10 Crucial Video Games That Saved Dying Franchises

It's easy to forget, Call of Duty was on life support before Modern Warfare.

assassin's creed black flag
Ubisoft

There are many reasons why a given franchise might finally collapse under the weight of its own success. For the most part, people demand innovation, and even the most diehard of fans will abandon a franchise that demonstrates an inability to evolve or mature meaningfully with the times.

In the rarest of occasions however, a certain game will come along at a crucial time, and salvage an otherwise dying franchise. It will shake up the formula, and reinvent the mechanics from the ground up, revitalising the series for a whole new generation of players. On these occasions, a franchise can be snatched back from the clutches of oblivion, and given a second chance to redeem itself in the hearts and minds of its most loyal fans.

Here are 10 games that saved dying franchises from themselves…

10. Call Of Duty 4: Modern Warfare

call of duty 4 modern warfare
Activision

Call of Duty wasn't always a sales juggernaut of the video game industry. In fact, prior to the release of Modern Warfare, the series was often outperformed by rivalling franchises, such as Medal of Honour.

Released in 2007 for PC, Xbox 360 and Playstation 3, Modern Warfare took the world by storm, earning multiple game of the year awards, and selling over fifteen million copies worldwide. To put it in perspective: Call of Duty 4 outperformed all previous entries in the series combined, and has since gone on to spawn countless sequels and spin-offs. By comparison, Medal of Honour: Warfighter was a commercial failure, and arguably killed that particular franchise, raising a very important question: Would Call of Duty be alive today, had it not shifted direction and reinvented itself?

As a testament to the game’s continued popularity, Call of Duty: Modern Warfare Remastered was recently announced by Activision, and has quickly become more of a talking point that Infinite Warfare. In fact, the legacy of the game is such that the remastered version will probably outperform more recent entries in the franchise, such as Advanced Warfare and Blacks Ops III.


9. Red Faction: Guerrilla

red faction guerrilla
THQ

Heavily inspired by the work of Phillip K. Dick, and originally released back in 2001, Red Faction tells the story of Parker, a miner on Mars who instigates a rebellion against the nefarious Ultor Corporation. The game emphasised environmental destruction and liner shooting, and was received positively by critics. In 2002, it even managed to spawn a sequel entitled Red Faction II, which was similar in both tone and style to the original.

Despite its relative success, the series seemingly disappeared, and was presumed KIA. In early 2008, six whole years after the release of Red Faction II, it was announced that Volition were working on a third instalment in the franchise. Few details were revealed, but a demo was showcased at E3 that very same year, highlighting the third-person gameplay, destructible environments and open-world exploration. In 2009, the game was finally released to the public, and was received positively by critics, praised for its versatile gameplay and creative storytelling.

Mixing up the formula, and reimagining the gameplay, Volition were able to revitalise a long dormant franchise for an all new generation of players. Unfortunately, the sequel, Red Faction: Armageddon had almost the opposite effect, damaging the series irrevocably with its poor sales, and forcing THQ to shelve the franchise entirely.

With that said, Guerilla prolonged the series' shelf-life considerable, and its eventually failure was only a consequence of THQ's dwindling finances, and eventual bankruptcy.


8. Assassin's Creed IV: Black Flag

Assassin's Creed Black Flag
Ubisoft

Assassin’s Creed 2 was a huge success, both critically and commercially. To this day, it’s considered the best of the series, and that’s unlikely to change any time soon. Unfortunately, AC being an annual franchise, Assassin’s Creed 2 was quickly followed up by three of the most uninspired, bland and repetitive entries in the franchise: Assassin’s Creed: Brotherhood in 2010, Assassin’s Creed: Revelations in 2011, and Assassin’s Creed 3 in 2012.

After several tedious entries, fans were crying out for something completely different, something utterly unique to reinvigorate a franchise which had grown noticeably stale in the three years since Assassin’s Creed 2. In 2013, fans got just exactly that: Assassin’s Creed IV: Black Flag, a game about swashbuckling pirates, and adventures on the high sea.

It sold over ten million copies, and was among the best selling games of 2013. It can also be credited with revitalising the Assassin’s Creed franchise, one that wasn't necessarily dying prior to the release Black Flag, but was certainly in need of a good blood transfusion.

In this case, Assassin's Creed IV: Black Flag saved the franchise critically, rather than commercially. But, who knows? Without it, maybe we'd all have finally gotten sick of the series, and moved on the greener pastures.


7. Alien Isolation

alien isolation
Creative Assembly

Released in 2014 for PC, Xbox One and Playstation 4, Alien Isolation was a welcomed respite after the astonishingly dismal, Aliens: Colonial Marines. It represented a genuine attempt to replicate the atmosphere of Ridley Scott’s original movie, and recapture the spirit of the entire survival horror genre. It did so in remark fashion, demonstrating an extraordinary dedication to the source material, perfectly recreating the tone of the 1979 film.

In the game, players take control of Amanda Ripley, the daughter of Sigourney Weaver’s character in the movies, as she attempts to escape the clutches of a murderous Xenomorph, a powerful extra-terrestrial with an incredible aptitude from tearing limb from limb. Alone, powerless and utterly ineffectual, Amanda must survive the creature, fulfil a whole host of objectives, and make her escape from the remote space station, the Sevastopol.

While the game received a mixed critical reception, and some surprisingly low scores from a handful of prominent online sources, it was generally heralded as a staggering success.

In reality, Isolation was given the almost impossible task of bolstering interest in a franchise that had been irrevocably damaged by the miserable efforts of Aliens: Colonial Marine. Somehow, it managed to succeed where others would have crashed and burned, recapturing our imaginations, and our interest in the future of franchise.


6. Wolfenstein: The New Order

Wolfenstein the new order
MachineGames

Released in 2014, Wolfenstein: The New Order was the seventh instalment in the Wolfenstein franchise, and the sequel to Wolfenstein (2009). Unlike its predecessor, the game was published by ZeniMax Media and developed by MachineGames, a newly founded studio comprised of employees from Starbreeze, the guys and gals behind The Chronicles of Riddick: Escape from Butcher Bay, and The Darkness.

In the game, players take control of William "B.J." Blazkowicz as he attempts to combat the Nazis in an alternate timeline in which Germany won the Second World War. Armed with an array of devastating weaponry, B.J. must fight his way through numerous environments, defeating hundreds of enemies, completing multiple objectives, and ultimately preventing his adversaries from taking over the world.

After multiple failed attempts to rejuvenate the franchise, The New Order was an immense success, both critically and commercially. It was one of the highest selling games of 2014, and spawned a standalone expansion pack the following year, entitled Wolfenstein: The Old Blood. In comparison, the two most recent attempts to revive the franchise enjoyed comparatively little success, especially Wolfenstein (2009), which was panned for its generic gameplay and lack of originality.


5. New Super Mario Bros.

New Super Mario Bros
Nintendo

Released in 2006 for Nintendo DS, New Super Mario Bros. was the first 2D, side-scrolling platformer in the series since Super Mario Land 2, in 1992. In fact, for over a decade, Mario existed exclusively in 3D, and during that time, none of his games were as particularly profitable, or commercially viable as their 2D counterparts. They certainly weren't failures, and many of them are still regarded positively today, but they didn't quite have the same mainstream appeal as Super Mario Land, or Super Mario World.

Super Mario 64 for instance, sold a respectable 11 million copies worldwide, but Super Mario Sunshine for the Nintendo GameCube sold less than half that amount.

By Comparison, New Super Mario Bros. sold over 30 million copies, making it the second highest selling Mario game of all time after the original Super Mario Bros. on NES. Likewise, New Super Mario Bros. Wii sold over 25 million copies worldwide, rivalling its handheld counterpart, and outperforming Super Mario Galaxy 1 & 2 combined.

For the longest time, Nintendo concentrated their efforts on converting their most lucrative franchise into 3D. This was done for the sake of innovation, and it certainly made a lot of sense at the time. After numerous commercial failures, they eventually resorted back to their original formula, and the results were two of the most successful games in the company’s history.

Now, in fairness, Mario would have likely survived regardless, but to what extent? The series wasn't nearly as profitable as it once was, and Nintendo has an awful tendency of eventually shelving franchises that don't meet their expectations.


4. Fallout 3

Fallout 3 The Pitt
Bethesda

Fallout 3 was in development for a long time prior to its eventual cancellation in 2003. The game was originally being developed by Black Isles Studios, and had been delayed on multiple occasions in favour of other projects. Eventually however, the company was disbanded, and the rights to the franchise were sold to Bethesda Softworks.

In 2008, Fallout 3 was finally released after an entire decade of development limbo, and was praised almost unanimously for its scope and design. To date, the game has been awarded multiple awards, and if often cited as one of the finest games of the previous generation. With that said, Fallout 3 almost never happened.

Interplay Entertainment, the original creators of Fallout, very nearly filed for bankruptcy back in 1998. The studio was in dire shape, and even after it went public, its financial issues persisted well into the 2000s. In 2003, Interplay were forced to disband Black Isles Studios, and has since been involved in numerous, costly legal battles with various other companies, including Snowblind Studios, Topware Interactive and Bethesda Softworks.

Thankfully, Fallout 3 made it into the right hands, but had the rights remained with Interplay, and had they actually filed for bankruptcy in 1998, Fallout 3 could have been lost in the shuffle entirely.

That didn’t happen, and Bethesda were able to revive the series successfully, reimagining the franchise for an all new generation of players, giving it the treatment it deserves in the process. Had it ended up in the wrong hands, who knows what condition the series may have been left in, or if it would have even made it to completion at all.


3. Metroid Prime

Metroid Prime Meta Ridley
Nintendo

Released in 2002 for the Nintendo GameCube, Metroid Prime is the fifth instalment in the Metroid franchise, and the first of a new trilogy of games. It’s often been described by Nintendo as a first-person adventure, rather than a first-person shooter, as the game represents something of a hybrid, merging exploration and shooting in order to create a remarkably unique style of gameplay.

In the game, players take on the role of Samus Aran, a bounty hunter tasked with preventing a group of pirates from performing certain genetic experiments on the planet Tallon IV.

Unlike previous entries in the series, the game is predominantly first-person, allowing players to explore three-dimensional environments unimpaired. Throughout the game, Samus can acquire power-ups by defeating certain enemies, and these power-ups allow her to solve numerous puzzles, and advance to previously restricted areas of the map.

In 2002, Metroid Prime accomplished multiple impossibilities: it successfully incorporated first-person shooting into the franchise; it bridged an eight year gap in the series; it reintroduced the universe to new players, and it managed to craft a genuinely engaging story in the process.

Had it failed, you can bet Nintendo would have shelved the franchise for a number of years, or even indefinitely. We have a lot to be thankful for.


2. Resident Evil 4

resident evil 4
Capcom

The GameCube remake of Resident Evil was a critical success, but a commercial failure. The game helped singlehandedly reinvigorate the survival horror genre, and was praised by critics the world over, but it subsequently failed to generate mainstream appeal. In 2005, after numerous failed attempts to revive the franchise, Resident Evil 4 took the concept in an all new direction, shifting the series away from traditional survive horror towards a more commercial action-adventure style of gameplay.

Something of a hybrid, Resident Evil 4 represented a pivotal moment in the franchise, introducing a third person perspective and shifting the emphasis away from survival horror, accentuating pockets of high-octane action more so than ever before. As a result, the game was considered a huge success, selling over six million copies worldwide, making it one of the most lucrative entries in the entire franchise.

Unfortunately, the shift eventually culminated in the release of Resident Evil 6, a game that couldn’t even passably be described as a survival horror. With that said, Resi 4 did nearly everything right, and it saved the franchise from fading into obscurity.


1. Fire Emblem Awakening

Fire emblem awakening
Nintendo

A series which began back in 1990, Fire Emblem has spanned over five generations of home consoles, and produced fifteen unique titles, including multiple sequels and spin-offs. Beginning on the Japanese Family Computer, and later thriving on the Super Famicom, Fire Emblem has always been a huge success with Japanese audiences, but has never enjoyed much success in the West, primarily due to poor localisation efforts on the part of Nintendo.

During an edition of Iwata Asks, former Nintendo president Satoru Iwata revealed that Fire Emblem Awakening was initially planned to be the final game in the series. After years of underperformance, Fire Emblem was finally being axed, and Awakening was developed as the final instalment in the franchise. Surprisingly, the game outperformed expectations, becoming the highest selling entry in the series, and earning itself a second shot.

Since then, Fire Emblem Fates has achieved a similar degree of success, with all three versions of the game selling over half a million copies worldwide. While many of the earlier entries in the franchise are still unavailable outside Japan, Fire Emblem may have finally cemented its legacy in the West, and secured a permanent place in our hearts.

Not bad for a series pronounced dead just four years previous.

--

Which games essentially gave a huge HP boost to a critical health bar? Let us know in the comments!


Contributor
Contributor

Formerly an assistant editor, Richard's interests include detective fiction and Japanese horror movies.