9 Most Disgusting Things Video Games Forced You To Do

Sever the finger, or abandon your kidnapped son?

Across the late 2000s, games seemed to suddenly realise they could throw you into all sorts of horrible moral quandaries, just to watch you squirm. Directors like David Cage would hit and miss through extremely divisive games like Fahrenheit/Indigo Prophecy, whereas developers Lionhead and Rockstar would inject more subtle consequences for actions you didn't even know were being monitored in Fable 2 and GTA IV respectively. However, like any entertainment medium, all that's left to do once the cards have been dealt is go bigger and better every time. More harrowing choices, more awful consequences, more feelings, dammit. It's resulted in some of the most memorable moments in gaming history, and not always ones you have full control of - or even for the most tasteful of reasons - although providing it got everyone talking, that was probably the end result anyway. You can be the judge on whether a game utilised its polarising subject matter for good or bad after checking out the following, and leave your own disgusting moments you were forced to play through for the sake of completion in the comments below.

9. Trevor's Torture Scene - Grand Theft Auto VRoc

Trevor Torture GTA V
Rockstar

kstar

Less a declarative "F**k you world, I don't care what you think!" statement of rebellious intent, more an ageing rocker screaming "Remember me?!" as they do something atrocious to get back in the headlines. GTA V's torture scene came out of nowhere, and was about as effective delivering a message as a postman with narcolepsy.

It's literally set up as a torture porn-style menagerie of implements you can pick up to bludgeon the hapless victim tied to the chair in front of you, and whilst the game does try to make a comment on American politics by noting the information you're getting is useless due to the circumstances, its execution favours indulging in violence for the sake of it, rather than anything else.

The sequence is mandatory if you want to play the story, the only 'choice' present is which weapon you want to use, and Rockstar's response was "Well, if you don't want to play it, turn the game off", which doesn't exactly sound like they designed the sequence to mean anything in the first place.


8. Mutilate Yourself, Or Abandon Your Son? - Heavy Rain

Heavy Rain Finger
Quantic Dream

Wannabe narrative mastermind David Cage has stumbled quite spectacular with most of his games, but the one that's both actually satisfying narratively and tonally consistent is Heavy Rain, the tale of a father, Ethan, trying to get his kidnapped son back from the mysterious Origami Killer. Cut to the third 'trial' the killer puts Ethan through, and he must prove his devotion to the cause by severing a part of his finger.

The catch, is you've only got a certain amount of time, the killer's watching through a camera, and you're in an abandoned apartment building with a smattering of random objects. As you can guess, it all gets pretty gruesome from here on out. Your options include burning an iron rebar so it can melt the flesh away, picking up a pair of scissors, some pliers, an assortment of rusty knives, and much more.

The game does give you the option to walk out, but in doing so you've condemned yourself to an early credits sequence and doomed poor Shaun ("SHAAUUUN") to a slow, death-by-rainwater drowning. Better get to it.


7. Trust Someone You Just Met, And Throw A Baby In An Oven? - The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt

The wonderful world of Andrzej Sapkowski's Witcher series is one of the most bleak, grungy and downright atonal you'll ever come across. It's like the destitute grime of Game of Thrones given the magical properties of Skyrim, and wrung through a couple of prime Eastern horror rollers.

Or to put it another way, it's absolutely fantastic, and knows how you drag you ever deeper into the bowels of its own subconscious, knowing precisely how you'll react when events like the above unfold. Enter the Possession quest, one that's set up around a demonic spectre called a Hym, who feasts on the minds of those who feel immense guilt.

Now, you can't just pretend you feel guilty about something, it has to be real, and so for Geralt to lure the thing out with the aid of the helpfully psychotic Cerys and her nondescript 'plan', he ends up being tossed the infant child of ruler Udalyrk, before being asked to lob it in a nearby furnace. You'd feel mighty guilty after that, wouldn't you? The game lets you decide what you think is best within a small time window, but when alls said and done it is revealed that the child would've survived anyway, thanks to another door in the oven. Oh Cerys, you little tinker.

What's she like at Christmas parties, eh?


6. Sacrifice The Human Race So You Can Be Happy - The Last Of Us

The Last of Us ending
Naughty Dog

Naughty Dog's magnum opus from 2013 is a game so pristinely polished and put together, they could happily retire and their legacy would continue to write itself. Such high accolades come from the close of the game, where upon realising your companion Ellie must be killed to extract the appropriate tissue from her skull for a cure, you play as Joel and get... well... a little annoyed. After mowing through a ton of Firefly security (who don't forget, are mostly freedom fighters trying to develop the cure for mankind), you come face to face with the surgeons prepping Ellie for the end. There's then no choice other than turning the game off, as walking up to them sees Joel butcher the main doctor with a scalpel, before scooping up Ellie and making for the nearest exit. Right then and there, it sets up one of the most monumental endings of all time, where the formerly unconscious Ellie gets lied to to maintain Joel's relative innocence, all for the sake of putting the solution to his own loneliness over the salvation of the human race.


5. Kill Your Best Friend & Mentor, Or Reveal Your Cover? - Splinter Cell: Double Agent

Splinter Cell Lambert
Ubisoft

We're long overdue another Splinter Cell instalment, and as Ubisoft have royally ballsed up both Watch Dogs and Assassin's Creed in the last few years (despite Syndicate being a solid title nonetheless), Sam Fisher and his high-tech gadgetry would be welcomed with open arms.

Last entry Blacklist actually got pretty far away from the continued exploits of Sam's core story, but back in Double Agent it was the first entry on 360-era consoles, and the first to put narrative at the forefront of the experience. 2006's Splinter Cell asked you to put a bullet in Lambert; your best friend and former handler from the other side of the microphone.

The alternative was to refuse and blast one of the enemies instead, but Lambert bites it further down the line regardless, meaning you were forced - out of the blue, I might add, it's very "Here's someone you know, deal with it" - to take care of the situation in one hell of a memorable scenario.


4. Sleep With A Prisoner's Wife, Then Kill Him - God Of War III

Aphrodite God of War
SIE

For all his acrobatic chain-flinging mastery, Kratos is an absolute dick in the God of War series - in particular, part three. At this stage in the narrative we're lead to believe that he's so completely consumed by revenge, that it blinds him to everything other than enacting it and taking down Zeus - an idea that's pushed to the borderline when you find Aphrodite and husband, Hephaestus.

First you'll meet up with Aphrodite in all her topless glory (and it is glorious), before sleeping with her in an instant - as she's all sex-mad and whatnot. But it's after this that you have dealings with husband Hephaestus, who's only in chains and reconciled to a life of torture thanks to Kratos' actions in the second game. Hephaestus explains he just wants to see his wife and daughter again, to which Kratos callously casts off any empathy, despite he himself losing a daughter - only for a boss fight to ensue as the craftsman clearly doesn't trust the God of War, and he ends up getting killed because of it, crying as his final breaths leave him.

Yes, it's super dark and yes, it makes Kratos one of the biggest monsters in gaming history - a trait seemingly lost on the scriptwriters, who champion his actions by giving you the 'Ladies Man' trophy for 'entertaining' (as they call it) Aphrodite.


3. Stab Your Only Companion To Death - The Walking Dead

Walking Dead Clem Dog
Telltale Games

The second season of Telltale's Walking Dead series really dropped the ball for the most part, but the first episode contains - for animal lovers anyway - one of the most most shocking and brutal scenes they'll ever take part in; being forced to stab a dog to death.

Now, the whole thing is done out of self-preservation and both parties' own survival instincts (the dog literally just goes feral at the sight of food), but it's the severity of how the scene goes from a nice relaxing moment of Clem trying to feed her newfound friend, to having to grab a blade and fight for her life. It'll see you mash the buttons with the same ferocity as the onscreen animations, and when it's all over you'll be shaking and clutching the nearest loved one, cursing Telltale for designing such an amazingly intense moment.


2. Taking Part In A Terrorist Attack - Call Of Duty: Modern Warfare 2

Possibly the most infamous and controversial scene in gaming history next to GTA III's 'acquisition' of prostitutes back in 2001, COD's attempt to delve into the minds of a terrorist by illustrating the helplessness of those on the receiving end of gunfire didn't really have a message behind it, other than "Hey, this stuff is really messed up, right?"

Infinity Ward did include the option to skip the level before it starts, but I'm including it here anyway as if you wanted to play the entirety of the game you'd paid for, that should always mean seeing everything on the disc. And honestly, like Rockstar's "well just turn it off if you don't like it" approach to controversy in GTA V, No Russian simply reinforced the notion that if you're going to bother including something like this at all, you need to do it well. Instead, you wander through this airport level, taking in the massacre of what was on screen, and deciding whether or not you wanted to take part by offing some civilians yourself.

There's no morality system or repercussion for doing so, the story plays out the same and so do the animations around you, ultimately meaning that you were denying yourself content if you so chose, or opting to watch a terrorist attack unfold if you didn't. Like GTA V's torture scene, it just isn't an effective enough way to present such sensitive subject matter.


1. Accidentally Deploying White Phosphorous On Innocent People - Spec-Ops: The Line

Switching gears considerably, Spec-Ops' lead writer Walt Williams knew exactly how to get a reaction out of the player, and come the mid-point in The Line as you're trying to figure out a way to take out an entire forecourt of enemies, your teammates eye a mortar that'll deploy the skin-scorching white phosphorus from above. Reservations are mentioned from your fellow soldiers as to just how inhumane this stuff is anyway, but then you hop into the viewfinder and start using the thermal indicator to find where the enemy patrols are regardless.

You kill off a few, before finding a larger group of icons together, to which your inbuilt "Ooh, I can kill a few of them at once!" trigger kicks in, and you wipe the whole area out. Except they weren't enemy soldiers, they were hostages, huddling together to stay out of the line of fire. The game plays on the effect of this massively for its final reveal and the descent into madness your main character Martin Walker slowly falls into - but it's this reversal of expectation that uses a standard way we all play shooting games and flips it on its head so severely, that'll stick with you forever.

What's your most disgusting moment you were forced to play through for the sake of completion? Let us know in the comments!


In this post: 
GTA V
 
First Posted On: 
Gaming Editor
Gaming Editor

WhatCulture's Head of Gaming.