10 Video Game Mysteries That BAFFLED Gamers For Years
After years of speculation, the truth behind these games are coming out.
Video games have proven to be a fertile ground for mysteries, captivating players long after the credits roll. From hidden rooms and secret characters to cryptic messages left by the developers, these enigmas and riddles encouraged players to explore platformers, sandboxes, and Soulslikes in ways the creators may never have intended.
Some of these secrets were intentional, while others emerge from glitches, fan theories, or misinterpreted hints. The allure of the unknown encourages collaborative detective work, since it pushes communities of gamers to data-mine for clues and dissect every line of dialogue. In times of desperation, they might outright ask the developers about these ongoing conundrums, hoping to gain a crumb of insight.
As a result, it's satisfying when a theory is proven right or a rumour turns out to be true, vindicating years or decades of speculation. On the other hand, some entries on this list remain unsolved to this day, leading to endless conjecture.
Whether or not these video game mysteries have been solved yet, every one of them left the gaming community utterly baffled for far too long.
10. Noob Saibot's Identity - Mortal Kombat Deception
Although the original Mortal Kombat was successful, the sequel surpassed it in almost every way, offering a better roster, tighter gameplay, and a lot more blood.
On top of that, MKII allowed players to face even more secret opponents if certain criteria was fulfilled. After winning 25 Versus matches in a row, you could face a shadowy ninja called Noob Saibot. Despite being a black reskin of Sub-Zero, players were fascinated by this elusive kombatant. Even though Noob appeared in numerous follow-ups, nothing was known about him, magnifying the speculation.
And when Mortal Kombat: Deception was released, the cat was finally let out of the bag. After completing the Arcade Mode with Noob, he's revealed to be Sub-Zero from the first Mortal Kombat, Bi-Han. When Scorpion was murdered, he erroneously believed Bi-Han was to blame and executed him. Due to suffering an unjustified death, Bi-Han was reborn as a vengeful wraith called Noob while his brother, Kuai Liang, took on the mantle of Sub-Zero.
Though revealing Noob Saibot's identity could've ruined his mystique, his backstory turned him into one of the most fascinating MK characters, as well as one of the most tragic. (Well, until Mk1 ruined it with the most recent retcon but let's just forget that happened.)
9. The Golden Coins - Gears Of War 3
The most common reason why video game secrets remain hidden for so long is because the method needed to discover them is unnecessarily overelaborate.
With that said, Gears of War's most enduring mystery is extremely simple to pull off. While traversing through the House of Sand in Act II Chapter 2, you may see three golden coins embedded in the trees. For five years, nobody could work out the purpose behind these coins. Nothing seemed to happened when you shot them, so it was believed the coins served as mere decoration.
Little did people realise you need to shoot the coins in a specific order. You have to start with the one beside the gnarled tree, then the one by the split path, and finally the one by the Locust catapult.
After blasting the third coin, you'll be directed towards a hidden shooting range where you must shoot Locusts bursting out of the ground. (It's like a hybrid of Duckhunt and whack-a-mole.)
This mini-game is worth a go since it's hilarious, addictive, and nets you a few free weapons, which should help with the rest of the mission.
8. The Chris Houlihan Room – The Legend of Zelda: A Link to the Past
Gaming bugs can be terrifying, since they can result in a soft-lock, a crash, or save data being lost. To avoid this, developers sometimes create a fail-safe room, teleporting the player there in the event of a glitch.
Arguably, the most famous fail-safe room in gaming is the Chris Houlihan Room in The Legend of Zelda: A Link to the Past. The hidden place is so named since it was created as part of a Nintendo Power contest, where the winner had his name immortalised in the game. When Link enters the room, he'll find dozens of Rupees and a tile that reads, "My name is Chris Houlihan. This is my top secret room. Keep it between us, okay?"
Although Nintendo Power ran the competition, few people could access this room, causing players to question its existence for years. But with the rise of emulators and ROM hacking communities, players were able to reliably trigger the glitch that sends Link to this hidden area.
Over time, the Chris Houlihan Room became a piece of Nintendo lore, celebrated not only as a quirky bug fix but also as a legendary Easter egg.
7. The Black Monolith Has Been Solved (But We Don't Know How) - Fez
Phil Fish's award-winning indie involves rotating a 2D world along a 3D axis, allowing players to discover hidden paths and solve spatial challenges. Some of the puzzles require a lot of brainpower, so anyone who completed Fez should be proud of themselves.
And yet, the Black Monolith Room stumped everyone. Even the lead designer, Trey Reyher, emphasised the cryptic slab is "practically impossible" to solve.
The most common theory to open the Monolith involves a configuration associated with Fez's release date - 4/13/2012. Players tried all sorts of combinations related to these digits but nothing worked, giving the fanbase little hope.
But after years of deliberation, Peter Silk became the first person to open the Monolith, which rewarded him with a unique item. The artefact doesn't do much, but it was nice to know somebody finally cracked the case.
However, Silk didn't solve the puzzle through skill. Instead, he used a program to generate every possible solution, one of which opened the Monolith. Although players should be happy Fez's most mind-bending mystery has an answer, we're still not exactly sure what it is.
6. Is A Baby On The Way? - Batman: Arkham Asylum + Batman: Arkham City
Batman: Arkham Asylum fanatics should be familiar with a hidden room inside the Warden's Office, which contains blueprints for Arkham City, hinting at the sequel. This secret was so well-hidden, nobody discovered it, compelling the creators to announce it two years after the game's release.
However, this isn't the only mystery that Arkham Asylum harboured. In Joker's Steel Mill, Batman can find a positive pregnancy test, suggesting Harley Quinn has a bun in the oven. This was a massive bombshell, especially if Joker turned out to be the daddy.
However, Batman: Arkham City made no reference to this sub-plot whatsoever. So, what happened? Did Harley lose the baby? Was it a random Easter egg? Did the supervillainess have the child in secret? Eager to get to the bottom of this, players began speculating endlessly, despite not getting any closer to an answer.
But there is one. In Arkham City's DLC, Harley Quinn's Revenge, a crib can be found in Harley's Hideout. By investigating this crib, you'll find a Joker doll surrounded by negative pregnancy tests. A box nearby warns the tests can produce false positives, indicating Harley was never pregnant, and the earlier test was a false reading.
It may be anticlimactic answer, but at least this lingering mystery had been put to bed.
5. Who (Or What) Is The Strange Man? - Red Dead Redemption
Being among the most celebrated games of all time, it goes without saying that Red Dead Redemption has been dissected to death since launch. And yet, even the biggest purists of Rocksteady's beloved western are no closer to uncovering the truth behind the Strange Man.
Appearing in remote locations and John Marston's cabin, the top hat-wearing gentleman exudes an unsettling calm and cryptic knowledge about the protagonist' past and future. Unlike normal characters, the Strange Man supposedly exists outside the rules of the game world, sometimes appearing and disappearing in the blink of an eye.
Any details the moustachioed entity gives about himself only amplify the mystery.. He declares he's an accountant "in a way" but doesn't go into any detail. He says "this is a fine spot" while admiring the area where John will be buried once he's gunned down by the law.
One character (and many players) believe the Strange Man is the Grim Reaper, who's keeping tabs on John before he shuffles off his mortal coil.
But until Rocksteady confirms this theory, it's likely we'll never know for certain.
4. Was Michael Jackson Involved? - Sonic The Hedgehog 3
The original Sonic the Hedgehog singlehandedly defined the Mega Drive and became an icon almost overnight. When Sonic the Hedgehog 2 became a smash success, it was obvious the blue speedster was becoming a gaming juggernaut.
Just when it seemed like the hype peaked, Sega announced Michael Jackson was composing tracks for Sonic the Hedgehog 3.
But after its release, there were conflicting reports whether the King of Pop was involved in the threequel. Some sources claim Jackson was unhappy how his music sounded on Sega's hardware and so, had it removed. Other reports stated Sega removed the songs to distance themselves from the rising controversy surrounding Jackson's personal life.
Although both parties said Jackson's music doesn't feature in Sonic 3, several melodies sound very reminiscent of the legendary singer's work, especially Ice Cap Zone and Launch Base Zone.
Speculation wasn't cleared until 2005 when STI director, Roger Hector, validated Jackson's music was used in the project. (This explains why the music for the aforementioned levels was replaced in re-releases, since licensing and copyright were too costly.)
This is frustrating since it was only confirmed Michael Jackson's music was in Sonic the Hedgehog 3... immediately after the game wasn't allowed to use it anymore.
3. Access The Inaccessible Room - Doom II
Even if you were a Doom veteran, completing the original hellish shooter was a tall order. However, it was nothing compared to Doom II, which was literally impossible to 100%.
But the reason why the game couldn't be fully completed wasn't due to skill, but a glitch. Near the Industrial Zone's exit, there's a door-shaped wall marked as a secret sector on the automap.
Naturally, players assumed that passing through this wall would gain them access to a bonus area. But according to John Romero, it was a dummy door erroneously marked as a secret.
Despite being created by accident, players were desperate to get inside so they could 100% the main campaign. The door can be bypassed via cheats, but there didn't seem to be any way to get through it conventionally.
But in 2018, visionary gamer, Zero Master, discovered you can clip into the supposedly impenetrable room by luring a Pain Elemental to the area and allowing it to shove you through.
As such, Zero Master became the first person to 100% Doom II in 24 years. Due to accomplishing this seemingly impossible feat, Romero himself congratulated the Doom advocate on X.
2. Entering the HMCS Bitter - Blood Omen: Legacy Of Kain
Although Soul Reaver and Soul Reaver 2 have proven to be the most popular entries in the Legacy of Kain franchise, the original Blood Omen garnered a resurgence over a decade after its release when an obscure Easter egg was discovered.
In 2010, a project was set up to recreate the PSOne title in 3D. While data-mining, a pirate ship was found called the HMCS Bitter. Even though it was a fascinating find, there didn't seem to be any way to access the vessel.
When the game's designer, Denis Dyack, was grilled about it seven years later, he revealed the Bitter could be boarded by flipping four switches hidden throughout the world of Nosgoth.
However, nobody had ever stumbled upon the quartet of switches before since they were invisible. Since Dyack didn't remember or care to mention where they were, it took players another three years to pinpoint the switches, allowing them to finally set foot on the enigmatic sailing ship.
There's nothing in particular to do on the HMCS Bitter, but it was reassuring to hear this secret has been put to rest, decades after Blood Omen: Legacy of Kain's release.
1. L Is Real - Super Mario 64
Being one of the most influential platformers of all time, it's no surprise Super Mario 64 had one of the longest enduring rumours in gaming.
In the Castle Courtyard, a stone plaque can be found in front of Boo's fountain. Although the text is blurry, some players suggest it reads, "L Is Real 2401."
Many fan-theories were thrown around surrounding the plaque's significance, but the common consensus was the "L" stood for Luigi, hinting that Mario's cowardly brother was an unlockable character. It was hypothesised the "2401" was a reference to how many coins were in the game (which seemed like a reasonable guess), indicating players needed to collect every coin to find Luigi. Of course, there was no substantial evidence to back this up, so all gossip surrounding Luigi fizzled away.
That is until the 2020 Nintendo gigaleak, which confirmed code for Luigi was in Super Mario 64's source files.
According to Mario creator, Shigeru Miyamoto, Super Mario 64 was meant to have a split-screen co-op mode, with Luigi serving as a playable character.
Even though this rumour has been supposed quashed and debunked time and time again, it turns out L Was Real all along.