10 Creepiest Video Game Enemies That Gave Everyone Nightmares

Keep telling yourself it's 'just a game'.

While movies, TV, and even books can all scare us silly, no medium has the ability to be quite as terrifying as video games. Because you're actually playing the game yourself it means you're instantly connected to the action, and if you're being stalked by a grotesque four-legged nightmare it's not just a character being tormented - it's you trying your best to get away. Regardless of graphics, technology or even genre, the creepiest video game characters are eternal, and it doesn't matter whether you first encountered these enemies when you were 15 or when you were 30, each and every one will have seared themselves into your brain whether you wanted them to or not. They weren't only scary because they made a loud noise or hit you with a jump-scare, these were genuinely terrifying enemies that preferred to subtly bide their time, teasing you out to the point where the anticipation was actually much more terrifying than seeing the monstrosities themselves. Ask any gamer and no doubt every single one will have a traumatic experience locked away about each and every monster on this list. Even if they aren't much to look at, these are the creepy enemies that haunted players for weeks even after they hit completion, and are the reason you still get that jolt of spine-tingling terror every time you boot up their respective games.

10. Cherubs (Doom 3)

Although many games have turned innocent babies into terrifying fear-monsters, the first time gamers became truly scared of the little fellas was in Doom 3. While you spend most of the game blasting demons back to hell with pump-action shotguns and BFGs, the title actually boasts plenty of subtle scares. In the moments of quiet where you had to rely on your torch to get around, there were some genuinely suspenseful moments in this sequel, but none of them quite matched the terror that would come with the screams of one of the game's cherubs. Part-baby, part-grotesque nightmare, there's something about the dead vacant eyes of these little creatures that remains terrifying to this very day. While most of the enemies in the game are huge death-wielding super-monsters, these small abominations are scary in a completely different way. Although they were threatening in themselves and were able to murder you with ease if you weren't paying attention, the cherubs mostly got the drop on you because you were too creeped out to actually look at them long enough to shoot them in the face.

9. Richard Trager (Outlast)

Although there are plenty of creepy characters that stalk you through the abandoned Mount Massive mental asylum in Outlast, none are quite as threatening as the sinister Doctor Trager. Upon capturing you and tying you to a chair, the good doctor lets you know he means business immediately by slicing off one of your fingers. Getting up close in personal, Trager is perhaps the most human of the enemies in Outlast, yet somehow that only makes the horror more realistic. Once you escape your trap it doesn't take long for him to know you're missing, and he'll chase you around the claustrophobic wing until you can get your bearings and escape. Unlike the other enemies in the game, this psychopathic surgeon is faster and more agile than your regular demented nutcase, and as a result the escape is much more intense than any of the other set-pieces in the title. While the music wails and the screams of his other patients are heard in the distance, if Outlast doesn't get your heart pounding at this point, it probably never will.

8. The Spider (Limbo)

The dark, eerie world of Limbo perfectly encapsulates everything you were scared about as a kid. Whether it was the fear of the dark coming across in the gorgeous black and white art style or the fear of been lost, again brilliantly realised in the moments of down-time in between puzzles, this 2D platformer had a great knack for transporting you back to the most vulnerable time of your life. But nothing cements Limbo's atmosphere of childlike fear than the giant spider that stalks you throughout a large chunk of the game. Potentially hidden in the shadows at all times, when you first encounter the enemy you might not even realise what you're dealing with - not until it's too late and you've already been speared by its legs, anyway. Silent and slow, there's something about the way the spider elegantly skulks around the screen that makes it so haunting. It doesn't have any nefarious motivations or goals, it's creation is to fuel that same primal fear you felt so deeply when you were a scared six year old, making Limbo's Spider one of the most imaginative and interesting enemies of any game in the past few years.

7. The First Zombie (Resident Evil)

Everyone remembers their first time, don't they? For me, creeping into a hallway in the original Resident Evil to find a lone zombie, quietly chomping on one of your missing team members before its attention turns to you, was one of the first times a video game properly chilled me to the bone. And I'm sure everyone has a story just like that about this genre-defining game. After a tense build-up exploring the ground floor of the eerily vacant mansion, the first zombie encounter in Resident Evil essentially comes out of nowhere. By this point you've already gotten accustomed to the game's mechanics; the fixed camera, the tank controls, the tense transitions between rooms - each and every new feature builds to this first reveal. The scene itself is perfectly done too, as the camera looms up to a close-up of the now-iconic zombie. That creepy build is immediately matched by the terror that comes with having to actually face-off against it, drawing your weapon against the monster in a claustrophobic part of the hallway with barely anywhere to run. In fact, It was such a well executed first encounter that pretty much every survival horror game since has copied it verbatim.

6. SHODAN (System Shock 2)

It's hard to make computers scary. As much as the '80s and early '90s wanted us to believe the internet could give birth to a terrifying digital land full of horrifying code and malfunctioning AI, cyberpunk stories rarely conjure great villains out of their setups. However, if there was one particular villain that could convince everyone just how pant-wettingly terrifying a potential all-digital future might be, it was definitely System Shock 2's SHODAN. Finding yourself isolated and alone on a space station, you soon become at odds with the game's megalomaniac artificial intelligence. Popping up now and again to talk to the player, SHODAN speaks to you with the same unnerving calmness that makes so many horror icons so unpredictable and so scary. System Shock 2 isn't an out-and-out horror game, there's no emphasis on jump scares or anything like that, but the whole title is filled with such a densely nightmarish atmosphere that you'll spend your entire playthrough completely unnerved - and when you shut off the game and go to bed, your mind's voice will no doubt be accompanied by the erratic and creepy SHODAN herself.

5. The Witch (Left 4 Dead)

Although Left 4 Dead is cut from the same cloth of 28 Days Later style zombie horror rather than the slow, suspenseful scares of Night of the Living Dead, this multiplayer shooter still boasts enough frights to terrify even the most hardened team of players. But the one enemy to guarantee immediately paralysing horror as soon as they turned up was The Witch, because as soon as you heard her distinctive haunting wail, you know you had to be careful. Although Valve's shooter is an extremely fast-paced game, once you hear the sounds of a witch everyone in the team needs to pick their shots and turn off their flashlights as to not alarm the overpowering enemy. Because if you make a mistake and disturb her, The Witch is going to tear you apart. Those unlucky enough to draw the enemy's attention will soon pay for it, as she rips through everything around her, ignoring your team mates and bolting straight for you, signalling certain death in the process.

4. Scissorman (Clocktower)

While some would cite Resident Evil or Silent Hill as the first real survival horror game, there were plenty of precursors that helped shape the genre before the release of those defining titles. One of those milestones was Capcom's 1996 point-and-click adventure game Clock Tower (or Clock Tower 2 in Japan - the original wasn't released in other territories.) Before my time, I didn't have the luxury of playing the unique puzzle game until years after it became a cult sensation, but even then, it was still an absolutely terrifying experience. You spend the entire game being stalked by the fan-titled Scissorman, who'd mess up your puzzle-solving gameplay by forcing you to escape and hide so you wouldn't be chopped to bits. Although the design of the slasher is rather silly in itself, the tension that builds around each of the villain's appearances often hits fever pitch, and the unpredictable nature of the Scissorman meant even the most innocuous of locations were filled with utter terror.

3. Lisa Trevor (Resident Evil Remake)

An original creation for acclaimed GameCube remake of Resident Evil, Lisa Trevor was the skulking abomination that lived below the iconic first game's mansion. Heard at the beginning of the title only through mysterious screams echoing from the mansion's elevator shaft, the haunting tale around Lisa Trevor is teased throughout the entire game in small diary entries or bits of environmental storytelling. Because you spend half of the game piecing together Lisa's tragic backstory, putting each new snippet of info into context while on your travels, you really become invested in the creepy story around the character. While Lisa Trevor herself doesn't have the most imaginative monster design, it's the mystery and suspense around the character that remains so unnerving to this day. From the initial screams at the start of the game to the final reveal, there's a resounding eeriness to the whole storyline that resonates throughout the entire game, and it makes for one of the most affecting experiences in any Resident Evil.

2. Pyramid Head (Silent Hill 2)

Before he became a poster child for an entire franchise, Pyramid Head was the unique creation of Silent Hill 2. Mute, intimidating and forever stalking, the villain was essentially a creepier Nemesis, as the ghostly manifestation would pop up to terrify you throughout the majority of the sequel. However, unlike Nemesis, Silent Hill 2's most iconic creation was scary because of how mysterious he was. Without any real backstory or explanation, you had no idea why Pyramid Head was chasing you throughout the game, and the hints the title did give you allowed players to come up with their own creepy interpretations of the character. Because he could appear without actually attacking you, the game was able to create a suspenseful and unpredictable atmosphere around the villain that made every one of his appearances a terrifying tour de force of uncertainty and supremely high tension.

1. The Baby (P.T)

Although the title and focus of this entry is the weird baby-like thing you find bloody and dirty in the sink of P.T's bathroom, you could pretty much include any character from the experimental horror game on this list and they would still come claim the top spot. Whether it's the instantly terrifying Lisa or the more subtle uneasiness of the radio announcer, everything about the atmospheric nightmare that is P.T will stay with you for days. However, 'the thing in the sink' is perhaps the creepiest of the bunch. You actually hear it long before you see it, with the baby's wails being heard as you move through the corridor, essentially becoming its own character as it haunts you through the early stages of the teaser. But then the previously-shut door to the bathroom cracks open slightly, revealing one of the game's most effective jump scares as you peek through it. It takes a while for it to fully open so you can finally see where the crying's coming from, but the suspense the game builds until that point around this mini-mystery is absolutely one of the highlights of the experience - and a huge part of what made P.T. go down in gaming history across 2014. What are your most nightmarish game enemies? Let us know in the comments!

In this post: 
Outlast
 
Posted On: 
Contributor

Josh has over 11 years of experience as a published writer, having worked nine of those years as a full-time content producer at WhatCulture. In that period he has created hundreds of articles, videos and podcast episodes for multiple WhatCulture channels, specialising in gaming, horror and film & TV. He now primarily works as a senior content producer and presenter on WhatCulture Gaming where he co-hosts the WhatCulture Gaming Podcast, a top 3 UK most listened to gaming podcast that he co-created in 2018. Over the years he has reviewed several high-profile gaming releases, covered industry events with on-site reporting, opined on breaking news, and even kicked off his interviewing career by chatting to childhood hero, Tommy Wiseau.