10 Things Alien: Isolation Will Do Better Than Aliens: Colonial Marines

There's an upside to hitting rock bottom...

The Alien franchise has had a long and storied history with the video game industry. Every film featuring the titular creature has had a video game tie-in; some multiple times. Between those and the numerous Aliens vs. Predator games, it€™s safe to say that the Alien is no stranger to video games. But as fans know, times have been tough for our favourite acid-blooded killer. Not only has it not had a decent film since the 90s, but its video game career has been pretty poor as well. It all seemed to culminate in last year€™s Aliens: Colonial Marines, a game that had been in development for more than half a decade and generated massive amounts of hype. To say it failed to live up to that hype would be an understatement. With graphics bordering on PS2/360 levels, an unacceptably high number of glitches, broken promises and just plain poor writing; it never delivered the authentic Aliens experience it claimed to aim for. Combined with the PR nightmare that resulted from the controversy, many fans are still reeling from the disappointment. However, there appears to be a glimmer of hope on the horizon in the form of Alien: Isolation. Developed by Creative Assembly, Isolation aims to replicate the feeling of Ridley Scott€™s masterpiece by having you face off with just one Alien as opposed to an entire hive, the formula replicated in every Alien game since 1986. From what has been revealed so far, Isolation looks to be better than Colonial Marines in every way, which admittedly shouldn€™t be difficult to achieve. Even if Isolation doesn€™t live up to the hype, these are the things it is sure to do better than Colonial Marines.

10. The Graphics

Aliens: Colonial Marines had shockingly bad graphics. Despite being released at the tail end of the last console generation, it looked like a high resolution game from the PS2/Xbox/Gamecube generation. It is a truly ugly game, especially on the consoles, where low resolution textures, consistent aliasing, and annoying pop-ins cripple any attempts at immersion. Overall, the lack of polish and attention to detail made it feel like an unfinished game. By comparison, take one look at Alien: Isolation in motion and you can instantly tell that it looks better by a thousand times. The graphical quality is up to standard with the expectations of this console generation, enhanced by incredible lighting which - given the subject matter and genre of game - is so important in immersing the player. Environments look photorealistic and little details like dust particles floating in the atmosphere only enhance that. The character models and facial animations are expressive and lifelike, unlike the stiff and lifeless characters in Colonial Marines. All this contributes to the more polished feel of Isolation, which gives us confidence that it was given the proper time to develop.

9. The Atmosphere

Colonial Marines desperately wanted to replicate the atmosphere of James Cameron€™s Aliens, and superficially it did. The design of the environments looked like they were taken straight out of Cameron€™s film, and the music perfectly complimented James Horner€™s infamous score. But the one aspect of that film it utterly failed to replicate appropriately was the tension and atmosphere. The mediocre shooter elements combined with the terrible A.I. sapped any potential for the game to be scary or intense. Since Isolation is based on the principles of the first film, by default it will have better atmosphere. The survival horror game design is inherently superior at generating genuine thrills and chills than a standard first-person shooter, and when combined with the aesthetics of the series should create a more intimately scary experience for the player. Instead of hordes of Aliens rushing at the player en masse, Isolation will have long stretches of quiet as you explore the darkness, all the while wondering if the Alien is around the next corner. That premise alone sounds more appealing that anything inside the Colonial Marines formula.

8. The Environment

While Alien was the first - and thus central - movie in the Alien series, it was James Cameron€™s Aliens that had the greatest influence in the way popular culture perceives the franchise. As a result, pretty much every Alien game has been based on the aesthetic qualities of that film, and it has gotten pretty boring. Combine that with the fact that every sci-fi military shooter has been influenced by it too, and it€™s no surprise that Colonial Marines didn€™t stand out when it came to its environments - it didn€™t help that they looked just as shoddy as the rest of the game. The developers of Isolation had the good sense to base the environmental design of the game on the first film, which had a style to it that has strangely never been used in an Alien game before. This untapped potential is a huge contributing factor to the excitement so far. For the first time, we get to explore a world based entirely on the 70s industrial space-aesthetic the first film birthed. This low-tech future world is so original despite being over 30 years old, and it is about time we got an Alien game based on that. It should go a long way into enhancing the more survival-horror driven gameplay.

7. The Horror

This one is a certainty. Colonial Marines didn€™t have an ounce of horror. Sure it tried, but at no point did it even come close to succeeding. Moments that were supposed to be scary, like your first encounter with an Alien, just ended up being throw away moments that are anything but. The closest it got is during a section where you have to sneak around blind Aliens, and even that ended up being funny due to the walking animations. Isolation is without question going to be a scarier game. Anyone who has had the chance to play it early has been enthusiastic about how tense and scary it is. This time the Alien is a proper enemy that can stalk and kill you, and then there are the androids, with their soulless inhuman eyes, that have the potential to be just as scary in a different way. It€™s not just about the Alien, but the entire experience of being isolated out in space while a Lovecraftian beast attempts to use your body for reproduction. Even if Isolation doesn€™t quite meet its expectations, the bar was set so low by Colonial Marines that it honestly won€™t take much for Isolation to be a scarier experience.

6. The A.I.

The intelligence of your enemies in Colonial Marines was€shall we say, not so good. The Alien and human enemies of the game both liked standing out in the middle of the open for you to shoot them, with the Aliens especially liking to run straight at the business end of your overpowered shotgun. They never displayed any sense of strategy or method; the game literally just throws as many at you as it can in the hope that it will prove to be a challenge. It€™s not, even on the hardest difficulty. There were even some instances where Aliens just stand still as if you aren€™t around. In contrast, one of the most talked about aspects of Isolation is the programming of the Alien itself. Knowing that the entire game hinges on the performance of this singular creature, much time and effort has gone into giving it proper intelligence in order to provide the player with a challenge. The developers have talked up its ability to adapt to your strategies, its awareness of the environment, and the variability of its behavior. Whether all these promises are mere posturing remains to be seen, but plenty of gameplay footage has been released which actually shows how difficult it is to stay alive against the Alien, which already elevates it above Colonial Marines.

5. Respecting The Alien

Perhaps the greatest failing of Colonial Marines was the disrespect it had towards the title creature. The Alien is one of the greatest fictional creatures ever, and the way in which Colonial Marines literally threw them at the screen for the player to mow down was a disgrace. They displayed no sense of intelligence or self-preservation - the ultimate killing machine was reduced to a mindless drone with no autonomous thought. In the opposite direction is Isolation, which looks to remind us why we should fear this monster. By having only one Alien in the game, there is no way it can be killed until the end of the game. It is the big bad boss; the one thing you absolutely do not want to encounter in close proximity. Everyone on the space station fears it because there is nothing they can do to bring it down, and it actually uses intelligence and awareness to manoeuvre around the environment to its advantage. This is how a proper digital rendition of an Alien should act; it should not be something that you can kill hundreds of with reckless abandon. Colonial Marines cheapened one of the greatest icons of horror, and Isolation looks like it will restore it to its former glory. And even if it doesn€™t quite make the mark, it is certain to still do a better job.

4. The Story

Despite being hyped as a true sequel to Aliens, the whole story of Colonial Marines felt like an uninspired waste of time. The setup was that a new squad of marines gets sent in to investigate the Sulaco 17 days after losing contact. From that point the story evolved to yet another conspiracy of Weyland-Yutani to study Aliens. If that sounds like it€™s been done before in other Alien games, that€™s because it has. The entire premise was just an excuse to get back on LV-426 for nostalgia€™s sake. Hicks is discovered alive, which is poorly explained and brushed aside. Despite this, nothing is gained by the end and the status quo remains the same. Even with only a few weeks left before release, we know very little about Isolation€™s story except for the premise. The black box of the Nostromo has been found and Amanda Ripley is given the chance to find out what happened to her mother. When they get to the space station Sevastopol to retrieve it, they find that it is being terrorised by an Alien, and Ripley has to figure out what is going on. The key ingredient that makes this premise better than Colonial Marines is its connection to Ripley. If you are a fan of the films, playing as Ripley's daughter as she attempts to find out what happened to a character we know and love is an emotional connection lacking from before. Instead of following a bunch of new characters with no historical relevance to the films, Isolation wisely keeps the story within the Ripley family. The story could end up dropping the ball overall, but this connection automatically adds value to Isolation€™s narrative, at least conceptually.

3. The Characters

Colonial Marines had bland, generic characters. Most of the cast was comprised of stereotypical space marines with little discernible personality between them. Cameron€™s marines may have had their archetypes, but they all had moments to shine and develop their characters. In Colonial Marines it is almost painful how much the game tries to replicate the banter that made Aliens so famous. And that€™s all Colonial Marines is: a soulless copy. Much like the mystery surrounding the story, we still know next to nothing about the principle cast. We know Ripley€™s daughter Amanda is the main protagonist whom the player controls, as well as the names of some of the supporting characters, but other than that we don€™t know much else. And while that leaves the quality of the characters at question, it is not difficult to be better than those in Colonial Marines; so much so that we are extremely confident that they will be. Again, Isolation€™s characters could be pretty basic and/or bland, and they will still be better. Just by virtue of not being marines for once gives the characters of Isolation the upper hand. That€™s what happens when the bar has been set so low by your predecessor.

2. Expanding On The Films

For years Colonial Marines was touted as the official sequel to Aliens we always wanted but never got. Such strong promises naturally created strong anticipation. In the end we got a standard story about marines being attacked by Aliens with forced connections to the films that contradict previously established canon. The only questions it answered were those that never needed answering in the first place. Instead it only made an already convoluted series (thanks to the AVP films) more confusing. Isolation on the other hand is actually attempting to tell a story worth telling. Amanda Ripley was only mentioned in a brief scene of the director€™s cut of Aliens where Ripley is informed of her death. Amazingly, she had never been used in the franchise since. Creative Assembly saw this and used that as the basis of the story. Now, obviously this could still end up being a contradictory mess like so many other additions to the Alien franchise, but could it really be as bad as Colonial Marines? Sure, but at this point that seems unlikely. And even if it is bad, just by connecting to the heart of the films (Ripley) and attempting to expand on an element of the series we€™ve yet to explore is a huge step in the right direction. Let€™s hope they are able to pull it off.

1. The Entire Game

All of the failings of Aliens: Colonial Marines touched upon here should outline just why that game was such a disappointment. The whole experience from beginning to end was a colossal screw up of epic proportions. Other than a somewhat fun multiplayer experience, the entire game was unworthy of the prestigious material it was based on. In contrast, all the aspects of Isolation highlighted here should show how much better as a whole it will be in comparison. Yes, perhaps there is a bit too much positivity being thrown around given how much we got burnt last time, but there are legitimate reasons to be a bit more excited for Isolation. Even if it ends up being a disappointment relative to the hype, there is no way it will be as bad as Colonial Marines. Between the countless video previews and hands-on demos, as well as the general openness of the developer (not the case with Gearbox), there is too much evidence supporting our confidence that Alien: Isolation will be an all around better Alien experience than Colonial Marines was. You can count on it. Are you excited for Alien: Isolation? Skeptical? Let us know in the comments!

Contributor
Contributor

Film and video game obsessed philosophy major raised by Godzilla, Goku, and Doomguy.