10 Awesome Video Games That Should Never Become Movies
There is only one thing that can make video game lovers both jump for joy and cringe at the same time: film adaptations. Video games that are selected for film have to be popular in order to attract an audience, fast-paced, and usually have a good story. These are excellent qualities for a potential Hollywood blockbuster, but that doesn't mean that our favorite games will translate well onto the silver screen. Unlike the Tomb Raider franchise, which many believe has had the most successful game to film transition, some games are either too long, too short, too broad, or too narrow to breach the gap between great video game and great film. There are other issues that can manifest as well; should the proposed film be live action, or would it appeal to audiences better if it's purely CGI? Could an animated film be successful, or are we alienating most of the audience-base by doing so? Then, if all the logistics are ironed out and a video game film is created, there's still the pesky question of whether or not the writers and producers actually pieced the puzzle together correctly and did an admirable job. With all the possible pitfalls of the game to film transition, here are a few incredible games we hope the powers that be never try to use:
10. The Legend Of Zelda: Ocarina Of Time
Ocarina of Time, first released by Nintendo in November 1998 for the Nintendo 64, is a classic RPG. It won Game of the Year in 1999 at the 2nd Annual Interactive Achievement Awards, among other honors. It has been rereleased for other consoles, and was such a success that a direct sequel, Majora's Mask, was released a mere 18 months later. Why it would make a terrible film: The main character, Link, travels back and forth through time, between when he is a child and an adult, in order to fulfill his role as Hero of Time. Half the time the character is prepubescent, and half the time he is fully mature, and that might not go over well with a film audience. In our hyper-sexualized society, films tend to insinuate sexual tension between characters, and also tend to reward the hero with a beautiful woman. Cue Princess Zelda who, despite not hooking up with an adult Link at the end of the game, makes the perfect prize. But any sexual or romantic tension between the two will feel awkward, forced, and possibly dirty. Link sleeps while his body transitions from child to adult, so just how adult can his mind actually be - especially when he continuously goes back and forth? That being said, an animated film could possibly be successful if devoid of romance and marketed with children in mind, but that would alienate much of the adult population who can actually appreciate the attempted adaptation.
9. Little Big Planet
Released in 2008 by Sony for the Playstation 3, Little Big Planet, LBP for short, took the world by storm through puzzles, the ability to create content, and adorable little customizable sack characters. The game had a decent pace, and also won several awards for its game design, art direction, visual engineering, and innovation in gaming. It was also named Game of the Year by several gaming magazines and websites. Why it would make a terrible film: There is no story. While this hasn't stopped filmmakers from borrowing ideas from pop culture in the past (Battleship, anyone?), it does present an issue. Inventing a story for LBP wouldn't be difficult, just throw in a villain and announce that the little sack guy has to complete the tasks (puzzles) to save his world, and you're clear. And while this might be a great movie to entertain the kids with, it might be too boring for adults to sit through. Even adults who love adorable sack people.
8. Fable
The 2004 action RPG from Microsoft for the XBOX has a compelling story, rich characters, and a protagonist who could literally be anyone, good or evil. Like the others, the game has won several awards for its innovation, its original score, and many others. Why it would make a terrible film: The question of good and evil. With television shows like Breaking Bad showing off how easy it is to create a likable bad guy, why not make the Hero of Oakvale villainous on film? The gameplay allows the player to make decisions that effect the character's appearance and alignment, so why not play with it a little? Whether good or evil, the film will be scrutinized for its main character, either for not pushing the envelope, or for pushing too far. Filmmakers, knowing this, will try to please everyone - and fail miserably. No one will be able to identify with the main character because he'll be so conflicted with himself; he'll seem too mean, or even too nice and a bit false. If the audience can't connect with the main character, the film falls flat.
7. The Elder Scrolls V: Skyrim
Skyrim completely blew Elder Scrolls fans out of the water in November 2011 when it was released by Bethesda. The art, story, and DLC were all top notch, and the game won roughly 20 awards. Why it would make a terrible film: Too much to cover. Taking all character creation possibilities out of the equation, we're still left with a long plot riddled with side quests that could be incorporated. How many of our characters accidentally became vampires that went in search of a cure? Who loved the Dawnguard and Dragonborn DLCs? Fans would love to see elements such as these incorporated into a Skyrim film, but with the basic plot as long as it is, it's unlikely that they will be satisfied by whatever the potential screenwriters come up with. The only viable solution would be a franchise with multiple films. The fault in that plan is that it banks on fans staying interested long enough to complete the series, and on writers distributing plot and sub-plot elements well enough to make the films flow and keep viewers engaged. Even if all of that were to pan out properly, possibly the most important hurdle is left unanswered: character species and alignment, which brings us to poor film choice number five...
6. Dragon Age: Origins
Origins is the first game in the Dragon Age franchise, and was published by Electronic Arts in 2009. Developers BioWare and Edge of Reality did a number on this one; the game won approximately 15 awards in one year. It focuses on a conscripted character who must unite a kingdom on the brink of civil war, as well as stop creatures known as Darkspawn from taking over the country and leaking into the rest of the world. Why it would make a terrible film: Too many character origins and types to choose from. Like all good customizable games, Dragon Age: Origins has multiple species and character classes to choose from. It also has two origin stories to choose from per race depending on the chosen character class. Players can also choose between male and female protagonists. The reason this makes a potential film difficult is that they are all good stories. Unless screenwriters chose a non-human protagonist for their film, it would look and feel like a cop-out. Or, even better would be a female non-human protagonist. Ladies play games too, and it's time they get more than eye-candy icon Lara Croft to look up to on the big screen.
5. El Shaddai: Ascension of the Metatron
While El Shaddai only won two awards following its 2011 release by UTV Ignition Entertainment, it made waves in the gaming community for its unfinished-style graphics, beautiful landscapes, phenomenal voice acting, and both 2D and 3D gaming and platforming mechanics. Why it would make a terrible film: Inconsistencies of biblical proportions. El Shaddai follows Enoch who, according to some religious texts, was a man who rose to the status of an angel, called the Metatron. In the game, Enoch the man is sent back to Earth to deal with rogue angels who have given forbidden knowledge to humans, established themselves as gods, begotten half-human and half-angel children called nephilum, and in general disobeyed everything they were meant to do on earth. If Enoch fails, God intends to flood the earth (aka, the Noah's Ark story) in order to cleanse it. Anyone who knows anything about Christianity knows that the Bible says this flood takes place. But if you beat the game, it doesn't. This, along with a few character inconsistencies will cause serious waves in the devout Christian community. While that doesn't necessarily matter for everyone, and shouldn't because it's a film, it might matter enough for screenwriters to change the game story's ending to appeal more to the religious crowd. It all depends on who writes the film.
4. Slender: The Eight Pages
It's short, terrifying, and while it hasn't won any awards, Slender has a sort of cult following needed to make the jump between the gaming and film entertainment platforms. It was released in June 2012 by Parsec Productions, and sports a very minimalist approach to the survival horror genre. Why it would make a terrible film: Not enough plot to go on. The plot consists of an unknown character waking up in the forest at night armed with only a flashlight of questionable battery power. The character then wanders around the forest looking for eight pages that consist of text and stick-figure art. If you see Slender, you run in the opposite direction and hope he doesn't catch you. If he does, game over. If you collect all eight pages? Slender catches you and the game ends anyway. Who is the main character? Why is he/she collecting the pages? How did Slender get you to that secluded area? Too many questions means too much liberty for screenwriters, and the minimalist charm of the game will be lost on the big screen.
3. American McGee's Alice
It's dark, sinister, and disturbing. The October 2000 release from developer Rogue Entertainment and publisher Electronic Arts is as captivating as it is disbelieving. The story follows Alice, who's entire family dies in a house fire after her second adventure in Wonderland. Ten years later, she's lost touch of reality and is pulled back into Wonderland from a mental institution. Wonderland is warped due to her mental state, and she's the only one who can stop the Queen of Hearts and return that world to beauty. Why it would make a terrible film: Ruined childhoods. There are plenty of Alice in Wonderland spin-offs out there, but none are this violent, stressful, or dark. Those who haven't played the game wouldn't know what to do with themselves in the theater, whether it be cringe at the gore or cheer at the uniqueness. Due to its probable placement in the suspense and horror genres, the film would also likely suffer from poor funding, and therefore lack the grotesque scenery and character designs that make the game so memorable and engaging.
2. Kingdom Hearts
It's been 11 years since Disney and Final Fantasy fans were first enchanted by Kingdom Hearts. The March 2002 release from Square Enix combines the two franchises as seamlessly as possible by having the main character, a boy named Sora, travel to different worlds in search of his friends, and in search of keyholes that he must seal in order to protect the worlds from the main antagonistic force, the Heartless. The game, and resulting series, has won several awards and has been outfitted for multiple platforms. Why it would make a terrible film: A film could never mesh these franchises so perfectly. A live action film would mostly be out of the question, and a high end CG movie similar to Final Fantasy: Advent Children would likely have to have an enormous budget, both for paying key voice actors and for creating quality CG characters out of the animated Disney ones. In addition, the movie would be either horrifically long or grossly gutted due to the length of the core plot. Now, an animated series of Kingdom Hearts on the Disney Channel would be both lighthearted and appropriate given the established plot. More adults out there would watch it than they care to admit, you can bet money on that.
1. Super Mario Bros.
Called the greatest game of all time by IGN in 2005, this 1985 release by Nintendo defined the side-scrolling genre. It has inspired several sequels and spin-offs, and has recently celebrated its 25th birthday. It's simple, pixelated, and iconic. Why it would make a terrible film: It already is. This may be cheating, but Super Mario Bros. has already been bastardized by the big screen. Nothing in the movie has to do with the game except that Mario and Luigi are brother and plumbers and that Daisy and various villains are involved. There's no bright shiny world with troublesome turtles and kind-hearted mushroom people; the setting and costumes are full of bad 80's references, dinosaurs have apparently evolved in a parallel world to look human, and not only is the princess not in another castle, but the romantic storyline follows Luigi and Daisy - Mario already has a lady, and her name isn't Peach or Toadstool. This movie should be a warning to all potential games ever considered for film - writers and producers will change and play with the game's plot to try to make it relevant to viewers rather than use what they have. Plot integrity means nothing next to perceived revenue, and abominations like this 1993 movie that even star actor Bob Hoskins regret, will be the end result.