10 Video Games So Bad They KILLED OTHER GAMES

Avengers ruined whatever momentum that Guardians of the Galaxy might have had.

avengers guardians of the galaxy
Square Enix

The fallout of a bad game can be akin to a bomb going off, with shockwaves spreading across months or even years after it is released. God knows Sonic fans are very tired of having Sonic 06 constantly rubbed in their faces, even coming up on 20 years down the line, but that's just the effect some games have if they're truly terrible. 

Yes, getting a really bad game can result in far worse than annoying internet memes - it can actually result in other games getting caught up in the blast. 

This is a rare occurrence, but it does sprout up every now and then. Games that bomb so hard that they either impact the success of a follow-up, cause a publisher to lose faith in the IP, order sequel development to cease, or in the worst cases, kill off the studio that made it entirely.

These games are the worst examples. Games that sank like the titanic, and the games that they dragged down to the briny deep alongside. 

10. Dino Crisis 3

dino crisis 3
Capcom

The crash and burn of the Dino Crisis franchise is infamous among Capcom fans by this point. One of the all-time great self-destructions of a once-great cult classic game series, and it's all thanks to the broken slog that was Dino Crisis 3. 

The Dino Crisis series was Capcom's other survival horror series that ran concurrently with Resident Evil. While it had, and still has, its fans, it always struggled to establish its own identity besides "Resident Evil but now the pretty woman is shooting at dinosaurs". If it had worked, Dino Crisis 3's more sci-fi/action-heavy approach would have been the shot in the arm it needed to get mainstream attention. 

But that's not what happened, is it? 

Instead, Dino Crisis 3 was an unmitigated disaster. A clunky, janky example of ambition exceeding talent. Useless weapons, overpowered enemies, environments that are way too damn large, topped with easily one of the worst cameras in gaming history. 

Naturally, Dino Crisis 3 killed the franchise dead. We know very little about Dino Crisis 4, but we do know that it was in development around the time that 3 was released, only to be swiftly canceled thanks to the critical and financial thrashing that 3 received. 


9. Haze

haze game
Free Radical

Lackluster sales can hurt an entire studio's output going forward. Even if the game itself isn't that bad, if the sales tank hard enough, it can make publishers and distributors lose faith in a studio's ability to turn out consistent quality. Enter poor Free Radical Design and their 2008 bomb, Haze. 

Free Radical had been getting by up until then with the cult classic Timesplitters trilogy, with a long-awaited fourth entry ready to set off down the pipeline. But before they did that, Free Radical decided to release a new project dubbed Haze. Meant as the studio's answer to Halo, Haze embodied everything emblematic of first person shooters of the mid-2000s. Sadly, that wasn't enough, and Haze bombed HARD. 

Free Radical was in dire straits after that, and Timesplitters 4 was unable to get off the ground - Free Radical unable to secure a publisher for years. That was, until they were bought up by the current "oh god, them again" of the gaming news cycle, Embracer Group. 

At first this seemed like a godsend, but we all know how that song and dance goes by now, don't we? Last year, Embracer Group-owned published Plaion announced that Free Radical was officially shut down, taking Timesplitters 4 with it. 


8. Gollum

The Lord Of The Rings Gollum
Daedalic Entertainment/Nacon

Hello again, Embracer Group.

When Embracer studio Daedelic bought the rights to make a Lord of the Rings game starring Gollum, Embracer Group saw this as just the beginning of a long, lucrative relationship with the IP. 

This, like all of Embracer's plans to brute force their way into the industry, blew up right into their faces, as Gollum was universally decried as one of the worst games of its year. And the year before that. And probably the year before that, too. 

The horrific love child of Embracer's terrible management and Daedelic not having the skill or manpower to match their ambition, Gollum is almost indescribably bad. Another Middle-Earth game was released later that year, Return To Moria, but due to a combination of its own shortcomings and - ya know - being associated with Gollum, that game bombed as well. On top of that, any Middle-Earth projects that Embracer had in the pipeline were swiftly canceled after Gollum dropped. 

Gollum was a disaster from top to bottom. A decent-enough spin on the proven formula of LOTR games, bogged down by a studio ill-equipped to handle the task, and a publisher that doesn't know what it's doing. 


7. Epic Mickey 2: The Power of Two

Epic Mickey 2
Disney Interactive Studios

When your humble scribe was but a child, I first learned of Epic Mickey from an issue of Game Informer talking about it when it was soon to be released. Everything I read, from the story to the concept art and early screenshots, told kid me that this was going to be absolutely incredible. 

I wouldn't end up buying it, for reasons only kid me will ever understand. But in retrospect, at least I spared myself the disappointment of stepping on this train bound for nowhere.

The Epic Mickey series came to a screeching halt in 2012 with the release of Epic Mickey 2: The Power of Two. While not the worst thing in the world, the game did little to improve on the problems present in the first game. Add onto that some truly abysmal AI, and you get a game that was met with - at best - lukewarm critical and financial reception. 

But Junction Point studios were not to be deterred, as they were already planning the next game: Epic Donald. However, the reception to Epic Mickey 2, as well as shifting priorities for their games going forward, compelled Disney to pull the plug on the franchise. 

Maybe if Epic Mickey 2 was better, Disney would've held on, maybe not, but Epic Mickey 2 stopped a once-promising idea dead in its tracks. 


6. Marvel's Avengers

avengers game loot
Crystal Dynamics

No live-service siren song has led to rockier shores than that of Avengers. 

The whole idea was a mistake from minute one. Pitching an Avengers game at the height of the MCU's popularity, only to make it a live-service game is the kind of plan that only sounds good to the kinds of MBA losers who make all of the decisions nowadays. In practice, Avengers was an absolute and total disaster, backfiring on Square Enix and Marvel hard. So thick and pungent was the stench coming off this game that, unless it was Insomniac's Spider-Man, few were interested in other Marvel video game projects. 

This was what befell Eidos-Montreal's Guardians of the Galaxy. 

A superior game to Avengers in every single respect, GOTG was nonetheless caught up in the fallout, tanking in sales due to sheer association. 

Guardians of the Galaxy deserved so much better from the gaming public that shunned it before even playing, and an industry that set it up to fall.


5. Tomb Raider: Angel Of Darkness

tomb raider angel of darkness
Eidos

There was a brief time when the Tomb Raider franchise was slotted into the "yearly release" model. Being a model that's basically doomed to producing lower quality games, as the dev team has to cut corner after corner to make deadline, it came as no surprise that this era of Tomb Raider crashed and burned with Tomb Raider: Angel of Darkness. 

Widely considered one of the worst entries in the franchise by longtime fans, Angel of Darkness was the result of the yearly model and its incompatibility with the genre of game that Tomb Raider inhabits finally coming home to roost. Primitive controls, an abundance of glitches, and the lack of any checkpoint system for reasons unknown. Core Design were stretched incredibly thin during the development of AoD, and it shows in the final product. 

Angel of Darkness was very nearly the death knell of the entire franchise, with Core Design going under in the wake of its failure and taking all of the planned sequels to AoD with it. 

Angel of Darkness was meant to bring Tomb Raider into the PS2 era, but what it actually did was send the franchise's gravy train hurtling off the tracks and into a ravine. 


4. Sonic And The Black Knight

Sonic and the Black Knight
SEGA

The Sonic Storybook series was an interesting experiment on Sega's part. Dedicating an entire spinoff series to exploring how motion controls can be implemented into the Sonic formula, using the framework of Sonic exploring different public domain stories to justify it narratively.

And then Sonic and the Black Knight came out.

The thing is, Black Knight isn't even that bad. The story is one of the best in the franchise, the sword mechanics had a lot of promise, and that soundtrack is absolutely sublime. But unfortunately, it hadn't 100% nailed down the formula. Combat was too stiff, motion controls - while improved - were still pretty unwieldy, and the level design still needed work. And with this being Sega's "do everything once and then never ever again" era, that spelled the doom for this branch of the franchise. 

The worst part is that there was clearly interest, both in Sonic Team and the fans, for more. Shortly after Black Knight came out, a Facebook poll was posted by Sega asking what setting fans would like to see in the next Storybook entry - with Greek Mythology winning out. That poll has since been deleted, as the fate of the storybook series was decided. 


3. Ride To Hell: Retribution

Ride to Hell
Deep Silver

Commonly considered to be one of the worst games ever created, Ride to Hell: Retribution was released to universal disdain and mockery for, well, basically everything. It's genuinely difficult to think of one thing this game doesn't screw up. But you don't need me to tell you that when much bigger guys like Scott the Woz and Yahtzee have taken this thing to task. So let's get down to the point. 

Eutechnyx and Deep Silver wanted Ride to Hell to be a flagship franchise, in the same vein as Rockstar's Grand Theft Auto series. So in a classic case of running before you know how to walk, they had two spinoff games in the works: Ride to Hell: Route 666 and Ride to Hell Beatdown, one for Xbox Live and the other for Mobile. 

Needless to say, neither saw the light of day. Turns out when you release one of the worst games of all time, it somewhat kills audience's investment in seeing more.


2. Too Human

Too Human
Silicon Knights

How ironic that a game that Silicon Knights moved heaven and earth for years on end to get released would be the one to destroy them in the end. Maybe if their original deal with Nintendo back in the 90s had gone through, things might have been different, but that's not how the story played out. 

Too Human is considered one of the worst games of its generation for many reasons. From its stiff controls to its baffling combat system, to its nothing story. But the biggest mark of infamy to this game's name is that, as mentioned above, it killed Silicon Knights and every game they were making. 

Well, that wasn't just due to the game's lackluster sales, but because their partner - Epic Games - discovered that Silicon Knights had plagiarized multiple lines of their developer code. Naturally, Silicon Knights were dragged to court over this breach of their contract, and Epic won, ordering that all copies of both Too Human and SK's other big release at the time - X-Men Destiny - be destroyed. Silicon Knights closed shortly thereafter, taking all of the games they were working on down with them. 

Too Human killed its studio, the other games by that studio, and even itself. What else could possibly top it?


1. E.T.

Et Atari Game
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VakiwDmJ-lI

Nothing can really top a failure on the level of Too Human other than the game that damn near killed video games as a medium in its crib. 

1983 is a year that will forever live in infamy among gamers. Atari and the other studios that represented the first wave of video game development had flooded the market with a truly sinful glut of video games - the lion's share of which were not very good. Frankly, the whole thing was a powder keg waiting to blow, with every game released playing the part of someone lighting a cigar right next to it - one of them was bound to be The One. 

And that fate fell upon poor poor E.T. for the Atari 2600. 

With one poor sonuvagun forced to construct the whole thing in just a few weeks to meet the Christmas deadline, what came out that year feels inevitable, looking back. E.T. was such a poorly made, cobbled-together mess, that the fallout of its release crashed the entire market, killing multiple studios and games still in development. And those that were lucky to come out bombed hard financially. 

E.T. was the straw that broke the camel's back, and very nearly wiped out the entire industry. What else could top this list?


Watch Next


 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

John Tibbetts is a novelist in theory, a Whatculture contributor in practice, and a nerd all around who loves talking about movies, TV, anime, and video games more than he loves breathing. Which might be a problem in the long term, but eh, who can think that far ahead?