9 Cancelled Superhero Video Games That Would've Made Millions

A perfect Dark Knight tie-in WAS in development, and we almost got it.

Considering how ludicrously successful the cross medium-spanning superhero genre has become (mostly through the rise of Marvel and DC's filmic output), each and every one of the following developers must be kicking themselves that they didn't see it coming.

Partly due to the only truly brilliant superhero games being either Spider-Man 2 and its wonderfully fun swinging mechanics, or Rocksteady's phenomenal Batman: Arkham trilogy, there are only a handful of titles that really nail your favourite heroes' abilities.

In fact, superheroes created by and for the industry tend to be way better experiences overall, with guys like Infamous' Cole McGrath, Prototype's Alex Mercer or even God of War's Kratos all having awesome origin stories, dogged drives to succeed and morally grey compasses forever twitching to and fro.

Back to the lack of comic characters or movie properties making the crossover though, as the stigma of bad superhero games could easily have been averted if any of the following came to fruition. For all sorts of reasons they ended up on the cutting room floor, but that doesn't mean they can't be picked back up in the future.


9. The Avengers

Go big or go home is the phrase, but thanks to THQ folding right in the middle of various products, they went as big as Marvel's most lucrative property and then had to give up anyway.

A few chunks of footage are out there of this Avengers tie-in that was supposed to release alongside the movie. However, rather than be a third-person smash-fest like Radical Entertainment's Hulk: Ultimate Destruction, it was a first-person team-based battler that almost had a Left 4 Dead vibe as you tackle scores of enemies, combining attacks as you go.

Note the awesome-looking in-air move you could pull off as Hulk, and the rather violent finisher Banner does on a fallen Super Skrull, snapping its neck with his bare hands - a far more adult-orientated move than anything that's in the film. The Avengers bit the dust purely through the financial disaster that was THQ's later years (their Australian studio were putting it together), but why it hasn't been picked up since is anybody's guess.


8. Spider-Man Classic (Web Of Shadows 2)

Sometimes you read about a cancelled game and the reaction is "Well, that's a shame, that would've been cool", but sometimes it's a sequel to one of the best superhero games of all time, and knowing the original team will never get to put out another instalment is simply soul-crushing.

Starting out as a sequel Spider-Man: Web of Shadows (quite the underrated gem, if you have the time) Shaba Games were working on Spider-Man Classic, a game that would retain the high-flying combat engine of WoS, but - get this - would let you play as both Spidey and Wolverine. The two of you would most likely switch on the fly like how Web of Shadows' red n' blue/symbiote suit swap was handled, and the story would pit you against Carnage and Mysterio.

Just look at the version of Mysterio Shaba were working up - he looks positively nightmarish, and had they got it out at the time, would've beaten Arkham Knight's rework of Scarecrow to the punch.

Just to drive home that sinking feeling in your gut that little bit more, the developers were massive fans of the comics, and noted the cutscenes would have a "panel by panel" aesthetic to help tie everything together. Right now a sequel to Web of Shadows remains ripe for the potential-tapping, as Shaba Games went bankrupt in 2009.


7. Daredevil: The Man Without Fear

Speaking of projects that desperately need to be picked up and finished, the world still waits on a Daredevil game, despite the Netflix TV show being the best thing Marvel's done in years.

The version of Daredevil that was in the works came from no-name devs 5000ft who, like THQ, met an early thanks to being strangled by their own purse strings. When publisher Encore shut down the project, they ended up losing $4.3 million in development costs that had already gone into creating what looked like an open-world experience, similar to Spider-Man 2.

Gamespot's retrieved footage above looks extremely... primitive, to say the least, but it did look like you'd have a blast jumping and swinging around the city as Daredevil regardless. Electra and Bullseye were also shown as a playable characters, but the best part is seeing the world through Daredevil's eyes to spot threats, counter them and gain the upper hand in any scenario.

Rocksteady are rumoured to be picking up another superhero franchise now that Arkham Knight rounded out their work with DC, and can you imagine if they picked up the Daredevil license next? Bring that on.


6. Untitled EA Marvel Fighting Game

Sunspot Marvel Comics
Marvel Comics

If you think really hard, you'll remember EA's Def Jam-style spin-off Marvel Nemesis: Rise of the Imperfects. The ambitious 2005 fighting game was very much in the style of the Def Jam's wrestling/brawling engine, but with the added bonus of Marvel's finest backing every blow. EA created a host of their own original fighters too, but thanks to an imbalanced roster and a ton of ridiculous animations making every fight a mad scramble rather than anything fun or tactical, it didn't take off.

Enter this untitled fighting game, another from EA in a very similar mould, but this time barely making it out the gate. Youtube channel PtoP uncovered the above footage which shows Hulk and Captain America throwing down, and the gameplay looks almost identical to any of the Dragon Ball Z games.

It was clearly in the early stages as the camera keeps getting snagged on the world geometry, but at least both fighters could interact with various parts of the scenery to smash into each other or slam right through to the other side. It's a very cool - admittedly fairly shallow - concept, but one that would suit fans of all ages who enjoy pitting their favourite heroes against each other and watching the fireworks.


5. The Flash

Flash game
DC

Combining the acrobatic ground combat of Saints Row IV and the eyeball searingly-fast speed of Burnout, developers BottleRocket Entertainment started work on a Flash game in 2007, but despite being around six months in with a working engine and some neat game mechanics, it wasn't to be, as rights-holders Brash Entertainment dissolved and tanked the project.

If you played Temple Run or any of the behind-the-back sprint-a-thons that sprung up after its meteoric success, you'll immediately be able to get a good idea on exactly how this would've played. By focussing entirely on trying to convey the speeds Barry Allen is capable of (without reducing the screen to a blurry mush), it looks like you'd always be kept on your toes, sprinting across city blocks, directly up buildings and even straight through groups of goons in a blur of broken bones and body-slams.

Combat in particular looks like great fun, a Mark of Kri-style button-per-person setup meaning you could take enemies out in style. Top it off with some traversal and free-running segments that tip the nod to Crackdown's infectious orb-collecting mini-games, and Chief Designer Greg Miller was spot on when he mentioned it was showing quite the amount of potential just before it got canned.


4. The Dark Knight

the bstman dark knight game
Warner Bros

Considering Batman Begins received a game alongside the movie, all eyes were on Nolan's spectacular sequel to do the same.

As such, EA - who had already signed a deal with Warner Bros. and developers Pandemic - forced the devs to alter their standalone Batman game, and morph it into a Dark Knight tie-in. Ultimately, the ends couldn't meet as Pandemic had to throw away the majority of the work they had in the bag, and we'd not get another official Dark Knight game until the mobile-only Dark Knight Rises.

As for what Pandemic did put together, that footage cropped up online, although it consists almost entirely of environmental work showing that the team were set on nailing the look and feel of Gotham, before starting on Batman himself.

You might know that Arkham Asylum came from this kerfuffle too, as EA's part of the deal expired in 2008 along with the movie's release. Pandemic went bankrupt and Warner Bros. needed someone to carry on and release a Batman game regardless. Thus, the rights were given to what was then a totally no-name (and therefore very cheap to hire) studio named Rocksteady, who would go on to do the impossible and become an overnight sensation, birthing one of the best superhero games of all time in the process.


3. Gotham By Gaslight

gotham by gaslight batman
THQ

Another victim of THQ falling apart at the seams (and there were a lot of them, those guys were huge), Gotham By Gaslight was to be based on the DC novel of the same name, depicting a 19th Century Batman whose armour was heavily inspired by steampunk aesthetics such as whirring gears and industrial materials.

Thankfully, Warner Bros. Montreal did include a skin paying tribute to the costume in Arkham Origins, but it's a far cry from the actual game that was being put together by atmospheric maestros and F.E.A.R developers, Day 1 Studios. You can see the skin below: As THQ were on publishing duties, this one disappeared into a PR black hole, seemingly never to emerge, despite it already looking to have quite the identity. Fog cloaks the streets and Batman's imposing cape flows naturally across all his movements, accentuating the whole "watchful protector" shtick more than ever - it really could've been something special.

Check out the main menu above, as it's worth noting how the game was set to include a 'Play Now' option (which granted, could just be a quick load), potentially leading to a free-roam option around the smoggy streets. The control scheme was set to include buttons dedicated to slow motion, quick-fire grenades and a flashlight, setting it apart from Rocksteady's titles by mixing detective work with full-on explosive warfare.

It goes without saying that the Arkham series proved offshoots or one-offs can work far better than when they're tied to specific films, and Gotham by Gaslight has enough source material for a perfect canvas that would then afford a great developer enough freedom to pull it off.


2. Green Lantern/Justice League

Starting out looking like a Green Lantern fighting game and morphing into a full-on Justice League smash 'em up, you'd get to play as everyone from Batman to Wonder Woman, Superman and Flash. There are two sizeable chunks of footage out there, one showing Batman fighting Superman years before the 2016 film would catch up, and another with each character brawling a ton of different enemies.

The BvS clip above is very similar to NetherRealm's Injustice games, but more interestingly you weren't locked to a 2D plain, allowing for a far greater amount of movement and tactics in combat. As a game engine, this looked pretty complete, with dodges and special animations fleshing out both fighters quite considerably.

The more recent clip above shows far more of the game off, retaining the visceral and fast nature of combat but pitting you against scores of foes as an excuse to show off as many moves as possible. The full roster included Batman, Flash, Green Lantern, Superman and Wonder Woman, all with various sliders denoting their strengths and weaknesses.

For whatever reason the entire thing went under (assumedly alongside the first cancelled Justice League movie) and this is all that's left. Still, with Batman tackling Superman in 2016 and another full-on Justice League movie in the works, it's very possible this will return alongside.


1. Superman: Blue Steel

Rogue Squadron developer Factor 5 went from strength to absolute and total failure when they released the motion-controlled PS3 exclusive Lair, and it's a downward slope that would take them six feet under in the following years. One of the shiniest gems in their crown at the time though, was Superman: Blue Steel, a working title that could've translated across into a truly awesome game.

Looking to carry on where 2002's Shadow of Apokolips left off, it also would've given you relatively large environments to best take advantage of Supes' myriad of abilities. In terms of aesthetics, Superman and Doomsday were as old school as they come, with Kal-El's costume in particular popping with old school charm and appeal.

Villains would've apparently included Lex Luthor and Darkseid, alongside Kryptonians Zod and Non, which if the trailer is anything to go by, was going to lead to some truly epic showdowns as you sent them barrelling through buildings and debris.


Gaming Editor
Gaming Editor

WhatCulture's Head of Gaming.