10 Mysteries Video Games SHOULDN'T Have Answered
Worst. Masked villain reveal. Ever.
Nothing ensures players remain entranced by a game quite like an enticing mystery - a storytelling enigma which has fans desperate to learn the answer later on in the game.
But it's also something which developers shouldn't take lightly, because if players spend potentially dozens or even hundreds of hours following a narrative thread only for it to fall short of the mark, they're going to be pissed. Like, really pissed.
In fact, sometimes the actual resolution to the ongoing mystery is so frustrating and dissatisfying that many fans probably wished they'd never even bothered answering them at all.
And that's absolutely the case with these 10 video games, each of which posed tantalising mysteries at the outset, only to serve up revelations which split the fanbase at best, if not left the vocal majority totally outraged.
From totally bats**t, left-field twists to silly reveals that had fans feeling straight-up insulted, and everything else in-between, these were not in any way, shape, or form the answers that most players were looking for.
While in most instances it didn't sink the game by itself, it nevertheless left a dark cloud hovering over the entire experience...
10. Where Is Spencer's Missing Wife? - Bionic Commando
2009's Bionic Commando follows government operative Major Nathan "Rad" Spencer as, in addition to fighting a terrorist outfit, he searches for his missing wife Emily.
Emily's fate is one of the game's major narrative threads, and in the climax, we finally learn what happened to her.
As it turns out, Emily was murdered and her brain was - get this - uploaded into Nathan's bionic arm, because for a human to sync with their bionic appendage, they need to bond emotionally as well as physically.
Wait, what?
Yep, Nathan's arm is actually his dead wife, a revelation so head-smackingly dumb that it almost circles all the way back around and becomes awesome, but not quite.
This bonkers revelation became such a meme after the game's release that, even for those who've never played Bionic Commando, it's what they most associate with it.
The attempt to do something different is admirable in its own perverse way, but given the utter unintended goofiness of the execution, the developers were just as well leaving Emily's fate up in the air.
9. How Are The Reapers Made? - Mass Effect 2
Much as Mass Effect fans were keen to learn how all that Reaper sausage (!) was made, many ended up regretting their curiosity once Mass Effect 2 lifted the veil on it.
At the end of the game, we learn that the villainous Reapers are effectively made from melted organic material, and will take the form of whichever species was used.
In this case it happened to be human beings, whose genetic material was fused together to form the infamous Human-Reaper.
You know what? We didn't need to know that badly.
Sometimes the mystery of a monstrous antagonist's origins are simply more alluring than the answers could ever be, and that was most certainly the case with the Reapers.
As decades of horror movies have shown us, it's often better to keep things ambiguous, because over-explaining a creature's backstory risks demystifying them to the point of silliness, as was absolutely the case here.
And yet, because Mass Effect 3's ending so thoroughly screwed the storytelling pooch, this blunder doesn't seem quite so bad in retrospect.
8. Who Is The Origami Killer? - Heavy Rain
David Cage's Heavy Rain revolves around protagonist Ethan Mars' desperate fight to save his son Shaun from the Origami Killer, and in the nature of mystery-thriller narratives, players expected to eventually find out said killer's identity.
But given the utter flop of a reveal we ended up with, it might've been best to not even bother.
Heavy Rain's big twist is that the Origami Killer is in fact one of the four characters we've been playing as, private detective Scott Shelby.
That's all well and good, except Cage didn't play fair with his audience, as a scene earlier in the game categorically makes it clear that Shelby can't be the killer, only for players to later realise they were playing the scene from Shelby's twisted, manipulated perspective.
It left a sour taste for many, because any great mystery narrative needs to be guessable by observant enough viewers, but Heavy Rain ultimately took excessive, cheap steps to ensure its big reveal couldn't be predicted.
Really, if that's the road Cage was committed to going down, he should've just ended the game without the killer's identity ever being revealed at all - it would've been a sight less frustrating than this dud of a twist.
7. What Happened To Josh? - Silent Hill: Homecoming
Silent Hill: Homecoming follows soldier Alex Shepherd as he ends up in Silent Hill while searching for his missing younger brother, Josh.
It's a pretty typical setup for the series, and rather than do anything fresh or interesting with it, Konami simply ended up rehashing the big reveal from the series' most acclaimed entry.
A flashback eventually reveals that Josh has actually been dead all along, having drowned in an accident caused by Alex himself years earlier, and through his trauma Alex has repressed all knowledge of it.
Gee, doesn't that sound incredibly similar to Silent Hill 2, where protagonist James heads to Silent Hill after receiving a letter from his dead wife Mary, only for the game to reveal that he smothered her to death and subsequently repressed the whole incident.
In theory there are worse ideas than borrowing liberally from the best, but perhaps not when it's in the very same franchise.
As a result, most Silent Hill fans saw Homecoming's big reveal coming a mile off, compounding the overall disappointment of the game being just fine.
Really, if ripping off Silent Hill 2 was the most inspired creative the game had going for it, did we really need to know what happened to Josh that badly?
6. Why Does Quiet Wear So Little Clothing? - Metal Gear Solid V
Metal Gear Solid V's new character Quiet proved controversial with players from the moment she was introduced, largely due to her skimpy mode of dress - that is to say, despite spending the game in the middle of a warzone, she wears an extremely revealing bikini-type getup.
But in 2013, creator Hideo Kojima gave an impassioned speech insisting that there was a legitimate storyline reason for Quiet's lack of practical clothing, calling her "the antithesis to the women characters... who are excessively exposed."
Most infamously, Kojima added, "once you recognise the secret reason for her exposure, you will feel ashamed of your words and deeds."
Except, it turned out that Quiet ended up leaving little to the imagination because... she breathes through her skin, and so covering up her flesh would suffocate her. Right.
This explanation only made the fanbase more irritated by the whole debacle, and if Kojima simply admitted he wanted to put a fan service character in the game or even said nothing at all, it probably would've been preferable to this insultingly gossamer-thin excuse for some on-screen T&A.
5. Why Does The Cop Suspect The Wife Of Murder? - Twelve Minutes
Twelve Minutes is an initially fascinating mystery game in which players are caught in a time loop, which culminates in the protagonist's wife being suspected of murder by a cop who enters their apartment.
It's an incredible hook for the rest of the game, enticing players to figure out precisely why their wife is being looked at for murder.
That is, until you get the extremely icky answers.
At game's end, it's revealed that the time loop is taking place in the husband's head as he tries to imagine a blissful future with his wife, who is actually his half-sister.
The cop meanwhile represents his father, who attempts to convince his son to end the relationship and move on.
Given the overwhelmingly negative reaction to the incest twist and everything associated with it, the developers were probably better off keeping things ambiguous and just not revealing precisely what was going on here.
4. Who Is El Diablo? - Army Of Two: Devil's Cartel
One of the primary villains in Army of Two: The Devil's Cartel is El Diablo, a top lieutenant in the drug cartel La GuadaƱa who, in addition to being a huge sadist, wears a mask to conceal his identity.
But the eventual revelation of who El Diablo is went down like a lead balloon with many fans, given that he was ultimately outed as Elliot Salem, one of the protagonists of the first two games who was apparently killed at the start of this one.
Except, Salem survived the apparently fatal truck explosion in the game's prologue, and feeling betrayed at being left for dead, decided to join the cartel under the guise of El Diablo.
Many expressed intense dissatisfaction with this twist, because it felt so thoroughly out-of-character for Salem to betray his T.W.O. teammates like this.
Whether you saw it coming or not, it was a woeful feat of character assassination, with most fans ultimately left wishing that El Diablo just never unmasked at all.
3. What Happened To Shaun? - Fallout 4
Fallout 4 sees the Sole Survivor wake up after 210 years in cryogenic storage, where they attempt to rescue their kidnapped son Shaun, who is said to be held in the mysterious Institute.
At the end of the game, it's revealed that the director of the Institute and overarching antagonist is Shaun, who due to being kidnapped 150 years into the Sole Survivor's deep freeze, is now an older man.
Except, given that we see Shaun get kidnapped decades prior to the Sole Survivor being finally thawed out, it was shockingly obvious that he'd turn out to be old when we finally met back up with him.
And with that in mind, it wasn't a tectonic leap to suggest that he might also now be running the Institute, because it's basically the most obvious route a writer could go for a "surprise" twist that's really not that surprising at all.
And with this rather uncreative approach to the whole missing son plot, Bethesda might've been better off opting for a more tragic outcome where Shaun is lost to time and the Sole Survivor never learns his whereabouts. At least it wouldn't feel quite so predictable.
2. Who Is The Arkham Knight? - Batman: Arkham Knight
After Batman: Arkham Origins jerked fans around with the wildly deflating reveal that Black Mask was actually The Joker all along, developer Rocksteady evidently learned nothing when it came to follow-up Arkham Knight and the identity of its titular masked antagonist.
Pre-release, fans quickly guessed that the Arkham Knight would most likely be Jason Todd, given the obvious parallels between the Arkham Knight and Todd's Red Hood alter-ego from the comics.
But Rocksteady straight-up refuted the notion of Jason being the Arkham Knight, loudly stating that the character was an entirely original villain created solely for this video game.
And so, when Jason was indeed revealed to be the Arkham Knight later in the game, fans set a world record for simultaneous global eye-rolling.
Now, should Rocksteady have just come out and admitted who the Arkham Knight was? Probably not, but they would've been smart to just stay silent on the matter.
Or better yet, don't leverage the game around this twist. If making the Arkham Knight an ersatz Red Hood was the best they could come up with, maybe don't even bother revealing who he is at all.
1. What The Hell Is Going On? - The Dark Pictures Anthology: Little Hope
The Dark Pictures Anthology: Little Hope sees four college students and their professor end up stranded in the titular ghost town after their bus crashes, where they're pursued by a glut of supernatural phenomena.
From start to finish, then, players are simply tasked with uncovering quite what the fresh hell is going on.
But Little Hope stumbles hard at the end, when we learn that one of the four students, Andrew (Will Poulter), is actually the bus driver, Anthony.
Anthony hallucinated the game's entire story after accidentally detouring into Little Hope, a town where he was the sole survivor of a traumatic house fire as a youngster.
And so, the majority of the game was basically rendered moot by the revelation that most of the characters we've spent time with aren't even real.
In a game that's all about player agency and carving your own path through the story with an ensemble cast, that was a huge mistake.
Almost anything else would've been better than this - heck, even just never really explaining what's going on at all and letting the game coast purely on its spooky vibes.