10 Platformer Video Games Nobody Admits Are Better Than Mario

Mario is FAR from the best.

Mario Donkey Kong
Nintendo

Let's not beat around the pixelated bush: The games industry has a pro-Nintendo bias.

That's the only reason games like Breath of the Wild can get perfect scores, and why aggressively mediocre games like Kirby Star Allies have a 73% on Metacritic. Nintendo simply gets a pass despite being stuck in the past, rarely crafting exciting new IP.

The best possible example of said bias is the company's mascot, Mario. To be clear, almost all of the Super Mario games are great, they're just nowhere near as good as youre led to believe. In fact, there are many better platformers out there, and many on the Switch alone that are better than any of Mario's.

This isn't some lame attempt at a hot-take to ruffle feathers, it's simple fact based on pure gameplay experiences, as well as games that offer so much more as a whole package.

Mario is great, but once we take our Nintendo-coloured glasses off, we can see he's just another cog in the platforming genre wheel. So what games are better than our favourite plumber?

10. Ori And The Blind Forest

Ori and the Blind Forest
Microsoft

Ori and the Blind Forest was Cuphead before Cuphead. Which is to say, it was the difficult indie darling that everyone loved and touted as one of Xbox's best titles.

And Ori remains a bright spot in the Xbox's library of exclusive titles. It's a challenging, MetroidVania-style platformer with a gorgeous art style and a story that will test the resolve of your tear ducts. Like any great MetroidVania, the world of Ori is designed to give you "aha" moments as you uncover new abilities, alongside how they can help you reach new areas.

And if the art style and world design wasn't enough, platforming itself is extremely solid; leaping across ridges, attacking enemies, and floating between thorny vines is tricky but not punishingly so. And perhaps best of all, the MetroidVania aspect of exploration ends up feeling like training for some incredible escape sections that really test your might.

Ori and the Blind Forest is a testament to combining excellent game design with gorgeous hand-drawn backdrops, music that makes your heart soar (and plummet), and a story that kicks you right in the gut. It all ties together in a package that is far more rewarding and exciting than any Mario.


9. Super Meat Boy

Super Meat Boy Thumb
Team Meat

As one of the OG digital-only games, 2010's Super Meat Boy was the poster-child for crushing difficulty before Dark Souls.

Clearly inspired by classic titles like Mega Man and Battle Kid: Fortress of Terror, Super Meat Boy tested the mental fortitude of even the most battle-hardened of platforming veterans. To this day it's one of the most difficult platformers of all time, and is nigh on inaccessible to casual gamers. You'll sprint, slide, and leap across chasms and spinning saw blades as you attempt to retrieve your girlfriend in a clearly Mario-inspired set-up. Though the similarities end there as Meat Boy is more a descent into hell than a romp through the clouds.

As is the case with any great game however, the difficulty is not manufactured, it's genuine. The levels are designed to look borderline impossible to complete but as you continue to play, and die, you gain a mastery over Meat Boy that few other platformers could ever hope to offer. And the difficulty scales in a way that feels fair, albeit no less infuriating.

Super Meat Boy is not for the faint of heart but if you can dedicate yourself to it you'll find an incredible fun and rewarding experience in return.


8. Donkey Kong Country: Tropical Freeze

Donkey Kong Tropical Freeze
Nintendo

To say a Donkey Kong game is better than a Mario game would be considered blasphemy in many Nintendo circles, but alas, that's exactly the case when it comes to Donkey Kong Country: Tropical Freeze.

Even though our beloved moustachioed plumber started out life in Donkey Kong, he quickly went on to outshine the gorilla across pop culture. While Donkey Kong Country was a great game, it was rightly beaten a year later by Super Mario World 2: Yoshi's Island. While Donkey Kong was still exploring the country in 1996, Mario made the iconic leap to 3D. And 3 years later when Donkey Kong tried to do so the same, it failed rather spectacularly.

All this living in the shadow changed in 2014, when Donkey Kong got his best game ever. Tropical Freeze is the perfection of the Donkey Kong formula; fun locations, inventive platforming, pounding music, memorable enemies, and a hub world that makes sense.

It's a fantastic overall package that is pretty damn difficult to boot - although it does offer other playable characters that make the journey easier. Nintendo will be hard-pressed to improve upon Tropical Freeze but we're excited to see what they come up with.


7. The Messenger

The Messenger
Sabotage Studio

Upon initial impressions, The Messenger is just another retro-style platformer for the modern day. Yet quickly it subverts those assumptions and proves itself to be so much more. Something truly special.

You see, The Messenger starts out as an 8-bit Ninja Gaiden-inspired action game, but halfway through it changes into a 16-bit MetroidVania. It's an unprecedented gameplay design choice and one that pays off in spades. Combining the two genres was no easy feat, but what we're left with is a tremendous achievement in design and execution.

Speeding through the initial levels feels great, with your character just the right weight, and the platforms just wide enough to make you question your jump midway through. And, while the MetroidVania portion isn't perfect, it's still fun and even more exciting when you consider just how good a sequel might be.

The Messenger is a beautiful game with an entrancing soundtrack. It feels less like it's attempting to recapture the glory of the eras it's emulating, and more like its blazing a trail all of its own, while wearing its inspirations on its bracer.

Easily one of the best platformers to emerge in the past two decades.


6. Inside

INSIDE game
Playdead Studios

A follow-up to indie darling Limbo was never going to be easy, especially when it took six years to arrive. However, Playdead shocked everyone with a game that was reminiscent of Limbo, but superior in every possible way.

Inside retained the aesthetic of Limbo, albeit vastly polished and improved upon, and added in some striking reds for effect. You can see the technical leaps the studio has made between games, and Inside overflows with atmosphere and tension as a result.

The game is set in a creepy world where you play as a little boy, digging deeper into a facility to uncover a mystery. That's a vague description, because Inside is a pretty vague game that lets you fill in the blanks it purposefully leaves open.

Mind-blowing story aside however, platforming is as close to perfection as you'll find. Gameplay serves the story and vice versa, in ways most games can only hope to achieve. Not only that but the animations are some of the best you'll see, whether indie platformer or AAA blockbuster.

Inside is a very special game - the type that only comes along every generation. A mesmerising blend of story, gameplay, music, and world-building. Exactly what a modern platformer should be.


5. Little Nightmares

Little Nightmares
Bandai Namco

Little Nightmares is one of the most underrated games of the current generation. It sets you in the shoes a tiny girl in a yellow slicker that evokes Georgie from It. You start off in a dark area with no background information as to where you are. Eventually you realise you're aboard a mysterious ship called The Maw, which is inhabited by large, lardy characters that want you dead.

You're forced to sneak around the 3D environments, while climbing upon tables, chairs, pots, doors, vents, and much more. The game is surprisingly creepy and tense, especially if you play with headphones in (and you should).

While most platform games have you simply falling into an abyss if you miss a jump, Little Nightmares is so much more frightening and anxiety-inducing. You won't be falling down any dark holes, but if you miss a jump from a table to the drawers, you'll be grabbed and eaten by one of the fleshy monsters.

Little Nightmares is just that, nightmare-fuel, but in all the right ways. The animations are great as your character moves in and out of the gorgeous environments, and few other games come anywhere near its level of polish, atmosphere, and genuine feeling of fear and dread.


4. Mega Man 2

Mega Man 2 Metal Man
Capcom

Some people like to say "gameplay is king", meaning gameplay is paramount to any video game, and if gameplay isn't up to scratch, then no amount of story or graphic fidelity can make up for it. While there is some hyperbole in that statement when applied to modern games, it certainly rang true in the 80's.

While the original Mega Man created the blueprint for the blue bomber to follow for some 30 years to follow, it was Mega Man II that perfected the formula. The sequel added better audio and visuals, passwords, and new power-ups, while retaining the innovative non-linear structure of the missions. Each boss feels unique and memorable, while providing Mega Man with a fun array of weapons to use in the other levels.

It's a masterclass in game design and, while being difficult, it's far better than its predecessor at presenting a fair challenge. It is the pinnacle of platforming in the 8-bit era, and that's no small feat considering the competition, including Mario himself.

Incredibly, Mega Man II is, to this day, still the best-selling game in the series. Which means, just maybe, gameplay is indeed king and class is permanent.


3. Celeste

Celeste mountain
Matt Makes Games

Celeste took the world by storm in 2018, with critics and gamers floored by its ability to meld gameplay with story in a way that precious few others have managed.

Celeste tells the story of Madeline, as she climbs Celeste mountain. It seems a pretty basic set-up that initially grabs you through it's beautiful art-style, and perfectly-weighted platforming. As you progress up the mountain though, the plot begins to reveal itself through masterfully woven conversations and gameplay.

And similarly to games like Super Meat Boy, Celeste features some crushingly difficult gameplay sections, but they aren't there to test your gaming prowess - instead focused on your resolve in a way that reflects the story. Celeste is about falling and getting back up; climbing your personal mountain.

Even when you start the game it offers you the option to play on an easier level but encourages you to try the regular mode with the simple, uplifting line, "You can do this".

Celeste is the perfect encapsulation of a modern platformer - one that weaves in story that strikes a nerve and causes you to break down in tears, while also motivating you to not lot your inner demons win. And if that isn't worth playing then what is?


2. Shovel Knight

1278903

Yacht Club Games is easily the best Kickstarter story in all of gaming. While so many Kickstarter's either fail to live up to their promises or...just simply fail, Yacht Club Games has over-delivered in every possible way with Shovel Knight.

The game released in 2014 on PC, Wii U, and Nintendo 3DS and was met with a wave of critical acclaim right off the shovel. It went on to win many year-end awards in 2014, and the titular hero became a very recognisable character of the modern gaming scene.

The base Shovel Knight game is a masterclass in platforming with fantastic humour, memorable bosses, and a very pleasing 8-bit graphical style. It's clearly inspired by games like Mega Man, Castlevania, and yes, Mario, but an evolution of all three.

As if that wasn't enough, Shovel Knight has received two expansions, with a third on the way. While the first DLC, Plague of Shadows, was fun, it was inherently the same game as Shovel of Hope. The second and third expansions however, are basically full-blown games.

Meaning if you buy Shovel Knight: Treasure Trove, you're essentially getting four of the greatest platformers ever made. If you're a fan of old-school platformers, Shovel Knight is as good as it gets.


1. Rayman Legends

Rayman Legends
Ubisoft

Rayman has been on the block for many a year, surviving in relatively niche circles. While you were playing Super Mario 64, your weird friend was trying to get you to play Rayman on the PS1. And yet, some 20 years later, Rayman Legends has taken the crown for the greatest platformer ever made.

Sound like hyperbole? It's not. Rayman has always had a fun, quirky art-style and solid gameplay, but it was 2011's Rayman Origins that opened everyone's eyes to how good the series could be. It was gameplay bliss that took the best parts of Mario, Sonic, and its own predecessors to craft an experience that is just pure fun. It has inch-perfect jumps, and channels Sonic with its momentum-building sequences that outdo anything the hedgehog could even dream of achieving.

Legends came a couple of years later and just tightened up the formula a bit more, as well as tossing in fantastic music-centric levels and more co-op. It's a tremendous game and the fact that it contains Rayman Origins within it only boosts the value further.

Rayman Legends is as good a platformer as there has ever been. It's the culmination of 30 years of building upon a genre with a gorgeous 2.5 art-style, funny characters, quirky soundtrack, and adrenaline-fueled levels.

Legends is the platforming benchmark.


In this post: 
Mario
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Curtis is from Ireland and lives in Canada now.