10 Most Underrated Video Games Of 2017

Star Wars Battlefront 2 is more than just loot boxes.

Star Wars Battlefront 2
EA

From both a critical and commercial perspective, bar a few controversies and major disappointments here and there, it could be argued that 2017 has been the strongest year of the generation so far in terms of quality games.

Each one of the three big platform holders have enjoyed multiple breakout successes that've helped shift millions of consoles, with the likes of Horizon: Zero Dawn, Cuphead and The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild all being some of the year's most beloved titles.

Likewise, indie and PC releases have similarly flourished, with gorgeous critical darlings such as Pyre and world-dominating phenomenons like PlayerUnknown's Battlegrounds coming out of nowhere to steal the limelight.

However, in between so many critically-acclaimed games becoming immediate GOTY contenders, there were just as many that didn't receive the dues they deserved. Under-appreciated and ignored in favour of other big hitters, these criminally underrated titles were wrongly cast aside by both critics and audiences when they released, but they deserve to be given another chance now that the year is winding down.


10. Mass Effect: Andromeda

Mass Effect Andromeda - Extraction
Bioware

Mass Effect: Andromeda was doomed long before it came out. While the dodgy trailers and gameplay footage set the spin-off out on the back foot, the myriad of bugs and glitches discovered at launch essentially killed it dead in the water.

While the sequel was admittedly a mess technically speaking, as well as underwhelming in comparison to other entries in the series, it was by no means a bad game. In fact, there was a lot to love about the sequel, not least the free-form planet exploration that allowed players to traverse uncharted environments and contribute to making them hospitable.

Likewise, while the main story also ran out of steam as it entered the final act, there was still an enjoyable journey to be had, with a lot of the missions doing a great deal to shake up the conventional Mass Effect structure in exciting new ways.

It was far from perfect, but it also wasn't the total disaster it was painted as, and by no means deserved to kill off the franchise as it did.


9. What Remains Of Edith Finch

What remains of edith finch canery
Giant Sparrow

Home to one of the most powerful narratives of the year, What Remains of Edith Finch's vignette style of storytelling allowed it to constantly switch up its gameplay as well as its thematic focus, chronicling the final days of each member of the Finch family.

Consequently, the journey towards unravelling the mystery at the heart of this extremely unlucky family avoids the pitfalls of other walking simulators that can sometimes become repetitive over a long period of time. Instead, Edith Finch throws you into Lovecraftian nightmares, a Halloween-style throwback horror movie and a show-stopping dip into high-fantasy that remains surprising even into the game's late stages.

The indie is better played without knowing anything about the plot, as even if you're not a fan of similar narrative-driven titles, Giant Sparrow's harrowing tale has enough variety and intrigue at the heart of it to make it appealing to any gamer.


8. Outlast 2

Outlast 2 Knoth Chapel
Red Barrels Studio

If there's one certainty about Outlast 2, it's that it's nowhere near as tight or as polished as its predecessor. That doesn't mean the title is necessarily worse however, and in fact the high points of the sequel far outmatch anything found in the original game.

Swapping the claustrophobic corridors of the Mount Massive asylum for the religious-cult-infested wilderness of Arizona, the open levels don't lend themselves as well to highly scripted scares or set-pieces, but they more than make up for it with a palpable atmosphere of pure dread.

The sequel moves into far more surreal territory than ever before as well, all the while cranking the body horror up to 11. Mutilated genitals, gruesome torture and literal crucifixions are all par for the course, making Outlast 2 one of the most unrelentingly intense horror games of the year.


7. Call Of Duty: WW2

Call of duty wwii campaign
Activision

It seems as though every November critics announce that "Call of Duty is back, baby", but while they haven't always been correct, they were dead on the money about 2017's WW2 being a huge set up in quality for the franchise.

Rediscovering its flow by returning to boots-on-the-ground gunplay, the title's multiplayer was once again outstanding, with exciting improvements like the Headquarters social hub and the new-and-improved Zombies being particularly enjoyable highlights.

Sadly, the campaign suffers a touch from feeling like more of a rollercoaster ride than an actual all-out war, but even then, the explosive set-pieces and characters do more than enough to carry it through.

It hits all of the WW2 cliches - the farmboy with a girl back home, the sergeant wound too tight and the all-American focus - but it presents these conventions so confidently, while still adding in a few original ideas, to make the story intensely engaging.


6. Middle-Earth: Shadow Of War

Middle Earth Shadow Of War
Monolith

When it released in August, Middle-Earth: Shadow of War became more known for its controversial implementation of microtransactions than being a superbly solid open-world adventure.

Throwing even more toys into the Lord of the Rings sandbox, players were encouraged to go wild with the newly-improved Nemesis system to strike up rivalries, lay siege to enemy encampments and create an army of orcs to aid them in battle.

Fortunately, the gameplay itself brilliantly complimented these addictive mechanics, with the new movement system in particular allowing you to get the drop on enemies in a more efficient - and stylish - way than ever before.

The campaign was admittedly pretty naff, but WB's series has never been about the main story: the real fun lies in the anarchy you can create and the memories you make by being hounded by a familiar set of mutilated faces.


5. Star Wars: Battlefront 2

Star Wars Battlefront 2
EA

Star Wars: Battlefront 2 is easily one of the most controversial games of the decade so far. Being the straw that broke the camel's back in regards to the industry's insidious adoption of loot boxes and microtransactions, the free-to-play business practices EA crowbarred into their highly-anticipated shooter were unforgivable and rightly criticised, but that doesn't mean the game itself isn't any good.

Because at the heart of it, Battlefront 2 is a huge improvement over the original. The added campaign doesn't quite live up to the hype it earned for itself in the run up to release, but it's still a rollicking good time for Star Wars fans, weaving an entirely original story while catching up with fan-favourite characters.

However it's the multiplayer that truly excels, moving away from the shallow, pick-up-and-play approach of the original to deliver properly deep and rewarding combat mechanics.

It's still difficult to separate the systems present in the game from their greedy intent, and both the Star Cards and unlocks drag the sense of progression down quite considerably, but the core of the game still offers the pure Star Wars thrills fans craved.


4. Assassin's Creed: Origins

Assassins creed origins
Ubisoft

Despite taking an extra year off, the launch of Assassin's Creed: Origins was far from smooth sailing, with bugs, glitches, and a slow-build introduction all pointing towards it being another dud entry into the franchise.

While it didn't make the best first impression though, the revamped sequel revealed itself to be an exceptional open-world experience the more hours players put into it, with fans slowly realising that the title was one of the best ever instalments in the franchise.

Not only had the combat, missions and traversal system been completely altered, but Origins also boasted a genuinely jaw-dropping playground for players to get lost in that had an almost Breath of the Wild level of detail.

Though some burned-out fans steered clear of the title, especially after first-impressions revealed the amount of bugs and problems that the game front-loads, the latest Assassin's Creed has more than re-energised the stagnant series.


3. The Evil Within 2

The Evil Within 2
Bethesda

The Evil Within 2 is everything modern survival horror games should be. Acting as a throwback to the likes of Resident Evil 4 as well as taking inspiration from contemporary open world games, the sequel confidently balances free-form moments of horror with the linear set-pieces the franchise is known for.

Likewise, the sequel excels in particular because it wears its horror influences so candidly on its sleeve, openly referencing moments from Twin Peaks, Silent Hill and The Last of Us. Paying homage to so many other iconic properties could have been a risky move if Tango Gameworks couldn't balance them with original ideas, but fortunately the studio was able to use these reference points to craft an all-encompassing horror experience.

More than that though, the throwaway plot of the original is replaced with a hauntingly emotional tale about a man and his family, which cuts through all of the biological terror and hokey ghost stories to deliver a genuinely engaging story.

If you like old-school survival horror, then The Evil Within 2 is a must-play release, and proves that Bethesda are one of the best supporters of quality single-player games in the industry.


2. Hellblade: Senua's Sacrifice

Hellblade SenuaS Sacrifice
Ninja Theory

While Hellblade: Senua's Sacrifice has received a handful of Game of the Year awards, it also suffered the ire of players who felt cheated at the title's short length and divisive use of puzzles and swordplay. Admittedly, they're right to criticise the indie title in that regard, as the constant reliance on matching shapes in the world that unlock doors to the next part of the map gets incredibly grating in the later hours.

It's what Hellblade does outside of the gameplay that makes it so interesting though, as the way Ninja Theory realises Senua's crippling psychosis is as haunting as it is a great metaphorical representation of the real-life condition.

Watching this tortured warrior battle her inner demons, led by a captivating performance by Game Awards winner Melina Juergens, resulted in one of the most exciting and daring gaming experiences of the year, even if the gameplay itself couldn't quite maintain the same quality.


1. Prey

Prey game
Arkane

Between The Evil Within 2, Wolfenstein 2 and Prey, Bethesda have had an amazing year. However, it's the latter of those titles which was the most impressive, indulging in MetroidVania influences in a way that made the map itself an intriguing puzzle to solve.

Consequently, simply exploring Prey's terrifying space station is enough to make it one of the most memorable games of the year, as no two people will make their way through it the same. Depending on how you build your character, interact with the environment and use your imagination, each new puzzle has a dozen ways to be solved, marking the reboot out as far more complex than your standard sci-fi shooter.

When it comes to sheer surprises, there was no game released this year that managed to constantly pull the rug out from under players like Prey, and its sci-fi throwback mentality not only made it the most underrated game of the year, but one of the best games of 2017 period.


Watch Next


Contributor

Josh has over 11 years of experience as a published writer, having worked nine of those years as a full-time content producer at WhatCulture. In that period he has created hundreds of articles, videos and podcast episodes for multiple WhatCulture channels, specialising in gaming, horror and film & TV. He now primarily works as a senior content producer and presenter on WhatCulture Gaming where he co-hosts the WhatCulture Gaming Podcast, a top 3 UK most listened to gaming podcast that he co-created in 2018. Over the years he has reviewed several high-profile gaming releases, covered industry events with on-site reporting, opined on breaking news, and even kicked off his interviewing career by chatting to childhood hero, Tommy Wiseau.