11 Things We Miss From Final Fantasy
If these returned, our Fantasies would Finally come true.
A new Final Fantasy game is automatically one of the most hotly anticipated on the market, and not without good reason. Hironobu Sakaguchi's last ditch effort to make a mark on the industry in 1987 resulted in a long-running franchise that has carved out a reputation for itself as one of the most stellar in the whole business.
The first nine games in the series were exemplary, but now there's a danger that it is starting to turn the way of Sonic. Though the past few Final Fantasies have been by no means bad, there's the distinct feeling that the games just aren't what they used to be. Betraying their roots with innovative new gimmicks has proved largely detrimental, and watering the brand down by insisting on milking every last drop out of it has not helped. Even the most ardent FF fan is beginning to lose confidence.
Taking a long-running franchise down a different path isn't necessarily a bad thing - there are some that could greatly benefit by this (Pokémon, perhaps?). However, methodically dismantling a series of what once made it great is never wise. Yes, today's Final Fantasy titles have all the artefacts of the games' legacy - chocobos, moogles, fancy summons, airships, and so on. But little by little, they've lost the fundamentals that made them so great in the first place.
Playing the most recent Final Fantasy XV demo, and judging by early videos of the Final Fantasy VII remake, it's hard not to worry that the series is set to lose even more of the crucial elements that once made it such a pleasure. The fact that something as simple as remaking one of the most popular games of all time - simply a case of the same thing with a new lick of paint - has resulted in a completely new episodic game of an entirely different genre is cause for alarm.
You can plaster all the chocobos and moogles you like into a generic s*** JRPG and it wouldn't suddenly transform it into a good Final Fantasy title; it'd remain a s**t JRPG, albeit with a Final Fantasy theme. Leave the chocobos and moogles out, but provide it with those integral features that once defined the series, and you get a wonderful game (also known as Bravely Default).
So what are modern Final Fantasy titles lacking which once made the series such a hallmark of quality? Here're eleven to get you started...
11. Random Battles
Nostalgia can do funny things to a person. The passage of time causes us to reflect fondly on things we once greatly disliked. Like school, or Moira Stewart. It's easy to wistfully yearn for those carefree 9am-3pm days with little to worry about besides getting the lurgy from touching a member of the opposite sex. Childhood, eh?
How we forget how much these things actually annoyed us. Going to school was just an impediment to staying home and playing games, and the last thing we wanted to do when we got in was sit and watch the news, with Stewart detailing the latest emergence in the Bosnian War in her authoritative, flat tone.
No, we wanted to rush upstairs, turn our SNES/PlayStation on, and settle in for a night of Final Fantasy. And with only a few hours before bed time, random battles represented nothing but a hindrance to our progress.
So why do we miss them now? Is it merely a function of a longing for the heady days of childhood?
Partly. But random encounters actually had their benefits. The system of enemies roaming the map introduced in Final Fantasy XII completely changed the way the game played; encounters were now on polar ends of the spectrum - either entirely avoidable or annoyingly obligatory. Our entire path through a dungeon was essentially pre-determined, with no possibility of lucking out and bypassing a battle whilst there was a roaming monster at the end of every corridor.
Final Fantasy XIII made the problem even more egregious, as the set pattern of foes rendered grinding an even more tedious chore. It's a strange state of affairs when one longs for that crushing sense of disappointment as the battle sting hits five metres from a save point.
10. Substantial Characters
By 'substantial', we're talking more layered than a stripper on the Copacabana. Give us some reason to care about the characters other than one primary motivation. Make them feel like real people. Develop them throughout the course of the game. It really is a remarkably simple concept, but one entirely lost to modern day Final Fantasies.
Final Fantasy VI had none of the technological prowess or dazzling glamour of Final Fantasy XIII, released some fifteen years later, but the depth of its characters was practically bottomless in comparison. Despite having an enormous cast, all the characters had their own backstory, motivations, and reservations. Even secondary antagonists such as General Leo were sufficiently developed to the point that they remain memorable today.
Come on, admit it: you can't remember the name of a single villain in XIII. Heck, can you name any protagonists in XII? If the PS3 outing's characters had all the depth of a thimble, it's predecessor's had that of a saucer. I've known pigeons in my garden with more personality than the utterly forgettable Ivalice troupe.
It'd be easy to point to VIII and say that most of its playable characters were also lacking any true development. It's a fair point, but the entire focus of VIII was centred around a love story between Squall and Rinoa. The subtle building of their relationship and the gradual evolution of their personas actually means Final Fantasy VIII has some of the most accomplished character development to ever appear in a game (or at the very least, a JRPG). So take that.
9. A World Map
Of all the complaints about modern games, the loudest and most frequent is that they have become increasingly diluted. Piece by piece, genres have been stripped of all the features that once made them so appealing, as the push for Hollywood production values - and the resultant production costs - have put actual content at a premium.
RPGs in particular have suffered, and especially Final Fantasy. One of the most thrilling aspects of any of the early games in the series was stepping out onto the game's map for the first time, presented with a vast world to explore. The sensation was later replicated as different modes of transport became available, from submarines to cars to airships, as gradually more of the uncharted globe opened up.
The map served important narrative purposes also; nothing can match the sensation of liberation than stepping out of Midgar for the first time, or the thrill of breaking free from Figaro to the wider world on the back of a chocobo.
Technical limitations - as well as dubious storyline demands - abolished the map for Final Fantasy X, as the player essentially walked in a straight line from the most southern tip of Spira to the most northern. Imagine walking from Patagonia to Alaska. That was Final Fantasy X. Apparently that's more realistic than having an oversized representative avatar walking around a globe.
An airship was eventually made available, but instead of having the freedom to explore the watery world, players instead could only choose locations from a menu. Thrilling.
Though Final Fantasies XII and XIII both offered big open plains to explore, ironically the games felt smaller due to a lack of world map. The Final Fantasy VII remake also looks set to dispense with this great tradition from the series - presumably because the developers are embarrassed about having a giant Cloud avatar roam the planet, aesthetically incongruous with the rest of their 'stylish' reimagining.
8. Nobuo Uematsu
Any discussion of video game music is incomplete without the name of Nobuo Uematsu. His scores for the Final Fantasy series stand out as some of the most beloved in the history of video games, and alongside Koichi Sugiyama, no person has done more to bring game soundtracks into the mainstream.
After composing the first nine games in the franchise alone, Uematsu was finally afforded assistance for the tenth iteration. For many, the distinct East-Asian inspired soundtrack lacked the melodic quality of previous Final Fantasies, with many pointing the finger towards the new collaborators.
After providing a handful of tracks for XI, Uematsu left the company to form his own venture. The reasons were relatively prosaic; Uematsu simply did not wish to move from Meguro closer to Square-Enix's new offices in Shinjuku. One of his Final Fantasy X protégés, Masashi Hamauzu, assumed the position of lead composer, but for many nobody could adequately replace Uematsu.
Whilst by no means bad, Hamauzu's scores for the trilogy of Final Fantasy XIII lacked the memorable affability of the older titles in the series, with the new tunes possessing an edgier yet less easily digestible tone.
The good news for Final Fantasy XV is that industry veteran Yoko Shimomura is set to take over the musical reins, and if there is any one composer in the business who can match Uematsu's ability to write memorable, affecting melodies, it is her. Nevertheless, Uematsu's absence from the series just represents another piece of the lost magic.
7. Fixed Camera Locations
Before hardware with practically unlimited power existed, designers and developers had to find the most ingenious ways to get the best out of the current systems available. The results were often better than if they'd been working with absolutely zero restrictions.
To compensate for a lack of true 3D power, developers throughout the '90s would often render or paint backgrounds in advance, with characters super-imposed above them in game. The technique allowed for lavishly detailed, highly realistic environments which were otherwise beyond the realms of possibility at the time.
Square's Holy trinity of PS1 Final Fantasy games were huge proponents of the technique, and as a result are amongst the most resplendently gorgeous titles of their era. Age has been kind to the trio; though low resolution means the backdrops look a little ropey on today's modern televisions, on the whole they remain jaw-droppingly beautiful.
Starting with Final Fantasy X, the power of the PlayStation 2 meant many environments were now rendered in real time, and as the series advanced, before long pre-rendered backgrounds were consigned to the scrap heap.
Final Fantasy XIII contained sumptuous fully 3D locales of undeniably dazzling quality. But compared to those early PS1 outings, something is lacking in the environments: character. By giving the player complete control over the camera, the concept of framing is entirely lost - imagine a movie where the director has no control over the shots. Gone are dramatic, atmospheric locations such as the cosy and welcoming Cosmo Canyon, or the looming, foreboding Mako Reactors. Instead, we have a series of undeniably beautiful but ultimately bland corridors, entirely lacking in personality, and utterly unmemorable.
All it would take to return the majesty of these pre-rendered backgrounds is to fix the camera in place. It's ironic that the power developers once dreamed of having at their disposal is now to the detriment of their games.
6. Towns And Cities
One of the biggest complaints about Final Fantasy from X onwards has been their sparse, soulless worlds. The biggest reason for this is their lack of real towns and cities, and by extension, their lack of NPCs. With no people or sense of activity, the worlds naturally feel barren and lifeless.
Final Fantasy X did feature the major settlement of Luca as well as the Bevelle citadel, but neither were at all explorable. At the very least they gave the impression that Spira was lived in and worth saving. By XIII however, inhabited areas were gone entirely.
There were a few instances when traveling across Pulse that the player encountered occupied towns, but they were nothing more than backdrops to a series of tunnels. For Final Fantasy XIII, Square-Enix fashioned an enormous world, but it was almost nothing more than ornamental. Not a single NPC to talk to. Not a single vendor to buy from. Not a single thing to care about.
By comparison, Final Fantasy IV actually only had a few dozen people populating its world, living in relatively tiny towns and cities of up to about five buildings. But the scale was irrelevant; the locales created the illusion of something much bigger than it was, and the world felt important. How could anyone care about the Calm Lands or Gran Pulse, basically two massive fields with tons of monsters in them?
5. Adult Themes
No, come on, stop tittering at the back there. I'm not talking about the sort of 'adult' themes briefly and disturbingly explored by Final Fantasy VII's Honeybee Inn, but rather the types issues that tend to affect real, grown-up people around the world on a day to day basis.
That is to say, emotions, relationships, and questions about the human condition. Not time travel.
OK, Final Fantasy hasn't always been a bastion of subtle or mature storytelling. Much of this can be explained by some fairly shoddy localisation; Nintendo's strict US censors ensured many of the series' more challenging themes were cut. Despite the lifting of these restrictions, writing in the franchise has inexplicably worsened as time has gone on, such that more than ever it resembles the work of a cliché-intoxicated teenager.
There's really no excuse in today's highly globalised industry. The business has grown bigger than one ever could ever have expected, yet it has paradoxically become infantilised in the process. Gone are the challenging themes of old. Final Fantasy VI grimly confronted the appeal of suicide in the face of abject hopelessness. Final Fantasy IX questioned the very purpose of existence, asking if our lives are meaningful if we're treated as nothing but numbers. Final Fantasy V pondered over the trustworthiness of a tree. It was all good stuff.
It's a far cry from modern Final Fantasy games, where the most searching question raised is: "what if I turn into a crystal?"
4. Levity
It may sound contradictory to complain about modern Final Fantasy's lack of adult themes one moment, and then decry them for lacking levity the next. The fact is, both are mutually exclusive, and both are problems. Just bear with me...
Recent Final Fantasy games take themselves extremely seriously, but they simply don't possess the strength of writing or narrative to justify their sobriety. With storylines seemingly from the imagination of a thirteen year old boy brought up on a diet of nothing besides animé and other video games, the solemn tone generally comes across as laughable. Except it's also boring. Which isn't laughable.
Earlier Final Fantasy games had big ambitions, but were not above humour. Final Fantasy IX is one of more subtly dark entries in the franchise, yet positively revels in its own particular brand of wit. The humour brought to the characters brings them to life, and creates a game brimming with endearing charm.
Final Fantasy XIII? Every character is a po-faced miser, with any jokes shared being excruciatingly forced. Final Fantasy XII barely even had a story, let alone any room for light-heartedness. What hope for Final Fantasy XV and its super-slick aesthetic?
Again, like the world map, XV's developers probably feel off-beat, humorous asides such as Final Fantasy IX's hilarious Mognet snail-mail sub-plot have no room in their lofty vision. They do. Humour breathes life into an otherwise soulless product. There's no room for snobbery in JRPGs.
3. Real Sidequests
Final Fantasy VI took us on a mammoth trip across a broken world to gather up all our lost companions, and some powerful Espers along the way. Final Fantasy VII transformed us into professional racing bird breeders with the ultimate goal of crossing the ocean to claim legendary materia. Final Fantasy VIII and IX hooked a generation of players on Triple Triad and Tetra Master respectively, whilst Final Fantasy X introduced the new sub-aqueous sport of Blitzball.
XII and XIII? They got us to fight monsters. Special monsters. Some of them were slightly different colours than the normal ones encountered in game. The rewards? Absolutely nothing!
The lack of true side-quests in XII and XIII (and to an extent X - besides Bliztball, the bulk of its extraneous content revolved around a battle arena) were largely the product of the greatly stripped down games. With no world map to explore, and no real towns and cities, what other form could extra-curricular activity take besides endless fighting?
The result was a set of games which felt largely insubstantial. Yes, there were many, many monsters to hunt in all three games, but prolonging the experience in such a way felt artificial rather than rewarding. Killing fifty tough enemies for the opportunity to fight yet another, even harder enemy was nothing compared to the sense of discovery afforded by exploring a secret hidden forest, or a crashed airship buried at the bottom of the ocean.
Content should enhance the game, not exist for its own sake.
2. No Voice Acting
Similar to those remaining few games which stoically continue to employ pre-rendered backgrounds, modern titles which are lacking a fully voiced script are seen as something of an anachronism. After all, the only impediment to entirely voice-acted dialogue in the past was a lack of disk-space; if they could have done it, they would have.
But again, freedom from restriction has proven more a hindrance than a virtue.
Excited by the spangly new hardware on offer by the PS2, Square-Enix went all out for Final Fantasy X, not only furnishing the game with fully 3D environments, but also giving a voice to its characters for the first time.
Unfortunately, neither came off well. Series director Hironobu Sakaguchi hoped to suffuse his cast with even greater emotion; the feat was seemingly made possible by the improved capabilities of the PS2, as it allowed for voice acting combined with realistic facial animations.
The technology couldn't improve the script writing however, nor could Final Fantasy X's wooden, soulless performers. Far from giving the characters greater emotional weight, they instead came across as entirely charmless. There was also that laughing scene. Remember that?
Though voice acting should lend a game a greater degree of realism - and therefore immersion - in later Final Fantasy games it has actually diminished the feeling of being transported to a fantasy world. Rather than the player imagining nuance and subtlety in written dialogue, it is instead entirely prescribed - and if it's bad, there's no escaping it.
There was never any bad dialogue before voice acting, it's an indisputable fact. Any guy who thinks that are sick. (sic)
1. Turn-based Battles
As with most items in this list/diatribe - the world map, pre-rendered backgrounds, lack of voice acting - turn based battles no longer feature in Final Fantasy because the developers view them as a relic from the past. The desire (and compulsion) to deliver a fast-paced, action packed game shouldn't necessarily be a bad thing - after all, who could complain about a fun, exciting battle system?
No, the problem is that Square-Enix have so far failed to execute an enjoyable battle system since ATB was abandoned.
We'll give X a pass here - it eschewed the active time meter but still featured a tactical, turn-based system that gave players absolute control about the course of battle.
XII was a shambles. By moving away from random battles, moving away from the world map, moving to real-time environments, there was now the necessity to engage in combat in situ, rather than transferring to a separate battle scene. Apparently the only way to do this was to abandon the turn based element and introduce a system so impossible to micro-manage that instead the preferred option was to give over control to the computer. Less interaction, that's the way to take a series forward.
XIII was no better in this regard, but at least it reintroduced a tactical element rather than being a bloody mess. Still only realistically able to control one character, the player was now essentially relegated to the role of coach, instructing the team of their preferred formation and changing on the fly according to the flow of battle.
Was it interesting? Yes. Was it fun? Occasionally. Was it Final Fantasy? Absolutely not. Players love Final Fantasy because of the things that made it Final Fantasy. Even in 2016, there is nothing outdated or bad about having a party that can individually be commanded in turn-based battles. It's fine for Persona, and it's pretty successful in Pokémon. Why is it no longer fine for Final Fantasy?