10 Worst Video Game Boss Battles Of 2018
They can't all be winners.
2018 has been a year of tremendous highs and abyssal lows for the video game industry. We've been graced by monumental releases like Red Dead Redemption 2, God of War, Hitman 2, and many others, but we’ve also been forced to slog through the tragedies of Fallout 76, Agony and Metal Gear Survive.
While gameplay, pacing, and storytelling used to be central to a game’s aspect, consumers today seem to more than ever factor a product’s monetization schemes and marketing into their judgement of a game’s overall quality.
That’s rightly so, as this generation has given rise to some downright shady activity, though it does mean that certain elements have become less relevant—Call of Duty dropped its campaign mode entirely, and that was far from the top criticism levelled at the release.
That said, we aren’t so far removed from the days in which single player experiences were the norm that we would allow the year’s worst boss fights to go completely ignored. With games media now drip-fed to us piece by piece and released in unfinished states, some villains come off as total afterthoughts, and these ten were particularly underwhelming.
10. Amaru - Shadow Of The Tomb Raider
Debuting in 2013 with the eponymously-titled Tomb Raider, Lara Croft’s recent reboot trilogy has gone over fairly well with series fans. Though it may borrow a bit too heavily from Naughty Dog’s Uncharted franchise in some places, these three games are by-and-large enjoyable.
That said, Square Enix’s tomb raiding triptic ends on a bit of a sour note. The lead up to the boss fight against Amaru in Shadow of the Tomb raider is suitably epic, but the fight itself is not.
Despite having been imbued with the power of an ancient Mayan deity, all Lara has to do to take this guy down is topple three totems and stab him with a dagger three times. Though it may well be a decent challenge on higher difficulties, this duel can be dealt with in all of five minutes on the more forgiving settings.
Though he boasts an AOE fire attack and shoots his bow once Lara gets out of range, Amaru is a pushover. The backup he calls in is less accurate than a stormtrooper with a faulty blaster, and players likely felt that the game’s ending was a bit of an anticlimax as a result of this woeful encounter.
9. The Shambler - Call Of Cthulhu
Had Cyanide Studios’ Call of Cthulhu been developed twenty years earlier, it likely would have been a point-and-click puzzle game. However, since that particular genre hasn’t been popular since Lucasarts gave up on it back in the late 1990’s, Cyanide had to settle for a gimped version of the Penumbra games.
That’s not to say that Call of Cthulhu is a bad title, it just feels like it doesn’t quite know what kind of game it wants to be. The first third of the game, for example, is comprised entirely of dialogue trees and light puzzles until it suddenly hits the player with an out-of-left-field boss fight.
Not only does the game not communicate how the boss is to be beaten, it doesn’t even state that the Shambler can’t be attacked directly at all. Instead, players have to stealth around a shadowy art gallery in search of a very specific dagger which—for some unexplained reason—can be used to destroy the painting through which the horror entered our world.
The resulting fight is a desperate case of trial and error as Edward Peirce stumbles to get his hands on the correct weapon without getting eaten by a Lovecraftian horror in the process.
8. Lust - Darksiders III
The long-awaited return of the Darksiders series hasn’t exactly gone the way fans expected. The title is a departure from the other two games in that, rather than taking heavy inspiration from Nintendo’s The Legend of Zelda games, it unabashedly apes the Dark Souls gameplay loop.
Though that isn’t inherently a bad thing, Darksiders III doesn’t offer the same bleak charm as the aforementioned RPG, and the boss fights are nowhere near as memorable. There are sixteen boss encounters in total, though some aren’t mandatory.
Unlike Dark Souls, most of the game’s bosses are humanoid figures around the same size as the player character. With most of the intimidation factor already gone, Lust was, in particular, really underwhelming.
Visually bland and unnecessarily wordy, she offers an uninspired fight which can at best be unfavorably compared to Dark Souls’ infamous Ornstein And Smough fight once Archangel Usiel joins the fray.
Contained entirely in a tiny arena and beaten in all of five minutes, this encounter could have been so much more interesting. Lust may be a relatively early boss, but that doesn’t mean she has to be a complete pushover.
7. Kingpin - Spider-Man
This PS4-exclusive title may be a solid contender for game of the year, but that doesn’t mean it is totally flawless. While it offers a spidey experience the likes of which fans haven’t seen since 2004’s Spider-Man 2, it falters slightly in a few areas.
While most of the game’s bosses are amazing in terms of both design and actual gameplay, the first boss encounter is a bit of a letdown. For starters, Kingpin is far from the most interesting Spider-Man villain, though Insomniac Games didn’t necessarily have to pull out all the stops for the first big fight.
Though technically a battle drawn out over three different phases, this part of the game can be over with in as little as a few minutes. Simply web up his turrets, and then fling some projectiles at him while throwing a few punches and kicks, and it’s over.
In the comics, Kingpin is sort of like Batman’s Joker in that he’s a criminal mastermind better at orchestrating his plans from behind closed doors than actually fighting (in some incarnations, at least). He deserves respect for going toe-to-toe against the Wall Crawler himself, but he’s far too easy nonetheless.
6. Forgotten Gaian - Death's Gambit
Speaking of games that desperately want to be Dark Souls, Death’s Gambit is a 2D action platformer that borrows nearly all of its gameplay and stylistic concepts from FromSoftware's ultra-difficult RPG. The only difference is that Death’s Gambit wasn’t afraid to show its lighthearted side from time to time.
The most crucial element of any Souls-inspired game would have to be the boss encounters; if they don’t meet the players expectations, then nothing will. Unfortunately, though Death’s Gambit does put forward some interesting ideas in that regard, many of the fights miss the mark.
Most underwhelming of all would have to be the Forgotten Gaian fight. While large in scale, it’s more annoying than challenging. Most of the encounter’s issues come from the fact that the camera constantly pans in and out in an attempt to capture the stone giant’s size, but it’s more distracting than it needs to be.
What’s more, the fight is actually against Ione, with the Gaian serving as a strange middleman. Half of the fight consists of wantonly smashing at its foot in an effort to bring Ione into striking range, which makes large chunks of the fight feel inconsequential and unnecessary.
5. The Horned One - Ni No Kuni 2: Revenant Kingdom
Ni No Kuni: Dominion of the Dark Djinn was an instant classic when it came out for the PS3 back in 2011, though most seem to have forgotten that this title was actually an enhanced port of a 2010 Nintendo DS exclusive. Eight years have gone by since its first release, and those original games remain as charming as ever.
2018’s Ni No Kuni 2: Revenant Kingdom is perhaps a little less captivating than its predecessor, but that relative consensus may have been the result of some seriously inflated expectations. Revenant Kingdom is a great game, but it simply isn’t quite as enchanting as the series’ first outing.
The worst aspect of the experience was by far the final boss fight against The Horned One. While plugging away at a boss for forty five minutes is pretty standard fare for most games in the genre, this overly-long fight is hindered by the game’s focus on real-time melee attacks.
The pseudo-Pokémon styled combat system seen in the first game is totally gone, and in its place is an underwhelming hack-and-slash affair. The game’s finale winds up being a monotonous button-mashing encounter, and the series is all the worse for it, unfortunately.
4. Fergal - Vampyr
Though an ambitious AA title published by Focus Interactive in June of this year, Vampyr suffered from some major issues at launch. The most notable problem stemmed from the fact that, though the game challenged players to risk killing some quest givers in exchange for upgrades and XP, there was no reason to do so because the gameplay was much too easy.
This has since been amended via a patch, but that doesn’t change the fact that, on the standard difficulty setting, most of the game’s bosses are outrageously meak. The obvious standout of the bunch being the Incredible Hulk/Vampire combo Fergal, who seems to talk the talk but was otherwise totally unintimidating.
There is very little to distinguish this boss encounter from any of the game’s regular enemies, and some common NPCs encountered on the streets of Whitechapel are vastly more threatening. Built up to be some sort of unstoppable force with much more vampiric experience than the player, this enemy crumbles like a pile of dry leaves.
Players who built there character around stealth instead of all-out combat may find this fight slightly more difficult, but, either way, Fergal doesn’t live up to the hype.
3. Wanderer Seth - Metal Gear Survive
Metal Gear lore is about as impenetrable as it could possibly be for newcomers, and, for those with little to no experience with the franchise, the goings-on in Metal Gear Survive are a little too convoluted to understand. The game is also so woefully terrible that few really care about the plot to being with.
Wanderer Seth is the only real mandatory boss encounter found in Metal Gear Survive, and rightly so—open-world survival crafting games aren’t typically known for their boss battles. With that in mind, it would have been a better move on Konami’s part to leave this one on the cutting room floor.
Hiding behind cover and plinking away at Seth just isn’t fun at all. What’s worse, the AI is absolutely brain dead, and he can frequently be found firing in the complete opposite direction of the player. Nobody wants to have to stop and craft things while fighting a boss in MGS, either, and yet here we are.
It’s upsetting to see what has become of the Metal Gear franchise. The series used to be rife with great bosses like The Sorrow, the End, or Psycho Mantis. Alas, Kojima has moved on, and times have changed.
2. Liu Bei - Dynasty Warriors IX
The final boss fight of the fantastically terrible Dynasty Warriors IX, Liu Bei is more a victim of the game’s overall flaws than an underwhelming outlier in an otherwise polished experience. The Dynasty Warriors series has always been known for its epic army-against-army boss encounters, yet this entry just falls flat.
One of the games most significant issues is that, though the developers shoehorned in an open world environment, very little attention is paid to world-building or storytelling. Most bosses are encountered without any real buildup or emotional investment, and they just end up feeling bland.
What’s worse is the downright atrocious English voice acting present in the title. The series has long been infamous for hoaky voicings, but this takes the cake by far. New players are highly advised to switch the the Japanese or Chinese dubs. Seriously, these actors speak like they memorized all of their lines phonetically.
Perhaps it is simply time to recognize that the Dynasty Warriors franchise is better left in the past. Modern publishers are far too eager to simplify the gameplay to capture broader audiences or insert micro-transactions which further ruin the otherwise legendary reputation of the series.
1. Scorchbeast Queen - Fallout 76
Love it or hate it, there’s no doubt that Bethesda’s Fallout 76 has been one of the most controversial titles to release in the last twelve months. A series known for its intense despair and moody isolationism, 76 throws all of that out the window in favor of buddy-centric survival co-op. Yay.
Yet, the Scorched Earth quest may be one of the most significant in the game as it’s one of the few quests which directly incentivises co-operative mission engagement. Reclaimers will need to be in groups of at least eight or ten to have a chance against this thing, something that becomes more of a hindrance during easier quests.
The boss fight itself, however, is pretty annoying. The issue is that, while the Scorchbeast Queen herself isn’t all that tough, there are so many extra enemies in the area that a majority of the encounter is spent quelling the rabble rather than fighting the beast herself. Plus, only Todd will know if the server or game will crash mid-fight, which is always sure to enthrall frustrated players. The Creation Engine is definitely good for another ten years, Bethesda, don’t worry about it.