15 Impossible PlayStation 4 Trophies Nobody Unlocked

Think you're good at games? We'll see about that.

There was a time when Achievements and Trophies were a revolution in gaming; little impulsive side-goals to your main thrust through a particular title, giving you a smattering of reasons to replay, experiment, discover secrets and talk about every facet of its existence with anyone who'd listen. Nowadays they've dropped off a little in terms of being the first thing you think of when the credits roll, but that hasn't stopped developers using these subtle triggers to inject some humour and much-needed replayability into their creations. On PS4 specifically there's a super simple way to access your Trophies in-game too. Simply head over to the icon on the main menu, then jump into a game. Whilst playing, double tap the Home button and you'll switch between the feed of the game itself and the trophy list, as the console treats them both as separate apps. It's essentially the easiest way to keep track of your progress until Sony implement some sort of Xbox One 'Snap'-like pop-up, but it works a treat, especially if you've been looking for an excuse to get stuck back into some of your favourite titles. That said, story trophies are all well and good, but it's the following 15 that'll really test your gaming mettle. Let us know in the comments if you managed to obtain them, and prepare for some of the most outrageous optional goals ever set by developers so far this generation.

15. Hunter's Essence - Bloodborne

The Dark Souls/Bloodborne collective fanbase are some of the most devoted to a good ol' fashioned gaming challenge around, but even they've been struggling with this one. To get the Hunter's Essence trophy you 'simply' need to obtain all 25 weapons in the game. "Easy", you might think, but you'll swiftly realise that 1. A bunch of them are in incredibly hard-to-reach places considering the game's already brutal difficulty, and 2. Three of which (Burial Blade, Flamesprayer and Blade of Mercy) are optional, depending on specific paths or choosing to spare/kill certain characters, meaning you'll have to replay the entire game to flesh out the other side of the coin. There's also the fact that each of these weapons comes with a price, totalling a hefty 300,000 Blood Echoes. You'd be better off spending these on your character's attributes to avoid being skewered to death in any number of challenging sections across the various levels, and therein lies the gore-soaked rub.

14. Executed - Metal Gear Solid V: The Phantom Pain

Completed MGS V? Clocked the replay missions with the extra modifiers and ran through all 157 Side-Ops? Good, give yourself a pat on the back - but you're not done. Instead, the fairly obscure Executed achievement asks that you spend the time finding every last one of the optional objectives in the main story and completing them. You might have noticed on the side of the screen as you're taking out random soldiers or obtaining blueprints, it'll pop up "Mission Objective 3/7", denoting that you've stumbled upon and executed an optional task - it's these you're looking for. Every mission has a good handful of these to complete, but to find narrow them down you'll have to spend time interrogating soldiers to locate things like specialist troops, rough diamonds or equipment. Luckily all the main missions can be replayed with whatever fancy tech you've crafted across on your save, and whichever of these objectives you missed will show up on a second visit, so now's the time to take that new Rocket Punch out for a spin.

13. Is That A Knife? - Mercenary Kings

Thanks to the deluge of 2D side-scrollers invading your games library left, right and centre, Mercenary Kings didn't take off as much as developers Tribute Games would've hoped, but that didn't stop a devoted following forming around its extremely fun gunplay, experimental level design and fantastically-animated pixel aesthetic. The trophy listed here is for really getting your Crocodile Dundee on, as you'll need to take down the already very challenging Steel Soldier with just your knife. There are a bunch of different blades you can spec with various status effects to pull it off, but you'll have to be quick at evading the Soldier's attacks in the first place, as he only takes damage from behind.

12. Card Collector - The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt

The Witcher 3 is still our frontrunner for Game of the Year 2015, and for good reason - even its mini-games are more robust and fun than other developers' full releases. As such, Gwent - the card-battler you can instigate against almost every major character across the story - has within it an alluring Pokémon-style 'collect-'em-all' element. Card Collector is exactly that, but just to mess with you, there are 199 cards in total, yet 79 are duplicates (the same base card with a different ability), leaving 120 uniques you'll have to make sure you have first. Snatch up the lot across any of your playthroughs (the game supports New Game+ as of Patch 1.08) and you'll get the trophy... until the DLC expansions undoubtedly add more to collect, anyway.

11. You Asked For It - The Evil Within

Shinki Mikami's awesome little horror title remains one of the most overlooked on all current hardware, but it's a game with a penchant for brutal difficulty through ammo scarcity and enemies that are far more nimble than your character, Sebastian Castellanos. The 'You Earned It' achievement is quite possibly the most instantly "NOPE!"-sounding of the lot on this list; beat the entire game in AKUMU mode, meaning any one hit will kill you. Yup, it's that 'simple'. Avoid the bag-headed chainsaw men, survive against the many screen-filling bosses who already posed quite the threat, and - especially in the latter levels - somehow stay in one piece when the level itself is deforming around you. Good luck.

10. Sharing Is Caring - Assassin's Creed IV: Black Flag

Thought Ubisoft's Uplay service couldn't be any more annoying? Well, they tied it directly to a trophy, meaning if you haven't signed up for an account and aren't logged in (which can happen a lot, being their servers are about as reliable as the AC games themselves these days), you simply can't trigger this trophy at all. The way it's supposed to go, is when you're gallivanting about around the Caribbean, the game should randomly spawn three 'social events'; a white whale, a Royal Convoy of ships and a social chest. The stickler is, not only can these things be anywhere on the gargantuan game map, but all three have to be shared socially on Uplay as you discover them, all on the same profile. If you come across something and you're not signed in, tough luck - that's your chance over and done with. Perhaps a server hiccup prevented something from synching even though you were? Again, no going back. It doesn't feel like Ubi really thought this one through to be honest, and Sharing is Caring remains one of the rarest trophies of them all because of it.

9. Solid Gold, Baby! - GTA V

The past few years have seen some absolutely ridiculous-sized open worlds brought into being, and so the masters of the genre themselves, Rockstar, thought they'd prove precisely why they're so highly regarded in the first place. GTA V came complete with a staggering amount of content; just a hulking beast of a game with perfected animations, an exquisite physics model and a host of awesome missions to complete. However, one key area the team changed things up from previous games was in giving you a reason to replay said main missions. Brought in through GTA IV, the Gold, Silver and Bronze medals elect to do exactly that. The 'Solid Gold, Baby!' achievement in particular though, wants you to earn 70 Golds across any combination of main missions or the Strangers & Freaks side quests you can find across the world.

8. Genocidary - Dead Nation

Dead Nation's isometric gun-happy charms are some of the most infectious on the system, so enjoyable is its pick up n' play nature that you'll be lobbing grenades into packs of walkers and finishing any stragglers off with your shotgun in no time. That's a good thing too, as the crazy-sounding Genocidary trophy wants you to blow away a grand (and exact) total of 53,597 zombies - an oddly specific number that pays homage to Dead Rising's Zombie Genocider achievement on 360, where you ended up wiping out the entire town for the sake of extra points.

7. Flawless Raider - Destiny

Destiny's Taken King content is trying its best to reinvigorate interest in what's always been an incredibly divisive game. Case in point; the Raids - unique Warcraft-influenced quests that see you and bunch of friends take on a mix of extremely challenging enemies, level design and stipulations, lasting for multiple hours at a time. These sections are only accessible once you've reached a certain level anyway, but the Flawless Raider trophy asks that not only you, but your entire raid party, make it through the entire segment without dying once. It might sound easy enough, but when you've got scores of enemies baying for your blood, environmental platforming sections that can spell instant failure and bullet-sponge enemies that mean you must divide to conquer, it's an incredibly tough one to get.

6. Chemophobia - Rogue Legacy

If you like Castlevania or any sort of puzzle-heavy side-scrolling hack n' slasher, check out Rogue Legacy, the stripped-back genius effort by Cellar Door Games - it's fantastic. One thing that's not particularly enjoyable, are the 'Remixed' boss fights, where the game will put you in the shoes of a unique character for that specific battle, tasking you to overcome some extremely arduous and impossible odds. The floating eyeball Ponce de Leon is one such battle, but as is par for the course for 2D scrollers, difficulty is immediately ramped up by simply filling the screen with things that'll kill you in one hit. The best bit is the character you get is named Sir. Dovahkiin after Skyrim's legendary protagonist (complete with a knock-back 'shout' to propel enemies away), but as the boss slowly takes up more and more of your free space with mine-like drones, the battle gets exponentially harder the longer it goes on.

5. FuturLab Certified - Velocity 2X

FuturLab's awesome mesh of top-down R-Type shooting with side-on run n' gun platforming is a potent combo that far more developers should take notice of - just imagine this with Shadow Complex's awesome depth-of-field levels and we'd be laughing. Anyway, for the developer-named 'FuturLab Certified' achievement, it's a kitchen sink approach that'll infuriate far more than it'll reward. Essentially, you need to obtain a Perfect rank on all 50 levels, but the process to doing so is predicated on not getting hit, as well as collecting all hostages, crystals and finishing in the quickest time possible - something that all has to then combine to give you a score that beats the previous Gold rank for each one. Several levels have various stipulations that'll really screw you over in this regard, but it's adhering to all the aforementioned rules during the final encounter that's the biggest hurdle of them all.

4. Ultimate Knack - Knack

Y'know, considering Knack's aesthetic is about as appealing as a bombed-out garden shed, his game was far better than people let on. Pegged as being 'for the kids' it actually had a brutal but fair difficulty curve, a trait that thanks to a Super Meat Boy-style instant restart, meant ardent gamers could reattempt any of the lengthy checkpoint-less sections as many times as necessary to get through. The trophy rollout catered to these sensibilities, providing a range of goals from completing the game on the highest difficulty (meaning you'd consistently die in one shot), getting five stars in every Time Attack stage, finishing some areas without taking any damage at all, among many others. For the 'Ultimate Knack' platinum though, you needed to obtain the whole lot, as it won't trigger until you've got every other trophy on the list.

3. The Silent - Don't Starve

Klei Entertainment are easily one of the most gifted and brilliant developers of our time, and their survivalist masterpiece Don't Starve is an entire world of content just begging to be explored, interacted with and mastered. Gameplay consists of a Harvest Moon-like combination of venturing into the wilderness and returning with whatever procurements you can find, the only constant being that you must have a light source when darkness sets in, otherwise the creatures on the island will kill you. There aren't any checkpoints unless you find specific items, and each new day is its own challenge - hence every unlockable character coming your way if you withstand the harsh environment long enough. Every one that is, except Wes, who you'll have to encounter first as a random trigger inside the Adventure Mode. Following his appearance you then need to defeat a number of Clockwork Monsters (a goal that's particularly hard, as combat isn't Don't Starve's strong suit), and if you emerge successful, Wes will pass out, disappear and be listed as a playable character, along with his trophy, The Silent.

2. Speedlunky - Spelunky

If you like your games super hard and unforgiving, Spelunky is right up there with Super Meat Boy as something that'll separate the gamers from the boys, so stupidly hard is its core loop of gameplay that you'll either fall in love or be vehemently opposed within minutes. Existing to provide a procedurally-generated world based on a number of templates - that'll completely change every time you die, which will be a lot - it's a rogue-like of the purest order. An average playthrough involves a huge amount of memorisation for items and enemy placement, and the Speedlunky trophy then challenges any who can make it through to go back and do it again in under eight minutes. Yes, just eight little minutes, with no shortcuts. Taken across the 15 levels on offer and a boss fight, that's just 30 seconds per level, before you account for exactly where to use each item or weapon, and precisely where to jump and move. It's so hard, only 0.7% of the gaming populace have this ranked on their profiles, which should give you a pretty solid idea of how unbelievably ridiculous the idea truly is.

1. Is There Anything You Can't Do? - Trials Fusion

RedLynx's Trials series essentially has the monopoly on infuriating gameplay and challenging game design, as there's just something so timeless and intrinsically annoying about trying to win against a physics-based gameplay model that's forever reminding you it's your actions that are to blame. For Trials Fusion and the cross-generational leap to next gen, the devs went all-out to better their previous level-based achievement unlocks, putting in the above trophy contingent on you besting the 120 optional goals within each main level. These can range from completing sections of a track without one of the wheels touching the ground, or taking a far more squirrelly and hard-to-control bike on an even windier course - basically it's just a way for the devs to have a right old sadistically-fuelled laugh in their board room, before seeing how many of you out there will do their best to overcome the challenge. What are your rarest or all-out hardest PlayStation 4 trophies? Let us know in the comments!

Gaming Editor
Gaming Editor

WhatCulture's Head of Gaming.