10 Most Infuriating Escort Missions In Gaming History

For all of the gripes you might have with modern gaming, is there anything as consistently, outrageously annoying as the escort mission?

For all of the gripes you might have with modern gaming, is there anything as consistently, outrageously annoying as the escort mission? You'll be having a blast playing through an awesome new game and then out of nowhere, you need to shepherd a usually wounded or useless character through a hazardous environment. The penalty for allowing the pathetic wretch to die? A tasty Game Over screen, and then you have to go through the whole thing again. Escort missions are easily one of the most-despised facets of contemporary gaming, yet developers continue to insist on including them in the most headache-inducing ways possible. Granted, the odd game has caught onto this and allowed the escort to die consequence-free (usually in side-missions), but given how most escort missions tie directly into the main narrative, you just have to keep re-trying until you find success. There are enough of these to fill a list of 50, but I've whittled it down to the 10 that scarred my psyche the most, the 10 that make me never want to go back to the game, no matter how great it is, for fear of wasting far too long babysitting some (usually unarmed) chump. As usual, please feel free to add your own suggestions in the comments! And did you actually manage to, dare I say, enjoy any of these missions?

10. Most Of The Game - H.A.W.X.

Generally I can let a game off if it has one short, relatively painless escort mission, and as fun as Tom Clancy's H.A.W.X. is, it contains more escort missions than I can remember. On their own, no single mission in this game is too frustrating, but taking up so much of the game as they do, they severely reduce the fun and make this otherwise entertaining shooter an absolute chore to get through. The only advice I can give is to ensure that you remain within the enemy targeting circle, as this will allow you to draw fire away from the aircraft you have to escort, which too often doesn't seem to be equipped with its own array of weapons. The only remotely memorable escort mission in the game is when you have to protect Air Force One, but that's really only because of the famed craft itself, whereas the rest of the mission is a rehash of everything we've seen before. Thankfully Ubisoft listened to the complaints, and H.A.W.X. 2 doesn't feature anywhere near as many escort missions.

9. Ashley - Resident Evil 4

Arguably the worst kind of escort mission is one that ends up hijacking the entire game, as is pretty much true in Capcom's revolutionary Resident Evil 4. As Leon S. Kennedy, you're tasked with locating and protecting the President's daughter, Ashley Graham, and after acquiring her earlier in the game, you have to babysit her for the rest of it (except for a few sections where she ends up being hauled off). It's a real testament to everything else in this game that I persevered through taking care of such a useless, shrill-voiced character: the key tends to be leaving her hiding inside dumpsters or telling her to stay put while you run ahead and take care of business. Otherwise, you've got quite the problem on your hands, as Ashley is extremely weak and can be killed with enormous ease, which becomes pretty frustrating if you forget to tell Ashley to stop, and she ends up being decimated by a booby trap. Unlike some entries on this list, at least she listens to what you have to say, and does serve a few puzzle-based uses throughout...

8. Yorda - Ico

Another game that's almost completely centered around its escort mission is Ico, which sees the titular protagonist escorting princess Yorda out of an isolated fortress, while shadowy creatures try to drag Yorda away. Though the mechanics on the whole are pretty well implemented (as they should be, given that the whole game revolves around it), Yorda is a pretty annoying escort simply because she's so useless and weak, and the awkward controls can make protecting her a real pain. The game gets a lot of things right, like actually creating a meaningful bond between the two characters (all the more impressive considering the lack of dialogue), and the game is only about 4 or 5 hours in length, though a revised control scheme and an escort character who didn't cling quite so eagerly to the damsel-in-distress trope would have helped the game no end. I'm sure plenty will disagree with Ico being on this list, but due to my own hatred for escort missions, I've only ever been able to play the game through to completion once.

7. Eva - Metal Gear Solid 3: Snake Eater

One of the few minor blips in an otherwise amazing game is the escort mission near the end of Metal Gear Solid 3: Snake Eater, where Big Boss has to protect a wounded Eva, and to make it worse, there are guards hot on your trail. Given how easy most of the latter part of the game is, this is definitely the biggest difficulty spike, and makes for a pretty frustrating experience. The real problem is that though Eva is mostly a helpful, likeable character, here she's injured and so her stamina drains away like a tap, meaning that you constantly have to feed her to keep her going (and if you run low on food, God help you). You have to take down the guards who attack, move forward a few feet, call Eva forward, feed her, rinse and repeat for what seems like an age. In the end, I opted to just knock Eva out and drag her across the map myself, as it meant having total control of the situation and not needing to worry about stamina. Still, this is way more challenging than the final boss fight that follows immediately after, and something I dread every time I replay MGS3.

6. Martin - The Elder Scrolls IV: Oblivion

Oblivion has a mostly excellent attitude towards vital NPC characters: it gives them "essential" status, meaning that they cannot be killed even if you try to attack them, though this all changes late in the game when you have to escort Martin from the Imperial Palace to the Temple of the One, to do battle with the Daedra. At this point, Bethesda stick a giant middle finger up at the player by removing Martin's essential status, meaning that he can be killed, which results in a Game Over. What's more, Martin is only wearing crappy Emperor Robes, so you have to pretty much spend the entire battle by his side, babysitting him to ensure he doesn't die. And unless you're some sort of preternatural expert at this game, Martin is doing to die. A lot. It doesn't help that Martin's dreadfully-programmed AI means that he actively attacks the Daedra, rather than simply fighting defensively: you must keep an eye on his attack patterns and help slay everything he fights.

5. Emma Emmerich - Metal Gear Solid 2: Sons Of Liberty

Talking of giant middle fingers thrust in the face of the player, Hideo Kojima wasn't merely content to give us an escort mission in Metal Gear Solid 2: Sons of Liberty: he made sure to set part of it in water, the second-most loathed mission-type in video game history. Protagonist Raiden has to escort Otacon's feeble sister Emma through a flooded underwater section, and making matters worse, she's scared of water, so you need to literally hold her hand every step of the way, while also dealing with Emma's lower O2 gauge, and bombs scattered throughout the area. Then there's Emma's fear of bugs, at which point you may as well just knock her out and drag her through the area while dealing with the guards posted around. Emma then has to make her way across a strut while Raiden snipes any enemies, cyphers and claymores in her way, only for Emma to be kidnapped by Vamp, and after a boss fight, she ends up expiring anyway. At least Kojima had the good sense to vary up the gameplay a little, but it's still one of the most painfully distended escort missions out there, all the more so because Otacon's sister is such a pathetic wimp.

4. Assorted Quests - World of Warcraft

This doesn't refer to any one quest in particular in the massively popular MMO, but the fact they take AI idiocy to a whole other realm. I strongly recommend you form a group before taking on most of these sorts of quests (especially at higher levels), because they can quickly turn frustrating when the figure you're escorting thinks himself a hero, and decides to start attacking anything within fighting distance. This will usually result in more mobs being lured your way, making what could be a relatively easy job all that much harder. Some escort figures will even just keep moving rather than actually being programmed to follow you, which is particularly troubling given that some scripted attacks will pop up out of nowhere, while you may still be taking care of other mobs the guy lured onto you. And this is all without even considering the fact that troll players can run in and just kill your escort if they so fancy. During my tenure as a WoW player, I tried to avoid these missions as much as possible.

3. The Alchemist - Spyro 2: Ripto's Rage

One of the most infamous missions in any platformer to date is the Alchemist escort mission from the otherwise excellent Spyro 2. The Alchemist must be escorted to Hunter, whose boots have been turned to stone, and only he has the potion to fix it. Lying between the two, however, is the Earthshapers, golem-like creatures who will attempt to attack the Alchemist, and one hit is enough to have you restart the whole dirty mission again. The problem is that the Alchemist doesn't walk in any clearly fixed, delineated pattern, but it's erratic and changes at the last moment: the key is simply to memorise his programmed route, though this is easier said than done because it's so woefully convoluted. Another issue is that the Earthshapers' attacks are very sudden, and as such putting yourself between them and the Alchemist is not as easy as it sounds. I don't think many missions gave me as many angry nights as this: I hate, hate, hate this mission.

2. Eileen - Silent Hill 4: The Room

Silent Hill 4: The Room was not up to the brilliant standards of the original three games, but it was still a suitable entry into the saga...at least for the first half. You see, the second half of the game has you taking Eileen Galvin under your wing, and believe me, this is no ordinary escort mission. The more damage Eileen takes, the more her possession by Walter Sullivan takes hold, and this can ultimately result in her dealing damage to herself, which you need to cure with holy candles. The real kicker comes with the fact that, unknown to the player, the amount of punishment Eileen takes throughout this escort portion of the game has a direct effect on how the ending plays out. The more damage Eileen sustains, the faster she'll end up walking into Walter's deadly thresher machine at the end of the game, and if you've been a good sport at protecting her, you'll manage to save her and get the "good" ending. A good trick is simply to run ahead of Eileen and clear the area before she can catch up, but really, this escort mission (and the fact we're kept unaware of its consequences) just ruined the game for me.

1. Natalya - Goldeneye

And now we have what is surely everyone's most hated escort mission ever. As ground-breaking as Rare's superb adaptation of the classic Bond movie was, this mission felt totally stuck in the past due to the horrendously awful AI of our companion, Natalya. Just the thought of the bone-headed hacker is enough to make me uncontrollably twitch, and it even makes the movie harder to watch. To put it simply, Natalya is the sort of escort character designed by someone actively looking to punish their audience: she gleefully runs headlong into gunfire, and it doesn't seem to matter if it belongs to the enemy or yourself. So infamous is this section of the game that a brilliant live-action spoof has been concocted. If you're man enough to try this mission on the mega-difficult 00 Agent mode, get ready to destroy all furniture in the immediate vicinity. A horrible, horrible section of an otherwise great game. Are there any other horrendous escort missions I missed? Let me know!

 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Stay at home dad who spends as much time teaching his kids the merits of Martin Scorsese as possible (against the missus' wishes). General video game, TV and film nut. Occasional sports fan. Full time loon.