10 Video Game Protagonists Who Were Doomed From The Start

The characters who had their ticket punched from the moment you popped in the disc

Persona 3
Atlus

The protagonist of a video game is meant to be the avatar for the player. Even if they have their own personality, wants and needs, that fact is indisputable. So it's unlikely, in most games, that things won't eventually turn out in the protagonist's favor. 

But that hasn't stopped some games from bucking this trend.

In fact, not only are some video game protagonists not destined for success, they can actually be doomed from the beginning to have a very sticky end. Whether it's dying at the end of the narrative, or something much more complex like - say - losing everything they had and needing to start all over again, some games tell you exactly how it's going to end the minute you press play.

These ten video game protagonists had nothing but misery awaiting them at the end of their stories, and they were the last ones to find out. And all that you, the player, could do, was sit there and watch them hoist themselves on their own petard. 

MAJOR SPOILERS FOLLOW...

10. Hawke - Dragon Age II

dragon age 2
Bioware

No one knew what to make of Dragon Age 2 when it first came out - besides its more primitive game design compared to Origins, its story left a lot of folks unsatisfied. And unfortunately, many failed to make the necessary critical leaps to figure out why that was: that Dragon Age 2 is a classical tragedy.

All Hawke wanted when they came to their family's home of Kirkwall was to make a name for themselves and regain the family fortune. And at the end of Act 1, they get both of those things. But if you're familiar with the trajectory of tragic narratives, then this was the first of many red flags that things were not going to end well for Hawke.

See, this title and stature just end up making more trouble for them, as the city's problems swiftly become their problems. City officials rope them into the increasingly volatile politics of the region, and the hotbed that is Mage/Templar relations drives bigger and bigger wedges between them and their found family of weirdos. 

By the end, it's their friend Anders that blows their entire life to hell by triggering the Mage/Templar war via the destruction of the city's Chantry, leaving Hawke with nothing as they have to flee the city.


9. Tommy Angelo - Mafia

mafia definitive edition
2K

Mafia narratives rarely end well. It goes with the genre. So it's no shock that Tommy Angelo of the original Mafia game meets with a rather unfortunate end.

Tommy spends years throughout the game helping his boss, Salieri, get to the top of the underworld's food chain. Only for his reward at the end to be one best buddy dead, the other responsible, and him about to be given a new pair of cement shoes. Well, actually, they try to kill him in an art gallery - it's more symbolic that way - but you get the idea. 

At the end, Tommy puts down Sam and strikes a deal with the cops to get his family new identities - the catch being that he has to testify in court to make sure Salieri goes down. 

The epilogue takes us years into the future, where an older Tommy is hunted down by Vito, the protagonist of Mafia II, and swiftly assassinated. Tommy, knowing the score and how it was always going to end, greets the shotgun barrel with a contented smile. 


8. Mandus - Amnesia: A Machine For Pigs

amnesia a machine for pigs manpig
Chinese Room

Amnesia: A Machine for Pigs features one of the most tragic protagonists in gaming history with Mandus. 

Mandus is, on no uncertain terms, a a genius - but one that became hampered by an increasing cynicism with the human form. Upon witnessing a vision while in Mexico that told him of WWI, the most devastating war in human history (a war that would claim the lives of his sons), Mandus' cynicism morphs into unbridled hatred. His machine - his masterpiece - originally built to help humanity, would be made instead to wipe them out before the coming of the 20th century. 

At the 11th hour, when the game actually begins, Mandus suddenly awakens from the years-long madness he has been trapped in. He spends the entire game trying desperately to stop the machine, to stop the horror he had set in motion, only to realize that there can be no redemption for what he's done. To build this horror, it's revealed that he killed his two sons before the human race could do it for him, and had sacrificed countless innocents to build his army of man-pigs. There is only one way a story like this can end. 

Mandus travels to the centre of his machine and gives his life to stop it. And, moments later, the clock strikes midnight, and the 20th century begins. 


7. Tidus - Final Fantasy X

Ffx yuna and tidus
Square Enix

If ever there was a poster boy for "did not sign up for this nonsense", it would be Tidus from FFX. The guy just wanted to play Blitzball, dammit. But instead, a giant eldritch god-whale thing named Sin shows up and destroys his home of Zanarkand. Tidus then wakes up in the world of Spira and gets roped into helping Yuna and her gang of oddballs complete the summoning ritual to try and defeat Sin. 

Among the many twists and turns the story of FFX throws Tidus' way, the biggest is the truth of Zanarkand. While Zanarkand did exist, the one that Tidus called home was actually a construction created by a race known as the Fayth. The Zanarkand that Tidus, his father, and Auron call home only exists so long as the Fayth are in their endless sleep - but if Sin is defeated - the sleep can finally end. And with it, the dream of Zanarkand. 

There's no turning back by this point, which is partly why Tidus takes so long to share this detail with his friends. And why he's so accepting of his death come the closing moments of the story. 

Tidus died at the beginning of FFX. He was just the last one to figure that out.


6. Wander - Shadow of the Colossus

Shadow of the Colossus
Bluepoint Games

Taking a deal with a demon is never a good idea in any scenario. At best you'll have to find a way to wriggle out of the price the demon exacts from you for its services. At worst? Well, it doesn't give you that chance. 

The second Wander took Dormin's deal at the beginning of Shadow of the Colossus, his ticket was punched. Anyone in their right mind would have seen Dormin's task of defeating the Colossi as the load of BS that it was - doomed to failure at best, and guaranteed to come with a catch at worst. But, of course, Wander is very much not thinking straight in this game, wracked with grief over the loss of his lover Mono. 

It turns out that the Colossi were housing the shards of Dormin's spirit. So killing them - while a horrific act on its face since the Colossi were innocent - also allowed Dormin to return to blight the land. 

Thus, while Dormin's end of the bargain is seemingly kept - with Mono waking up at the end of the game - Wander is punished for his actions, and turned into a horned baby. 


5. Batman - Batman Arkham Knight

Batman: Arkham Knight
Warner Bros. Interactive Entertainment

Arkham Knight is the story about Batman's deconstruction and reconstruction. It breaks down Bruce Wayne as a character to build him back up into the legend that Gotham needs. Unfortunately, this requires Bruce Wayne to die—at least spiritually. 

The game outright tells you at the start how it's going to end: "This is how it happened. This is how The Batman died". And whilst there's a bit of a positive bumper to the narrative's conclusion, you do see Batman's legend dragged through the mud in this story. He fails to protect his loved ones multiple times, he is put through the ringer throughout the entire thing and, right at the end, Scarecrow gets what he wants.

Batman unmasks himself in front of the entire world, effectively destroying his legend. And although Scarecrow gets very soundly beaten shortly afterwards, just listening to the goon conversations throughout the city shows that the damage has been done. They aren't scared of him anymore. 

Batman enacts the Knightfall protocol, returning to his home and blowing it to smithereens with him and Alfred inside. An indeterminate amount of time later, we see that Batman has become something else... something more. A literal living legend. Just a shame about what it cost to get him there. 


4. Arthur Morgan - Red Dead Redemption 2

Arthur Morgan
Rockstar

Red Dead Redemption 2 is a prologue to the original, so it doesn't take a genius to figure out that player character Arthur Morgan is probably not making it to the end credits alive. Unfortunately, the game is very good at quickly making you hope against hope that somehow you're wrong about that. I mean, they already did the "hero tragically dies seeking redemption at the end" thing with the first game, surely they wouldn't do it again. Right?

Wrong.

Arthur Morgan's story is one of failure after failure—from failing to keep his relationships alive to failing to keep the Van Der Linde gang from going down the wrong path. And in the end, whether you have high or low honor, the result is the same: Arthur dying alone, having lost everything. Even the life he sacrifices himself for—John and his family—are, unbeknownst to him, doomed to tragedy themselves. 

Arthur is one of the most lovable and compelling protagonists in gaming history, so you keep hoping he'll find some way to make it out, only for the game to reinforce that your first impression was the right one. Arthur was a dead man from the start.


3. Booker DeWitt - Bioshock Infinite

Bioshock infinite
2K

"Bring us the girl, wipe away the debt".

This is the order that brings private eye, Booker DeWitt, to the rally in the sky known as Columbia. Or at least, that's what Booker believes at first. But after a several hour adventure hopping across time and space with the aforementioned girl, Elizabeth, Booker makes a truly mind-bending discovery. 

See, the entire city is built around the cult worship of a supposed prophet named Comstock. And no matter what dimension Booker and Elizabeth hop to, Comstock is seemingly always there waiting in some form or another. And then Booker finds out why: he is Comstock. Comstock is another version of Booker, having gone down a somehow darker path than Booker himself - building the city of Columbia and the Christofascist worship within it in another life. 

To keep from spoiling the rest of the game, the end finds Booker and Elizabeth coming to one conclusion: if they are to be rid of Comstock and Columbia, then Booker has to die.

Unlike the previous two games, there is no alternate ending. It was always going to end this way for Booker. 


2. Noble 6 - Halo: Reach

Halo Reach
Bungie

The moment Halo Reach was announced, everyone knew how it was going to end. The first game begins in the aftermath of the planet's destruction at the hands of the Covenant, the Fall of Reach is foundational to the franchise's lore, and the game's many trailers did not shy away from the inevitability of this game's tragic ending. 

The fact is, Noble Six died the second he landed on Reach. 

The goal of Halo Reach goes from defending Reach from the Covenant to getting its greatest assets off the ground before it's too late, as more and more Covenant ships descend on the doomed planet. One by one, Noble team is brutally killed off by the enemy, until - at long last - it's just Noble Six against an entire planet out to kill him. Naturally, he doesn't last long. Noble Team dies, but their actions ensure that they will never be forgotten. 

When writing a prequel, you have no choice creatively but to take into account how the game you are preceding begins. And for a game like Halo Reach, the best way to do that is to lean into the tragedy. 


1. Makoto Yuki - Persona 3

Persona 3 reload
Atlas

Persona 3 is the story of the final year of Makoto Yuki's life. From the opening animation that plays before the title screen of the original release, to the first cutscene of the game proper, you are told, on no uncertain terms, exactly how the game is going to end: Makoto Yuki is going to die. 

This setting of tone fills the player with a sense of dread, as they watch constantly for the moment when the sword of Damocles falls and Makoto's fate is sealed, and also perhaps, a way out of this inevitable fate. But neither comes, because for all the connections Makoto makes throughout the game - for all the development he has as a character - his death is inevitable.

Because Persona 3 is a game about how we deal with the inevitability of death. Some fight against it, some live in denial, and some learn to accept it. Makoto Yuki's journey is about coming to terms with his own mortality, and in the end, facing it. 


Watch Next


 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

John Tibbetts is a novelist in theory, a Whatculture contributor in practice, and a nerd all around who loves talking about movies, TV, anime, and video games more than he loves breathing. Which might be a problem in the long term, but eh, who can think that far ahead?