10 Video Game Franchises With Only ONE Good Game
Catching lightning in a bottle twice is REALLY hard.
Consistency is crucial for a video game franchise to remain successful in the long run. However, cranking out masterpiece after masterpiece is anything but easy.
As such, even the biggest properties will drop the ball every once in a while. Although Sonic the Hedgehog, Final Fantasy, and Mortal Kombat have had their ups and downs, each IP has offered plenty of solid titles over the years.
But there are certain series that have had some rotten luck, only managing to toss out one great title throughout their entire run. Sometimes, the brand gets it right on their first attempt, and every sequel fails to recapture the magic. Whether the developers try to churn out more of the same or go in a bold new direction, nothing seems to work.
Other times, a gaming property will have to go through multiple instalments before perfecting the recipe. For whatever reason, the creators find themselves unable to deliver the same level of quality again.
Even though these ten gaming series should be commended for delivering some absolute gems, it's a shame they only managed to pull it off once.
10. Zone of the Enders
Hideo Kojima's sci-fi hack-and-slash follows a young pilot called Leo Stenbuck who uses his space mech to defeat robotic forces.
Though Zone of the Enders was praised for its camerawork and combat, it was undermined by its brevity, badly translated script, emotionless voice acting, and poor characterisation.
Fortunately, the next entry, The 2nd Runner, remedied these issues and tightened up the already impressive gameplay. Basically, the first sequel was like a superior version of the original. Now the developers figured out what worked and what didn't, Zone of the Enders should've become the next big thing.
But it didn't. Though the Fist of Mars spin-off tried something different by using turn-based mechanics, it was pretty bland.
Konami hoped to renew interest by releasing a HD remaster of the first two titles. Sadly, ZOE HD Collection was so half-assed, the creators shouldn't have bothered.
Though the VR version of The 2nd Runner looks breath-taking, the mech's frantic speed makes it hard to control and harder to lock onto enemies. These sudden movements can be so distressing, some players suffered motion sickness.
If Konami released a straightforward sequel after The 2nd Runner, Zone of the Enders could've become more recognised.
9. Watch Dogs
The E3 2012 trailer of Watch Dogs set a high bar, showcasing next-gen lighting and textures.
Sadly, Ubisoft's hacktivism-centric title failed to live up to expectations, due to its derivative gameplay, technical issues, and of course, its downgraded graphics, which looked nothing like how the promotions suggested. Watch Dogs' false advertising was so infamous, it could've tarnished its name beyond repair.
Luckily, Watch Dogs 2 was closer to what players were expecting from the original. The hacking mechanics came in more variety, including remotely controlling vehicles, interacting with drones, and manipulating traffic lights.
Although the first one was combat-heavy, Watch Dogs 2 allowed players to decide whether to go in guns blazing or rely on stealth. There was a lot of replayability, since players are incentivised to try the same missions a number of ways.
Sure, it had a rough start, but it seemed like Watch Dogs was in business, especially after the sequel sold 10 million units.
Too bad Watch Dogs: Legion failed to impress. To be fair, this entry had creative ideas, especially the recruitment mechanic that allows you to draft NPCs. But this concept was mishandled and the gameplay was rife with bugs, mediocre combat, and repetitive missions.
Though Watch Dogs was once promising, it looks like a one-trick pony in hindsight.
8. Perfect Dark
GoldenEye 007 may have revolutionised first-person shooters but Rare's spiritual successor, Perfect Dark, surpassed the James Bond title in almost every way. The futuristic FPS boasts more diverse missions, head-bopping soundtracks, cool gadgets, an onslaught of astounding weapons, and enemy AI that's impressive by today's standards.
With Perfect Dark receiving universal praise, everyone was expecting a follow-up. Although things were touch a go when Microsoft acquired Rare, the British developers assured gamers that another Perfect Dark was on the cards. Several years later, a prequel called Perfect Dark Zero launched on the Xbox 360.
And the overall reception was... meh. By no means a terrible game, Zero regressed in many areas, including voice-acting, enemy AI, story, and level structure.
Shortly after, 4J Studios devised a remaster of the original with a higher frame rate, an online multiplayer, sharper textures, and refined character models.
And the overall reception was once again... meh. Despite looking drastically better, 2010's Perfect Dark was less polished, due to its repeating textures, floaty aiming, and stiff controls.
Also, the enemy AI becomes noticeably worse in every instalment, since each of the baddies this time are as useless as a chocolate teapot.
Considering how influential Perfect Dark was, the gaming community deserved better.
7. Golden Axe
Golden Axe was an arcade hack-and-slash released in 1989. Due to its success, the sword-and-sorcery co-op was released on many systems, becoming one of the best-selling Genesis games.
Though beat 'em ups were a dime a dozen at the time, the Conan the Barbarian-inspired title stood out, due to its tight combat, catchy chiptunes, and addictive steed riding. Also, blasting enemies with a screen-filling dragon never stops being fun. Ever.
With other Genesis classics like Sonic, Shinobi, and Street of Rage churning out solid sequels, it was understandable when Golden Axe followed suit.
Unfortunately, Golden Axe II added nothing new, even using the same graphics and sound as its predecessor. Somehow, the threequel was worse, due to its shoddy graphics and imprecise combat.
Sega tried to reignite interest in 2008, publishing a 3D reboot called Golden Axe: Beast Rider. Sadly, this blunder lacks everything that made Golden Axe special. Despite the fact the magic potions were integral in previous titles for launching mega-attacks, this mechanic was removed. Even though beast-riding was the biggest selling point, it's the worst part of the game. Also, there's no co-op, making the main campaign a solitary and dull experience.
Though it was once one of Sega's proudest properties, Golden Axe has been effectively dead for decades.
6. Call Of Juarez
Despite the fact Techland's original cowboy shooter was atmospheric and the shooting mechanics were awesome, it was let down by fiddly controls, poor stealth, and linear levels. (Also, the platforming sections and the whip mechanics were indefensibly awful.)
Techland took all the criticism onboard for the prequel, Bound for Blood, removing the platforming and stealth elements. But due to the braindead AI and samey missions, it was still far from great. But Bound for Blood was a step in the right direction, so fans were hoping it would be third time lucky.
But Call of Juarez: The Cartel swapped out Mexican standoffs and horse riding with drive-by shootings and taking down drug dealers. Even if this modern reboot was disassociated from the series, it was still a mess in its own right.
Just when it looked like COJ was out of juice, 2013's Gunslinger set things right. The fourth entry ditches the semi-realism and embraces the flashy action of Spaghetti Westerns. The gameplay is deeply addictive, rewarding players with bonuses for performing combos and slo-mo kills.
Also, it's nice to see real cowboys like Billy the Kid, Jesse James, Butch Cassidy, and the Sundance Kid being incorporated into a Wild West game.
Though Call of Juarez was all over the place for a while, its future looks bright than ever now, thanks to Gunslinger.
5. Tenchu
In 1998, Acquire released a ninja title for the PSOne called Tenchu: Stealth Assassins. In this game, the heroes are equipped with a wide range of weapons, including shurikens, smoke bombs, grenades, land mines, grappling hooks, and poison rice cakes. Since ninjas are meant to remain unseen, players need to be cautious and tactful, rather than maiming everyone in sight.
Unfortunately, the stealth mechanics were overshadowed by Metal Gear Solid, which was released around the same time. Nevertheless, this underrated title had potential, so it was reassuring when Tenchu spawned a whopping nine sequels.
And every one of them was atrocious. In fact, they got progressively worse. The first few sequels were underwhelming. The last few entries, like Dark Secret and Shadow Assault, were borderline unplayable. (Weirdly, the abominable Shadow Assault was created by powerhouse developers, FromSoftware.)
Although 2008's Shadow Assassins was a slight improvement, it didn't matter since the franchise went into hiatus indefinitely immediately after.
Considering how promising Tenchu, it was a shame to see it fizzle out. With that said, it's a miracle Tenchu lasted as long as it did, since the series had a major drop in quality almost immediately.
4. Outlast
With Resident Evil and Silent Hill cornering the survivor horror market for decades, it's difficult for similar titles to thrive.
But 2013's Outlast made an instant impression. Red Barrels' psychological chiller opens with a journalist investigating a story in a dilapidated asylum, only to learn it's been taken over by monstrous psychopaths.
What makes Outlast stand out over its peers is the fact you can't attack anyone, forcing you to sneak around enemies, lurk in shadows, or hide in lockers to avoid being murdered. Not only does this make the gaming experience more strategic, it elevates the fear factor exponentially.
So, when Outlast 2 was announced, fans were curious to see what new developments and innovations it would bring to the table. However, the sequel went backwards, thanks to its scripted enemy AI, predictable jump-scares, and tedious chases sequences.
Now, one misfire isn't the end of the world. And The Outlast Trials prequel sounded intriguing, since it explores the story's deep lore. (It also boasts a four-player multiplayer, which is always a plus.)
Unfortunately, The Outlast Trials suffers from laborious missions, grindy gameplay, and imbalanced AI. It's also obvious the main campaign was primarily designed for co-op, as it's way too hard on single player.
Although the first Outlast is worth a go, there's no need to check out the rest.
3. Shadowrun
Shadowrun is a tabletop role-playing game set in a dystopian future where magic and technology coexist. Due to its popularity, it was bound to be adapted into a video game. However, being adapted into a good video game was a different story altogether.
The first three entries (all with the same title) suffered from slow pacing, dreary combat, and limited NPC interaction.
The fourth instalment (also called Shadowrun) tried something different, turning the franchise into an online shooter. It was an ambitious idea, but it didn't pay off. Though Shadowrun Returns went back to basics, its poor quality made the biggest advocates question whether the tabletop could be adapted well.
So when Shadowrun Dragonfall received positive reviews, it was a cause for celebration. Built on the foundation of Shadowrun Returns, Dragonfall improved in every aspect. The combat system is still turn-based, but gave a sense of real strategy and variety, especially with the ability to modify and upgrade characters with cyberware. There were some unpolished elements and glitches, but The Director's Cut refined everything to perfection.
After 21 years, it looked like Shadowrun finally found its stride. However, the follow-up, Shadowrun: Hong Kong was nothing special, so it's possible Dragonfall was a one-off.
2. Crackdown
Crackdown was a sleeper hit for the Xbox 360 when it was released in 2007. The action-adventurer combines open-world exploration with superhero antics, allowing players to leap across rooftops while blasting everything in sight. It also offered a lot of flexibility, since you could take down gang bosses in any order.
Instead of evolving the formula, Crackdown 2 felt like an expansion pack. It reused the same city with minimal changes and replaced the imaginative gang battles with banal fights against mindless creatures. The game lacked a compelling antagonist, and the mission structure became formulaic. While the core gameplay remained the same, the innovation was virtually non-existent.
After years of delays, Crackdown 3 launched with a whimper. Due to its outdated single-player campaign, unpolished gameplay, and lack of mission variety, people wondered why this blunder spent so long in development. (Not even President Camacho himself, Terry Crews, could save this one.)
While Crews’ involvement added personality, Crackdown 3 failed to deliver anything new beyond what the first instalment achieved over a decade earlier.
Even though any gaming property can recover from a dud, Crackdown 3 may have killed the brand for good.
1. Five Nights At Freddy's
To paraphrase Conquest from Invincible, Five Night at Freddy's is a victim of its own success. The original was a simple yet terrifying point-and-click experience that took advantage of psychological horror and mystery.
Due to how easy it was to develop, Scott Cawthon and his team cranked out multiple sequels in rapid succession. (In just over a decade, Five Nights has released 20 instalments, which is a remarkable achievement.)
Unfortunately, the novelty wore off almost immediately. What was once an imaginative horror IP became formulaic, relying on the same mechanics with the mildest variations.
The straightforward story became increasingly convoluted, with the sequels tossing in dream theories, alternate timelines, ghost children, and an excessive number of new characters. Instead of adding depth, the complexity has made the story frustratingly difficult to follow.
Rather than maintaining the minimalism of the first one, the sequels introduced more action-oriented and less atmospheric gameplay. While looking at glitch-riddled open-worlders like Security Breach, it's obvious Five Nights has become a shell of what it once was
Five Nights at Freddy's may still be lucrative but risks fading into irrelevance if it continues to prioritise quantity over quality.