10 Insanely Confusing Video Games Levels You Got Totally Lost In

Watery dungeons, levels made from blood trails... who thought these were okay?!

Halo flood
Microsoft

All of us have been there - playing a game that we're completely captivated in, only to reach a level or dungeon where you end up excruciatingly wandering around in circles for hours. Getting lost in levels is a problem that has lessened over the years as games have become increasingly simplified.

Where today we complain about how worlds are too easily navigable, back in the day the problem would be how the hell we're supposed to find our way through them (and remember, in the olden days the equivalent to asking the internet was writing to Games Master and hoping our question was one of the few deemed worthy of being published in the magazine).

So here's an anti-tribute, if you will, to the levels where we whiled away the hours, stuck in their endless corridors of copy-pasted textures or wraparound geography that made them nigh-on impossible to get out of.


10. Water Temple - Legend Of Zelda: Ocarina Of Time

Nintendo
Nintendo

Coming across the Lakebed Temple in Twilight Princess for the first time caused many gamers to emit a resigned 'here we go again' sigh, because it's clearly a successor to the infamous Water Temple in Ocarina of Time - the most confusing dungeon in the Zelda canon.

Submerged beneath Lake Hylia, the Water Temple is made up of five floors which you move between by regulating the water levels. There isn't much finesse to the level design here, which feels like a whole load of rooms messily plastered over each other. In the original N64 version, the constant need to go into your equipment screen to put on the iron boots made it a particular drag, though this was fixed and made more accessible in later remakes.

As if water levels weren't bad enough in games already, this one managed to be confusing as well as cumbersome to play. If it didn't happen to exist in one of the best games of all time, most of us would probably have given up at this point.


9. Wood Side Apartments - Silent Hill 2

Konami
Konami

Silent Hill 2 is a game intentionally designed to be disorienting, as you wander around in a psychological and literal haze trying to figure out why you received a letter from your supposedly dead wife from the titular town. One of the first buildings you enter in the game - the Wood Side Apartments - embodies that confusion perfectly.

Spread across three almost pitch-black floors of corridors, rotting apartments, and the infamous mannequin monsters, the corridors look near-identical to each other, and the map is intentionally obtuse. It doesn't show you your current location, forcing you to rely on red scribbles that show you which doors are locked as you attempt to open them.

As well as being geographically confusing, the apartments contain several logical-yet-cryptic puzzles involving clocks, rubbish chutes and coins, which can take a long time to figure out. It's a deviously confusing and tough start to a challenging game, feeding perfectly into the tone the devs wanted to convey.


8. Any Dungeon - Elder Scrolls II: Daggerfall

Bethesda
Bethesda

Flying way back in time to the days before such notions as 'user-friendly' existed, the dungeons in the infamously oversized second entry in the Elder Scrolls series were dark, hellish warrens that consumed many an intrepid traveller.

Filled with identikit textures, and a grim palette of murky greys and browns, Daggerfall's dungeons were huge and procedurally-generated, meaning that there was pretty much no way to memorise their layout. There was a so-called automap that appeared as you explored, but it was so convoluted that you were better off grabbing a pen and graph paper, and mapping the places out yourself.

The forcibly intricate nature of these dungeons were enough to put plenty of people off from pushing on with Daggerfall, particularly those coming to it from a position of privilege like Oblivion.


7. Vivec - Morrowind

Bethesda
Bethesda

One of the unique and charming things about Morrowind is that while it has a half-decent map and navigation system, it doesn't in any way hold your hand, and you often need to rely on good old-fashioned roadsigns or word of mouth to find certain places in the game.

But one area where a satnav system would've been handy is the central city of Vivec, an impressive but disorienting place made up of nine pyramid-like islands that are connected to each other via walkways. Almost all of these cantons look identical, with each one having four tiers, so your map is completely useless at telling you where you'll find stairs to ascend the cantons, and walkways to move between them.

If you find yourself on the ground level, then a nifty trick is to use the boatman to take you across the water to whichever canton you want to get to, turning your visit into a Venice-like sightseeing tour rather than 'gerbil trapped in a maze' experience.


6. Nightmares - Max Payne

Max Payne Dreams
Remedy Entertainment

The two nightmares in Max Payne make my lists for all number of reasons - from how scary they are to how difficult they are to get through. This level isn't something that can be overcome with your deft bullet-time skills, and instead is something you pretty much have to guess your way out of.

Firstly, you need to weave your way through a maze of corridors that loops back on itself unless you take the right path. You're supposed to follow the sounds of your baby's screams to get out, but frankly it's hard to tell whether they're getting closer or further away. Once you manage to find your way out of the corridors, you then enter another maze - this time made up of blood trails floating around in space that are not only confusing, but extremely thin and easy to fall to your doom from.

If you're familiar with these tedious levels, they can take you as little as a couple of minutes to get through, but people have been known to end up here for as long as 45 minutes. An appropriately nightmarish experience.


5. 8-4 - Super Mario Bros

Nintendo
Nintendo

Once you've nailed the path here that ensures you won't get stuck in an endless loop on the final level of Super Mario Bros, finding your way out of is something you could do blindfolded. But come into it fresh, and you'll be left scratching your head as the level timer ticks down, before freaking out when you get the dreaded noise to indicate that your time is running out.

8-4 looks like your typical Bowser castle - all white brickwork, black backgrounds and red lava, but it's not a simple matter of just traversing it from left to right like other Mario levels, as it'll keep you coming back to the same places unless you jump into the correct pipes. There's no real way of knowing which pipes you're supposed to jump into, because nothing says good level design like goddam guesswork, right?

To make things even more confusing, there are two Bowsers on this level, but one of them is a fake one you need to fight if you go the wrong way. How lovely.


4. The Great Maze - Super Smash Bros. Brawl

Nintendo
Nintendo

Smash Bros. is a fighting game, right? We can all agree on that. And while I always found 'adventure modes' in one-on-one fighters a bit contrived, I can appreciate why people enjoy working their way through the Subspace Emissary levels in Smash Bros. But whoever designed this mode must have run out of creative juice or had a breakdown upon making the final level, which is essentially a gauntlet run of all the bosses in the game.

What makes it worse is that to actually fight them, you need to seek out randomly placed doors that lead you through to each one. These doors are scattered all over the level, so really you need to use the in-game map - a damn map in a fighting game - to know where to go. It obviously goes for that whole 'Metroidvania' feel, but fails miserably.

As you defeat the bosses and less doors remain in the level, it turns into a scavenger hunt, as you go back and forth in increasing frustration, just hoping that you happen upon that elusive door to take you to the next fight.


3. Blighttown - Dark Souls

FromSoftware
FromSoftware

One of the most notorious areas in the Souls series, Blighttown is a dingy, decrepit place deep in the bowels of the earth. The area is incredibly dark, and it's easy to overlook rickety paths you're supposed to go down, or a Blowdart Sniper hiding in the seemingly endless towers of wooden scaffolds.

The general rule in Blighttown is that you want to keep heading down until you reach the very bottom, but the area is so homogeneous and disorienting that it's easy to go up one path, then circle back round without realising that you've already been in that place before. Even when you make it out of the shambolic town itself and reached the bottom, you need to find your way through a murky swamp, then after you've defeated the boss you need to scale a confusing water wheel to finally find your way out of there.

There are few experiences quite as relieving as finally emerging back on the surface after surviving Blighttown, which almost makes the experience worthwhile. Almost.


2. Limbo (E3M7) - Doom

id Software
id Software

When it comes to confusing levels, Doom was certainly king, but as I wrote earlier about Daggerfall, it seems that every video game level from the 90s was designed with the intention to get us lost (maybe with the twisted logic that it keeps us playing for longer?).

Doom thrives when you're pinned down against an assortment of demons and somehow manage to blast your way out of them, not when you're using teleports to bounce around between near-identical room, hoping that one of them will somehow spew you out where you want to actually be. Along with the excess of teleporting, you also need to tug away at a huge number of switches, which don't open up something that's immediately visible to you, but some piece of wall that you have to then go and search for.

True to its name, this map will leave you feeling like you're running around in endless circles, and it seems that even the demons prefer not to hang out here as indicated by the fact that there are hardly any of them in the entire level. It's been said many times before for many different reasons, but 'John Romero, what in the seven circles of hell were you thinking?'


1. The Library - Halo

Microsoft Studios
Microsoft Studios

So revolutionary in so many ways for the FPS genre, even the great Halo was guilty of the occasional piece of level design that felt like a throwback to the 90s. Credit to the Library for being one of the creepier and more atmospheric levels in the game, but it was still a dark, confusing mess of vast chambers and corridors that were impossible to tell apart.

On top of that, you had to deal with what felt like endless waves of Flood enemies while trying to figure out where the hell you're supposed to go. This meant that playing the level (unless you somehow memorised it), would often entail hugging a wall until you found some way through while shooting hordes of enemies. Oh, and watch that flashlight battery, because without it you're screwed.

The toughness of the Library has made it something of a Badge of Honor in the Halo community, and earned it a solid rep as a fun co-op level. Get through the Library's combination of confusing layout, endless enemies and excessive length of Legendary difficulty, and you can consider yourself the most masterly of Master Chiefs.

Which video game levels left you lost and confused? Are you still stuck in them now? Do you need the emergency services to help get you out? Let us know with a comment!


In this post: 
Max Payne1
 
First Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Gamer, Researcher of strange things. I'm a writer-editor hybrid whose writings on video games, technology and movies can be found across the internet. I've even ventured into the realm of current affairs on occasion but, unable to face reality, have retreated into expatiating on things on screens instead.