11 Influential Video Games That Have Aged Horribly

Time and tide wait for no game, not even the most influential.

Goldeneye 007
Rare

The video games industry is one that has grown from nothing to one of the most profitable entertainment industries in the world over the span of five short decades.

As a result, there are a number of games in living memory that have been dubbed landmark titles; whether for their innovative gameplay, for creating a new sub-genre, or for offering a fresh new take on an existing format, and we've all got a favourite that we remember fondly for one reason or another.

But what happens when you pull out your favourite childhood trend-setter, only to realise that playing it now is more of a chore than you ever remembered?

It's undoubtedly a result of the progress that these games themselves helped usher in, but there's something profoundly upsetting about realising a game that helped shape modern gaming now feels like little more than an unplayable mess of poor visuals and cheesy dialogue, or a classic title simply being overshadowed by its own sequels.

Before we start the list, it's probably worth prefacing the entire thing with a gentle reminder that each and every one of these games is a veteran of the industry and deserves our utmost respect.

That said, let's take a closer look at the ways in which these influential titles have aged horribly, shall we?

11. Mass Effect

Mass effect
Bioware

Mass Effect was the spark that lit a wave of renewed interest in sci-fi and role-playing games, and it did so with a tightly-packed story in a huge, open galaxy filled with choices.

Giving players the choice between not only their style of gameplay but also the personality of the player character was something that encouraged multiple playthroughs, and if you enjoyed playing Mass Effect at release, it probably wouldn't be hard to tempt you to pick it up again today.

Once you do, however, you'll be faced with a game much less polished than you remember it being.

The game's UI is not particularly user-friendly, and the inventory system in particular is difficult to navigate and understand. The combat feels unwieldy and infuriatingly less fluid than that of its sequels.

Therein lies Mass Effect's problem: The amount of effort that went into refining its strengths for the follow-up was so spot-on that it actually made the first game something of a slog to get through in retrospect.

While it's not the worst problem for a game to have, it certainly make replaying this monumental title a dull and frustrating endeavour.


10. Tomb Raider

tomb raider original
Eidos Interactive

Tomb Raider broke the mould in more ways than one.

First off, it gave us one of gaming's first (and most successful) female protagonists. It also laughed at the notion that platforming games should be colourful, childish affairs, instead opting to blend platforming with puzzles and a healthy dose of gunplay for good measure.

The result was wildly successful that was highly praised for its blending of multiple gameplay elements and (at the time, at least) groundbreaking graphics.

Playing it back today is an interesting experience.

Tomb Raider is old enough now that its controls feel awkward and clunky, and its graphics are a throwback to a time when polygonal humans were deemed realistic.

The worst part of all, though, is the way that Ms. Croft herself was treated in the game's promotional material. Objectified and made out to be some sort of sex symbol, video game's first real leading lady deserved so much better than the late '90s gave her.

Especially when it was in such stark contrast to the way she was portrayed in the game itself - giant triangular chest notwithstanding.


9. Gears Of War

Gears Of War Delta Squad
Microsoft

The game that launched a thousand rip-off cover shooters (including one that inexplicably belonged to the 50 Cent fictional universe), the first Gears of War was released in 2006.

Featuring an original, gritty narrative about a squad of troops battling against a subterranean enemy known as the Locust in the hopes of saving the human population of the planet Sera, Gears of War combined third-person action with immersive storytelling in a sci-fi setting, and people just couldn't get enough.

Gears of War soon blossomed into a popular franchise, spanning not just multiple video games but a number of books and comics too.

Gears of War holds up well in terms of gameplay, but being a product of the mid-'00s, there are a few issues with the narrative that don't come off too well in today's landscape.

Firstly, all of the game's main characters are gruff, oversized tough guys so musclebound that it's a wonder any of them can even get behind the cover they so famously shoot from. Secondly, they all come off as so two-dimensional that it takes all of the humanity out of the story.

If it were released today, the game would be dubbed a massive narrative misfire, something which is all too obvious when you replay the iconic title.


8. Super Mario Kart

Super Mario Kart Title Screen
Nintendo

Back in the day, Mario Mario was just an unassuming plumber with a ridiculous name recruited to help save a kidnapped princess.

Fast forward a little, and he's a gaming icon who has competed in the Olympics (not the real ones), played golf, tennis, and found some fame on the racing circuit as a world-class kart driver.

If you spent the intervening time in a coma, you'd be understandably confused as to how this small mustachioed Italian man who rarely changes his clothes has achieved such heights of success.

It all started with Super Mario Kart.

Taking the characters from a popular platformer and injecting them into a racing game wasn't the norm back in 1992, but Nintendo did it anyway.

The result was a craze that has never stopped growing, Super Mario Kart marked the beginning of the Mario franchise's expansion, something that's still going strong today.

However, if you go back to play the title where it all began, you're in for a disappointing time. Compared to its more recent counterparts, Super Mario Kart is dull and lacks many of the features of gameplay that the series has adopted since.

You're much better off starting with Mario Kart 64 and working your way forwards from there.


7. The Elder Scrolls III: Morrowind

Elder Scrolls Morrowind
Bethesda

Influential: Brought open-world fantasy into mainstream gaming in a less child-like setting.

Horrible: visually unimpressive, with a less intuitive control scheme and inventory/journal system than more recent titles in the franchise that makes playing it incredibly frustrating.

The Elder Scrolls III: Morrowind brought the series into the modern era of gaming, and showed us exactly what a fantasy RPG could look like: open, filled with quests and NPCs and lore that could easily consume your every waking thought if you were to allow yourself to fall into it.

Morrowind is still quoted as an inspiration for many modern fantasy titles, and the formula that Bethesda struck back in 2002 is still serving them well today.

The problem is, when you pick it up today, Morrowind isn't an easy experience. It feels less smooth that it once did, and its visuals have since become incredibly dated and unimpressive.

Maybe we've just been spoiled by the added levels of freedom and tweaks to basic gameplay offered by later titles, but Morrowind just doesn't feel as user-friendly as it once did, which is incredibly frustrating for fans of Oblivion and Skyrim going back for a look at where the franchise really took off.


6. GoldenEye 007

GoldenEye 007 Aztec Level
Rare

Ask anyone who was alive in the '90s what the best shooter of the decade was and odds are you'll soon find yourself listening to them rant about their friend who always insisted on playing Oddjob.

There's simply no question that Goldeneye was instrumental in building the popularity of the FPS genre, and it's remembered fondly by all those who played it growing up.

Not only did Goldeneye offer a great FPS story based on the movie of the same name, but it gave us endless hours of fun playing split-screen multiplayer engaged in bloody deathmatches with our friends and loved ones, and cultivated a love of multiplayer gaming in a generation of impressionable youths.

That said, attempting to play it again now will leave you feeling more dissatisfied than you'd expect.

After spending years playing well-polished shooters like COD and Battlefield, Goldeneye controls like a rusted tank recently discovered at the bottom of the ocean. Add to this the fact that online multiplayer has rendered split-screen entirely obsolete, and screen-watching will no longer be a mere annoyance but an infuriating throwback to the days of not being able to trust anyone.

As sad as it may seem, it's probably best to leave Goldeneye in the past, if only to preserve your treasured memories of this groundbreaking title.


5. Resident Evil

Resident Evil
Capcom

Resident Evil is one of the most well known franchises in all of gaming.

While its reputation has taken several blows over the years, it always seems to bounce back, and the franchise remains to be one of Capcom's biggest earners.

The game that started it all, Resident Evil, began a behemoth multimedia franchise that was able to capitalise on our collective obsession with a zombie apocalypse, and it did it with a game so infamously wonky that it's been the butt of countless jokes since its 1996 release.

Following a small group of the Raccoon City Police Department known as S.T.A.R.S., the game takes place in the Spencer Mansion as they investigate a number of bizarre cannibalistic murders.

What seemed a little odd in the mid-'90s has become laughable today, and playing through a game filled with a ridiculous amount of strange voice acting is certainly good for a few chuckles. Or, it would be, if Resident Evil wasn't so frustrating.

The game's camera is notoriously uncooperative with players, and seeing what you're actually doing while navigating the rooms and hallways of the mansion is an entirely thankless task.

Still, playing through the game just to hear yourself referred to as "the master of unlocking" is more than worth it. Thanks, Barry.


4. Shenmue

SHENMUE game
Sega

While Shenmue's influence might not be the most noticeable on this list, you'll find that elements of it have permeated into all of recent years' most successful titles.

Praised by critics for its environmental detail, open and interactive game world, day/night and weather systems, varied minigames and NPCs' daily routines, Shenmue took realism in video games to new heights, and it's remained well loved ever since.

Shenmue's charm lies in the mingling of each of these little realities, and while those who loved it really loved it, there were still many that failed to see its charm.

While many of the elements that made Shenmue such an immersive experience have since become standards of the industry, playing it back through today it feels like little more than an odd mix of minigames and extensive quick time events.

After changing our expectations of how games should approach realism, Shenmue was sadly hung out to dry, and its most defining features now struggle to stand out among all the titles that it inspired.


3. Tony Hawk's Pro Skater

Tony Hawks Pro Skater
Activision

Another entry that might sting for children of the '90s. There are two undying truths about the first installment in the Tony Hawk franchise, and they are:

1) No game did more for bringing skater culture into the mainstream,

and 2) no iconic sports game has ever aged as badly.

While the first THPS game started an absolute craze for all things radical, its practically impossible to wring any enjoyment from the original game when played today.

The problem, once again, is that the game's sequels made so many improvements to the original's gameplay that it's not easy to go back to skating before manuals, reverts, spine transfers or any of those other Tony Hawk staples that smoothed out the kinks as the years wore on.

However, he issues with the way that THPS has aged were addressed in the recent remaster, retroactively adding in the tricks that were absent from the first two games.

Tony Hawk's Pro Skater was a phenomenal title in more ways than one, though. It boasted an absolutely incredible soundtrack of music from the alternative scene, and introduced an entire generation of children to music they may otherwise never have heard. For that, Mr. Hawk, we thank you.


2. GTA III

GTA III
Rockstar

Few games are more iconic than Grand Theft Auto III.

Introducing audiences to the concept of open-world, sandbox gameplay alone was enough to cement GTA III's place in history, but many also look back fondly on the hours of their childhood spent aimlessly mowing down pedestrians.

Taking the GTA franchise into the third dimension, GTA III marked a change in the series by taking a more narrative-heavy approach, something which the series is still doing today.

The problem though, is that in the years since its 2001 release, GTA III has aged horribly. While the most obvious way that this is the case would be visually, that's also the most understandable, with the capabilities of consoles having come a remarkably long way in that short space of time.

The worst offender is actually the game's lack of depth. Now the novelty of committing crimes in 3D has worn off, it's hard to ignore how paper-thin the game's characters are, and there's little emotional weight carried by anything in the game, especially when compared to the colourful and memorable characters introduced to us in Vice City just one short year later.

Though GTA III marked the first 3D game in the series, playing it today reveals it to be still a little too 2-dimensional.


1. Crysis

Crysis pc
Crytek

At time of release, Crysis was everywhere.

Its name quickly became synonymous with cutting-edge visuals and gameplay, and was hailed as the beginning of the end for all other shooters.

While that strange prophecy never came true, it did spur other developers on, leading to the landscape of video games taking something of a leap forwards, and whether you were a fan of Crysis or not, we all owe something to the unprecedented amount of hype around the 2007 FPS.

However, despite its graphical prestige, Crysis simply doesn't play as well today. Even from the remaster, there are AI issues and gameplay mechanics that just feel outdated and overplayed.

Good-looking or not, games have come a long way since Crysis was released, and most of those are much more than skin deep.

It's a shame, because Crysis' remaster should have been a cause for much celebration, but instead it left many players simply scratching their heads at how old it made them feel.


Contributor
Contributor

Antisocial nerd that spends a lot of time stringing words together. Once tried unsuccessfully to tame a crow.