Gerry ventures there, it doesnt seem that bad at all. Granted, were only there for moments but theres a definite impression that the Lanes were surviving comfortably. They didnt appear starved, there was a military presence and there didnt seem to be any zombies about at all. All these are extreme luxuries when compared to the situation in the book. I guess it might have been too much to ask for the films well-documented struggles with finding an ending meant parts had to be cut out somewhere, but much like every other point in this list its still an opportunity missed. Documenting the struggles of those refugees gave a sense of the desperate situation many ordinary people found themselves in by showing just how grim it was, but the film doesnt really take the chance to explore that theme. Wherever the cameras go Israel, Cardiff, the ships, South Korea all the people are holed up and living in relative comfort despite the plague. Truly, thats a bit odd, and missing a vital part of the zombie experience.
4. The President
OK, just to be clear in the books, much like in the film, the President does die. However, much as its supposed to work in a system of government, he is replaced by his deputy. This is the way it works in the book when the original President is bitten, the Vice-President known simply as the Big Guy is sworn in. Make no mistake, within the narrative the role of the Big Guy thought to be Colin Powell is massive. As President, hes the one who organises the American defence and keeps the USA from falling into the hands of undead monsters. Granted, were still very early on in the book by the end of the film, but still, the Presidents actions should be felt. Speaking about him in the book gave the impression that an entire country was on its knees, that a zombie outbreak could potentially topple a whole system of government. It gave the book an epic-ness often sorely lacking in most on-screen or on-page tales zombie tales. Yet in the film, were told in a throwaway line that the President is dead and his VP is missing, leading to one hell of an anti-climax. Effectively, theyve eradicated a major character at a stroke, leaving the film missing a sense of grandeur which cannot be replaced, no matter how much Gerry goes globetrotting. Without people like Heads of State, the entire film is just one deputy secretary scheming with his friend on a boat, and thats just sad for a film about Armageddon.
3. Quislings
If Im being honest, I can see why they didnt add quislings into the film their very existence could probably ramp the rating up to an 18 if their obligatory devoured-by-zombies death scenes didnt. But it doesnt stop me from being sad about it. To refresh your memory, a quisling named after a Nazi-puppet Norweigan president during World War II is a human whose mental faculties have broken down. Unlike most people in World War Z, they werent able to engage the fight or flight choice when faced with danger. They simply shut down and try to act like zombies, feeling no pain and attempting to bite you on sight. Furthermore, while zombies devour them, they dont even react pretty grim stuff. Again, I can see why they didnt put them in, but I still think they wouldve made a worthy addition to the film. World War Z is primarily a horror tale and a lot of that horror comes from what people do, not the zombies themselves. It was George A. Romero who once said that all zombies are is an instrument for change in man as such, if the book was simply about zombies devouring humans it wouldnt be a genre classic. But its not just about that, its about different human reactions to that change some people become good, some people become bad and some people become quislings. Yet when the film was given the same chance to implement this more nuanced approach encompassing all human emotions, it spurned it. There were no quislings, and to be honest, the man who tried to rape Gerrys wife apart, there werent even many bad people. Frankly, thats a colossal misstep in what couldve been the definitive film about zombies.
2. Zombies Walking
Much like omitting the quislings, I can understand why they chose to turn the films zombies into fast runners. To many people, the slow zombie has become a joke weve subjected them to satire in Dawn Of The Dead and Land Of The Dead turned them carnival sideshows. Theyre a tad useless, and their un-threatening nature is made all the worse when contrasted with the oh-god-no running zombies pioneered in 28 Days Later, who are an altogether more terrifying beast. Yet call me a sucker for tradition, but I think I preferred the walking zombies. While the filmmakers made some fantastic visuals out of the runners (the Israeli wall-climb being a particular highlight), theyre honestly too threatening to really exist within the narrative of World War Z. Does that make sense? Yeah, probably not. Heres what Im trying to say the slowness of the zombies was an integral part of the books narrative and turning them into sprinters will give the sequel writers a massive headache. Because they were slow in the books, they could be adapted to and though the humans got their behinds kicked (and then eaten) at first, they adopted new battle strategies and eventually got back on top. The fact it was a climb to get to that point was what made the turnaround so thrilling. Keeping them sprinting negates this whole process, because it looks like too much of a challenge. Yes, watching a fast zombie headbutt their way through a car windshield onscreen is terrifying, yet perhaps the filmmakers cut their nose off to spite their face. They looked for a cheap thrill in this film at the expanse of massive pay-offs in the next, and as the sequels roll in this might end up seeming like a bad choice.
1. The Battle Of Yonkers
If theres one thing the World War Z film doesnt lack, its set-pieces. From the opening everybody-run-from-the-horde scene to the zombies climbing the Israeli walls and the superbly tense Cardiff laboratory sequence, the main highlights of the film dont disappoint. Its a rare film which chooses to blow up a plane in mid-air and have the main character survive it, but World War Z has the balls to get away with it. Yet really, there was always one major set-piece that was missing for me the Battle of Yonkers, pretty much the signature set-piece of the book both in terms of scale and meaning. The US armys overconfident stand against the zombies showcased like nothing else that conventional war didnt work against the onrushing hordes, simultaneously scattering the army and forcing a rethink of strategy. Its a major turning point in the book yet the film just drops it completely. Admittedly what they replace it with is pretty cool, but taking one of the definitive scenes out of the film adaptation is a strange decision, in my eyes. Maybe it was just a choice of tone the Battle of Yonkers is brimming with satire about the mindset of the American army, yet the film chose play all the carnage relatively straight. Its a bit disappointing really what usually escalates a summer blockbuster is some sort of subtext (think The Dark Knight and the Patriot Act), and hypothetically, World War Z was no different. Yet when presented with this choice to cash in its chips and ride that horse all the way to good reviews (to mangle two metaphors), it chose not to. Its an odd decision, and it stops a good film from being a great one. Agree or disagree? feel free to comment!