4 Reasons Why Batman: Arkham Origins May Fail
Before I begin this article, I should state that I do not want the upcoming Batman: Arkham Origins to be either a critical or a commercial failure. Arkham Asylum and its follow-up Arkham City are amongst the finest games that have been released in recent years and whilst a new entry wouldve been welcomed a while back, there are a number of negative signs (in my opinion, at least) looming over this upcoming prequel that cannot be ignored, though Id happily be proved wrong when the game is released on the 25th October. In principle, the game is similar to its predecessors, featuring the Caped Crusader as he uses his detective skills, combat abilities and array of gadgets to thwart the plans of supervillains across Gotham City. On the surface, more of the same gameplay that made the previous two games great, so why do I have my doubts? Let us continue 4. Its Release Date
As previously stated, Arkham Origins has an autumn release date the 25th October. Its predecessors were also released at that time of year and sold well despite being made to compete with the yearly iterations of Call of Duty, FIFA, Assassins Creed et al, but there are a few other things on the horizon that could deflect the attention of gamers away from the Dark Knights latest outing. This year, Batman is competing not just with other games in the busy autumn/Christmas market, but two new consoles, the Playstation 4 and Xbox One, both of which have currently unspecified Q4 release dates. As Arkham Origins is exclusive to the current generation Playstation 3 and Xbox 360, it could well be ignored by early adopters of the new technologies, who may wish to spend their money on next-generation open world games such as Watch Dogs instead. Theres also the small matter of Grand Theft Auto V, which is released worldwide on the 17th September and is one of the most eagerly anticipated games of all time. Its sheer size, widespread appeal, heavy promotion and likely dominance of shop floor space could easily make some gamers forget about the existence of Arkham Origins, particularly as the current state of the economy means that some individuals can only make one major gaming purchase every few months or so.
3. Its Change Of Voice Cast
Arkham Asylum wasnt expected to be such a massive hit, given the sketchy reception that games based on superheroes (Im looking at you, Superman 64) have received in the past, but one thing that it had going for it were ties to Batman: The Animated Series, notably the inclusion of Kevin Conroy (Batman) and Mark Hamill (The Joker) as voice actors. Conroy and Hamill reprised their roles in Arkham City, with Hamill publically announcing before the games release that it would be the last time he voiced the Joker character, who will instead now be voiced by Troy Baker (who in recent months has played Joel in The Last Of Us and Booker in Bioshock Infinite, two high calibre games, admittedly). Conroy, meanwhile, is being replaced by Roger Craig Smith (Ezio from Assassins Creed), in a change supposedly justified by the fact that Arkham Origins is set five years before Arkham Asylum. Does the voice of an adult man change noticeably in half a decade? Not really. Will Batman be as impactful without Conroys gruff voice? Will the Joker be as dastardly without Hamills vocal talents? Only time will tell.
2. Its Content
The last few hours of Arkham City were spectacular The Joker, Hugo Strange and Talia Al Ghul all met their maker whilst Ras Al Ghul, in typical fashion, disappeared after the Caped Crusader thwarted his Protocol 10 plot. How would Batman function after the death of his archrival? How would Azrael and Hush, both of whom had been introduced in the game and flagged for future investigation, tie into proceedings? What would happen to Gotham now that the Arkham City project was finished? What would become of the likes of the Riddler, Deadshot, Zsasz and Bane following their incapacitation at Batmans hands? It would seem that were destined not to know, given that Arkham Origins is a prequel and will not carry on the plot threads woven by its predecessors. Whilst exploring Gotham City in its entirety and interacting with the likes of Black Mask, Deathstroke, Anarky and the Falcone family is an interesting prospect, itd be much more appealing (to me, at least), if it was all tying into an already established sequence of events. The lack of Riddler Challenges could also limit Arkham Origins' lifespan by a few hours, though collecting all 400 was one of the most tedious aspects of Arkham City. The unconfirmed prospect of multiplayer could make up for this, but the multiplayer in several similar single-player focused games (such as Bioshock 2 or Dead Space 2) in the past has felt tacked-on and added very little to the game. Thankfully, the combat and predator challenge maps that were previously tied to the Riddler Challenges will make a return, with a recent press release indicating that Deathstroke will be playable on said maps as DLC.
1. Its Change Of Developer/Writers
The other three entries on this list are purely speculative, as despite being a prequel with a new voice cast and a questionable release date, Arkham Origins could thrive on quality alone, as Rocksteady have more than established their credentials with the last two games in the series, right? But heres the kicker, Rocksteady arent developing Arkham Origins. Instead, Time Warner (their parent company) have passed the responsibility onto WB Games Montreal, a Canadian subsidiary whose only work in the industry to date has been the underwhelming port of Arkham City released for the Wii U. This means that the entire creative team (including the writers Corey May and Dooma Wendschuh have replaced established Animated Series scribe Paul Dini) has changed and teething problems could ensue as a result evidenced by how many series have floundered after changing developers. When the next Batman film is inevitably released it will be ruthlessly (and perhaps unfairly) compared to the Nolan trilogy, regardless of its individual merit. The same will likely happen to Arkham Origins, whose new developers (who Im sure many are initially willing to give the benefit of the doubt) have a mammoth task to accomplish if they are to win over a fanbase who hold Arkham Asylum and Arkham City in very high regard, as they are not likely to tolerate a substandard release. Will Batman: Arkham Origins live up to the high standards of its predecessors or will it suffer under the burden of expectation? Discuss away in the comments section.