10 Most Infuriating Cards In Magic: The Gathering

From stopping effects to stopping you playing the game, what are the most annoying cards in MTG?

Teferi Time Raveller
Wizards Of The Coast

For a game that's been going for 27 years and has over 10,000 unique cards, the game is surprisingly well balanced. No, please don't shoot me for saying that, I know that there are a good deal of crazy effects, ridiculous mechanic and game-breaking combos but most formats regularly put out ban lists and stop the deck-builds that are just too good. Still, Wizards of the Coast aren't perfect, they're the ones who balanced D&D after all, and there are a few cards that slip through the cracks here and there.

These cards aren't necessarily the most powerful or the easiest to play, but they are the ones which pack the most punch - and by that I mean be prepared for your opponent to want to punch you in the face if you play one of these cards, as this is a list of the 10 most infuriating cards to play against. Most of these cards aren't just annoying for your opponent, but can also be exhausting for you if you're the one playing these ridiculous cards, unless your deck is specifically built around them.

So draw your seven cards, prepare your strategy and...do nothing because my card said so.

10. Aura Shards

Are you sick of those pesky enchantments and artifacts that your opponents are playing? Well, you could stack your deck full of targeted removal, or you could simply include one of these. In all seriousness though, please don’t, you’re likely to lose a lot of friends if you play this card.

On the flip-side. Playing against this card with any deck can be mind numbing. While it might not look like much from the get-go, this effect triggering every time its controller plays a creature means it will eventually wipe out all of your artifacts and enchantments. That, again, might not sound like much as there are board wipes which do similar things, but this sustained effect means that you can’t even risk playing these types of cards for fear that they’ll be quickly removed.

And if you happen to be playing an artifact deck when your opponent whips this out, congratulations, that one card just lost you the game.


9. Rule Of Law

Have you ever had one of those turns where everything comes together and you play out your entire hand? Maybe it’s even better than that and you’re able to draw almost your entire deck, playing out the best parts of it with something like Omniscience and working your way to a strategic victory. Or maybe it’s simpler that that, perhaps you just know that on your turn you’ll play card A followed by card B and it’ll trigger an effect which can help you pull back when your life total isn’t looking so great.

Regardless of which of those situations you’re in, prepare to say goodbye to that luxury. Rule of Law is a card that for only 3 mana stops you playing spells. Oh, don’t get me wrong, you can play ’a’ spell, but not multiple. Every turn, everybody at the table has to choose what the most useful thing to do is as everyone looks at one another hoping that the other players have some sort of enchantment removal.


8. Teferi, Time Raveler

While aggro decks are fine, and playing with all of your mana on your own turn is fine also, many magic players enjoy the complexities of playing most of their cards on other peoples’ turns, of playing mind games of whether you have that counterspell in your hand or if you have something to stop the boatload of damage about to come your way.

I’m of course talking about instant spells, one of the most core and key components to any game of Magic the Gathering. Some decks have but a few, others revolve around them, and some people choose to deny everyone this joy. Teferi, Time Raveler completely shuts off other people playing spells outside their own turn, while allowing its caster to maintain this luxury. It completely stops some decks from working at all, forcing players to use their well-planned strategies on their own turn when it’s less convenient or do nothing at all.


7. Torpor Orb

An enormous percentage of creature cards in MTG have effects which only trigger when they enter the battlefield. Blizzard’s card game, Hearthstone, calls this ability Battlecry but Magic doesn’t have a specified term for this. Regardless, many creatures, including staple creatures in most decks, have it. From Sin Collector to Eternal Witness, these cards can make up the fundamentals of a deck or can be give you the effects which let you finally win that drawn out game.

For only two mana, in any combination of colours or colourlessness you like, you can completely shut this mechanic down. Yup, Torpor Orb blocks these effects completely. What’s more, as it specifies that creatures entering the battlefield don’t trigger abilities, any existing cards you might have on the board that trigger when a creature enters now just don’t. That Angel’s Tomb you have on the board to produce some angels when you play a creature? Nope, it doesn’t trigger.


6. Linvala, Keeper Of Silence

Something potentially even more essential to the game of Magic the Gathering than battlefield entry effects are those effects which you activate. Whether it be through mana or by tapping the card, there are so many creatures with an ‘activated ability’. Sure, if your opponent is playing a Deathrite Shaman in your casual friendly game then go for it, they probably had it coming, but in no other circumstances should you ever consider being ‘that guy’.

As well as outwardly preventing some of the most interesting and powerful creatures in magic from doing what makes them great, you also completely shut down smaller creatures like mana dorks. So, in a game where you’re playing mono green and you’re rushing out your elves for the big game-winning play, your opponent suddenly brings out Linvala, Keeper of Silence and suddenly your mana dorks are worthless 1/1s or 0/2s.

What’s more, while many cards on this list affect everyone, this one only targets opponents meaning the guy who plays this has nothing to worry about.


5. Time Stretch

There aren’t many things you can do in this game that are better than winning yourself an extra turn. It allows you to set up combos where there were none, lets you play riskier, and more often than not can ensure that you win the game. Annoyingly there are multiple cards in MTG that let you do this, but rest assured that most of these cards require very specific conditions, are hard to pull off, and normally limit you so that you can only do this once every few turns at most.

So, unless your opponent is playing some sort of infinite combo deck which allows them to keep stacking turns, you don’t have to worry about them too much…well, except for this card. Honestly, it astounds me that a spell like Time Stretch was even printed in the first place. For 10 mana, very achievable goal in formats like EDH, you can get 2 extra turns for the price of a single card. If played against you, this spell will singlehandedly force you to sit there twiddling your thumbs as your opponent plays card after card in all three of their turns until they eventually grind you down.


4. Contamination

Playing a deck that isn’t partially black? Well, I guess it sucks to be you. Contamination is one of those cards which will not only break up friendships for the player’s blatant complete disregard for other peoples’ enjoyment but will likely get you hurt if you decide, for whatever sadistic reason, to play this in a tournament. The single creature sacrifice each turn from its controller is hardly steep price when in completely lock down multiple people from doing anything at all.

By making all lands tap for black mana, you not only stop other colours from being produced but you also prevent double lands from working properly. If you don’t happen to be playing a deck with black in it when this card is played against you, and you can’t counter it, then you can’t physically do anything. You better hope your colourless cards can pull you through because otherwise you’ve lost.

Even if you are playing black in a dual or tri-colour deck, say goodbye to everything that isn’t that specific colour because your opponent was clever enough to spend 3 mana on an enchantment in their mono black deck.


3. Vorniclex, Voice Of Hunger

Everyone loves cards that can produce any colour of mana. It allows us to play more experimental decks with a higher number of colours. They’re a staple in any rainbow/WUBRG deck and it makes us feel happy when allowed those rare effects which let us tap mana for any colour. If this was all that Vorniclex, Voice of Hunger did then he’d still be an incredibly good card.

However, his secondary ability means that whenever any other player taps their lands for mana, they don’t untap during the next untap step. So sure, you can still spend your mana, but if you do then you won’t be able to do much on your next turn. So, you either skip a turn or you don’t do anything with your mana which makes you again skip a turn. We’ve already been over how good having a turn advantage over your opponent is.

Contamination may be more powerful against non-black decks but Vorniclex doesn’t discriminate, making him overly powerful in every situation.


2. Back To Basics

While on the subject of lands not untapping, this card completely hates against any multi-coloured decks. While Back to Basics is in play, any non-basic land doesn’t untap, meaning you can say goodbye to those double lands and those dual-colour gates. Three colour decks become completely shut down and even some two-coloured decks which are struggling to find mana are completely put on hold, and don’t even mention the rainbow/WUBGR decks out there. Even lands with no colour generation like Strip Mine can’t be untapped, meaning any deck with any sort of mana diversity gets trashed from the moment this is played.

This land favours its owner playing only basics, mana dorks, and it synergises with cards which allow you to untap lands as it only specifies that they don’t untap during your untap step. So, while you’re struggling to build up your own mana, your opponent is using abilities to keep theirs open.


1. Jokulhaups

As far as board wipes go, there are many who would describe them as a necessary evil to put a stopper on overly aggressive aggro decks. However, there are not many board wipes which target lands, partially because they’re a terrible idea. Unfortunately however, Jokulhaups exists. It not only destroys all creatures like a typical board wipe but also gets rid of all artifacts and lands, meaning everyone, including the caster, basically loses everything.

A clever player will float all of their mana, play this card, and use what remains of their floated mana to play whatever creature they can afford and win with several turns of uncontested board presence. While I can completely understand playing Armageddon which only targets lands, allowing the caster to play a load of mana rocks in preparation, this card is made all the more infuriating since it isn’t even necessarily good for the player who uses it.

Completely putting a halt on the game and basically having to restart it with the remaining deck each player has is in no way fun and incredibly frustrating, making this the card which ranks as number 1 on this list.

What did you think of this ranking? Share your opinions down below.


Contributor
Contributor

Hi, I'm Rhys, aspiring author and WhatCulture writer!