10 Most Scandalous Gaming Moments Of 2014

Yes, more women in games! Erm, on second thought...

Gta V Banned What a year it has been for the humble gamer. As time keeps flowing like a river so too does the capabilities of video games, both graphically (you could look at a river in a title on the PS4 or Xbox One and it€™d look like an actual, real life river, with real-time reflections and everything) and mechanically (you€™re just as likely to play a Call Of Duty that has you crawling through a watery trench into battle as you are an indie title where you play as a Pooh stick floating listlessly along a babbling brook, getting you to question the nature of your existence and the inextricable pull of fate). The big consoles have began to really pay off on their early promise, and hey, it looks like the WiiU might finally be worth buying! Because, y€™know, new Zelda. Old games are being resurrected - yay Grim Fandango, but don€™t mention Final Fantasy VII - and Steam continues to herald a renaissance in PC gaming, with their Greenlight program being right up there with the likes of Kickstarter in terms of bringing new, interesting voices to the medium. Not that it€™s all been sunshine, lollipops and free DLC. Far from it. The year in gaming hasn€™t been free of controversy (when is it?), with hardcore players especially being struck down with buggy launches, crummy online play and a whole bunch of other disappointments. Then there are some of the wider cultural issues 2014 has brought to light, not to mention some tabloid-worthy scandal. Hasty cancellations, check. More than a handful of controversies involving the app store, check. Censorship, sexism, and ethics in games journalism? Check, check, and double check. Here are the ten biggest video game scandals of 2014.

10. The Saga Of Flappy Bird

The story of Flappy Bird has much in common with the Greek myth of Icarus, who flew too close to the sun, causing his wax wings to melt and sending him plummeting to his death, in a rather ironic but pretty harsh lesson about hubris. Yep, Flappy Bird is almost exactly the same, except instead of wax wings you prod the screen to make him fly, and there€™s more repurposed (read: stolen) Super Mario graphics. A sort of test piece by aspiring developer Dong Nguyen, the game became a surprise hit when it hit the app store. A surprise because on paper the game should have zero appeal, consisting as it does of some aforementioned half-inched Nintendo graphics and incredibly simple gameplay where you try and get a bird (which looks more like a fish) safely through a side-scrolling level. People leapt to the challenge of getting the bird-fish as far as possible. Nguyen was the real winner, however, as at the height of its popularity his terrible game was pulling in $50,000 a day from in-app advertising. At least until he suddenly decided to take it down, presumably because of the negative attention the game had drawn, and the phenomenon disappeared as quickly as it arrived.

9. Phil Fish Actually Retires, From Real This Time

Anybody who€™s settled down to watch the 2012 documentary Indie Game: The Movie will realise that Phil Fish is an odd bird (gamers are always getting those two creatures mixed up, apparently). The film focuses on a handful of grassroots developers, with the maker of Braid coming across as a complete tool, the pair behind Super Meat Boy being basically decent and relatable human beings, and the creator of Fez...is difficult the diplomatic way of putting it? Difficult. Throughout the development cycle of his superlative 2D-yet-3D pixelly platforming puzzler Fish had to deal with the loss of his creative partner and all the ensuing legal palaver that followed, which didn€™t really help with the already fiery temperament he wielded. Following some kick back to his public persona, he announced his retirement from the industry last year. It stuck for about as long as every one of Jay-Z€™s attempts at retirement do, however, with Fish still being fairly active within the indie gaming scene, although he stood by the cancellation of a sequel to Fez (more€™s the pity). Following his speaking out about one of this year€™s other big scandals, however, the company records of Fish€™s studio Polytron were hacked and leaked, and Fish announced he was putting the company - and the rights to Fez - up for sale.

8. Hatred€™s Developers Are White Supremacists

At a time when the impact of violence in the real world has been at its highest, with bloody wars still being fought across the globe and American culture especially being wracked by a series of highly publicised killings (usually with guns, usually white men killing young unarmed black men), the trailer that announced upcoming €œrampage simulator€ Hatred seemed particularly wrongheaded. And it only got worse from there. This was also at a time when games were dealing with that constant image problem, with most outside observers being of the opinion that they€™re all just murder simulators anyway. Which obviously isn€™t true, but Hatred looks to be some pretty damning evidence to the contrary. Seriously, just see how much of this video you can get through before feeling sick to your stomach. The icing on the cake of all that was the response of developers Destructive Creations to the initial reactions to the game, making out like they were on a righteous crusade against the ill-defined €œpolitical correctness brigade€. Which should€™ve been a tip off to the fact that said developers have turned out to be Neo-Nazis - or at least, they look it based on their fashion choices. Yay! Video games!

7. Facebook Buy The Oculus Rift

Not that everything has to be about the societal ills of the world being amplified or reflected in art. There€™s also good old fashioned people being ripped off, or else interesting new start-ups being absorbed by larger corporations who will probably sap all of the interesting-ness out of them. With the news earlier this year that Facebook were buying up the developers of revolutionary virtual reality headset the Oculus Rift, you got a two-for-one on both! Honestly, what are Facebook planning on even doing with the technology? Some at the time speculated about some crazy new way to interact wth your least favourite social network, or else some more immersive take on FarmVille, but that wasn€™t the real scandal. Well, it was part of it, anyway. Just not the whole story. Y€™see, the Oculus Rift came about thanks to a phenomenally successful crowdfunding campaign organised around Kickstarter. That means the company couldn€™t have existed, much less reached such levels of popularity, if it weren€™t for excited gamers kicking in a few sheckles. So discovering the company had been sold to Zuckerberg for a cool $400 million in cash and $1.6 billion in Facebook stock had them wondering if maybe they should be entitled to some of the spoils€?

6. Dungeon Keeper Mobile Bleeds Players Dry

If the wallets of gamers have been feeling a little lighter than usual this year, it isn€™t thanks to the usual hardware upgrades or swathe of DLC packs released just in time for the holidays. No, it€™s because it seems like the industry as a whole is out to bleed its audience dry even more so than usual; the Oculus thing was a bit of a grey area. Dungeon Keeper, less so. The long-awaited remake of the classic strategy game originally developed by the iconic Bullfrog Studios under the infamous Peter Molyneux, the original put you on the other side of the usual equation by making you play as a demonic villain attempting to build a lair in a classic fantasy setting, repelling the attacks of knights in shining armour. The mobile game had all that, too. It was also free! Well, sort of. In fact the new Dungeon Keeper was a free-to-play title, which meant technically it didn€™t cost anything, but you€™ll have trouble advancing through the game unless you spend a load on in-app purchases. Bringing back the shambling corpse of an old game and demanding money to see it dance wasn€™t well received by players, nor the Trading Standards Agency, who demanded EA stop advertising the game as €œfree€ at all.

5. GTA V Pulled From Stores In Australia

A late entry that nonetheless has earned its spot in the list of this year€™s biggest gaming scandals was the recent news that the high-definition Xbox One and PS4 re-releases of Grand Theft Auto V would not be sold in Kmart or Target stores in Australia. The decision was the direct result of a petition for the major supermarkets not to stock the titles on the basis of their depictions of violence against women, something which is put paid by the fact the petitions were organised by rape and abuse survivors. Rockstar has a history of this in Australia. The country€™s rating systems when it comes to video games appears to be especially strict, with the hyper-violent output of the Scottish studio often coming a cropper of the particularly stringent set of guidelines the Aussie authorities list, with the particularly psychopathic Manhunt 2 just getting flat-out banned in the country, and countless other non-Rockstar titles being censored or cut for various reasons. The removal of GTA V from shops is a little harder to argue with, however, since it€™s the right of Kmart and Target to not stock certain products if they don€™t want to and, well, you can€™t really argue that Grand Theft Auto doesn€™t allow you to solicit prostitutes and murder women in graphic ways. Whether you think this is a scandalous repression of free speech is another thing...

4. Assassin€™s Creed Has No Room For Female Characters€

Much like their geeky brethren comic books, video games have long since had a problem with representation. The industry and culture as a whole still seems to labour under the faulty belief that the only people who play games are (usually white) men, and that girls are not only not allowed in this He-Man Woman Haters club, but they have an active disinterest in ever picking up a controller. As such, the amount of playable female characters in games that aren€™t Lara Croft - ie with proportions meant to appeal to the base desires of a male player - are remarkably slim, because if there aren€™t any ladies playing video games then why would you bother coding in characters for them? Which is ridiculous on two counts since, duh, women do play games, and if dudes can suspend their disbelief to play as a magical Italian plumber they can probably deal with being a woman. Unfortunately if you€™re an Assassin€™s Creed fan that latter thing cannot be tested, since Ubisoft failed to put a female character in the latest game Unity. Which might not have been as big a deal if the developers hadn€™t claimed the reason they didn€™t bother was because it would€™ve simply taken too much work, which is of course nonsense and should be treated as such. And was!

3. ...And Metal Gear Solid Probably Shouldn€™t€™ve Bothered

Phantom Pain On the other hand, maybe it€™s best the that people currently in charge of developing AAA titles not be entrusted with creating female characters. They€™ll only muck it up. Although it€™s hard to imagine Ubisoft would have messed up quite as catastrophically (if they€™d managed to find the time in between creating a living, breathing, realistic recreation of French Revolution-era Paris) as the most recent instalments in the Metal Gear Solid franchise which just...ugh. Germaine Greer wept. The Metal Gear Solid games are good at a lot of things. Despite all of director Hideo Kojima€™s long, rambling cut scenes he does have some interesting things to say and insights about the nature and future of human warfare, the games are always incredibly fun and manage to conversely not take themselves too seriously, and the constant redesigns of the cardboard box are always welcome. Where it consistently falls down, however, are in its female characters, and Metal Gear Solid V looks to be no exception. That weird prologue game Ground Zeroes had one female character, who was raped and then had a bomb put in her vagina the player has to remove at the finale. Things don€™t look like they€™ll improve much with Metal Gear Solid V proper, either, as The Phantom Pain stars a single female character. A sniper. Who enters the battlefield in a bikini and suggestively ripped tights. What the heck, Kojima?

2. Far Cry 4€™s Racism Problem

Part of the scandal surrounding Assassin€™s Creed: Unity and the lack of a female character was rooted in how poorly Ubisoft handled the outcry. They could€™ve apologised, they could€™ve acknowledged that was a mistake. Instead they tried to palm people off with some boohockey about how difficult it€™d be to render a female character, how much more work it€™d take, something which was shot down by no less than a previous Assassin€™s Creed developer. Somebody in Ubisoft€™s PR department better have been fired this year, because they managed to pull off a similar cock up when it came to the company€™s second big tentpole release of 2014. Along with a handful of screenshots the first image released from open-world first person shooter Far Cry 4 earlier in 2014 was the cover, which depicted a white dude using an Asian native€™s head as an armrest. It was an image with some fairly obvious connotations of colonialism, oppression and racism, all of which people were more than a little uncomfortable with. As it happens that guy turned out to be the games villain, and those are all themes the story dealt with (and were rightfully critical of). Instead of saying all that and nipping it in the bud, Ubisoft claimed it was a fuss over nothing, and thus created a tidal wave of easily-avoided controversy.

1. #GamerGate

Unfortunately the biggest controversy of the year in gaming must also count amongst its 2014€™s most scandalous moments. At least, it would be nice if it was simply a moment, but the #GamerGate train seems to just keep trundling on unabated, despite the widespread desertion from the movement of those that actually cared about ethics in games journalism, and a series of pieces in the mainstream press that rightly pegged it as rooted entirely in sexism, racism, and general awfulness. Sparked by revelations about the sex life of indie developer Zoe Quinn, #GamerGate positioned itself as some sort of radical movement to get more transparency in games reviews. What it more often did was attempt to silence the voices of women in the industry, by directly attacking them through social media and releasing personal details (like addresses and bank account info) online, often leading to IRL harassment and the involvement of police. Certainly sounds like a movement preoccupied with ethical standards. There were those that actually did care about ethics in games journalism - which is an actual problem, and one not spoken of enough - but siding with what was essentially a hate group made such concerns as easy to dismiss as the crackpot theories of people who use terms like €œfeminazi€ entirely unironically and would probably bloody love to play Hatred. It€™s unfortunate that such a scandal will be the one to characterise 2014 in gaming, but it€™s an event that shouldn€™t be forgotten. In many ways it spoke to the rest of the scandals on this list - remembering it might help them never happen again.

In this post: 
GTA V
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Tom Baker is the Comics Editor at WhatCulture! He's heard all the Doctor Who jokes, but not many about Randall and Hopkirk. He also blogs at http://communibearsilostate.wordpress.com/