13 Hugely Under-Rated 2014 Video Games

The games from last year that deserve much more praise...

It's fair to say that 2014 wasn't exactly a banner year for video games, what with so many AAA titles such as Watch Dogs, Destiny and Halo: The Master Chief Collection disappointing for numerous reasons, and the three new consoles from Nintendo, Microsoft and Sony didn't really manage to make much of a dent. Still, if you forget the various controversies about frame-rates, resolutions, connectivity issues and Gamergate, there were certainly plenty of great games released last year, a number of which you likely wouldn't have expected. These 13 games, whether absurdly silly indie games, sequels and spin-offs many dismissed without even playing, or titles that were released practically broken before being fixed months later, all ended up being hugely underrated, their quality far exceeding what the Metacritic score and muted online discussions seems to say about them. These are the games that, on the face of it, you might not give a second look to on the basis of their premise, their low-key nature or some mixed reviews, but if you actually give them a chance, you'll find something that just might prove surprisingly entertaining. If you've dismissed any of these games, maybe think again about giving them a shot. Here are 13 hugely underrated 2014 video games...

13. Octodad: Dadliest Catch

Metacritic Score: 69 One of the weirdest games to arrive last year or in fact in any year, Octodad has players controlling (or at least attempting to control) an octopus who is trying to convince everyone around him that he is, in fact, a human. The gameplay revolves around having Octodad perform relatively routine tasks like shopping at the supermarket, but the game's control scheme, in which players must maneuver each limb separately, makes it enormously, hilariously difficult. Though it would be easy to dismiss Octodad as a lazy game with terrible controls (as many critics did), Young Horses, Inc. have taken a potential flaw in their game and totally run away with it. The frustration in how hard it is to move Octodad around is what makes the game so genuinely challenging: complete with a ton of self-aware slapstick humour, the developers turned poor coding into an actual gameplay mechanic, and the results are oddly satisfying. With its agreeable indie game price and short length, there's no reason not to give this barmy caper a go.

12. Assassin's Creed Rogue

Metacritic Score: 72 It's easy to have it out for Ubisoft and the Assassin's Creed franchise as a whole right now, what with the developer's shady recent business practices, and the generally disappointing reception to the last core Creed game, Assassin's Creed Unity. However, that's no reason to take it out on the surprisingly satisfying previous-gen spin-off, Rogue. Though its lack of a release on current-gen consoles suggests it's a lower-tier Creed title, actually playing the game tells an entirely different story. Sure, it doesn't reinvent the wheel, but it adds just enough mission variety to justify its existence, with the Assassin Interception side missions in particularly being a clever change-up of the series' rules up to this point. It's hardly the best game in the series, but deserves more credit and recognition than it's had, regrettably buried amid the considerable controversy revolving around Unity's low quality and parity issues.

11. Velocity 2X

Metacritic Score: 86-90 As you can see for yourself from the Metacritic score, Velocity 2X certainly isn't a game that suffered with critics, but it's quite possibly a game you've never heard of nor played, even though Sony did offer it as part of the Instant Game Collection back in September. It's a game few have spent their time discussing, even if it's unquestionably one of the most thrilling games of last year. An ingenious blend of side-scrolling platforming and shooting along with side-scrolling spaceship action, Velocity succeeds on the strength of its variety and its gorgeous comic book-inspired visuals. Though it seems a little on the easy side at first given that the player is given infinite lives, you'll be glad for it once some of the more labyrinthine levels show up later on. With numerous collectibles on each stage, there's a ridiculously addictive quality to re-playing levels to beat your own score, adding even more value to one of 2014's most artistically brilliant games, AAA or not.

10. Trials Fusion

Metacritic Score: 79-80 Though Trials Fusion received a fair share of praise upon release, the consensus seemed to be that it didn't quite live up to the brilliance of the previous game, Trials Evolution, in part because it lacked an online multiplayer mode, and also because it didn't really seem to improve upon what came before. That said, Trials Fusion is as ludicrously addictive and controller-throwingly difficult as Evolution, and if you've managed to make your way through every level the game has to offer, consider yourself a pro. While perhaps not a revolutionary step forward, the addition of mid-air tricks and quad bikes are very much welcome, and it's simply a case of more of the brilliant, frustratingly challenging same. Plus, it's not all over yet: a full online multiplayer mode will be patched into the game soon.

9. Pure Pool

Metacritic Score: 67-75 A pool game isn't exactly the most thrilling proposition for most gamers, yet VooFoo Studios delivered an unexpectedly brilliant replication of the pool hall experience with this visually stunning simulation title. Who knew that one of the year's best-looking games would be a) an indie and b) so damn cheap to buy? Even once the novelty of the visuals wears off slightly, it's hard to pull yourself away from this game when the AI is so insanely difficult. Just getting through the Rookie stages is enough of a challenge, but making it past the Pro opponents requires a near-supernatural level of skill that's simply beyond the patience most players will have for a game of this type. Still, it's a thinking man's title that reflects the real game brilliantly, and while many wouldn't ever think to play a game of this kind, it's absolutely worth spending a few pounds on. VooFoo have officially raised the bar for sports sims.

8. Call Of Duty: Advanced Warfare

Metacritic Score: 78-83 After 2013's Call of Duty: Ghosts proved to be the worst-received game of the series, few were expecting much from the Kevin Spacey-starring follow-up, Advanced Warfare. However, Sledgehammer Games gave the franchise the boost of vitality it needed by throwing Titanfall-esque veritcality into the mix, making for a multiplayer experience that's more chaotic and satisfying than ever. Sure, the campaign is still too short and Activision have failed to come up with a way to keep people playing once they Prestige, which likely explains why the game once again fell on deaf ears for a lot of stubborn gamers who simply dismissed the game on the basis of the franchise it's in. Even so, it's one of the year's best FPS titles for sure, and a remarkable entry into a franchise that most quite rightly got fed up with long ago.

7. Entwined

Metacritic Score: 59 Experimental "art" games aren't exactly for everyone, but they do have a clear appeal: they're usually short, not especially difficult and gorgeous to behold, three descriptors which suit this indie rhythm game perfectly. Though critics complained that it was too short and not substantial enough, Entwined was a relaxing, trippy journey about two souls who combine to become a majestic beast. There's not much more to the game than using the analog sticks to guide the two characters into coloured segments, but it's an excellent change of pace from the sort of games you're probably used to playing, far away from the stress of yet another military shooter. It's totally uncomplicated, and sometimes rather than a deep, complex story with rich gameplay mechanics, that's exactly what you want.

6. Wolfenstein: The New Order

Metacritic Score: 79-81 The latest attempt to reboot the stagnating Wolfenstein franchise is another game that, though well-reviewed and commercially successful, just didn't get many people talking, and it seemed to be mostly forgotten within a few weeks. While hardly one of the year's best games, it was nevertheless a pleasant surprise, an ultra-violent throwback to the goofy brilliance of the original game. With its interesting alternate timeline narrative, an interesting mix-up of stealth and action gameplay, great pacing and plenty of welcome bursts of humour, this is easily the best Wolfenstein game in years, and one that practically nobody expected to be this good. After the failure of 2009's Wolfenstein reboot, many thought the series near enough dead, but this inventive entry proves there's plenty of life left in the old dog yet. It's just a shame this one flew surprisingly under the radar.

5. Secret Ponchos

Metacritic Score: 65 Yet further proof of the value of Sony's Instant Game Collection, Secret Ponchos hit PSN last month and is one of the PS4's more uniquely entertaining online shooters to date. While reviews have focused on criticising the game's simplicity, that's exactly the beauty of it: it doesn't take more than a minute to get to grips with the mechanics of this Wild West shooter. The sheer sense of chaos is what really makes this work, that an enemy can approach from any direction and at any time, but the protracted nature of each gunfight still gives you plenty of opportunity to mount a counter-attack. Sure, it's not a game that's totally dripping with features, but for a free PSN game that's great to jump into when you've got a spare half an hour, what more could you want?

4. Alien: Isolation

Metacritic Score: 78-81 Here's another game that ended up relatively well-received by critics, but many gamers were simply too burned by previous poor Alien games to give this one a try, and as such they've missed out on one of the year's most surprisingly entertaining (and terrifying) titles. Sure, Alien Isolation is a little too long and some of the difficulty spikes feel a bit unfair (especially when you haven't been able to save in a while), but it's a game of pure, gut-wrenching dread like hasn't been seen in quite a while. If too many survival horror games these days make the player feel too comfortable, Isolation is the total opposite: having to spend most of the game simply fleeing from the Xenomorph, there's an overwhelming vulnerability here that keeps the pulse racing throughout. After Colonial Marines was a disappointing dud, it's not exactly surprising that some dismissed this game as another failed effort to adapt the Alien license, but the final product proves that suspense-driven gameplay seems to be the most appropriate approach.

3. Murdered: Soul Suspect

Metacritic Score: 51-59 While critics were right to call out Airtight Games' latest title for its relatively uneven visual presentation, as everyone knows, graphics certainly don't make or break a game, and that's definitely the case with this inventive supernatural detective story. The nitty gritty of finding clues and investigating your own demise is a total blast, as well as interacting with other restless souls going about resolving their own unfinished business. In addition, combat and stealth sections help break things up and keep gameplay relatively varied throughout. While the game certainly could've done more in the visuals and characterisation departments, it's an ambitious and entertaining effort that mostly works, and certainly wasn't worthy of the scathing reviews it received, which combined with poor sales resulted in Airtight closing just a month after the game hit stores.

2. Lara Croft & The Temple Of Osiris

Metacritic Score: 73-75 A lot of Tomb Raider fans steered away from 2010's Lara Croft and the Guardian of Light because they dismissed it as a silly downloadable title that wasn't a "proper" Tomb Raider game. While the isometric platformer was indeed a far cry from the third-person mechanics of the core titles, that didn't invalidate it at all: the game received rave reviews even if that did little to endear some players to it. The long-awaited sequel, Lara Croft and the Temple of Osiris, has suffered through a similar below-the-radar treatment, which is somewhat apt given that it's pretty much just more of the same...not that this is a bad thing in any way. Extremely entertaining both as a single-player experience and as a co-op romp, Osiris is a short but sweet blast through a number of elaborate, visually rich tombs, coming complete with a number of optional Challenge Tombs which will no doubt have players coming back to try and top their high score. It's hardly a particularly challenging game and may not sway too many who have already turned their nose up at this spin-off series, but Osiris is also a welcome stop-gap as Tomb Raider fans everywhere anticipate the upcoming Rise of the Tomb Raider.

1. Driveclub

Metacritic Score: 71 For starters, it has to be said that every bad word written about Evolution Studios' troubled racer over the first two months following its release were pretty much on the money. The game, which launched with crippling server problems, was savaged by the gaming press and players alike, while many felt justifiably annoyed that the promised PlayStation Plus version was delayed, and 3 months later, has yet to materialise. However, having played the game in January 2015, it's safe to say that the servers are mostly stabilised now, and while hardly a revolutionary racer for the ages, Driveclub certainly is a satisfying racing game with plenty to offer those desperate for a PS4 driving game. The track and car selections are far from comprehensive, but the Tour mode is insanely addictive, the graphics are gorgeous, and now that it works, online play is a whole lot of fun. Sadly, the damage has mostly been done to the game already, and it's undestandable that most aren't prepared to pay money to a studio who screwed up so badly. Still, the game is already available for roughly half its original retail price, so what better time to dive into what is now a criminally misunderstood racer? Which video games from 2014 did you find to be the most underrated? Shout it out in the comments!

Contributor
Contributor

Stay at home dad who spends as much time teaching his kids the merits of Martin Scorsese as possible (against the missus' wishes). General video game, TV and film nut. Occasional sports fan. Full time loon.