9 Polarising Levels That Almost Ruined Great Games

Gliding, fist-fighting, detective work and... tank battles?!

Game developers have it tough, no doubt about it. What other profession do you come across where your chosen creative outlet takes multiple years to put something together, there are millions of dollars backing every subsequent feature shown to the public - and when it finally releases you get what, like a month of coverage before the it all simply dies off again? That's not always the case for everything (and smaller budget masterpieces like Her Story, To The Moon or Gone Home prove keeping things under wraps to the last minute can work a treat), but for the bigger studios, they have every movement tracked like a hawk - which goes triple when you're trying to make an impact or follow up on something special. It leads to crazy amounts of pressure, coupled with the inbuilt need to create and innovate despite all those surrounding aspects, research pointing you in certain directions or publisher demands to curtail to - the end result being strange abominations of design like what you're about to see, remember and shudder. The thing is, these aren't necessarily outright despised levels or designs - they've got just as many lovers as they do haters, and is customary now to debate every detail of something online, plenty fans always spring out of the digital woodwork to remark that it all "Wasn't that bad, really". Well, was it? Let us know in the comments what levels you never agree on with anyone else regardless of good or bad - as chances are, you're not alone.


9. Fighting The Blue Guys - Uncharted 2: Among Thieves

Having a supernatural element come in out of nowhere in any archaeologically-focussed narrative just seems par for the course, although rather than being an undefinable force of God (or whatever) that was inside the Lost Ark in Indiana Jones and more of a Crystal Skull-type head-scratcher, Uncharted 2 decided to have you tackle a race of blue super-humans for the big finish. Granted the first game ended with a similar "They're not dead after all!"-reveal when the Spanish colonists reanimated and started baying for blood, but at least if you got the setup right, you could have some fun pitting them against the more regular soldiers you'd been tackling across the campaign. Uncharted 2 pulled this same reveal, except restricted you to a tiny arena-like structure where any close-quarters interaction with these grenade-tossing fiends was essentially a one-hit kill. Uncharted's combat is always frantic and scattershot at the best of times (which is part of the appeal and the embodiment of Drake's character himself), but by forcing you into such a confined space against enemies that already felt like a reach conceptually, just came across as misguided.

8. Blighttown - Dark Souls

Thanks to the Souls series cultivating one of the most diehard and unforgiving fanbases out there, absolutely anything - glitch, bug or otherwise - is simply "part of the experience". Got chopped from an enemy because you were stuck between the wall and a rogue piece of pottery? That's Dark Souls. An enemy's swipe glitch out and caught up to where you'd previously dodged because the game decided you were 'supposed' to die? That's Dark Souls. The list goes on. However, one particular part of the first game that's remained un-patched and in its original buggy-as-hell form is Blighttown; a section where the framerate slows to a flip-book crawl, enemies swarm you in seconds and an ever-present amount of flying drones are forever closing in on you.
In short it's agonising, but don't let that get in the way of fans telling you you're only getting "the real Souls experience" if you can then come out the other side in one piece.

7. Getting Your License - Driver

On the one hand you've got an opening section that quite simply was so infuriating and impossibly hard, it crippled the Driver series in the eyes of the public so much that GTA easily swayed in and stole its crown. The flip-side though, was developer Reflections having the sheer balls to put forward a level that ensured only those who remained afterwards would take the rest of the experience seriously. You literally had to perfect your skills through sheer trial and error to progress and make the grade, mimicking every similar scene of a character testing themselves like you more commonly see on the big screen. There were no HUD elements, lines on the ground showing you were to go or how to perform, it was just you, a car, a parking lot... and a one minute time limit to pull it all off.

6. The Interrogations - Splinter Cell: Conviction

Talk about your games that had troubled pasts filled with divisive decisions; the followup to Splinter Cell: Double Agent was initially pegged as something of a third-person brawler featuring a Sam Fisher "pushed to the brink" as he tried to recoup his life following the death of both his daughter and fan-favourite boss, Lambert. Following a disastrous showing at E3 2007 (where a bearded Fisher threw tables at guards and proceeded to look about as much like Splinter Cell as Arkham Knight's PC port did a working product), the only thing that carried forward in terms of a more 'hands-on' approach to gameplay were a string of interrogations, whereby you'd batter opponents mercilessly through a string of contextual prompts until they caved. It literally boiled down to hitting an action button and watching many brutal animations play out (a face-meet-toilet seat here, slam through a desk there, you know it is) and despite it upping Fisher's game as an 'effective killer'/psychotic maniac, fans to this day debate whether they fitted the darker tone Ubisoft were going for, or just felt too out of place in a game otherwise focussed on stealth and evasion.

5. Defending Earth - Mass Effect 3

Have you had a reminder the end of Mass Effect 3 was terrible? Perhaps you've gone quite some time before anyone brought it up, it is 2015 after all. Anyway, just so no one ever forgets; The End Of Mass Effect 3 Was Terrible. Moving on - but not really - Bioware's final hours of the third Mass Effect were truly a strange experience. From building up your army comprised of various space aliens, tech and weaponry, it converged to a singular point on Earth, where a fairly small boxed-in area was essentially meant to represent you fighting a galaxy-wide invasion for as long as you could. Gameplay-wise it amounted to the developer doubling down on the gunfights present across the campaign (and sole focus of the multiplayer), something that was fine in small doses, but forced upon you for a good half hour? Well, perhaps the agonising feel of battling on for what felt like forever was intentional. The ending that came after all this is another story (and usually the focus of any Mass Effect 3-focussed conversation), but it was this choice to wrap up what had been such a well thought-out franchise stuffed with impactful moments and memorable characters... with a thoroughly bread n' butter firefight that outstayed its welcome after only a few minutes.

4. Any Driving Level - Jak 3

See? Arkham Knight wasn't the only game to shoehorn in some awkward ground-based driving sections to a game engine that really didn't need them. Back in 2004 (yes, it's been that long) Naughty Dog needed something to reinvigorate their new flagship franchise, and having taken to the skies in Jak 2 with all manner of flying vehicles and hoverboard-skills, the third instalment saw them do... the exact opposite, grounding everything and ensuring the only travel you'd be doing would be in awkwardly-handling dune buggies. It was positively Mad Maxian in its visual approach, with the vehicles in question having all sorts of angular metal shapes and armaments bolted onto their frames to survive the sand-blasted wilderness surrounding the city. The problem came any time a main mission asked you to win a race, retrieve an item or essentially spend any time doing so - as raiders would tip your vehicle over in seconds, the controls were extremely loose in practice and the general feel of movement was annoyingly weightless.

3. No Russian - Call Of Duty: Modern Warfare 2

Massively effective comment on your average gamers' propensity to blow everything away that's right in front of them, regardless of the moral implication - or a horrendously misguided 'terrorist simulator' that stands for nothing other than sending a message through sheer brute force? The world couldn't decide then, and it certainly can't decide now - especially since Call of Duty in 2009 was in the process of blowing up into the cultural phenomenon it currently resides as. The creative team at developer Infinity Ward have been scattered across all manner of studios, and aside from the Black Ops games we've not seen COD go anywhere near such controversial material since; unless you want to count Kevin Spacey getting his Frank Underwood on to discuss geo-political presence and America as a self-destructing inevitability in Advanced Warfare. Regardless, Modern Warfare 2's foray into extremely challenging subject matter ended up essentially being cast aside in favour of talking about how much fun it was to rack up killstreaks or blast the evil muahaha'ing villain Makarov right in the eyelids. Let us know in the comments where you stand on it in 2015.

2. The Drone Tank Battles - Batman: Arkham Knight

So after more than a year of fervent speculation, Batman: Arkham Knight released to almost unanimously positive critical praise. Likewise, the fan side of things was fairly loaded with "Best thing ever!" responses and a handful of specific plot moments are justifiably exactly that. But then there's the negative side, the armoured-up cannon-topped elephant in the room; that Batmobile, and everything that comes with it. Sure for the most part it's a huge amount of fun just barrelling through Gotham and torpedoing enemy cars with the barest whiff of care for the environment as they cascade off road and through a line of bus stops, but holding down the left trigger changes form into a tank, which from there it's dodge n' shoot city. Lasers appear on the screen pointing to what areas are about to be fired upon, missiles launch from off-screen and track your position within seconds (meaning you must take them out or be blown to smithereens) and the whole thing is done with more screaming alert noises and in-your-face HUD elements than Steel Battalion. In the end it's no surprise people are actively giving up on Arkham Knight's best bits simply because these parts of the game are so badly handled, but like some band of resistance fighters slowly erecting their flag, there are a contingent of Batmobile-lovers out there, too.

1. The Raids - Destiny

It's either extremely intelligent or completely bewildering from a designer's point of view to put your best content behind hours upon hours of game time, a very harsh level cap you need to surmount and a string of identical missions - but that's what makes Destiny such a stupidly fascinating game. Not in an overtly positive or negative sense - after all there are just as many supporters of Destiny's money-sucking ways as their are watchers from the sidelines frothing at the mouth. Instead the brass tacks of the matter is the design ethos; a filing cabinet of a game with the barest of structures both narrative or through game mechanics, elements slowly being slotted in across months of production. And what are the crown jewel of these possibilities? The Raids; innovative experiences best played with friends or companions you can put your faith in to watch your back. You'll tackle puzzles, stealth sections, unique bosses, level designs and more - but only if you first got on board with the game's repetitive nature, and then grind gear until they became available in the first place. What are your most polarising levels nobody can ever seem to agree on? Let us know in the comments, and check out the full gaming section for more!

Gaming Editor
Gaming Editor

WhatCulture's Head of Gaming.