10 Most Depressing Video Game Endings Of All Time

What happened to the days of saving those in distress and going home with a pouch full of gold coins?

Video games were never supposed to have depressing endings. After investing many of our valuable hours in beating the game, we want to be gratified with a happy ending where the heroes overcome evil and go down to their local for a few pints while the bad guys are put in the slammer; Mario saves the princess, Crash puts a beating on Doctor Cortex and Andy is reunited with his dog Whiskey (hats off to those of you who get that one). The modern era of video gaming has seen a shift in this happy ending dynamic, however. With games becoming more and more frequently regarded as a legitimate artform, the endings have adapted to reflect this artistry, trying to evoke an emotional response or challenge gamers rather than rewarding us with what we want to see. Huge innovations in technology also mean that game creators now - unlike in the earlier years of gaming - have the capability to produce the visuals to carry an intricately devised story much like in a big-budget animated film. Combine this with growing numbers of top-level actors like Ellen Page, Liam Neeson and Willem Dafoe lending their voices and likenesses to games and suddenly you see why a game€™s finale now has the ability to carry us off on an emotional roller-coaster. No longer do we start playing a video game expecting all the good guys to merrily return to their fairytale homes in the Mushroom Kingdom by the end. This pessimistic expectation is indicative of the video gaming industry€™s evolution into more of an adult medium overall. Here are the 10 Most Depressing Video Games:

10. Red Dead Redemption

Despite the parodying and high-jinx Rockstar always bring to the table, they are also somewhat ironically the masters of the emotionally taxing grand finale. Their instant-classic take on the Western genre Red Dead Redemption has an ending which is still the cause of much pain in the minds of gamers four years later. Though three years after the ending to the main game€™s story you are given the chance to avenge the dishonourable murder of the game€™s protagonist John Marston with his son Jack, this is very little consolation as John remains dead and Jack has been forced to enter a life of murder which his father wanted him to avoid. When that no-good yellow-belly Edgar Ross shows up at your ranch with his sizeable posse, all the loveable rogue you play as can do is send his wife and son to safety and accept his fate. You then confront the mob and have a quick-draw event to kill off as many as possible, though regardless of how many you fell, John€™s fate is tragically sealed. This is an excellent yet extremely depressing move by Rockstar €“ rather than just depicting John€™s death as a cutscene we are directly involved in it and blame ourselves that our limited skill on the quick-draw wasn€™t enough to kill the entire mob. A Silver Lining? As mentioned previously, it does feel good to avenge your father as Jack. However, killing one man doesn€™t bring another back to life €“ after all, an eye for an eye and we€™re all blind.

9. Tomb Raider: The Last Revelation

Our love affair with Lara Croft and her rather large triangular breasts began in 1996, and three games and three years later came Tomb Raider: The Last Revelation. Taking place primarily in Egypt, Lara accidentally releases the ancient evil of Set and thus is on a mission to rectify her giant mistake, all the while being chased by her former mentor Werner Von Croy who has been possessed by him. After finally imprisoning Set again, Lara makes her way out of the temple as it collapses around her. Von Croy, now free from the evil influence offers his hand to help her to which Lara stoutly refuses, still unable to trust him as he has been a puppet for the preceding parts of the game. Von Croy then is unable to help Lara up from a ledge and is forced to leave as the temple collapses around her. This ending may not be as heart-wrenching as some but many of us believed that the ultimate heroine and woman of our dreams had just died in front of our eyes and that really made our heart sink. It was only with the release of Tomb Raider Chronicles in 2000 that we were told the well-received news that Lara had made an unlikely escape from the temple. Some diehard fans of the series might say that the real Lara died in the temple, as there hasn€™t been a Tomb Raider that lived up to the standard set by her earlier games since The Last Revelation. Quite depressing in its own right really. A Silver Lining? Crystal Dynamics' superb reimagining of the Tomb Raider franchise in 2013 was an excellent game (complete with a fittingly happy ending).

8. Shadow Of The Colossus

While the story of Shadow of the Colossus was a little bit predictable as the game went on, it is still undeniably depressing. You play as Wander; a young man who has been charged to hunt down and defeat 16 creatures of epic proportion in order to save Mono; his true love. After you defeat the last of the giant beasts it becomes all too clear that they weren€™t actually the bad guys but they were there to stand in the way of an evil demon called Dormin. With the Colossi having gone the way of the dodo, Dormin was free and quickly set about ruining your life by possessing you and turning you into some half-goat half-human infant that your love, Mono, decides to take care of. The knowledge that you were the reason these benevolent guardians were slaughtered and you are responsible for all the disharmony in the world created by Dormin is a difficult (and depressing) pill to swallow. A Silver Lining? Hunting down and fighting the Colossi was a blast until we realised they were the good guys.

7. Sid Meier's Civilization V

For a game which ostensibly has no story it may come as a shock that this exceptionally well made strategy game has found a place among this assembly of the saddest endings in all of video gaming. However, picture this scenario €“ you are Ramesses II, the greatest leader Egypt ever had, and you are approaching the final turns in a gargantuan game of Civ. You have nursed an empire from the stone ages which now covers a vast portion of the globe and your cities are all considered cultural hubs by other civilisations. Onto the scene comes warmongering Ghengis Khan who proceeds to launch his nuclear warheads at all your major cities. The conurbations which you had put so much time into to make thrive have been destroyed and their peoples either killed or dying in the fallout. Part of what makes Civ such an incredible strategy game is that the extreme detail it goes into means that after an hour or so of play you actually feel like a nation€™s leader, wholly responsible for the wellbeing of its people. This is why when you€™ve put potentially tens of hours into a game and all of a sudden an aggressive rival decides to come along and try and ruin your day, you feel not only an intense feeling of frustration but also genuine remorse that you€™ve failed your people. A Silver Lining? You may have been defeated but there€™s nothing stopping you booting up a new game and making Ghengis pay right from the Ancient Era.

6. Mafia 2

Vito Scaletta owed many thing to his friend Joe. First he helped Vito get discharged from the army, he gets him connections within the Mafia so he can make a (not so honest) living and gives him a place to live. While his tastes were sometimes a little eccentric and his attitude a little off-the-wall, Joe was one of the few people you could actually trust in the dog-eat-dog city of Empire Bay. It is for this reason that the ending of Mafia 2 is so depressing. After Vito is successful in killing his former boss as a favour to his good friend from prison, Leo Galante, it becomes clear that without the help of Joe it may not have been possible. Joe and Vito get into separate cars and are on the way to celebrate their success when Vito notices the car Joe is in turns off onto a different road. Galante then claims that Joe was not part of the deal, implying he is being sent to be killed. It really is enough to make you shed a tear when you realise the friend you had been so reliant on is being sent to slaughter and there is nothing you can do €“ the game is over and you haven€™t been given the happy ending you thought you had won with all your hard work. A Silver Lining? A particularly optimistic person might find some way to convince themselves that Joe wasn't killed €“ we didn't actually see it happen after all.

5. L.A. Noire

Another horrifyingly depressing gaming ending and once again we see Rockstar at the helm, the scoundrels! LA Noire was essentially CSI on crack in the 1940s. You played as detective Cole Phelps who, despite his personal problems with his wife, is a likeable and hard-working character. As Phelps, you encounter the corruption of the LA Police Department first-hand, discovering that several politicians and colleagues are involved in an insurance fraud scam. After more investigating we find out that the people at the heart of the scam have kidnapped Phelps€™ love interest, Elsa. Phelps manages to rescue her but as they are escaping becomes trapped in a sewer system that is flooding due to heavy rainfall. Phelps gets swept away before he can climb to safety. Perhaps the most depressing thing about this game€™s ending is that one of the corrupt officers, Roy Earle, can be seen speaking in Phelps€™ honour at his funeral in the final scenes of the game. Way to twist the knife there Rockstar. A Silver Lining? Phelps is at least given the hero€™s funeral he deserves.

4. Mass Effect 2

Mass Effect 2 is a very time consuming game; you play as Commander Shepherd who has been bought back to life by the highly dubious Cerberus corporation in order to help stop the impending threat of the Collectors and Reapers. To do this you have to recruit a crack-team of the galaxies finest fighters from a broad spectrum of alien races, and in doing this you learn about the characters and bond with them. You can even start a romantic relationship with some of them €“ it seems that even in space you need a release. So, when it gets to the final mission and you€™ve forgotten to upgrade your ship, you didn€™t have enough renegade or paragon points to resolve the conflict between Tali and Legion and you picked the wrong people to do certain jobs, you€™ll be utterly mortified at the ending you get. Everyone dies like a shoddy B-grade horror movie; everyone you worked so hard on recruiting and gaining their loyalty lies dead, shot down by some advanced alien weaponry. In a puff of smoke all your work is undone and a set of characters you€™ve genuinely bonded with have died and subsequently failed in their mission. A Silver Lining? Even if your version of Shepherd died you are still able to play Mass Effect 3, though be warned it has the potential to be even sadder.

3. Heavy Rain

It must first be stated that this particularly depressing ending is but one of the 17 possible outcomes of Quantic Dreams€™s masterful story-driven crime game. In order to access it, Ethan must get arrested and Madison and Norman have to either die or fail to get to the warehouse at all. In other words, your performance during this play-through of Heavy Rain had to have been pretty woeful, so perhaps you are deserving of the fate which befalls you. It is hard to wish such an ending on even the most hopeless of gamers though as €“ as its name suggests €“ the €˜Hopeless€™ ending to Heavy Rain is deeply psychologically draining. As if the extremely troubling death of his eldest son Jason in the game€™s prologue wasn€™t enough, in the €˜Hopeless€™ ending Ethan is arrested for the death of his younger son Shaun and is found guilty of being the Origami killer. Consumed by guilt at having being unable to save either of his sons, Ethan hangs himself in prison. Quantic Dream? More like Quantic Nightmare. A Silver Lining? One ending down, sixteen to go. Perhaps on your next play-through you€™ll keep Shaun alive and keep his dad out of jail...

2. Metal Gear Solid 3: Snake Eater

When it was released some 10-years ago Metal Gear Solid 3 comprised the normal nukes, espionage and stealth which fans of the series had come to love but what Snake-aficionados didn€™t bargain on was for Konami to throw them a spiteful little curve-ball which left them feeling empty inside after the credits hit the screen. This curveball was of course the now infamous twist at the end of the game which saw Snake killing his former mentor, The Boss, under the false pretence that she had defected to those conniving Soviets. The Boss of course had not defected €“ she had in fact staged the betrayal in order to infiltrate Volgin's ranks; exactly the same move employed by Snape to get in the fold with Voldemort! In the game€™s final cutscene Snake stands over The Boss€™ gravestone, laying down his former mentor€™s gun and some flowers to show his respect. He then salutes and sheds a single tear. How could you do this to us, Konami? A Silver Lining? We all still went out and bought Guns of the Patriots and Ground Zeroes, so Konami couldn€™t have hurt us too bad. It€™s either that or we€™re just huge pushovers.

1. The Walking Dead

The final climatic episode of Telltale€™s superb venture into the world of The Walking Dead is easily the most depressing in a game overflowing with deeply saddening moments. In the closing sequences of the game, Lee €“ the player€™s character €“ has been bitten by a zombie and finds himself embroiled in a race against time to ensure Clementine€™s safety; the young girl he has tasked himself with protecting. After eventually finding her, Lee lays dying and explains to a distraught Clementine what has happened. She begs you not to become one of €œthem€, to which you then have to choose whether to make the innocent young girl shoot you or leave you to rot away into a zombie €“ both extremely tempting choices, right? Regardless of your choice, The Walking Dead€™s ending is as depressing as the medium of video gaming has ever been. Not only do we see a man we€™ve grown extremely attached to in Lee die but we are also subject to a deep feeling of failure as we know we have left Clementine relatively unprepared in the harsh, unforgiving, zombie-plagued world we had vowed to shield her from. Whether you€™re a 14-year-old kid playing or a father-of-six, it is impossible not to feel that parental responsibility for little Clem. The ridiculously strong emotional response provoked by The Walking Dead€™s finale is all the result of Telltale€™s sublime storytelling abilities €“ if ever there was an aptly named developer, they are it (unlike Quantic Dream). A Silver Lining? Over the course of the five episodes Lee was able to prepare Clem for survival in the Zombie-apocalypse, as evidenced in the game€™s second season. Which titles left you just feeling hollow inside as the credits rolled? Let us know in the comments!

Contributor
Contributor

Hailing from South East London, Sam Heard is an aspiring writer and recent graduate from the University of Warwick. Sam's favourite things include energy drinks, late nights spent watching the UFC with his girlfriend and annihilating his friends at FIFA.