10 Most Crushing Gaming Disappointments Of All Time

I€™ve seen my fair share of disappointments in my twenty-one years on this rock. There was the time I saw the brilliance of The Phantom Menace. There was the time I couldn€™t go on The Hulk ride in Florida because I was too short; and there was the time I was tricked into trading one of my Pokemon cards (a shiny Raichu) for a fake Mew. Since then, I€™ve matured with a Pink Floyd style wall surrounding me so I€™ll never be disappointed again; or so I thought. Like everything in the world, there is a fair share of disappointing games and while I would put an absolutely massive amount on this list, I just can€™t include them all. So think of this not as THE ten disappointments, but obviously the ten most crushing disappointments I have personally played so far. I€™ll most likely create another list at some point. So maybe I should rephrase the title and call it€ €˜My Most Crushing Gaming Disappointments of All Time€. So Far€™ I digress. Even though games like Alone in the Dark and Haze are renowned for their s**ttyness. Luckily, I€™ve never played them and therefore am not including them to my list. Also, (just to clarify) when I say €˜disappointing€™, I mean the game failed to satisfy our expectations. Furthermore, don€™t expect to find older titles like E.T or Bomberman: Act Zero on this list because they€˜ve been spoken about time and time again, and all I€™d be doing is throwing my two scents into the already full coin purse. Warning: there are spoilers and adult humour in this article.

10. Silent Hill 3 €“ May 23rd 2003

In my fantastic opinion this would be much, much higher than number ten, however, because I have such a love for Silent Hill 2 I am somewhat clouded in my judgment. That in mind I do understand that Silent Hill 2 isn€™t without its terrible tank controlled, drunken camera angled, awful combat problems; but I€™ll elucidate why Silent Hill 2 is a shining example of gaming prowess at a later date. As a quick history lesson, the first Silent Hill wasn€™t what I€™d call incredible as it revolved around some childish cult and controlled like a tapir on a Segway. Fortunately, the second moved so far away from the original I€™d scarcely call it a sequel. With the Silent Hill flag flying high I could be forgiven for exploding in excitement when news of a third instalment echoed from Konami HQ, but I was a young foolish boy back then. Silent Hill 3 isn€™t disappointing because of the horrible controls that are not so much tank style as they are lashing protagonist Heather€™s legs to a rotting elephant seal. It€™s not the fact the Heather€™s voice actress (coincidentally named Heather Morris) delivered her lines like a disgruntled mailman. What truly killed Silent Hill 3 was its underwhelming, boring story about a girl that seemed completely inept; falling into the plot rather than being the driving force behind it. Without spoiling the endings, Silent Hill 3 only has three ways to end; one being the €˜Normal€™ ending which is the stock ending you get no-matter what you do on your first try. So even if you collect the four thousand points for the €˜Possessed€™ ending on the first go, you€™ll be stuck with the €˜Normal€™ ending which is dreadful. The reason it€™s so dreadful is that Silent Hill 3 is a spiritual sequel to the first, revisiting the whole cult malarkey and totally p**sing all over the franchise. This consequent p**sing started a horrendous smelly slope that gave birth to deformed children like Silent Hill: The Room and Homecoming which threw out immersive horror for cheap loud noises. Silent Hill 3 completely destroyed the franchise that almost ten years of development hasn€™t undone. Cheers Heather, outstanding job.

9. Uncharted 3: Drake's Deception- November 2nd 2011 (EU)

I have always enjoyed Naughty Dog€™s games like Crash Bandicoot before he moved to Konami and was entirely ruined. I also liked Jak and Daxter for its colourful charming world that was punishingly difficult at times and actually felt like an adventure. Alas, the second and third games were bloody terrible and all the racing malarkey just turned me off like a girl when I tell them: €œI€™m a video game journalist€. After a few years Uncharted: Drake€™s Fortune exploded onto our shelves and while having a bit of an iffy story, the adventure more than made up for it. Among Thieves was the second instalment and again, while having an even worse story, the cinematic set pieces were extremely entertaining, like punching a sperm whale. So by the time Drake's Deception came out I was ready for a pretty poor story, but some outstanding cinematic spectacles. Whilst this was somewhat true because the ship and plane scenes are pretty amazing, the story and more importantly the ending, was inexcusable. The conclusion is almost like a fairy-tale and seems completely rushed. I know Uncharted has always dabbled in the whole ancient magical artefacts nonsense, but double D took it way too far. Also, the dialogue is so Americanised and cheesy it makes me recoil like an embarrassed armadillo. The chemistry between Drake and Elena Fisher has never been excellent, but in Drake's Deception it€™s so stock I may use it to flavour my soup. It€™s so safe and commercial; Elena has a spunky tough chick disposition while Drake (when he is around her) becomes utterly stupid like his brain fell out his arse. We€™ve seen this in countless movies and having it in the game world hasn€™t made it any better. Drake and Sully€™s dialogue however, was decent and even funny at times, but I still left Uncharted 3: Drake's Deception feeling pretty disappointed. As my last gripe, I have always found Drake's posture very odd, like he€™s constantly got a bad back; I can€™t be the only one who thinks that.

8. Star Wars: The Force Unleashed II - October 29th 2010 (EU)

As I am a Star Wars fan, and I say "Star Wars fan" with an incredible amount of jam in my mouth because €˜New Hope€™ and €˜Empire Strikes Back€™ are the only good ones, I felt the need to buy Star Wars: The Force Unleashed. I supposed the game was entertaining in a mindless way, but that€™s about it. Anyway, after The Force Unleashed came and went I was intrigued to see what they€™d do for the sequel as, (spooky spoiler) you die at the end, which for story continuation isn€™t great. However, all my doubts were put to rest because The Force Unleashed II has no plot in favour of seemingly random events between about four levels. It€™s bloody bananas, it€™s like the development team were creating DLC then realised if they popped Yoda€™s face on the back of the box art; fans would buy it so fast they wouldn€™t have time to complete it, which I honestly think happened. The Force Unleashed II is a perfect example of a game that€™s padded more than a leaking urinal. The number of times you have to defeat some huge automaton is just plain silly. It seems every other step a robot is hiding round the corner waiting to shock you like the world€™s worst surprise birthday party. But, the worst part of Star Wars: The Force Unleashed II is the loveably named: Starkiller. He is too damn powerful. The man€™s a walking death machine and I have no idea why he hasn€™t recognised he€™s the most commanding thing in the universe and started a dictatorship. This means no enemy poses any threat and makes a padded game ironically painfully short. Adding to that, the end battle with Mr. Vader was so laidback my spine snapped.

7. Mass Effect 3 €“ March 9th 2012 (EU)

Come on. This isn€™t a surprise. Even though I said in my last article Mass Effect 3 had €˜a massively disappointing ending and I€™m not even a fan€™; this doesn€™t mean I don€™t understand how irritating it was. I put my spare time into each Mass Effect game admittingly half-heartedly, only to have an ending that was so poor I felt like calling the Salvation Army. However, that in mind, the disappointment starts way before the arse of an ending. Mass Effect 3 starts on Earth where Commander Shepard is on trial for whatever you decided in the previous game. After the Reapers attack Earth, Shepard being a courageous leader leaves and so begins this era's romantic adventure. Being BioWare we all know the set-up. A huge amount of your time will be defending some base that resembles Hoth and chatting with people that look like dinner plates. The cover-based system returns and is largely unchanged from the previous titles. The only difference I could see is the controls feel more stiff and rigid like Commander Shepard is carved out of wood. One vulgar change is the most clumsy dodge roll, like Shepard knows we€™re watching and is coming across with stage fright. Shepard€™s dialogue is awful and he sounds like a bloody robot. He gives off the impression that he doesn€™t care about saving the universe and would rather head down to the bar and try to score with some alien. And as always, the cut scenes are pants. Half the time characters will suddenly take a long pause mid-sentence like they€™ve smelt a rancid fart. Identical to Mass Effect 1 and 2, you have choices throughout which change the course of your own personal experience, when in actuality, it boils down to one single choice you make in the last stretch of the game. And those endings are so God awful it makes me wish I spent my time more productively like creating a PowerPoint on: Commander Shepard: The Sexual Predator. I€™m just thankful I€™m not a fan of the series because I would be one million times more frustrated than I am now.

6. Resident Evil 5 €“ March 13th 2009 (PAL)

Alright, the zombies are Black, but this isn€™t the reason that it was disappointing, so let€™s take no notice of the cries from idiots because like a child walking into traffic, attention is all they want. Resident Evil 5 well and truly mishandled the chance to exploit the success of Resident Evil 4, the game which put Capcom back on the map. Sure Resident Evil 5 had the same control set up and quick-time events, but it lacked imagination as a lot of the set pieces where similar to RE4. Like Star Wars: The Force Unleashed II, it has that DLC feel because the campaign is excruciatingly anorexic in length. Adding to that, it is buggy as all hell. I played it both on my PS3 and on a friend€™s 360 and while the PS3 seemed better with rendering problems, both games kept freezing or locked my gun out so I couldn€™t change weapon and things of that horrid nature. Having a sidekick really put my knickers in a twist because you have to keep an eye on her and it€™s just another bloody mouth to feed. Tell me why she€™d spend hours pistol popping a horde of zombies when carrying a massive shotgun? Tell me why after getting completely overrun by said horde would I have to break away from what I€™m doing and save her (admittedly) nice arse. And why, oh bloody hell why, does she use all the healing items if she so much as scrapes her knee? There I was hanging on by a damn thread, but not having any healing items in my utterly ridiculous nine-box inventory screen I had to crawl over to her and request a spray. However, she had other plans because her tummy was feeling a little dickey and used five bloody sprays and left me for dead. My hunch is, Capcom didn€™t think that RE4 was going to explode like it did and when it was time to make RE5 the idea bucket was totally empty, but this doesn€™t excuse the level of poor design on their part. Still, it€™s not as bad as Resident Evil 6, but if you thought RE6 was going to be a decent game you probably thought using a brick would make an excellent substitute for a sandwich.

5. Dishonored €“ October 12th 2012 (EU)

001 The hype for this game was so outrageous it led me to believe that it was going to be bloody horrible, but as someone who enjoys stealth/arguably free-running in video games I waited till it came down in price and gave it a whirl. And, while whirling about, Dishonored demonstrated once again free-running doesn€™t work from a first person perspective. It€™s like playing as a bloody giraffe because I feel like my characters neck is seven feet long and fears the treacherous spotted hyena. Dishonored was supposed to be an incredibly flexible stealth, somewhat steam-punk experience, but let me tell you having the ability to teleport in a stealth game is like me competing in a blind triathlon, it€™s just not fair and everyone€™s going to think I€™m a t**t for trying it. Also, gunning against enemies armed with a cockney accent and a wooden stick when you€™re armed with a sword, a crossbow, a gun, the power to control plague rats as well as other animals, the ability to travel through time, the power to turn people to ash, the ability to concentrate air into an orb which can be used to attack enemies without touching them; isn€™t what I€™d call a fair fight. Furthermore, the plot is pretty poor. For starters, the whole story could have been avoided if our playable character Corvo just coughed up some words and said: €œNo I didn€™t kill the Empress, some bloke popped in and shivved her. I was busy catching up on Desperate Housewives€. So why he just randomly takes the blame is bizarre to say the least. Dishonored has a moral choice system consisting of two endings depending how you play the game. I stealthed through Dishonored and got a pretty pants ending, so I looked at the alternate ending online and it wasn€™t any better. What Dishonored does well is having a sandbox mission style that could have redeemed the game to a miniature extent, if it wasn€™t only nine petite chapters long.

4. Portal 2 €“ April 21th 2011 (PAL)

I know this is going to be hard to swallow like filthy black tar, but Portal 2 was a disappointing game. Yes, the graphics were great, the controls lovely and fluid and the dialogue was fantastic, but level design and the story are the two snags in Portal 2. Firstly, the entire middle-to-end portion consisted of painfully irritating levels where you€™d search a dull brown empty room for the single solitary white spot, and there€™s a sex joke in there somewhere, so much so that I wondered if my PS3 wasn€™t rendering the level properly. I resorted to a walkthrough online purely because I didn€™t have the strength to continue like a man filling his pockets with rocks before walking into the sea. Secondly, the story just got in the way. Now don€™t get me wrong, I love it when the story takes front and centre, but there are two occasions where the plot jumps in mid-level and stops you completing the puzzle. It aggravated me because I enjoy the feeling of accomplishment when I best GLaDOS at her own game, so having her stop me is like me giving you a picture of a beautiful country house to assemble and then, kicking it off the table and telling you your parents are getting a divorce. Regrettably, all the quite frankly astounding jokes weren€™t enough to make up for the fact I felt disappointed at the end. Though it does culminate in a pretty awesome ending, unfortunately it arrives too late like the world€™s most indolent paramedics. Portal only had a handful of people working on it and this meant the game was watertight. However, with Portal 2, you feel the whole wave of Valve behind it, which is why it€™s so jam-packed, like Valve wanted to fatten Portal 2 up till it inevitably burst.

3. Crysis 2 €“ March 25th 2011 (EU)

001 Mother of Richard Dawkins, this is one of my all-time hated games. Crysis bloody 2 is so bad, the first time I bought it I thought it gave me a UTI and returned it within a week. I couldn€™t take how face punchingly terrible it was, but I€™ll be damned if I let a game beat me, and I recently re-bought it. And, because I€™m apparently a masochist; I spent eight hours non-stop playing through it from start to finish and now, I am unquestionably sure that Crysis 2 was a waste of my damn time. Liking the first game to an extent because the story was alright and it€™s hard to forget that the CryEngine does one thing brilliantly, and that is jungle environments, setting Crysis 2 in a city seemed a tad odd like someone knocking on your door with a tea spoon. Okay, there are parts set in the jungle so those who bought it on PC can watch their computer smoulder, but these parts aren€™t long and then it€™s straight back to grey, wrecked New York. The story goes; Aliens invade New York and infect everyone with a chesty cough apart from you, Alcatraz and Prophet from the first game. Some huge insertion doesn€™t go to plan and to save your life, Prophet puts you in the nano-suit but doesn€™t say every enemy in the city wants to kill whomever is in that suit. So it€™s not so much saving your life as slightly prolonging it. While Crysis 2 paces itself well at the beginning with a nice relaxing walk through the broken streets of New York, for me it becomes far too relaxed and falls asleep. A building does fall down at some stage, but I think that was something to do with poor workmanship rather than an exciting set piece. What also got my blood boiling was how Alcatraz throws objects like a sparrow swims. Adding to that, your stealth robe deactivates when you throw anything making that ability absolutely useless. And, while I€™m talking about crap abilities, your armour, sprint and cloak all use the same energy which is bloody senseless. If you cock up a stealth section because you ran out of juice, you€™re not going to be able to flee like a little girl. Then again, for some reason the aliens stop flying around in their super high-tech space ships in favour of walking about sightseeing completely disinterested with you and your special suit. Maybe this is why the game is so bloody easy it makes buttoning your shirt seem taxiing. One immense problem I have with Crysis 2 is anyone who plays it will never discuss the actual game play or plot, and will blabber on about the CryEngine like it€™s a pant-wetting miracle. I don€™t care how good your damn graphics engine is. Life has a good graphics engine and it€™s bloody awful.

2. Batman: Arkham City €“ 21st October 2011 (EU)

After Batman: Arkham Asylum surprised me in 2009 like a fish splashing out of your Coco Pops, hearing about the sequel being set in a city of all things disappointed me from the get go. One of the fantastic parts of Arkam Asylum was in the name; it€™s set in an asylum over one-night, keeping the story tight as a 18th century woman's corset. Also, it made sense that all of Batman€™s villains would be trapped in the asylum and not just knockin€™ about in some cartoonish sectioned off metropolis. Furthermore, it seems in a desperate attempt to get everyone in, each villain's screen time has been cut in half. Gone are the lengthy nightmarish Scarecrow scenes and in its place, we have each villain quickly yelling their plans at Batman before handing it over to the next. The Riddler is back with his question marks and in an attempt to counter sexism on his part, has given Catwoman a few of her own. Even though in Arkham Asylum I wanted The Riddler to have an actual physical role, I almost wished they didn€™t pop him in Arkham City because like I€™ve said above, there are too many villains clogging up space, like a blocked toilet. Plus, I was hoping for more in the first encounter. I did like what the developers were trying to do with his character, but in my eyes the perfect Riddler would be riddles set in Saw-style traps. However, everything I loved is still in Arkham City, Batman for one; the fantastic controls and combat, the nifty gadgets and the villains while misplaced, were a good representation in this realistic Batman world. What did get on my nerves was having to play as bloody Catwoman, who looks like a smelly hooker and is about as likeable. Plus, not being a thirteen-year old boy, I did not enjoy her (apparently) funny and or sexy dialogue which, I guess was added to set women back another fifty years. Whilst Catwoman controls like s**t and is nothing like Batman and his fabulous cape, they both suffer with how bloody dark and cluttered the city is. I understand the developers were trying to create a certain frightening mood for Arkham City, but it makes me look like a bit of a plonker if I€™m yelling about justice and righteousness to a damn bin because I can€™t see what the Hell€™s going on. Arkham City isn€™t that bad of a game and the game I love is in there somewhere. However, creating a sequel has only added filth to a title that was almost squeaky clean.

1. LA: Noire €“ 20th May 2011 (EU)

When I heard that L.A: Noire was to be set in the late 1940s and was going to be so heavily story driven the wheels were going to buckle, it certainly got my interest stick up. And, for the first three hours it was a fantastic game, the characters were engaging, the scenery was brilliant and I liked how you couldn€™t whip out your gun willy-nilly. This isn€™t GTA boys and girls; you€™re not Niko Bellic, a man who€™s so trigger-happy I€™m surprised he€™s not American. Anyhow, the game is played through chapters and the serial killer section by far was the most appealing with its twists and turns finishing in a pretty intense pursuit through an underpass. After that however, the story seemed to call it a day and went home to have a quickie before bed. Once you have foiled the plans of a serial killer, heading down to vice and arson to either find some crack whore or lumber around a burnt down house for ten minutes isn€™t exhilarating...it€™s awful. What really aggravates me is there€™s so much to like in L.A: Noire and yet it still didn€™t work. However, being the crafty man I am I have discovered why that is. It peaks too early like an inexperienced peeping Tom. I understand Rockstar wanted to start off with a bang, but remember after a bang there is the inevitable mess that must be cleaned up. Nothing thrilling happens for a massive amount of L.A: Noire and the impressiveness of the animation does begin to dither. The level of realism does go a wee bit over board when (after a mission) you are graded out of five stars which includes finding clues, interrogation technique, suit etiquette and damage to your car and the city. I understand you€™re a cop and you shouldn€™t smash the city you€™re trying to protect, but don€™t take away a star because there€™s a ding on the bloody bonnet. And while I€™m on cars, they handle quite differently from GTA4, meaning they turn faster than a straight man in the presence of Robert Downey Jr. The final nail in the coffin of L.A: Noire is the utterly out of place ending. The game till now has been about interrogations, locating clues and the controversy around Mr. Phelps. But then, we find ourselves armed with a flamethrower in a flooding sewer burning gangsters alive. Oh deary, deary me. It€™s like Rockstar couldn€™t think of an exciting ending to fit with the neo-noir mood so said: €œscrew this€, and opted for ridiculousness. On the well-animated face of it, L.A: Noire is a decent game for the first few hours, but it really phones it in after that. It€™s still a great concept, and I would like to see Rockstar have another crack at it. Lord knows we need games with actual story elements, rather than games where the writers create the plot by inhaling paint fumes for half an hour. There you have it, that€™s my list over with and I can at last go back to playing Far Cry 3. With any luck, it won€™t end up on my next disappointment list.

 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Thomas James Hunt is a British Video Game Critic who is a rather unpleasant character in the journalism world. So brace yourself for some nasty behaviour in the form of articles.