10 Unhinged Video Game Characters That Would've Made Perfect Villains

Sometimes the "good guys" just don't seem all that good.

It€™s not uncommon for the bad guys in video games to be stark-raving lunatics that care nothing for human life, but more often than not, the heroes can seem more deranged than the villains, acting recklessly, hysterically, or downright unhinged. Take Trevor from Grand Theft Auto V for example, a twisted killer and maniac who doesn€™t see reality quite the way it really is. He€™s also a psychotic torturer who is single-handedly responsible for one of the most disturbing scenes from the entire game, in which the player is forced to bludgeon a man almost to death with various tools. Oh, and he€™s an implied cannibal, yet we spend more time in his company than any of the crime figures and shady characters you'll be taking down. Odd choice for a hero, don't you think? The unadulterated evilness of bad guys is part of the reason they can be so entertaining, but when the hero or heroine starts acting like a psychopath, you start to wonder if that character is really worth rooting for at all. You might even start to wonder if they€™d make a better bad guy. So, with that in mind, here€™s 10 Video Game characters that would€™ve made perfect villains...

10. Nathan Drake (Uncharted)

Nathan Drake is a monster. Not only do his actions result in the deaths of hundreds of people, but he seems to actually enjoy maiming and murdering them. Remember when you€™re given a tranquilizer gun in the second game? No? That€™s because Nathan holds onto it for all but five minutes before discarding the thing in favour of more conventional, lethal firearms. Just look at the man€™s silent takedowns for goodness sake! They range from non-lethal smacks to the head to full on neck snapping with one hell of a crack. Think about it; how many ancient ruins as he single-handedly decimated? How much treasure has he pillaged for himself? How many friends has he gotten killed by leading them into certain death situations? Beyond a shadow of a doubt, Nathan Drake a nutcase, which is why he€™d make a perfect villain. Just imagine a story in which Nate encounters another adventurer seeking the same ancient artefact, only this adventurer wants it for a museum and not his own personal horde. The player would assume the role of the other adventurer, tentatively forming an alliance at first with the reckless and amoral Nathan Drake. Over the course of the game, Nathan€™s actions would steadily become worse and worse until you€™re forced to intervene and prevent him from burning down an ancient temple or mutilating someone unnecessarily. From that point on, you€™d be at odds. Nate would be out for his own interests, and you€™d be fighting for a greater purpose.

9. Travis Touchdown (No More Heroes)

Travis from No More Heroes is another example of a character who has no problem decimating everyone he comes into contact with. This wouldn€™t be a problem if Travis had a noble goal or no other options, but he doesn't. So, why is he doing it? Because he wants to sleep with a stranger who promises Travis sex if he can kill the nine deadliest assassins in the world. That€™s it. Unlike Nathan Drake, Touchdown does have some positive characteristics. He feels respect toward those he deems €˜true warriors€™, he€™s highly knowledgeable and often poetic, and violence against women makes him feel uncomfortable. Of course, by the time we get to the second game Travis seems to have gotten over this discomfort, slicing both men and women to shreds with the same degree of reckless abandonment. So if anything, maybe he€™s getting worse. It€™s for these reasons that Travis Touchdown would make a perfect villain. He€™s already amoral and self-involved, he already cheats in battle to get ahead despite his claims to be an honourable warrior. Just add a pinch more narcissism and Travis is ready to transform into a seriously dangerous antagonist.

8. Dante (DmC: Devil May Cry)

The Dante from the original Devil May Cry series was a pretty likeable hero in many ways. His one-liners and cavalier attitude toward dangerous situations may have put some people off, but he had a heart of gold. Though his macho posturing occasionally verged on the obnoxious, Dante had a whole host of positive characteristics. He took on jobs from poorer cliental despite the lack of pay, he had a strong sense of justice and he never fought humans or opponents who were obviously weaker than himself. In 2013, Ninja Theory released DmC and introduced the world to the all-new Dante, a vulgar and unlikeable brat that spends the vast majority of the game acting unnecessarily aggressive and mean-spirited. He€™s like a teenager who thinks he€™s a rebel, a brooding outsider that can just about sum up the necessary energy to care about the fate of the world. In comparison to old version, the new Son of Sparda comes across as an unstylish, womanising adolescent that takes little responsibility for his actions and their consequences. If he were transported to the universe of the original Devil May Cry, his superhuman powers would actually make him a worthy adversary for the original Dante. Now that's a parallel dimension crossover we'd like to see.

7. Jackie Estacado (The Darkness 2)

As a contract killer for the Italian mafia, Jackie Estacado may have deserved a lot of the terrible things that happened to him throughout the course of the first game. For instance, we know that he€™s killed a lot of people, some of which were likely entirely innocent. We also know that he€™s been involved in crime since the tender age of twelve. But knowing any of this information doesn€™t prevent Jackie from being an incredibly sympathetic character with a motivation we can all easily understand: revenge. At the end of the first game, Jackie is told by The Darkness that he will be taken over if he takes the life of his uncle Paulie. He gets told rather explicitly €œTake his life so that I can take yours€. Knowing this, Jackie decides to pull the trigger anyway. Fast forward five years to the release of The Darkness 2, I was honestly expecting Jackie to be the new antagonist. After all, his story was complete, he had gotten his revenge and forfeited his humanity in the process. I was expecting a Luke Skywalker/Vader type thing with The Darkness selecting a new host to overthrow Jackie and take up his mantle. Sadly that didn€™t happen, with Jackie remaining the same spine-ripping maniac he was beforehand - however that only gives him real potential on the opposite side of the fence if they ever make The Darkness 3.

6. Trevor Phillips (GTA V)

Most Grand Theft Auto characters are at least a little unstable, it€™s almost a staple of the franchise at this point. In fact, having a moralistic protagonist in a GTA game almost defeats the entire purpose of the series, but most characters demonstrate at least some restraint. CJ from San Andreas had no qualms with chasing down a trainload of gangsters armed to the teeth with machine guns, but he showed remorse for having to kill his two closest friends Ryder and Big Smoke. Admittedly, that€™s not much to go on, but it€™s something. Trevor on the other hand, is the embodiment of depravity and psychosis. Not only is he a killer, torturer and implied cannibal, but he also doesn€™t seem to value the lives of even his closest friends. Case and point: his relationship with his friend Floyd. Not only does Trevor abuse him (pretty tame for a GTA game) and get him attacked by soldiers as a distraction during a heist (again, not too bad) but then it€™s implied that he takes sexual advantage of Floyd (Okay, beginning to cross the line) finally murdering him and his girlfriend for asking Trevor to leave their house (aaand the line is now a dot). Trevor is a bad guy already, just swap some of his allegiances and he can play the antagonist in any future instalments of the series. You wouldn€™t even need to change that much about his character, or anything for that matter. He€™s a pretty detestable villain already.

5. Conker (Conker's Bad Fur Day)

Don€™t let his appearance fool you, Conker the anthropomorphic squirrel is a belligerent alcoholic with a tendency to urinate in public. Armed to the teeth with a shotgun, throwing knives, a machine gun and his own foul mouth, Conker€™s goal is very simple: get home to his buxom girlfriend Berri before he€™s turned into a table leg. This may surprise a few people but despite his bad language and usage of drugs and alcohol, Conker is part of the same universe as Donkey Kong. That's right, Conker was a playable character in the 1997 kart racer Diddy Kong Racing. It was an early iteration of the character long before Rare turned him into a depraved boozer, but it does means that Conker and Donkey Kong exist in the same shared universe. Though Nintendo would never allow it, can you imagine a game in which the innocent and naïve trio of Donkey, Diddy and Dixie had to put an end to the intoxicated mayhem being caused by everyone€™s favourite degenerate squirrel? It€™s something that would never happen of course, but that won€™t stop me from dreaming.

4. Kratos (God Of War)

Tricked into killing his family by the Gods, Kratos has been on the warpath ever since, maiming and murdering some truly epic foes in order to get his revenge. Until the final instalment of the series, I often wondered how it could possibly end well for our destructive protagonist, especially considering the fact that Kratos had either killed or made enemies of everything in existence by this point. Were we expected to believe he would settle down and raise crops, or start a book club? He€™s a battle-hardened monster raised on a diet of blood and entrails, there was no way it could end well for him. So, why not have him become the thing he despised most? Imagine if Kratos had taken up the mantle of Zeus at the end of God of War 3 and kept Athena€™s powers instead of sacrificing them. We already know that Kratos likes to spend his time murdering innocent people and pillaging cities, so why not? Like Nathan Drake and Jackie Estacado, Kratos is a already more than halfway there. He was a beast long before he made a pact with Ares, and he continued to act like a monster until the very end. Add some divine powers and he€™d be an unstoppable juggernaut, a worthy adversary for any future hero to overcome.

3. Adam 'Kane' Marcus (Kane & Lynch: Dead Men)

You might have been expecting Lynch to make this list due to the fact that he€™s a highly medicated, paranoid schizophrenic with much less of a grip on reality than Kane. He acts recklessly and unpredictably, killing innocent bystanders and wreaking levels of havoc that are unfathomable, but he€™s also prone to hallucinations that prevent him from fully comprehending a given situation. What€™s Kane€™s excuse? Both men are killers who don€™t seem to value human life very highly, but at least Lynch knows that he€™s an evil scumbag that deserves to die, at least he takes accountability for his evilness. Kane€™s continuous justifying of his own misdeeds is what makes him truly dislikeable. He€™s manipulative, spineless and hypocritical, often dismissing any blame for his terrible acts of barbarism on account of the need to save his family. Now I know I mentioned early that having compelling motivations can make a character more sympathetic, but with Kane I get the impression that his family just aren€™t really his primary concern. In fact, it seems as though he€™s only saving them to expunge his own deep-seated feelings of guilt at getting them involved in the situation in the first place. After all, we never really get the impression that he particularly cares about them, and his actions suggest that he doesn€™t value any human life besides his own. It€™s that level of irredeemableness that really sets Kane apart as a perfect villain. He€™s convinced himself that he has a noble goal that justifies his unforgivable acts of murder and mayhem. Sounds like the quintessential antagonist to me.

2. Raiden (Metal Gear Solid 2)

In 2001, Hideo Kojima introduced the world to Raiden, a whiny, generic-looking hero with the voice of Sonic the Hedgehog. Though he wasn't entirely loathsome, Raiden€™s biggest flaw was that he simply wasn't an interesting character, especially compared to the previous hero of the franchise, Solid Snake. Despite his detailed backstory that involved being a child soldier, it was almost impossible to feel anything toward Raiden who looked and acted like a cardboard cutout pretending to be a human being. Though Raiden has evolved throughout the series and managed to win over some of the fans, it€™s still almost impossible to care about the guy. He no longer looks boring, but his incredible abilities and aptitude for destruction render him a thoroughly unsympathetic character with little personality for the audience to relate to. So, make him a villain. Solid Snake has made a career out of fighting adversaries that outclass him physically, Raiden would fit right in with the likes of Liquid Snake, Grey Fox and Revolver Ocelot. Plus, it might finally make him somewhat interesting. His tragic backstory (the one that€™s been shoved down our throats for the past fifteen years) can act as his motivation for turning to the dark side and forming his own militia of hardened cyborg-soldiers. At the very least, it will justify Raiden€™s creation and give him something to do in any future instalments of the series.

1. Mario (Super Mario Bros.)

Everyone€™s second favourite Italian plumber isn€™t above stomping on a few Goombas to save the princess, but at some point you start wondering when it will all end. The Mario series is starting to feel like an infinite loop, a hellish Groundhog Day situation that forces Mario to save Princess Peach from the evil clutches of Bowser again and again, and again... and again. At some point the poor guy is going to snap, the pressure of endlessly repeating the same sequence of events finally turning his mind to mush. Luigi€™s been phoning in his performances for years, but Mario is always expected to be the hero no matter the circumstances, no matter how many times he€™s already cleared the same identical desert stage or crushed the same Goomba into dust. What better motivation for a villain? Disconcerted with having to save the same princess from the same baddy day after day, Mario joins forces with Bowser to bring about a new age of darkness in which no one is allowed to do the same thing twice. Under the rule of this new totalitarian regime, Princess Peach would remain under constant lock and key, and the inhabitants of the mushroom kingdom would be rounded up forced to play a twisted version of Mario Party with rules that are in a constant state of flux. The new hero would be Luigi of course (everyone's real favourite Italian plumber) who would lead a rebellion of Toads to overthrow his tyrannical older brother and save the princess, thus beginning a new infinite cycle of kidnap and rescue that will last forever. At least... until Luigi snaps. Which 'heroes' would you rather go up against, instead of embody? Let us know in the comments, and join the ranks over at whatculture.com/write if you'd like to contribute your own content!

Contributor
Contributor

Formerly an assistant editor, Richard's interests include detective fiction and Japanese horror movies.