8 Utterly Mind-Blowing Dark Souls Trilogy Fan Theories
Praise the speculation!
Aside from difficulty, Dark Souls is known for its cryptic yet incredibly rewarding storytelling. Plots unfold via environmental clues, item descriptions and logical connections. There is very little exposition in the Dark Souls series, and practically no narration.
Yet, bother to pay attention to all these details and the world of Dark Souls becomes a fascinating place. This unique form of storytelling makes Dark Souls incredibly ripe for fan theories and speculation, and over the years there have developed a number of fascinating discussion points.
Spawning three games, the Dark Souls series is like a cryptic (and brutally difficult!) Rubik's Cube just waiting to be solved by eager players.
From the tragic backstory behind one of game's easiest bosses, to the reason those pesky Mimic chests exist in the first place, here are eight utterly mind-blowing Dark Souls fan theories.
8. Pinwheel Is A Man, Wife And Child Fused Into One Body
If you've only played Dark Souls once, chances are you might not even remember Pinwheel. If you do, you probably remember him as that boss in the Catacombs that was surprisingly, mercifully easy. Though fans of the series commonly regard Pinwheel as something of a joke, there's a lot of interesting lore speculation surrounding him.
Pinwheel is a single body wearing three masks: Mask Of The Father, Mask Of The Mother and Mask Of The Child. The theory states that after his wife and child passed away, the man attempted to find a way to resurrect his family (hence why he's found near Gravelord Nito, God of Death). Meddling with dark magic is risky business, however, and the family was fused together as a single entity.
Mask Of The Father's item description talks of the great burden the man carries, which appears to be entirely literal, as the Mask Of The Father is the lowest on Pinwheel, as if under the cloak he's carrying the Mother and Child. There's also the fact that players fight Pinwheel in a crypt filled with hundreds of books, as if he's desperately researching some sort of fix. And to top it all off, one of Pinwheel's main attacks is separating itself, as if trying to split back into three different entities.
7. Golden King Jeremiah Is Infected By A Massive Parasite
If you've spent any time playing a Dark Souls game online, chances are you've come across someone wearing King Jeremiah's headpiece. It's notable for being absolutely huge: A tall, yellow-bandaged bowling pin that sprouts from the wearer's head. As goofy as it looks, it may actually serve a much darker purpose.
For a start, the headpiece bears a striking resemblance to a certain parasite in Blighttown that's stuck to a wall - the shape is nearly identical. Near the parasite you find a whip, and King Jeremiah is the only enemy in the game to use such a weapon.
There's also the fact that Jeremiah uses chaos pyromancies to fight you, and the parasite is found on the path to Izalith, home to this form of pyromancy. Lastly, he's found in the Painted World, a realm things are banished to, in order to protect the outside world.
Is it possible he chose to exile himself once infected? The bandages suggest something quite sinister is lurking beneath. Original concept art for the character also shows tiny, worm-like creatures sprouting from Jeremiah's headpiece and body. How lovely.
6. King Vendrick Didn't Steal An Artefact Or Heirloom, He Stole The Giants Themselves
During Dark Souls 2, one of the central conflicts is that of the giants against the kingdom of Drangleic. Throughout the game we see evidence of a previous war, and even get to go back and witness this war ourselves by entering the memories of giants.
We're told that the war is kicked off when King Vendrick travelled across the sea and stole something from the giants; and the nature of what that something is, has long been speculated on.
Initially, many thought Vendrick may have travelled to Dark Souls 1's Lordran, returning with the Kiln or the Lordvessel. However, a more convincing theory is that Vendrick didn't capture an artefact at all, but a bunch of giants themselves, returning with them to Aldia's Keep for experimentation.
This is made even more convincing by the fact we're specifically told it was after this event that golems began showing up, which are visually very similar to Giants, but appear to be artificial creations. Plus, Vendrick actually uses golems to defend his castle, and they can be found both inside and guarding the main door. It makes much more sense for a war to kick off over the capture and torture of prisoners rather than the theft of an heirloom.
5. Anri And Horace Are Separated By A Familiar Trap
In Dark Souls 3, one of the most memorable NPC encounters is that of Horace and Anri of Astora. Anri is incredibly important, and is involved in one of the game's endings. Horace, on the other hand, is a silent protector of Anri. Throughout the game the player encounters both NPCS on multiple occasions, until the Catacombs of Carthus when the two become separated. Anri appears to slightly lose her mind at this point, seeming disorientated and disheartened by the loss of Horace.
Horace is later found at the Smouldering Lake below Carthus, having hollowed. Many players have wondered how exactly the two are separated, given how loyally Horace tails Anri and their obviousness closeness. Yet it's possible the answer is right there in the open.
During dialogue, Anri mentions that a trap splits them up. If you pay attention near the slope that triggers the first skeleton ball trap, at the bottom of the path there's a gate which the ball crashes into. Next to that gate is a switch with a snapped handle - a unique model found nowhere else in the game.
If Anri and Horace triggered the trap, Anri would have made it through the gate, but Horace's huge equipment load would have made it so he couldn't run. Anri likely made it through the gate and triggered it to close, causing the ball to smash into the switch and destroy it, separating the two.
4. The Ornstein Seen In Dark Souls Isn't Real
Dragonslayer Ornstein is one of the most fascinating characters in the whole series. He served as one of Gwyn's four knights, and was known for his dexterity when it came to taking down dragons. Most players will remember Ornstein as one half of the Ornstein and Smough power couple, also known as one of the most excruciatingly difficult bosses in the entire game (probably the entire franchise).
Yet, there's a strong case to be made that the Ornstein seen in the first Dark Souls isn't Ornstein at all, but is rather an illusion meant to protect the Lordvessel. For a start, an Ornstein-like being is fought in Dark Souls 2, but wearing darker armour.
This might not be Ornstein either, but things are cast into serious question by the fact that it's possible to find Ornstein's armour next to the Nameless King boss in Dark Souls 3, along with the a description stating that Ornstein left Anor Londo in order to track down Gwyn's first born.
So if Ornstein left Anor Londo, how can he be killed there? Illusion is a very common theme in Anor Londo: Gwynevere is an illusion, as is the sun itself. It makes a lot of sense for Ornstein to be one, too.
3. Mimics Started Out As Thieves From Oolacile
Mimics are up there amongst Dark Souls most memorable enemies, but few people actually stop to consider what they really are.
Treasure chests with massive tongues and long, gangly limbs... surely they're just supposed to be unsettling, right?
Well, Dark Souls wouldn't be Dark Souls if there wasn't the potential for things to get a little deeper. Remember those humanoid enemies in Oolacile, which you can visit during the Artorias Of The Abyss DLC? Well, take a look at one side by side with a mimic – their bodies are alarmingly similar. Both have long, thin limbs and they share that striking arm position, elbows pointed in the air as if broken. According to the Symbol Of Avarice item (basically a Mimic the player wears on their head) it marks a symbol of shame worn by a long lost clan, who were obsessed with greed.
Connecting these things is the sorcery Chameleon, which allows players to transform into objects so they can blend into the environment. A pretty useful spell for someone obsessed with greed, right? Just change into a treasure chest and wait for people to deposit valuable stuff. Oh, and where was the spell developed? Oolacile. The true kicker is that there is even a secret animation between a mob from Oolacile and a mimic chest in Oolacile Township. The mob wanders up to the mimic then points and laughs at it, as if in total recognition.
2. Dark Souls Takes Place In The Same World As Demon's Souls
In Demon's Souls, the world is gradually enshrouded by a deep fog, which cuts off the kingdom of Boletaria from the outside world. Though neighbouring kingdoms send scouts and warriors to investigate this fog, none return after entering it. The spread of the fog is associated with the awaking of the Old One, a great demon residing below a hub called the Nexus.
This theory postulates that the ending in which the player does not return the Old One to slumber is canon, and over time the world is completely covered in a grey mist. The demons take over, killing everything in their path except for the dragons, who are simply too powerful to be felled. Eventually, the dragons begin to kill the demons, and the Old One dies.
Ages pass, and eventually the Archstones from Demon's Souls hatch like seeds, causing Dark Souls' “arch trees” to sprout. The world is now nothing but trees, dragons and mist, just like the Age Of Ancients.
Finally, from the Old One's corpse comes a flicker of life, a spark that causes the development of the First Flame. It's a startlingly seamless transition!
1. The Ancient Dragon In Dark Souls 2 Was Created By Aldia
Players should remember a certain moment in Dark Souls 2, when after making it through the Dragon Shrine, they're met by an enormous dragon who speaks telepathically and gives you the Ashen Mist Heart, which allows you to enter the memories of long deceased giants. Though anyone who has attempted to fight the Ancient Dragon will likely have much more painful memories of the encounter…
There are a bunch of reasons, however, to believe that the Ancient Dragon isn't actually a dragon at all. King Vendrick's brother Aldia is known throughout the game for his bizarre experiments with various creatures: right before making it to the Dragon Shrine you've got to go through Aldia's Keep, which is filled with all sorts of caged experiments.
There's also a suspicious acid pit in the Keep beneath a bunch of giant corpses... which is important, because upon killing the Ancient Dragon, you receive a Giant Soul, not a Dragon Soul.
Seems suspect, doesn't it? Queen Nashandra also refers to the dragon as “a prop; a false deity” after you meet it. And besides, according to the first Dark Souls, all the Ancient Dragons are dead. All the more reason for a mad scientist to try and create one, right?
Let us know your own favourite Dark Souls theories in the comments below!