10 Video Games That Gut Punch You In Act One
Guys, calm down, the game just started!
Act one of a story is typically seen as the "safe" portion of the narrative. It's where things are set up, the characters and their dynamics are introduced and the world is explained in basic terms so you know what's going on, where it's going on and why.
It's usually then act two and three where the gut punches come in, seeing as how now that everything is set up and the characters are established, the writers can play around freely.
But some writers have a touch more confidence than that, quickly establishing the rules and then immediately breaking them just as you're starting to really internalize them. And some of those moments can really, well, gut-punch you. These are moments that appear in or cap off act one, either in the opening moments, or setting up the following two acts.
Sometimes it really is just better to start off with your all is lost moment. Makes things more expedient that way.
10. Worldwide Destruction - Saints Row IV
Hard to punch both the characters and audience in the gut harder than literally blowing up the planet.
Saints Row IV starts off by having the boss of the Saints turned president of the United States being abducted by an alien warlord and subjected to a virtual hellscape. But if it were that easy to keep the avatar of chaos and carnage known only as "the boss" down, we wouldn't have a franchise.
So of course the boss breaks free and tries to get back to Earth... and then the alien warlord blows the planet to hell, taking a huge chunk of the cast from Saints Row The Third with it.
This scene loses points for it mainly being played for laughs, but it's still the entire planet being blown up in the first act of the story. That's still a ballsy way to cap off the first segment of the story.
9. Sarah's Death - The Last Of Us
Zombie apocalypses were pretty well done by the time the first The Last Of Us came out, so it needed a good hook to make it feel fresh. And nothing says "the collapse of society and innocence", like playing as a little girl who is shot by a panicking soldier during a zombie apocalypse.
Starting off The Last Of Us from the POV of the young Sarah rather than her grizzled father was a stroke of genius to sell the true horror of a society falling apart all around you. This little detail just further sells the thick atmosphere of terror and dread, as everything Sarah has known her whole life falls at the seams in the span of an hour, before finally dying horrifically in the arms of her dad.
This is both a brutal punch to the gut for the player, who - let's face it - knew the kid was probably gonna die, but the death scene was still sold so well that knowing it was coming hardly mattered, as well as the perfect tone seller for the rest of the game. This is how The Last Of Us starts, the opening says, so imagine what's coming.
8. The Flood Return - Halo 3
Halo 3 gives poor Master Chief enough to test his blood pressure, what with the Earth being under siege by the Covenant, the UNSC being firmly on their back foot, and now he has to trust The Arbiter, the guy who's been trying to murder him up until this moment. The last thing John needs right now is a rematch with the eldritch Flood with the already ravaged Earth as the battlefield.
So anyway, the Flood crash land on Earth.
Just when it looks like the UNSC is about to get a leg up on the Covenant, the ship containing the last Flood hive crashes down onto Earth and immediately goes to work expanding across the planet. Things are already bad enough, so seeing this sends your heart crashing down into your stomach. It's about as perfect a "things just got somehow worse" moment as this series has done, and this is the same series that gave us Halo Reach.
7. Killing Toriel - Undertale
Undertale has one of the best opening levels in gaming history, telling and showing you everything that can be expected from this game - especially if you reset the game and try "certain parts" again.
The most notable characters you meet in Undertale's beginning are Flowey the Flower and Toriel, Guardian Of The Ruins, and the self-designated mother figure to the child protagonist.
But when you try to go out and see the world that Toriel is trying to keep you safe from, she finally demands that you prove that you can survive. And it's here where Undertale takes first-time players and slams a pickup truck into their gut by having them accidentally murder poor Goat Mom. This early in the game, first-timers are unlikely to truly understand how the kill/mercy system works, and thus will not be able to figure out how to keep from murdering Toriel.
Oh, and if you think of resetting the game and trying again, this time with a guide to help you through it? You CAN, but as soon as the fight is done, Flowey demonstrates this game's excellent memory by mocking you for what you did afterwards.
6. Nuclear War - Call Of Duty 4: Modern Warfare
Up until Modern Warfare, the Call Of Duty franchise was mainly known for being a WWII shooter series. But when that was bringing diminishing returns, they created Call Of Duty 4: Modern Warfare and effectively changed the gaming landscape forever.
And there's no moment that best encapsulates that than the infamous nuke scene.
Near the end of act 1, your character and a bunch of other army guys stage a raid on a terrorist cell because, well, they got a nuke, and that really shouldn't continue.
That's the kind of plan that really can only end badly though. Don't believe me? You don't have to, because the game proceeds to cut the cord holding up that little sword of Damocles, ending act 1 with a nuclear warhead going off and killing everyone.
Except for your character, of course, who has just barely enough time to crawl out of the wreckage of his helicopter and see the mushroom cloud climbing up into the sky before succumbing to his wounds - not to mention enough radiation to give someone superpowers - and dying.
5. Hero Slapdown - Xenoblade Chronicles
Xenoblade Chronicles is a nightmarishly long game, easily one of the longest JRPGs around, and considering that it's also the size of an MMO, it's a wonder players' Wiis didn't burst into flames as soon as it read the disc.
But I digress, the way the game telegraphs to you just how long a journey you have ahead of you is nothing less than soul-crushing. The first act of the game sees main characters Shulk and Reyn on their journey of vengeance, helping out a soldier named Sharla to save her people from the monstrous machines known only as The Mechon. This particular group of Mechon is stationed in a cavernous dungeon known as the Ether Mines, led by a creature known as Xord, whom Shulk and friends have to fight a total of three times before he finally goes down. Shulk emerges from the mines, the player feeling like the biggest badass in the world.
And then the main bad guy appears with a horde of Mechon identical to Xord, as if to simply say "oh you kill ONE of us and you think you're hot stuff? Cute."
This cutscene demonstrates just how much game is left to go before you reach the end, in perhaps the most terrifying way, as the player and Shulk are made to realize the true breadth of his mission.
4. Waking Sands Slaughter - Final Fantasy XIV
For many, the moment Final Fantasy XIV became what it is now to so many is at the end of A Realm Reborn where, major spoilers, you and the scions get royally screwed over by pretty much everyone and you have to go on the run from the cops.
But that's a long time from the game's start, so what keeps people playing through the infamously clunky beginning? Simple: the slaughter at the Waking Sands.
You, the warrior of light, return from your latest adventure to find all of your friends are either dead or captured by the Garlean Empire, who somehow found a way into your secret hideout without anyone inside or out noticing until it was too late. The only one left breathing is the tiny little pixie you picked up as a buddy in a previous quest, who then proceeds to die in your arms.
Your scribe has gotten a lot of his friends into this game, some with more difficulty than others, and it's this scene that got them to pay attention to what the story was actually doing. This is where Final Fantasy XIV becomes the black hole that sucks you in and never lets go that its fans prop it up as being.
3. Lost In Space - Mass Effect 2
No better way to start off a game where literally anyone can die than by launching the main character out into the cold unforgiving void of space!
You all know how Mass Effect 2 starts by now. After thwarting the Reapers in the first game, Shepard is sent out to hunt Geth because their ranting about the impending Lovecraftian squid machine god apocalypse was seen as, shall we say, politically inconvenient.
Shepard definitely knows all about things that are inconvenient though. Such as The Collectors - the enigmatic cronies of the aforementioned Lovecraftian squid machine gods - popping out of hyperspace and blasting the Normandy to hell and sending them hurtling out into another planet's orbit. That's DEFINITELY inconvenient.
It was also a good way to set up the theme of this game that will follow it all the way to its finale: no one, not even super space marine Shepard, is safe this time.
2. Family Drama - Bioshock
Bioshock has earned its rep for a lot of reasons, but particularly how it handles the build-up to its masterstroke of a twist.
When silent protagonist Jack is trapped in Andrew Ryan's perverse, self-indulgent monument to kissing Ayn Rand's feet known only as Rapture, the only one he - and thus you - can seemingly trust is the mysterious rebel Atlas. The thing is, though, Atlas has taken a good hard look at Rapture, and has decided that his little war is over and that technically, both sides lost because this city is about three large-ish explosions away from sinking even further into the reeking crevices of Davy Jones' Locker. So, he asks you if you would kindly see to helping his wife and son get out of this madhouse - promising to get you on the sub to the surface right after them.
So you make your way over to the sub where Atlas says his family is... and then Ryan blows it to hell along with them inside.
The reason the Would You Kindly twist works so damn well is that the game pulled a perfect red herring with this scene. You've just been through this genuinely traumatic experience with Atlas, turning what was once a detached guide into a sympathetic brother-in-arms. So when Atlas reveals that literally all of it was a lie, that there never was an Atlas, and that he was the enigmatic rival to Andrew Ryan, Fontaine, the whole time - it hits all the harder.
1. Sword Of Light's Corruption - Dragon Quest XI
The undisputed king of the act one gut punch, by a wide margin, is Dragon Quest XI: Echoes Of An Elusive Age.
Dragon Quest is known for being the comfort food of JRPGs: nowhere near as unhealthy as, say, McDonald's, but nothing too subversive or mind-blowing either. With each new instalment you know the gameplay will be refined, and the more problematic elements of the past will be addressed (one could write a thesis paper on the subtle, progressive subversions of harmful stereotypes that is Sylvando alone) but the classic JRPG elements will remain intact.
And then DQ11 ends Act 1 with the bad guy winning.
Act 1 of DQ11 is LONG, with even the most impatient player racking up 20 hours by the time they get the Luminary and his merry band of weirdos to Yggdrasil The World Tree, to retrieve the ultimate sword of light. Only for antagonist Jasper to attack the team and absolutely wipe the floor with them, paving the way for his master, The Dark Lord Mordegon - who had been possessing the body of the seemingly mad King Carnelian for the past 20 years. It was all part of a long game leading up to claiming the sword of light for himself, corrupting it, and bringing the world tree down on the planet, interrupting the cycle of life and death and bringing about the apocalypse for good measure.
Oh, but before any of that, just to add insult to injury, he takes away The Luminary's chosen one powers and then destroys them, leaving the heroes with literally zero means of opposing him. The World Tree falls to earth, killing untold amounts of people in the impact, with more to die after as the newly ascended Mordegon unleashes his horde on the world.
This game doesn't just end act 1 with a gut punch, it ends it with about 5 consecutive gut punches that leave you writhing on the ground in the fetal position. And all the game has to say to you after is "Did you think this would be easy? Get back up."