10 Video Game Puzzles NOBODY Figured Out

FINE, I'll Google it.

mortal kombat havik
NetherRealm

In many ways, the most rewarding moment in a video game is when you complete a frustrating puzzle. To defeat a boss, you need skill and timing. But when it comes to cracking a cipher, you have to use your brain. Titles like Portal, Braid, and Fez are so satisfying because you have to be smart to beat them. (Or you could just use an online walkthrough.)

Even though it can be unbearable when you're stuck on a certain section, it makes the whole gaming experience better when your toiling pays off, and you emerge triumphant.

But sometimes, the developers make a puzzle so intricately complex, it seems unsolvable. Thanks to a lack of clues or logic, not even a bonafide genius could work out these devious cryptographs without a step-by-step guide.

More often than not, you decode these brain-teasers, not with deduction but through dumb luck. Upon completion, you usually don't feel relieved. Instead, you're left reeling from shock, since the conundrum in question was so absurd.

We all know gamers love a challenge, but who actually managed to decipher these ridiculous puzzles?

10. The Rubber Duck – The Longest Journey

Longest Journey
Funcom

Early on The Longest Journey, our protagonist, April, will spot a a key wedged on the subway track. Because you can’t obtain the key without the rails electrocuting you, you need to turn off the power.

In any other game that doesn't want the player to lose the will to live, you would flip a switch to deactivate all electronics, hop onto the rails, and swipe the key.

But in The Longest Journey, there's over a dozen steps to perform this single action. You need to (takes deep breath) go to your apartment and use the gold ring that your dad gave you to loosen the clamp off a water pressure system. (If that sounds convoluted, that's the first phase.) Then, you have to toss breadcrumbs at a rubber ducky outside, which attracts a seagull. By nibbling on the bread, the bird will accidentally puncture the toy. (Before you ask, yes, this is part of the same puzzle.)

After that, grab a clothesline, go downstairs, pick the ducky up, tie it to the clamp, reinflate it, and then use it to collect the key.

If you know what you're doing, this section should only take ten minutes. But no one on their first playthrough will notice the rubber ducky and think, "Well, I obviously have to chuck bread at this thing to retrieve the key at the subway." When you phrase it like that, you can see how surreal the whole situation is.


9. The Waterfall – Earthbound

Earthbound Waterfall
Hal Lab

In role-playing games, you're expected to perform a lot of side-quests, backtracking, and collect all sorts of wacky gizmos. But considering Earthbound has our hero fighting evil tents, musical notes, and Salvador Dali's melting clock, it's won't surprise you to learn some missions are a bit... weird.

So, when Ness and his crew are asked for the password to pass beyond Grapefruit Falls, the player assumes they’re meant to input a code. Because you never received one, you’ll naturally explore the area, trying to find some message or clue.

Of course, you won't find one since the so-called “password” is to stand still behind the waterfall for three minutes. Obviously, no one would think of doing this because... that's not a password! A password is a word or phrase. Standing around is... standing around.

In the game's defence, there is a random Mr. Saturn in Saturn Valley who tells you how to get behind the waterfall. But if you don't happen to bump into this particular NPC, you could never figure this puzzle out yourself.

Even if you speak to him, it mightn't register what he's seeing since the Saturn people usually speak in gibberish. Also, the cursive in the Mr. Saturn's lettering is so hard to read, most people don't notice he's told you the password in the first place.


8. Wait… Braille? – Pokémon Ruby/Sapphire

Pokemon Ruby Braille Puzzle
YouTube

Because the random encounters in Pokemon can get repetitive, each instalment is sprinkled with a couple of brainteasers. Since the franchise's demographic is kids, the sections that require you to use a bit of grey matter are pretty rudimentary. Even when these puzzles are tricky, using your noggin' is more fun than grinding against the same monsters for hours on end.

But even the most dedicated Nintendo fans would rather face an army of Mewtwos armed only with Magikarp than venture into The Sealed Chamber in Pokemon Ruby/Sapphire. If you wish to obtain the Regi-trio, you'll need to head into this hidden cave and decipher a code in braille.

In theory, this section should be easy. Once you write down what letter each marking stands for, the answer should reveal itself. But because it's unclear which markings represent commas and full stops, it's hard to figure out what the message means, even if you deciphered the letters.

If you read the markings with perfect punctuation, it's still confusing, since the clues are awful. One hint reads, "Wait for time to pass twice." which means you're meant to stand still for two minutes. (Why does unsolvable puzzles always involve standing still??) Considering how difficult it is to reach this area and decode these markings, it would've been nice if the instructions were clearer.

This section endured so much scrutiny from the fanbase, Game Freak had the braille simplified when the updated version, Pokemon Emerald, was released.


7. Unlocking Liu Kang - Mortal Kombat: Deception

Liu Kang
NetherRealm Studios

Mortal Kombat: Deception was the first instalment in the franchise to have an open-world mode called Konquest. Upon your travels, you'll find treasure chests dotted around each world, which contain art, music, money, outfits, and most importantly, playable characters.

However, the caskets containing kombatants are much tougher to find, since they only exist for a few seconds per day. Even if you know precisely where one of these chests are, it will only be there at a specific time. If you don't open the case within that timeframe, you'll need to try again the following day. You can meditate to speed up time to avoid waiting around for hours, but it's still a very annoying method to unlock characters.

So how do you find out when and where these caskets appear?

And the short answer is - you don't. You are given no clues on the location or time of these chests appearing, meaning most players will find them by being at the right place at the right time, rather than relying on deduction or skill.

But because Liu Kang is the combatant that players desired the most, the developers deliberately made the casket to unlock him exceptionally difficult to find. You see, his chest doesn't appear once per day - it appears... once per week! The chances of stumbling upon that exact spot at the exact second on the right day is one in a million.


6. The Peanuts - Grim Fandango

grim fandango
LucasArts

Like most adventure games, Grim Fandango doesn't take place in a world shaped by logic. To reach The Petrified Forest, you need to steal a seagull's eggs. If you want the correct numbers for the ticket printer to come up, you'll need to track down a picture of cats.

And if you're looking for rocket fuel, you better stock up on peanuts because... we all know how combustible peanuts are... apparently.

Even if you somehow drew this conclusion, turning peanuts into fuel is not straightforward. You need to insert these munchable legumes inside a mug before placing it beside the toaster. You then have to put oily rags inside the toaster, causing it to catch on fire.

When the mechanic dashes in, he'll try to put the flames out with a fire extinguisher. But as every science teacher in the world knows, this chemical reaction magically transforms the flammable nuts into rocket fuel.

Look, we all know Grim Fandango is regarded as among the most underrated point-and-click titles of all time. But while performing head-scratchers like this, you can't help screaming, "How was I meant to figure that out?"


5. Crossword – The Samaritan Paradox

Samaritan Paradox
Faravid Interactive

The Samaritan Paradox follows a cryptologist called Ord investigating the apparent suicide of author, Jonathan Bergwall. Throughout the case, Ord is hounded by many questions. Did Bergwall actually kill himself? Does his daughter know more than she's letting on?

And most importantly, how was the player expected to solve that frickin' crossword section? During your investigation, you'll come across a boat owner who will help with the case, but only after he completes his crossword. (Not sure why that takes priority.)

After Ord helps with the crossword, he notices there's only one clue left - the detective's name from Bergwall’s novels. Naturally, the most logical thing to do is to explore the most likely places where Bergwall's books would be.

But if you investigate the library or the writer's office, you'll find zip. The only place you can find the book is... a random pub. If you go up to the hunched over customer by the table, you'll notice he's reading the book you were looking for. (Because it's impossible to see what this NPC is reading, most players discover this by accident.)

But you're not done! To make this section more innane, this guy won't show you his copy unless you give him money, (but only the specific coins you find in the bar's couch). After he steps away from his table to use the coins for the jukebox, you can swipe his book and finally learn the character's name.

Was it worth it? Not in the slightest.


4. The Heist - Escape From Monkey Island

Escape from monkey island
LucasArts

Because Monkey Island has had rock-hard puzzles since the franchise's inception, fans should be fully aware of what they're getting themselves into any time they play a new instalment.

Having said that, Escape from Monkey Island takes non-sensical mysteries to a whole new level. In this point-and-click adventure, Guybrush Threepwood is going about his business when he's framed for a bank heist.

So, you do what any rational person would do to prove their innocence - you locate a love letter hidden on the inside of a sealed manhole. (Based on this clue alone, you can tell this whole mission is going to be nuts.) You then insert the names in the love letter into a story as a means of currency to buy prosthetic limbs from a shop owner. (Yes, you read that correctly.)

If you received the correct prosthetics, you can place them where the manhole was, and use it as a trampoline to twang yourself onto the bank's roof. Using the other prosthetics while inside the bank, you can find the means to clear your name.

This entire section is so unnecessarily complex, you’ll probably forget halfway through why you are collecting prosthetics or digging around manholes in the first place.


3. ...Pretty Much Everything - Shadow Of The Beast II

Shadow of the Beasts II
Psygnosis

In the hands of a master, you can complete Shadow of the Beast II in under 30 minutes. But the road to mastering this platformer is long, treacherous, and deeply unfair.

In the beginning, you’ll come across two levers. By pulling one, the elevator will lower, allowing you to continue. By pulling the other, you’ll fall to your death.

So, if you pull the wrong lever, you can just try the other one next time, right?

Unfortunately, the correct lever is randomized. To avoid perishing at this point upon every playthrough, you need to ask a random character which lever is safe. But since every NPC is programmed with tons of responses, you can be there forever, trying to make him say something informative.

Another moment of great contention is the bridge monster. As soon as this beast lumbers towards you, you'll instinctively attack him until he dies. If you do that, congratulations. You just lost the game!

You were supposed to lure this monster towards you, until his weight caused the bridge to cave in. By jumping into the hole, you can continue in your journey. Since there's no way you can know this, first-time players will slay this creature, killing their progress.

Then, there's that infernal snail. This overgrown mollusc stops you dead unless you give him 36 coins (which happens to be every coin in the game). Because it's never implied that currency is important, you'll probably won't have enough cash.

If you thought you can backtrack and collect the money, Mr. Snail doesn't give you the option. If you are one coin short, you can't go any further.

As ludicrous as these "puzzles" are, what makes them more infuriating is how the game doesn't tell you how to solve them until AFTER it's too late to do so!


2. The Broken Puzzle – Destiny 2

Destiny 2
Bungie

Sometimes, you'll come across a puzzle in a game that's so preposterously difficult, you genuinely think it's unsolvable.

But in the case of Destiny 2, the developers actually created an impossible-to-solve cipher by accident! In the Season of the Forge expansion, the player must crack a seven-level code, which involves blasting symbols, each of which only becomes visible while using a specific weapon. If you shoot the wrong spot or use the wrong weapon, you'll get swarmed by enemies.

Wanting to provide a real challenge for hard-core players, Bungie kept the hints to a minimum. Although the developers didn't expect anyone to solve it straight away, they thought it was peculiar when they realised a grand total of ZERO people had completed this section.

Upon investigation, they discovered the issue - the hint for the last segment of the cipher... wasn't in the game! Because of this, nobody had a clue how to get past this room.

After learning of this blunder, Bungie uploaded a new hint online to complete the last section. After that, it only took 42 minutes for someone to solve it.


1. Think Backwards – King’s Quest

Kings quest
Sierra

There are few gaming franchises with more meddling puzzles than the King's Quest series. Every instalment is chockfull of indecipherable riddles, brutal conundrums, and time-consuming mind-bogglers.

But the original entry probably has the most confounding puzzle in all of gaming. As you navigate through the forest, you'll come across the gnome, Rumpelstilskin. He tells you he will aid you in your adventure, but only if you guess his name.

So, when you input "Rumpelstilkin" and are alerted it's incorrect, you'll assume you misspelt it. (This is understandable since there's five official ways to spell it.)

But no matter what way you spell it, you're told it's wrong. So, what gives?

Well, if you were paying attention, you'll remember the imp said he was from a backwards realm. He also mentions that "sometimes, it's wise to think backwards." If you noticed these hints, you'll rationalise the answer must be his name written backwards - Nikslitslepumr.

So, when you triumphantly insert this name, you are told... it's wrong... again. By this point, you do what everyone does - give up and check the answer online.

And that's when you find the horrifying truth. It turns out the "think backwards" hint wasn't exactly true. You don’t reverse the letters – you invert them, so A becomes Z, B becomes Y, C becomes X, etc.

By doing so, “Rumpelstilskin” becomes “lfnkovhgroghprm” (which totally rolls off the tongue). So, after you input this code, you are free to carry on.

However, few people have played beyond this section, since they become so infuriated by the absurdity of this "puzzle", they never bothered picking up King's Quest ever again.


Watch Next


Contributor

James Egan has been with Whatculture for five years and prominently works on Horror, Film, and Video Games. He's written over 80 books including 1000 Facts about Horror Movies Vol. 1-3 1000 Facts about The Greatest Films Ever Made Vol. 1-3 1000 Facts about Video Games Vol. 1-3 1000 Facts About James Bond 1000 Facts About TV Shows